Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 27, 2007 Sivan 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A Palestinian boy holding an automatic rifle during a Fatah rally against Hamas in the West Bank city of Jenin on Wednesday. (Reuters)
Last update - 10:24 17/05/2007
ANALYSIS: With Hamas dominant, is there salvation in occupation?
By Avi Issacharoff, Haaretz Correspondent

Four days into the current round in the Palestinian civil war in the Gaza Strip, with Fatah fighting Hamas, several phenomena have emerged:

1. Hamas has won every confrontation since fighting started Sunday. Its military dominance and supremacy are clear. Nearly all the fatalities have been from Hamas attacks. Even the five Hamas militants killed Wednesday died in an assault by their comrades against a Fatah force that took them hostage. Hamas is conducting itself like a military organization: It moves its forces, positions snipers, uses light artillery (mortars, for example), sets up ambushes in strategic locations, and systematically targets Fatah's leadership in the Gaza Strip, based on hit lists it has drafted.

2a. Fatah's leadership vacuum is the main reason for the group's defeat in the current round. Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas is still not showing signs of leadership. He is still afraid to take definitive action against Hamas, even though Hamas is harming the symbols of his authority. Last night he issued a statement, again, ordering a cease-fire, even though most of his men have been on the defensive since the fighting began and have not initiated action.

Advertisement

2b. The leadership vacuum is even more blatant given Mohammed Dahlan's absence from the region. The Palestinian national security adviser managed to rally Fatah's loyalist groups during the previous round of fighting. Dahlan even initiated action against Hamas, including the raid on the Islamic University, a hotbed of Hamas activity. It is not clear whether Hamas planned this current outbreak after confirming Dahlan was out of the picture, but the fact of the matter is that this round caught Dahlan hospitalized in Cairo following back surgery. If the fighting ends soon, Dahlan will come out as the only man in Fatah capable of preventing Gaza from falling to Hamas.

3. The Israel Defense Forces attack against the Hamas Executive Force headquarters in Rafah was not aimed at putting an end to the Qassams. Such attack actually may strengthen Hamas' standing among the Palestinians. But in view of television shots of Sderot being evacuated and given the approaching Labor primaries, the Israeli leadership is finding restraint difficult.

4. The Gazans are repeating one clear message: only Israeli occupation will save them. There is no other solution on the horizon.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
24 hours in Tiberias
Faith-restoring Kebab; a tour of the Old City, and whiskey at the Scots Hotel.
The city on the hill
A new book on Jews and Arabs in Haifa has valuable anecdotes, but misreads the past.
  1.   Insane............ 04:37  |  bill Pearlman 17/05/07
  2.   Israeli occupation? 04:42  |  no one in particular 17/05/07
  3.   Point 4(last Parag) is INSANE-Only Israel occup will save them 04:51  |  Alan SA 17/05/07
  4.   Comeuppance 05:08  |  Amir 17/05/07
  5.   REBBE-KING-MOSHIACH WARNED M.KATZAV IN 1991 THAT THIS WILL HAPPEN 05:11  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 17/05/07
  6.   This solution will only work if one cares more about 05:35  |  Jon 17/05/07
  7.   Gaza. 05:46  |  sandra chitayat 17/05/07
  8.   Israel dose not owe Gaza anything 05:49  |  David G 17/05/07
  9.   Israeli occupation is NOT a solution 05:57  |  spyguy 17/05/07
  10.   No other solution but a free and independent Palestine. 05:58  |  Timothy 17/05/07
  11.   Fatah and Hamas are equally evil 06:01  |  Terje 17/05/07
  12.   Israeli occupation will save them? 06:02  |  Natallie Durson 17/05/07
  13.   To #2 06:08  |  Marty E, 17/05/07
  14.   Seems to be what Israel is waiting for 06:18  |  lakshmi 17/05/07
  15.   to no one in particular 06:20  |  Harry 17/05/07
  16.   gaza 06:21  |  michel 17/05/07
  17.   YOU CANNOT OCCUPY MADNESS 06:23  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/07
  18.   Change will only come from within 06:24  |  Ron 17/05/07
  19.   Haaretz for Israeli "Occupation"??? wow, what is happening to Haa 06:30  |  Tom 17/05/07
  20.   Let The Palestinians direct their violence towards each other... 06:33  |  Tom 17/05/07
  21.   Idiot 06:35  |  Paulo 17/05/07
  22.   Hamas is the democratically elected 06:45  |  samos 17/05/07
  23.   The Myth of the Armed-To-The-Teeth Palestinians 06:49  |  Timothy 17/05/07
  24.   #9 Spyguy 06:49  |  * BEN JABO 17/05/07
  25.   The only solution 06:52  |  hammad hassan 17/05/07
  26.   IDF will occupy Gaza after Hamas destroys Fatah 07:01  |  Voice of Reason 17/05/07
  27.   Arab states to help Gazans 07:01  |  Harry 17/05/07
  28.   GAZA 07:03  |  bruce 17/05/07
  29.   No solution for Gazans but Israeli occupation 07:04  |  Roxy 17/05/07
  30.   Nix the photo of the young boy with an M-16. 07:11  |  Timothy 17/05/07
  31.   Right Wing: We Told you so! 07:11  |  online reader 17/05/07
  32.   Hamas v. IDF 07:19  |  steve 17/05/07
  33.   Israel or Egypt to occupy 07:25  |  Felix Drost 17/05/07
  34.   The Pals will get a HB Victory 07:34  |  RickD 17/05/07
  35.   Israel or Egypt to occupy #2 07:35  |  Felix Drost 17/05/07
  36.   No more Arabs in West Bank and Gaza 07:49  |  George 17/05/07
  37.   Bill Pearlman 08:15  |  Omar 17/05/07
  38.   Timothy - the photo is reality, not a stereotype 08:20  |  Gina 17/05/07
  39.   #30, Timothy 08:34  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/07
  40.   The REAL motive behind the attacks on Sderot! 08:36  |  Samy 17/05/07
  41.   The gun the Palestinian boy is holding. 08:37  |  Maureen Ann 17/05/07
  42.   #15 Harry - A slight flaw in your plan 08:41  |  spyguy 17/05/07
  43.   Haaretz make up your mind! 08:45  |  An Australian 17/05/07
  44.   Of course Israel has to send in the IDF back in 08:48  |  Johnboy 17/05/07
  45.   One option for a safe and secure Sderot 08:49  |  Jonathan 17/05/07
  46.   #24 Jabo - When will you understand? 08:51  |  spyguy 17/05/07
  47.   to #30 08:53  |  Boris 17/05/07
  48.   READ MY POSTS WHEN DISENGAGEMENT PROPOSED 08:53  |  paul harris 17/05/07
  49.   #33 Felix, you have GOT to be joking 09:00  |  Johnboy 17/05/07
  50.   Hamas is their elected government 09:03  |  An Australian 17/05/07
  51.   Maureen Ann -- only the depraved hand out weapons to children 09:06  |  Gina 17/05/07
  52.   Occupation will not work 09:06  |  Yosef 17/05/07
  53.   The Gazans should seek help from Egypt 09:07  |  Gina 17/05/07
  54.   Fascinating, "only Israeli occupation will save" the Arabs in the 09:11  |  Avi 17/05/07
  55.   Let them duke it out 09:12  |  Alison 17/05/07
  56.   PICTUREA Palestinian boy holding an automatic rifle.chidren -- 09:23  |  PETER SM 17/05/07
  57.   PICTUREA Palestinian boy holding an automatic rifle.chidren -- 09:23  |  PETER SM 17/05/07
  58.   PICTUREA Palestinian boy holding an automatic rifle.chidren -- 09:23  |  PETER SM 17/05/07
  59.   The clear message 09:23  |  sh 17/05/07
  60.   Egiptian occupation? 09:25  |  Uri 17/05/07
  61.   NeoLibertarian 09:27  |  What does it mean?!? 17/05/07
  62.   Please not re-occupation!! 09:27  |  Esther 17/05/07
  63.   Timothy is like Eleanor Rigby 09:29  |  Yonatan 17/05/07
  64.   #46 spyguy - exactly right 09:32  |  Johnboy 17/05/07
  65.   salvation in occupation? 09:34  |  eliot 17/05/07
  66.   MAKE THE GAZA Strip into a parking lot 09:40  |  Eric 17/05/07
  67.   johnboy is right 09:42  |  christa 17/05/07
  68.   Better proposals have been made 09:43  |  Yonatan 17/05/07
  69.   ~spyguy ~ 09:43  |  Nerys 17/05/07
  70.   #30 Timothy - nix yur thinking! 09:45  |  Yonatan 17/05/07
  71.   George # 36 09:47  |  christa 17/05/07
  72.   THEY VOTED HAMAS & TERROR-THEY DON`T DESERVE ISRAELI OCCUPATION 09:48  |  Ben 17/05/07
  73.   #44 There is no occupation 09:57  |  Adrian de KLerk 17/05/07
  74.   DONT DO IT ISREAL - STAY OUT OF GAZA 09:59  |  Adrian de Klerk 17/05/07
  75.   To # 36 George (contd) 10:03  |  christa 17/05/07
  76.   Finally, Ha`aretz Realizes The Truth 10:08  |  Ben Israel 17/05/07
  77.   The only thing that will save US is to kill them all. 10:11  |  Sanity 17/05/07
  78.   #44, johnny 10:13  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 17/05/07
  79.   Stupid call 10:20  |  Gaza 17/05/07
  80.   #10 Tim 10:36  |  MLK 17/05/07
  81.   It probably was Maureen Anne 10:36  |  Zelkha 17/05/07
  82.   Hamas dominant 10:39  |  DANNY KATS 17/05/07
  83.   #23 Tim 10:43  |  MLK 17/05/07
  84.   Scroungers got what they elected 10:47  |  Joseph 17/05/07
  85.   26VOICE OF AMERICA you should know 10:51  |  Alan 17/05/07