Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., May 21, 2007 Sivan 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:25 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Former MK Avigdor Yitzhaki. (Archives)
Last update - 18:10 16/05/2007
New law to require referendum before future Israeli withdrawals
By Shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondent

The Knesset plenum on Wednesday passed a new law requiring a voter referendum before any further Israeli withdrawal from territories. The law was passed in its preliminary reading despite strong opposition, including from the prime minister's bureau.

The law, passed by a margin of 26 MKs for to 18 against, was the initiative of former coalition government head and Kadima MK Avigdor Yitzhaki. MKs Ze'ev Elkin and Marina Solodkin of the Kadima faction voted in favor of the law, as did head of the Labor faction Yoram Marciano and fellow Labor MKs Avishay Braverman and Orit Noked.

The law was supported by a concerted effort on the part of a lobby for the Golan Heights communities, who maintain that a potential Israeli withdrawal from the Golan Heights will be much less likely to occur if it will require the approval of a national referendum.

Advertisement

A law written by MK David Rotem (Yisrael Beitenu) and MK Zevulon Orlev (NRP) was also passed by the Knesset plenum during its preliminary reading on Wednesday. The law would require MKs to pledge their devotion to keeping Israel "a Jewish and democratic state, both in character and symbolism."

The law is one of a number of new legislative measures taken against Arab MKs after the revelation that the security establishment suspects former-MK Azmi Bishara (Balad) of assisting Hezbollah during the Second Lebanon War.

During the debate in the General Assembly, MK Zehava Gal-on (Meretz) called the law "a fascist law" and MK Ahmad Tibi (Ra'am-Ta'al) said that "soon enough they'll require us to wear a uniform."

MK Rotem stated that if faith in the State of Israel is fascist, "then I'm a fascist."

MK Orlev added that the passing of the law signified "a great day for the Knesset and the State of Israel. Zionism won. The Knesset has proven that it is not ready to commit suicide."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Peretz's role
The DM could bridge gaps between elites and the masses who vote Netanyahu.
Winning campaign
A commercial featuring Stephen Hawking was voted the best ad campaign of 2006
  1.   Referendum 16:23  |  Brod 16/05/07
  2.   sense AT LAST no more idiotic disengagements 16:43  |  paul harris 16/05/07
  3.   Two Victories for democracy 16:57  |  Freedom 16/05/07
  4.   the left are upset because they hate democracy 17:22  |  lars 16/05/07
  5.   Mazal Tov 17:26  |  Ofer 16/05/07
  6.   Democracy? 17:34  |  steve 16/05/07
  7.   #6 LOL, are you going to leave US to give your land totheIndians? 17:42  |  LOL 16/05/07
  8.   Loyalty pledge = right to hold office? Vote? 18:27  |  Omran 16/05/07
  9.   CHAP 329 OF SHULKHAN ARUKH PROHIBITS CONSESSIONS AS LIFE THREATS! 18:30  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 16/05/07
  10.   NATIONAL OPINION CAN BE FOOLED. ONLY SHULKHAN ARUKH IS FOOLPROOF! 18:31  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 16/05/07
  11.   Make the Law RETROACTIVE 18:31  |  * BEN JABO 16/05/07
  12.   allegiance 18:32  |  ken 16/05/07
  13.   Steve #6 18:34  |  JJ 16/05/07
  14.   and what was the position of other 76 MK`s 18:45  |  misha 16/05/07
  15.   #13 What country is the epitome of following "international law"? 18:45  |  Question 16/05/07
  16.   More shoddy reporting by Haaretz 18:51  |  Polybios 16/05/07
  17.   #7 not the same 18:54  |  Point 16/05/07
  18.   No. 7--lol 18:56  |  steve 16/05/07
  19.   no. 15 18:58  |  steve 16/05/07
  20.   To # 7 18:58  |  Mick 16/05/07
  21.   re 14 ... 19:04  |  JW 16/05/07
  22.   Dangerous law 19:07  |  Esther 16/05/07
  23.   let everyone part of Israel`s polity vote 19:07  |  Jeff Goldman 16/05/07
  24.   A couple of steps in the right direction 19:13  |  Chaim 16/05/07
  25.   So Glad to read this! Thank you Israeli Knesset! 19:26  |  Alicia 16/05/07
  26.   A step in the right direction. 19:31  |  Avrum 16/05/07
  27.   Finally a bit of good news! 19:44  |  Simon Kaye 16/05/07
  28.   Aw, Now Ain`t That Just Too Bad! 19:48  |  Jeff Northridge 16/05/07
  29.   Re # 22 , Esther , Dangerous Law 20:03  |  Henk 16/05/07
  30.   #6 Steve 20:05  |  * BEN JABO 16/05/07
  31.   Will some MK please run for Pres of the USA? 20:39  |  Jim 16/05/07
  32.   # 15 Answer 20:47  |  Jim 16/05/07
  33.   #29 Henk from Petach Tikva 21:06  |  Jim 16/05/07
  34.   For #29 Henk 21:07  |  Esther 16/05/07
  35.   BEN JABO 21:40  |  Moury 16/05/07
  36.   Halleluyah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 21:53  |  me 16/05/07
  37.   To #22, Dangerous ignorance should be your topic 21:56  |  me 16/05/07
  38.   #30 Also, you Americans stole Hawaii 22:09  |  Hehe 16/05/07
  39.   referendum & Loyalty 22:30  |  Michael 16/05/07
  40.   Jewish and Democratic state 23:11  |  AMerican 16/05/07
  41.   GIVE BACK TEXAS AND CALI, AND NEW MEXICO... 23:23  |  yonatan ezra 16/05/07
  42.   HOPEFULLY MORE GOOD LAWS WILL FOLLOW! 23:26  |  yishay banatz 16/05/07
  43.   #35 Moury 23:42  |  * BEN JABO 16/05/07
  44.   no. 38--Hehe 23:50  |  steve 16/05/07
  45.   The German word for it is Gleichschaltung 23:51  |  John 16/05/07
  46.   No law at all 23:51  |  Axel 16/05/07
  47.   Israeli law is not above international law 00:14  |  Jeff 17/05/07
  48.   # 43 ben jabo 00:27  |  Axel 17/05/07
  49.   To American # 40 00:38  |  christa 17/05/07
  50.   Q15 01:09  |  JJ 17/05/07
  51.   Both laws are good! 01:21  |  Hal 17/05/07
  52.   Sorry for once can someone clarify 01:24  |  rich 17/05/07
  53.   American 01:53  |  rich 17/05/07
  54.   Reponse to Ben Jabo 02:27  |  Sylvia 17/05/07
  55.   New law to require referendum before future Israeli withdrawals 02:46  |  alex 17/05/07
  56.   #32 Jim touche... 02:46  |  MLK 17/05/07
  57.   #40 AMerican 02:50  |  MLK 17/05/07
  58.   So Israel still thinks it can keep an indefinite occupation? 02:54  |  Johnboy 17/05/07
  59.   #44 AXEL PLEASE OPEN YOUR EYES 02:57  |  MLK 17/05/07
  60.   A Two-Edged Sword 03:01  |  Mark of Lewiston 17/05/07
  61.   Good show, mates!! 03:49  |  Webster 17/05/07
  62.   Democracy 04:58  |  Gordon 17/05/07
  63.   # 5 Ofer, I`m with you, Mazal Tov indeed!!! 05:46  |  Virginia 17/05/07
  64.   # 47 Israeli law, maybe not. God`s Law, absolutely. His Word is 05:49  |  Virginia 17/05/07
  65.   The Real Deal 08:37  |  MLK 17/05/07
  66.   # 59 MLK 11:25  |  Axel 17/05/07
  67.   #48 Axel`s words of wisdom (LOL) 15:59  |  * BEN JABO 17/05/07
  68.   Was this an answer for me, Ben Jabo? 16:26  |  Axel 17/05/07
  69.   BEN JABO #67 23:13  |  Moury 17/05/07
  70.   Democracy 00:57  |  Inigo Montoya 18/05/07
  71.   #69 Moury 16:55  |  * BEN JABO 18/05/07
  72.   zionism=racism 18:44  |  A. 19/05/07
  73.   racism 19:04  |  A. 19/05/07
  74.   #72 A 22:15  |  * BEN JABO 20/05/07
  75.   #67 Ben Jabo 06:00  |  Sam 21/05/07
  76.   #75 Sam - I hate to tell you 08:02  |  * BEN JABO 21/05/07
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: And now, the IDF's killing of an unborn child
Responses: 296
David Chinitz: Sitting on the Holocaust - Jews, Germans, Iran
Responses: 74
Cabinet decides to continue strikes against Hamas
Responses: 216
Editorial: Painful sanctions must be imposed on Iran
Responses: 69
Ultra-Orthodox Jewish group declares war on computers
Responses: 50
Rosner's Domain
* What binds America and Israel together?
* New Guest: The 2008 candidates lack in foreign policy experience
* The challenge of the Fort Dix six
* For U.S.-Israel relations, Yitzhak Rabin was best


More Headlines
07:31 U.S. policy turnabout may enable Israeli-Syrian talks
07:26 Nine die in IAF Gaza strikes, 8 of them in home of Hamas official
08:19 Herzog's aid plan for Holocaust survivors draws criticism
08:25 Palestinian group urges Rolling Stones to boycott Israel
07:36 Sderot