Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 30, 2007 Sivan 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:06 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The end of Sharon's path
By Akiva Eldar

Tzipi Livni complained to foreign diplomats last week that Israel left the Gaza Strip and dismantled all the settlements in Gush Katif, but that the Palestinians are reciprocating with salvos of Qassams. Really, that is not the proper way to behave. What, Livni and the apple of her eye, Ariel Sharon, were unaware that Hamas terrorists do not behave nicely? They thought Khaled Meshal and Mahmoud a-Zahar would send them flowers? It is hard to decide which is worse - that they failed to take into account the possibility that disengagement without an agreement with the Palestinians would increase the threat against the communities in the southwestern Negev, similar to what happened after Israel withdrew from Lebanon without an agreement with Syria; or that they left the Gaza Strip knowing full well that it would fall like a ripe fruit into the hands of Hamas.

The foreign minister provided the answer herself not long ago. In an interview on U.S. television, she admitted that it would have been better to leave Gaza as part of an agreement rather than to "toss the key into the street." The "street" is Hamas, of course, whose leading slogan is "resistance defeated the agreements." Ehud Olmert's best course of action since entering Sharon's shoes was violating his own great election promise to "follow in Sharon's path." There is no sign of convergence, and no vestige of unilateralism. The "no partner" mantra has given way to courting "moderate Arab leaders" and to longings for the "peace process."

Withstanding the pressure to reconquer the Gaza Strip also shows that Olmert is not following Sharon's path with eyes closed. So far, he has refrained from ordering a Gaza replay of Operation Defensive Shield, which brought the Israel Defense Forces back into the West Bank. And perhaps he learned the lesson of the Second Lebanon War - that a massive attack against Arab civilians unifies the Muslim world against the Israeli enemy and its "partners" in the pragmatic Arab camp.

Advertisement

Like always, this serves the radical stream in Hamas, which dislikes the partnership between Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas, seeks to undermine the Dayton plan to strengthen Fatah, and objects to the Arab peace initiative. The way to rehabilitate what Sharon left of the partner is, therefore, precise and cautious use of power against Hamas, retrieving the key from the street and delivering it to the right address. This could be done by responding affirmatively to Abbas' request to extend the calm (tahadiyeh) to the West Bank and by ordering the IDF to attack only "ticking bombs," with discrete cooperation with the Palestinian Authority's security apparatuses. As far as we know, there are no tunnels under the Jordan River that could be used to smuggle weapons into the West Bank during a cease-fire. And why shouldn't the government apply the Dayton program to ease conditions throughout all the territories, showing the residents that only the moderate camp can restore their hopes?

Granting the Palestinian partner these small and important measures is essential, but this will maintain the status quo temporarily at best. To embark on a new path, Israel must take a big step forward, along the route charted by the Arab League's peace initiative. Opening a channel to Damascus, whether secret or explicit, via which Israel would assure Syria that an accord on the Golan would not lag behind an agreement on the Palestinian territories, would not just calm the northern front; Khaled Meshal's host could also exert more long-term influence on the southern front than a few Israeli air attacks on Gaza weapons laboratories would.

Hamas' violent clashes with Fatah in the streets of Gaza are nothing more than a dress rehearsal for the great confrontation the group anticipates in June and July. The attempt to blend a religious movement (whose ideology does not allow it to recognize a Jewish state) and a secular national movement (which has internalized the limits of its power) did not succeed. Sooner or later, whether through gun slits or the slits of ballot boxes, the Palestinians will receive another opportunity to choose which path they prefer. The Israelis will, too.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Taste the city
From French fries to calamari rings to health food, the Taste of the City Festival has it all.
Far from immaterial
Comme il faut embarks on a new approach to fashion this summer, gimmicks intact.
  1.   Good idea, but the Arabs must make a step too..... 10:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/05/07
  2.   Don`t look for peace in this century 10:58  |  Natallie Durson 24/05/07
  3.   No Partner 11:37  |  Martin 24/05/07
  4.   The Right of Return 11:58  |  Bernie 24/05/07
  5.   Keep on Dreaming! 12:15  |  Sharif Hafez 24/05/07
  6.   Big Step: Eldar and Lefties leave Israel to make room for the pal 12:21  |  Absolute Sweden 24/05/07
  7.   Best solution is to expel all Gazans to Egypt 12:44  |  Tomer 24/05/07
  8.   dialogue with Syria 13:05  |  moshe 24/05/07
  9.   The bottom line question for making PEACE possible... 13:06  |  J.M.Jordan 24/05/07
  10.   The out streched Arab arm for peace 13:24  |  Phillies Wright 24/05/07
  11.   IS THIS THE DAY FOR THE MOST STUPID COMMENTARIES. 13:28  |  paul harris 24/05/07
  12.   Mr. Hafez in Egypt 13:49  |  Jane 24/05/07
  13.   Sharon`s path 13:54  |  Al 24/05/07
  14.   Sensible article,extend the ceasefire to the West Bank and 14:18  |  lakshmi 24/05/07
  15.   A good start, place territories under a UN trusteeship 14:57  |  El-birawi 24/05/07
  16.   too late, too late, too late, too late 15:20  |  Khalid 24/05/07
  17.   Right on! Akiva 15:33  |  Dutch 24/05/07
  18.   The paradoxes of punditry ad nauseam 15:33  |  David Hoffman 24/05/07
  19.   Gaza to Egypt, West Bank to Jordan 15:53  |  a better way 24/05/07
  20.   The "peace process" is a disaster & must be abandoned 16:13  |  Chaim 24/05/07
  21.   To Jane # 12 16:24  |  Sharif Hafez 24/05/07
  22.   Moderate Arab leaders? Thats an oxymoron. 16:35  |  David 24/05/07
  23.   Continuing this war on the Palestinians 16:45  |  avi 24/05/07
  24.   naive 17:05  |  michael 24/05/07
  25.   #19 Correct. Gaza to Egypt, W.Bank to Jordan. NO STATE FOR....... 17:06  |  Vittorio 24/05/07
  26.   Swiss (Dino)....not quite 17:10  |  Ibrahim 24/05/07
  27.   Jane, we can only judge by Israel`s behavior. 17:14  |  Ibrahim 24/05/07
  28.   to David # 22 17:17  |  Sharif Hafez 24/05/07
  29.   Haaretz, have you forgotten already? 17:21  |  Walter 24/05/07
  30.   Eldar - Will His Delusions Never Cease ? 17:31  |  Tod Zuckerman 24/05/07
  31.   23Avi,very realistic appraisal,since Iran is sure to develop its 17:36  |  lakshmi 24/05/07
  32.   NO PEACE INITIATIVE--NO MIDDLE EAST FOR ISRAEL 17:37  |  Dutch 24/05/07
  33.   Jane and Israel wants peace 17:52  |  Angela 24/05/07
  34.   Khalid`s tragic disjunction 18:02  |  David Hoffman 24/05/07
  35.   Declare desire to end occupation 18:10  |  david 24/05/07
  36.   NO PARTNER 18:15  |  Simon 24/05/07
  37.   Akiva Elder 18:19  |  Ah 24/05/07
  38.   We All Have Different Opinions-Leiberman Is Not the Only Voice 18:25  |  Jane 24/05/07
  39.   # 26 Ibrahim 18:27  |  Swiss (Dino) 24/05/07
  40.   Hi Ibrahim - I Hear You 18:28  |  Jane 24/05/07
  41.   Hi Ibrahim - I Hear You 18:28  |  Jane 24/05/07
  42.   INTERESTING, ALL ENEMIES OF ISRAEL LIKE ELDARS IDEAS, WONDER WHY 18:36  |  Jorge 24/05/07
  43.   To Avi #23 18:38  |  David Hoffman 24/05/07
  44.   Khalid`s cheap threats 18:43  |  Alex 24/05/07
  45.   Jane, I accept your peace gesture 19:15  |  Ibrahim 24/05/07
  46.   Ibrahim Hello 19:39  |  Danite 24/05/07
  47.   Unfortunately, Palestine first and Syria second 19:51  |  Tosefta 24/05/07
  48.   "The attempt to blend... 19:54  |  Jim 24/05/07
  49.   david from Royal Oak...a little lunch at pita express? 19:55  |  Ibrahim 24/05/07
  50.   The attempt to blend (part 2) ... 20:09  |  Jim 24/05/07
  51.   Just who exactly are we supposed to agree with? 20:10  |  Efox 24/05/07
  52.   re: # 3 No partner 20:18  |  Jim 24/05/07
  53.   To #40, David Hoffman 20:20  |  avi 24/05/07
  54.   I feel encouraged by the posts today,since there are many with 20:23  |  lakshmi 24/05/07
  55.   re: # 5 Sharif Hafez Keep on Dreaming 20:37  |  Jim 24/05/07
  56.   # 7 Tomar 20:41  |  Jim 24/05/07
  57.   Ibrahim stop your nonsense 20:51  |  Danite 24/05/07
  58.   Peace? Never...... 20:54  |  Mexi 24/05/07
  59.   # 10 Phillies Wright, France 20:54  |  Jim 24/05/07
  60.   Very Very Few Still Cling to the Greater Israel POV 20:59  |  Jane 24/05/07
  61.   # 11 Paul Harris 20:59  |  Jim 24/05/07
  62.   To Jane# 37, PLEASE PUBLISH! PROVE YOU ARE A DEMOCRACY! 21:19  |  Sharif Hafez 24/05/07
  63.   31David Hoffman,your intellectulism is a welcome relief from some 22:40  |  lakshmi 24/05/07
  64.   Ibrahim, I am still waiting 22:48  |  david 24/05/07
  65.   Hey Ibrahim no lunch for me?? 23:11  |  Danite 24/05/07
  66.   no return 23:47  |  zichron 24/05/07
  67.   #39 Swiss (Dino) on "accepting" the plan 23:56  |  A Lebanese 24/05/07
  68.   a reasonable person 23:57  |  melchizedek 24/05/07
  69.   #48: Jim - I couldn`t have said it better 23:59  |  A Lebanese 24/05/07
  70.   arab peace illusion 00:51  |  real vision 25/05/07
  71.   40 Jane (and Ibrahim) -- Mostly I admire your posts but I must 01:04  |  Searcher 25/05/07
  72.   4 Bernie - Right of return 01:13  |  Nicolas from Paris 25/05/07
  73.   Delerious Doris 01:20  |  Jo Jo 25/05/07
  74.   67, A Lebanese 01:34  |  Nicolas from Paris 25/05/07
  75.   # 67 A Lebanese 01:37  |  Swiss (Dino) 25/05/07
  76.   Why isn`t Eldar writing for Aj Jazeera 01:41  |  Sheik your booty 25/05/07
  77.   Israel must reject all and not just part of the Arab League plot 02:02  |  Joseph E . 25/05/07
  78.   A better way?? 02:09  |  George 25/05/07
  79.   You`re All Invited To Join In 03:46  |  Jane 25/05/07
  80.   Hey Akiva 03:55  |  Avrum 25/05/07
  81.   79 Jane A few months ago I thought Ibrahim... 04:26  |  searcher 25/05/07
  82.   #19, #25 Giving Gaza to Egypt and WB to Jordan 04:34  |  Johnboy 25/05/07
  83.   A very fine article indeed 04:44  |  Johnboy 25/05/07
  84.   To 53 Avi and 63 Lakshmi 05:35  |  David Hoffman 25/05/07
  85.   Which of the 3 options are you advocating for Israel? 05:55  |  MG 25/05/07
  86.   Sharif Hafez, (62), from Egypt, demands democracy in Israel. 06:08  |  Fortuna Benmayor 25/05/07
  87.   will never be enough 07:33  |  izzy d 25/05/07
  88.   big step 15:47  |  Jeff 25/05/07
  89.   Responce to #84: Palestinian reconciliation? 17:09  |  avi 25/05/07
  90.   #82 - how about a referendum? 00:35  |  a better way 26/05/07
  91.   to Bernie #4 01:55  |  zeev 26/05/07
  92.   The "peace process" is a disaster - translated 00:58  |  Shlomo Shunn 31/05/07
  93.   America needs to pull plug on Israel 01:09  |  Shlomo Shunn 31/05/07
 Today Online
British lecturers union backs call for boycott of Israeli academe
Responses: 433
Haniyeh: PA gov't wants truce, ball now in Israel's court
Responses: 195
Yitzhak Laor: Shin Bet wants democracy for Jews only
Responses: 93
Rosner: Rice is still being eyed as a U.S. presidential candidate
Responses: 46


More Headlines
01:12 U.K. union backs calls for boycott of Israel academe
23:45 Qassam rocket hits electricity pole, lands on Sderot home
23:40 Peretz: We do not intend to enter Gaza, 'restraint is power'
23:30 Leading candidates to run on single ticket in WJC elections
01:37 UN Security Council votes to set up special Lebanon tribunal
01:19 ULA threatens to strike in schools hit by steep budget cuts
00:10 Witnesses: Two Palestinians killed in West Bank explosion
21:41 Frontline status approved for Sderot-area communities
18:43 Ayalon meets with Peretz over support in Labor leadership race
19:46 EU parliament chief urges Israel to free Palestinian lawmakers
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved