Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 20, 2007 Sivan 3, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:39 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Sovereignty has a price
By Israel Harel

A decade ago, at the start of the events marking the 30th anniversary of the liberation of Jerusalem, the city's mayor warned: "We are approaching the time of the decisive battle for the very heart of Jerusalem." And how did the mayor at the time, who went on to become acting prime minister and is now the prime minister, carry out that "decisive battle"?

At Sunday's special cabinet meting dedicated to the unification of Jerusalem, Mayor Uri Lupolianski summed up the results: "East Jerusalem is liable, God forbid, not to be under Jewish sovereignty ... Hamas will conquer Jerusalem within 12 years." In remarks reminiscent of the conclusions of a committee of inquiry into another decisive battle, Lupolianski said: "In order not to lose the city to Hamas ... a long-term strategic plan, not ad hoc solutions, is needed."

Lupolianski based his prediction on a study by the Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies, the main points of which are: In the past 40 years, the city's Arab population has increased by 257 percent, compared with only 140 percent for Jews. Of the city's population of about 700,000, 34 percent is Arab. In 12 years this will rise to 40 percent, and by 2035 to 50 percent.

Advertisement

At the official ceremonies that have been held over the past 39 years at Ammunition Hill to mark the city's unification, all prime ministers, including Ehud Olmert, have promised that Jerusalem will remain the undivided capital of Israel forever. Olmert made similar promises when he was mayor and had the authority to realize them. After all, at the end of the day, Jerusalem's unity is determined more through the daily physical implementation of plans than by grand pronouncements.

Olmert himself is waging the "decisive battle" for Jerusalem that he announced a decade ago with about the same skill with which he pursued the Second Lebanon War. This ongoing failure to impose total sovereignty in the capital of Israel - which his predecessors in the Prime Minister's Office share - requires, as in the wake of the Lebanon failure, a change in philosophy. Above all, we must instill in the people the belief that if we can triumph in a military battle, there is no doubt we can triumph in the battle for sovereignty.

The proposals to withdraw from the eastern part of the city are proposals of desperation rooted in the defeatist spirit that guides many of the country's opinion makers: Those who pushed for the Oslo disaster, the flight from Lebanon and the uprooting of Gush Katif, one of whose results is the Qassam rockets on Sderot.

Yesterday, the paratroopers who fought to liberate the capital gathered in Jerusalem to mark the historic occasion. Many came with their grandchildren after showing them the battle routes. They learned that the acts of heroism on Ammunition Hill, in the street of death and in Wadi Joz had not been translated into the necessary actions. All the governments that were voted in to carry through the great victory of the Six-Day War - of which the liberation of Jerusalem was the symbolic, historic and political peak - failed in this mission, and not only in the Jerusalem sector.

But if we only will it so, the situation is reversible: We must adopt a bold, ambitious strategy to ensure Jewish sovereignty in all parts of the city, including East Jerusalem, in parallel with increasing the city's Jewish population significantly. A special ministry, headed by a skilled senior minister with leadership abilities must be appointed to carry out this strategy. The budgets must also be in keeping with the goal.

There is a price to sovereignty. The absolute price - the price of life - we paid 40 years ago, with about 200 soldiers. They believed that in the wake of their sacrifice, Jerusalem would remain undivided. Their sacrifice is thus worth the economic and diplomatic price that must be paid to ensure that it was not in vain.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A diet for the soul
How do you start a diet whose first step is to not watch TV for an entire day.
Between the lines
Olmert's testimony to the Winograd committee leave much room for interpretation.
  1.   KEEP DREAMING ISRAELIS 09:26  |  indrajaya 17/05/07
  2.   yawn YAWN fire THE LOSERS AND GET TOUGH !1 09:38  |  paul harris 17/05/07
  3.   Yes, a final solution is needed 09:40  |  Ben 17/05/07
  4.   Despite the disappearance of physical barriers 10:34  |  sh 17/05/07
  5.   Official: Political Zionism is bankrupt 10:37  |  Josh Goldman 17/05/07
  6.   We All Know The Answer. 11:18  |  Terry 17/05/07
  7.   #4 Ben 11:30  |  D 17/05/07
  8.   Of course Jerusalem is ours 11:46  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 17/05/07
  9.   Why couldn´t Jerusalem be a neutral, sovereign City? 11:53  |  Alicia 17/05/07
  10.   A World City 11:54  |  Ben Azai 17/05/07
  11.   Sovereignty 12:04  |  Ralph 17/05/07
  12.   Israel has lost a long time ago. 13:59  |  Andreas 17/05/07
  13.   Present day Jerusalem should become an international entity 14:18  |  Bandar Michaels 17/05/07
  14.   Jerusalem, D. C. 14:27  |  Johnny Weintraub 17/05/07
  15.   Rebuild the Temple: pilgrim tourism will fuel Israeli economy 14:28  |  AV 17/05/07
  16.   End Israeli retreat! 14:31  |  Chaim 17/05/07
  17.   We want bus shuttles to the Temple Mount on Jewish holidays 14:42  |  AV 17/05/07
  18.   re: 7, Ben 15:31  |  Warren J 17/05/07
  19.   re: 7, Ben 15:38  |  Warren J 17/05/07
  20.   #18 Warren 15:40  |  D 17/05/07
  21.   In Tibet 25% of the population are Buddhist monks 16:07  |  AV 17/05/07
  22.   #21 AV 16:20  |  D 17/05/07
  23.   Eerie pice 16:47  |  Jeremiah 17/05/07
  24.   Greed is an ugly thing 17:11  |  Natallie Durson 17/05/07
  25.   1 out of 3 is better than none, Haaretz 17:13  |  Polybios 17/05/07
  26.   ah jerusalem of dreams 17:15  |  will 17/05/07
  27.   Ben Gurion 18:26  |  David Hoffman 17/05/07
  28.   And what about the world Indrajaya et. all? 18:41  |  David Hoffman 17/05/07
  29.   Real and not hyped respect 19:06  |  David Hoffman 17/05/07
  30.   #15: Rebuild the temple?! 19:36  |  Tasha 17/05/07
  31.   sh, wrong, the pantomime is all on your part 20:32  |  Jake 17/05/07
  32.   Polybios, excuse me? 20:37  |  Jake 17/05/07
  33.   jerusalem 21:42  |  Paul 17/05/07
  34.   indrajaya...whether you like it or not.... 22:12  |  maria 17/05/07
  35.   I thought the censorship was for "hate" comments not 22:12  |  Virginia 17/05/07
  36.   natallie durson....that`s the problem...while the exiled jews 22:26  |  maria 17/05/07
  37.   It is not defeatism but realism 22:35  |  Amin Nusseibeh 17/05/07
  38.   read this 22:42  |  person 17/05/07
  39.   #24 NATALLIE AND THE USUAL FICTION COME BACK IN 22:44  |  paul harris 17/05/07
  40.   Maria - fascinating! 22:54  |  Josh Goldman 17/05/07
  41.   Jake 22:54  |  sh 17/05/07
  42.   your "bold, ambitious" strategy already exists 23:13  |  Pssd Off American 17/05/07
  43.   telling the truth is racism to you josh goldman.... 23:42  |  maria 17/05/07
  44.   # 1 - Keep on dreaming, Muslims ! 23:43  |  Paul Henzen 17/05/07
  45.   # 1 - Keep on dreaming, Muslims ! 23:43  |  Paul Henzen 17/05/07
  46.   Natalie Durson 23:49  |  Connie 17/05/07
  47.   # 13 Jerusalem should remain Israeli 23:53  |  Paul Henzen 17/05/07
  48.   # 40 Arabs are NOT indigenous! 00:00  |  Paul Henzen 18/05/07
  49.   I`m the boss and it`s my city.So I am laughing at all you guys... 00:39  |  G-d 18/05/07
  50.   Maria - you should read more 00:43  |  Josh Goldman 18/05/07
  51.   Paul Henzen #48 00:47  |  Tareq 18/05/07
  52.   SEPARATE OURSELVES FROM THE TENT OF SECULAR HUMANISM ?? 00:52  |  Bill. 18/05/07
  53.   # 51 Palestinian gays prefer Israel 01:14  |  Paul Henzen 18/05/07
  54.   East Jerusalem is NOT part of Israel 01:24  |  Fred Farkelsteinman 18/05/07
  55.   # 47 paul henzen 02:29  |  Axel 18/05/07
  56.   Muslim citizens of Jerusalem prefer to be part of Israel 05:15  |  Joe 18/05/07
  57.   sh, perhaps I did not make myself clear enough 06:40  |  Jake 18/05/07
  58.   Jerusalem 06:56  |  Gordon 18/05/07
  59.   Josh Goldman I`m sorry for to remind you 07:35  |  Jake 18/05/07
  60.   Josh Goldman, RE "Ashkenazi arrogance" 07:41  |  Jake 18/05/07
  61.   # 55 Axel - Israel has day zero, too 09:13  |  Paul Henzen 18/05/07
  62.   AV #21 - Tibet, spirituality? 19:12  |  Yehudit 18/05/07
  63.   let the Israelis buy the land 22:24  |  Howie McGregor 19/05/07
  64.   Jerusalem will always be in Isreal 05:35  |  David 20/05/07
 Today Online
Gilad Sharon: Why does Egypt hate us?
Responses: 230
Bradley Burston: Talkbacks are for cowardly bigots
Responses: 614
Amira Hass: The West is punishing only the occupied
Responses: 222
Israeli and British academics meet over proposed boycott
Responses: 294
Survey: 71% of Israelis want U.S. to strike Iran if diplomacy fails
Responses: 290


More Headlines
02:14 Cabinet to mull int'l force at Philadelphi route
03:34 Palestinians: Three killed in IAF strike on vehicle in Gaza
04:51 U.S. pressing Israel to bolster pro-Abbas forces in Gaza
04:32 ANALYSIS: Gaza violence not over for Israel or Palestinians
20:52 Hamas, Fatah gunmen stand down as cease-fire takes hold in Gaza
02:37 Barak aides pressure Pines-Paz, Yatom to bow out of primaries
01:13 Students still undecided on whether or not to accept government's offer
06:36 Ulrta-Orthodox Jewish group declares war on computers
03:52 Database upgrade threatens mental patients' privacy
05:04 Sderot mayor to demand gov't declare state of emergency
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved