Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., June 22, 2007 Tamuz 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:58 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Forty years of 'unity'
By Haaretz Editorial

What a pity that we can't convert into shekels the lip service public figures have been paying for 40 years to the slogan "united Jerusalem." The sea of words that has been spilled over the biblical reference to Jerusalem as a city that has been "joined together" could have filled the deep and gaping chasm between East Jerusalem and West Jerusalem.

As every year, the joy of Jerusalem Day, which is commemorated today, will skip over a significant portion of the city's residents. All that is left of the annexation of Palestinian neighborhoods to the western, Israeli part of Jerusalem is a dry Knesset law, government decisions that lack substance, and the blue national identity cards that symbolize Israeli residency.

Jerusalem Day reminds a third of the 730,000 residents of the ostensibly united city that they are second-class citizens - or, worse still, a "demographic problem." Israel has separated them from their brothers in the West Bank and has made no effort to give them the feeling that they are wanted here.

Advertisement

After listening to the flowery speeches of the politicians and city leaders about the removal of barriers between the eastern and western sections of Jerusalem, the celebrants are advised to cross the line that marked the city's border until the Six-Day War. A few hundred meters from the Western-looking areas of West Jerusalem, they will discover neglected neighborhoods and dilapidated infrastructure, poverty and overcrowding, unemployment and despair. These are the outcome of 40 years of deliberate discrimination. In practice, more than 30 percent of Jerusalem's population receives just 10 percent of the city's budget.

In the new neighborhoods established for the Jewish population in the "united Jerusalem," not one child stays home because of a shortage of classrooms. By contrast, some 15,000 children in East Jerusalem are not registered with the education authorities in the city due to a shortage of more than 1,300 classrooms. It's no wonder that half the high school students in East Jerusalem drop out of school.

East Jerusalem is also home to 75.8 percent of the poor children in the city. Some 22 percent of East Jerusalem residents - about 31,600 people - are under the care of the municipality's welfare services, and 62 percent of families there live below the poverty line.

The construction of the West Bank separation fence has allowed the government to revise the borders of Jerusalem, which were drawn in the heat of the city's capture, and separate from hastily annexed Arab neighborhoods. However, the politicians are sticking to their shallow slogans. Fearing that their rivals will accuse them of dividing Jerusalem, they perpetuate the deprivation of a third of its residents; some 55,000 East Jerusalem Arabs who hold blue identity cards and live in the "Jerusalem envelope" area have found themselves on the other side of the fence, cut off from the city's municipal center.

Ehud Barak was the first prime minister who suggested dividing the city based on the principle of what the Jews have the Jews get, and what the Arabs have the Arabs get. The Clinton plan, the Geneva Accord and the Arab peace initiative also propose a similar basis for dividing the city. It would befit Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, who was a senior partner to the failure when he served as mayor of Jerusalem, to replace the slogan of unity with a reasonable and fair policy for division of the city.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Professional help
Offering the finance portfolio to a successful businessman is tempting, but unwise.
Palm qualms
Palm trees planted along a stretch of Ibn Gvirol Street have irked residents.
  1.   A Jewish Jerusalem is better for Seculars 09:52  |  AV 16/05/07
  2.   We want bus rides to the Temple Mount on Jewish holidays! 09:55  |  AV 16/05/07
  3.   HAARETZ EDITORIAL ON UNITY OF JERUSALEM 10:03  |  ESTHER KANDEL 16/05/07
  4.   Reason against ideology or a little test for everybody....... 10:29  |  Swiss (Dino) 16/05/07
  5.   time to face reality 10:46  |  Peter 16/05/07
  6.   Yom Yerushalayim 10:48  |  Anthony Warshaw 16/05/07
  7.   Haaretz wants Jerusalem to be like Gaza 11:41  |  Ken Jurist 16/05/07
  8.   The "Clinton plan" for Jerusalem was my idea and now I reject it. 11:42  |  David Eli Barchas 16/05/07
  9.   If Hamas rules the Arab neighborhoods- or even Fatah does 12:01  |  Shalom Freedman 16/05/07
  10.   Haaretz Editorial 12:01  |  Moshe Kanzen 16/05/07
  11.   Why would Olmert - promoter of racist Jerusalem policies - do it? 12:39  |  www.kibush.co.il 16/05/07
  12.   As if the Current PM Could Even Hold a Pen 14:25  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 16/05/07
  13.   Who will control the other side??Not the PA!! 14:27  |  Dr Alon 16/05/07
  14.   Willing to Give Up the Whole Enchalada 14:42  |  Jane 16/05/07
  15.   East, Central & West Jerusalem, One Holy City 14:44  |  Bandar Michaels 16/05/07
  16.   Same thing is true of Tel Aviv and most other cities 14:52  |  Johnny Weintraub 16/05/07
  17.   MORE NONSENSE FROM HAARETZ ? WHY ? 15:08  |  paul harris 16/05/07
  18.   division of Yerushalayim 15:19  |  bear 16/05/07
  19.   More Questions than Answers 15:20  |  Ronnie Wolman 16/05/07
  20.   Listen Up Haaretz 15:21  |  Elizabeth 16/05/07
  21.   Forty Years of United Jerusalem 15:24  |  Mitchell 16/05/07
  22.   HA-ARETZ RIGHT HAND IS GONE 15:41  |  abram 16/05/07
  23.   Jewish for Jews Arab for Arabs Too Simple! 16:07  |  Ben 16/05/07
  24.   EnchIlada 16:20  |  Sho 16/05/07
  25.   Divide! Divide! Divide! 16:20  |  christoph 16/05/07
  26.   Jerusalem 16:29  |  Brod 16/05/07
  27.   Divide it fairly, or unite it as a city for All. 16:35  |  Abe Hayeem 16/05/07
  28.   55,000 Arabs in Jerusalem is 55,000 more than the 16:51  |  CHick Corea 16/05/07
  29.   Swiss #4 16:55  |  Polybios 16/05/07
  30.   Anthony Warshaw 17:07  |  Polybios 16/05/07
  31.   JERUSALEM IS SALAM NOT SALAMI 17:10  |  Emanuel 16/05/07
  32.   united Jerusalem 17:17  |  Ellen Rosser 16/05/07
  33.   Ordinary men like Meshal and Haniyeh... (to #25) 17:18  |  christoph 16/05/07
  34.   The zero sum game of the misguided Israelis. 17:33  |  Ibrahim 16/05/07
  35.   Arabs already have 21 capital cities. Yerusahlyim I-SHELANU 17:44  |  Feiglin Supporter 16/05/07
  36.   BRILLIANT, NEXT DAY KASSAMS START FLYING 18:54  |  Jorge 16/05/07
  37.   Haaretz is nuts! 19:05  |  Chaim 16/05/07
  38.   To Moshe Kanzen 19:39  |  Otto Rand 16/05/07
  39.   To Dr. Alon: a great formula for peace! 19:50  |  Otto Rand 16/05/07
  40.   Echa 20:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/05/07
  41.   In Denial About the Realities of Jerusalem 21:03  |  Smadar 16/05/07
  42.   Divide and fall 21:47  |  The Other Alan 16/05/07
  43.   Smadar, indeed Kollek did #41 22:44  |  Yaakov Sullivan 16/05/07
  44.   #10 23:56  |  alan 16/05/07
  45.   Jerusalem is holy to Jews only 00:00  |  Hal 17/05/07
  46.   DOES HA`ARETZ DARE PUBLISH THIS LETTER ????? 00:07  |  Wendy 17/05/07
  47.   Forty Years of FREEDOM 00:49  |  Dr David I. Gross 17/05/07
  48.   #28 02:18  |  kiwi girl 17/05/07
  49.   Chaim is nuts!!!! 02:29  |  kiwi girl 17/05/07
  50.   Al Quds is in our hands 02:42  |  Amin Nusseibeh 17/05/07
  51.   Muslim citizens of Jerusalem want to be part of Israel 04:33  |  Joe 17/05/07
  52.   A PIECE OF THE CAKE FOR PALESTINIANS 04:36  |  juan 17/05/07
  53.   Yaakov Sullivan #43 04:41  |  Smadar 17/05/07
  54.   Why keep showing the Dome of the Rock in pictures, in Haaretz 05:23  |  Leena Ades 17/05/07
  55.   Jerusalem is one city. No separation 05:33  |  Jason 17/05/07
  56.   40 Years of Fragmented "Egyptian" Unity, now ascend to "Israel" f 05:46  |  Leena Ades 17/05/07
  57.   to the Kiwi Girl 06:13  |  Hj 17/05/07
  58.   kiwi girl 06:58  |  Connie 17/05/07
  59.   I MADE A PROMISE ON MY WEDDING DAY SO DID YOU 07:15  |  JOSEPH B 17/05/07
  60.   HEART ATTACK on Israel 08:42  |  Wendy 17/05/07
  61.   Too bad the Arabs don`t want to join as equal loyal citizens 09:02  |  Reuven 17/05/07
  62.   Connie 09:09  |  kiwi girl 17/05/07
  63.   SOME PEOPLE DON`T KNOW WHAT JERUSALEM IS! 09:11  |  SPTZ 17/05/07
  64.   "Kiwi" Racism . . . 09:16  |  Wendy 17/05/07
  65.   to JOSEPH B #59 09:35  |  zeev 17/05/07
  66.   65# Zeev Time to tell us are you on drugs ? 06:10  |  Akram Zekaria 19/05/07
  67.   Hal - Who cares? 18:42  |  Me me me 19/05/07
  68.   to Akram Zekaria #66 - part 1 19:25  |  zeev 19/05/07
  69.   to Akram Zekaria #66 - part 2/2 23:28  |  zeev 19/05/07
  70.   1)68&69#Zeev. Let us both talk clean. 02:22  |  Akram Zekaria 20/05/07
  71.   2)68&69# Let us both talk clean. 03:06  |  Akram Zekaria 20/05/07
  72.   to Akram Zekaria #70 - part 1 12:10  |  zeev 20/05/07
  73.   to Akram Zekaria #70 - part 2 12:12  |  zeev 20/05/07
  74.   72/3# Zeev.The road to Peace shorter than a second diaspora. 01:47  |  Akram Zekaria 21/05/07
  75.   SPTZ : Haaretz Must Explain !? 02:31  |  Akram Zekaria UK 21/05/07
  76.   HAARETZ MUST EXPLAN !? 07:23  |  Akram Zekaria 21/05/07
  77.   to Akram Zekaria #74 17:57  |  zeev 21/05/07
  78.   we are tenants on land that G-D says is His 19:18  |  hierokeryx 21/05/07
  79.   77# Zeev. 13:27  |  Akram Zekaria 22/05/07
  80.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - part 3/3 10:20  |  zeev 24/05/07
  81.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - part 2 17:05  |  zeev 24/05/07
  82.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - part 1 12:10  |  zeev 25/05/07
  83.   to Akram Zekaria #79 - and something else 12:14  |  zeev 25/05/07
  84.   Arab East Jerusalem 20:35  |  Joseph 22/06/07
 Today Online
Burston: They're here, they're queer, be proud of Israel
Responses: 108
Move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Responses: 108
Shmuel Rosner: Is there an alternative to a Palestinian state?
Responses: 58
Yossi Sarid: U.K. boycotters should boycott themselves
Responses: 117
Asher Maoz: ACRI must challenge view of Jewish state as 'foolish' idea
Responses: 35


More Headlines
18:08 Abbas sacks top Fatah security chief after Hamas victory in Gaza
17:08 House okays Egypt aid cut over Gaza smuggling, human rights
15:47 Lieberman slams plan to free PA tax funds as gesture to Abbas
18:26 Hamas: Abbas won't be able to wipe out Hamas' sovereignty
14:36 Security forces nab 'Hezbollah-trained' suspect in W. Bank raid
20:39 Hamas says will not block deal to drill for natural gas off Gaza shore
14:46 Report: Iran says it has 100 kg 'enriched uranium materials'
19:25 Woman killed, four seriously injured in blaze in southern Tel Aviv
15:59 Scholars mark 60th anniversary of publication of Anne Frank`s Diary
13:36 U.S.-led move to back Abbas gov't blocked in Security Council
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Israeli History Documentaries.
Own a piece of Israel?s treasured past.
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved