Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., May 21, 2007 Sivan 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:35 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
First, we'll shoot a bit, flex a muscle
By Zvi Barel

The pictures are familiar, and so is the automatic response: fighter aircraft bombing a "bank of targets" and Israeli tanks positioned on the outskirts of Gaza. The justification is also present: The State of Israel cannot refrain from responding to the firing of Qassams. But the protection of Sderot residents is not the issue here, since the state could long ago have built a protective mantle for the homes and schools of Sderot. Rather, again, it is the state's prestige that is on the line.

It is the same prestige that contributed quite a bit to creating the real strategic threat facing Israel. This threat is not expressed by the terrifying Qassams that are causing Sderot residents to flee from their city, but rather by the disintegration of Gaza, by the subjection of its million and a quarter residents to the reign of gangs, by the neutralization of the ability to build a strong, united Palestinian leadership, and by the establishment of a state of terror in Gaza, which operates almost in isolation from any central Palestinian administration.

The reason for the state's prestige being in question is its need to justify the decision not to recognize the Hamas government and to impose an economic siege on the territories. At the same time, Israel has conditioned the Palestinians' ability to exist on a matter of honor - on Hamas' recognition of Israel. How ridiculous now is the tally of triumphs and defeats of Fatah versus Hamas, of corpses on one side versus corpses on the other side, and the mathematical determination that Hamas is winning on the street. Is it not the same Hamas that already won over the street in the elections last year? The same Hamas that maintained the welcome cease-fire for many long months? The same Hamas that signed the Mecca Agreement and accepted the Arab Initiative?

Advertisement

Hamas is not a pleasant movement. It includes elements of terror and draws its sources from a fanatical religious ideology. But Hamas and the Palestinian unity government, as long as the latter still holds up, are the best address Israel has at the moment. This government is not just the only one that has the potential to control the "State of Gaza," it is the only one that is still interested in the fate of its public and, therefore, is influenced by the pressure of that public. It is the only one that is also threatened by the firing of Qassams on Sderot. But without the means to provide benefits for its citizens, it is also paralyzed.

Anyone looking for analogies and rushing to compare Gaza to Somalia or Iraq, would be well advised to complete the analogy. Iraq also lacks a strong government capable of imposing order and security, but the government in Iraq, as well as the American administration, is ready to talk with everyone, including Ba'athist terror gangs and Shi'ite terror organizations, in order to achieve quiet. No reasonable person in the American administration would reject a year-long ceasefire - not to speak of a 20-year ceasefire - because of matters of prestige or recognition. The American government did not stop channeling money to the Iraqi government, even though a considerable part of it is being used to acquire weapons or ends up in private pockets. The main thing is to be able to maintain some semblance of normal life.

This is the proper analogy Israel should adopt. Instead, there is more prattle about a political horizon, while in practice there is economic strangulation - though this strangulation has neither stopped the flow of arms into the Gaza Strip nor the firing of Qassams. This strangulation is nothing more than collective punishment aimed at subduing the ideology of Hamas. And in this it has also failed.

For the thousands of residents of Sderot, who again are becoming pawns in the hands of the government of prestige, it would not have mattered how the government achieved the quiet that it enjoyed in recent months. Whether the government speaks with Hamas or opens the gates of the border passages, whether it conducts comprehensive peace talks or just suffices with a cease-fire - from their perspective, and from the perspective of most of Israel's citizenry, the quiet is the main thing. This means: in Sderot, not to hear the whistling of incoming rockets; and in the other parts of Israel, not to hear about Sderot. But now, first of all we will shoot a bit, flex a muscle, brandish international support, and argue about Gaydamak's evacuation enterprise. But the government will refrain from doing the essential thing - letting the Palestinian government work.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Peretz's role
The DM could bridge gaps between elites and the masses who vote Netanyahu.
Winning campaign
A commercial featuring Stephen Hawking was voted the best ad campaign of 2006
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: And now, the IDF's killing of an unborn child
Responses: 230
David Chinitz: Sitting on the Holocaust - Jews, Germans, Iran
Responses: 55
Cabinet decides to continue strikes against Hamas
Responses: 149
Editorial: Painful sanctions must be imposed on Iran
Responses: 50
Ultra-Orthodox Jewish group declares war on computers
Responses: 41


More Headlines
02:17 8 dead as IAF strikes Gaza home of Hamas lawmaker
22:18 Hamas, Fatah agree to end all hostilities in the Gaza Strip
02:44 Sderot shock treatment center sees steep rise in new patients
01:40 Woman reported killed in explosion at mall in East Beirut
01:57 Shin Bet: Wiretaps can be used to guard state's Jewish nature
21:25 IDF called up untrained soldiers to fight in Second Lebanon War
01:47 Mars candies to remain Kosher after removing animal products
15:03 Iranian official: We're making good progress on nuclear program
20:49 PM, pressed to act, vows to grant Sderot 'frontline' status
21:06 AG: JNF cannot discriminate against Arabs in allocating land rights
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved