Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., May 31, 2007 Sivan 14, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:53 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 13:54 15/05/2007
Israel's worst blunders since '67 - and the Arabs'
By Bradley Burston


Given the cultural gulf between Israel and the English-speaking world, it could just be that the entire Hebrew language is, in fact, untranslatable.

Certain words, in any event, defy transmission into English. One of them is mech'dal, a blunder of colossal dimension, a historic mistake that is, no less, a betrayal, a breach of sacred trust.

All Israelis have their personal list of mech'dalim perpetuated by their government, their military, and others in positions of authority affected them and, frequently, embittering their very lives. Here is one:

October, 1973: Government fails to heed warnings of war.

Result: Israel unprepared for Yom Kippur War, in which more than 2,600 IDF soldiers were killed. The widespread feeling that the government had forsaken its duties spurred widespread alienation on the left, and fueled the messianism of the settlement movement.

Prime suspects: Defense Minister Moshe Dayan and Prime Minister Golda Meir.

November, 1995: Yitzhak Rabin assassinated

Result: Peace process with Palestinians enters ultimately mortal downward spiral. Polarization between religious right and secular left builds dramatically.

Prime suspects in failure to anticipate and prevent assassination: Shin Bet security service, then headed by Carmi Gillon, and undercover agent Avishai Raviv of the Shin Bet department monitoring Jewish extremism.

June, 1982 and after: Conduct of the First Lebanon War

Result: Broad dissension on Israeli home front, exacerbated by continuing casualties during 18-year occupation. Sabra and Shatilla killings by Israel's allies caused worldwide condemnation of Israel.

Prime suspect: Ariel Sharon.

July, 2006: Conduct of the Second Lebanon War

Result: Loss of Israeli deterrent capability, possibly far-reaching implications for Western attempts to curb terrorism and armed Islamist groups. Loss of faith on the part of civilians under Hezbollah rocket attack, and on the part of soldiers sent to war without clear orders, or proper equipment, arms and food and water.

Prime suspects: Ehud Olmert, Amir Peretz, Dan Halutz.

May, 2000 & August, 2005: Withdrawal without negotiations

Result: Loss of deterrent capability, boosting image of Hezbollah and Hamas as victors over Israel. Effectively, a slap to moderate Arab leaders who favor negotiations. In the case of Lebanon, pullout was slap to Israel's militia allies. In the case of Gaza, pullout caused sharp polarization within the IDF and the wider society. Subsequent attacks by armed Palestinians and Hezbollah ended efforts for further withdrawals.

Prime suspects: Ehud Barak, Sharon.

September, 2000: Allowing Sharon to visit the Temple Mount

Result: A Palestinian uprising which saw thousands of deaths, including that of the peace process.

Prime Suspect: Ehud Barak.

April-May, 1968: Gov't allows Jews to settle near Hebron

Result: Settler movement establishes principle that settlers, and not the government, will set the agenda for new settlement - regardless of the consequences of the choice of location - and that actions which may violate the law will be rewarded in the end with legalization and ex post facto authorization.

In the end, the settlement map was constructed, in part, to stymie efforts to cede land in peace agreements.

Prime Suspects: Labor governments of the late 1960s and early and mid-1970s, with Sharon later spearheading expansion.

1996 - present: Israeli leaders' displays of disrespect for Palestinian counterparts

Result: Often gratuitous mishandling of peace negotiations, encouraging mutual violations of signed agreements.

II. Sample of top blunders of the Palestinians:

1. They believed the world.

The world has always acted as though it supports the Palestinians, and wants to aid them to succeed.

In reality, the world has done precious little to aid them.

2. They believed the Muslim world

See 1 above.

3. They believed Arafat

He lied to them, allowing them to believe, among other peace process planks, that the right of return was attainable. He also led them to believe that they, and not his Fatah colleagues, would be the primary economic beneficiaries of peace.

4. They believed Nasrallah

He promised, shortly before the outbreak of the Al-Aqsa intifada, that Israel, when attacked, would collapse like a spider's web.

5. They believed that suicide bombings and Qassam attacks would aid the Palestinian cause.

_______________


Recent blogs:

The Arabs will never forgive us
Confessions of an anti-German racist
Israel - Love it or leave it
To Hamas, for Independence Day

__________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Taste the city
From French fries to calamari rings to health food, the Taste of the City Festival has it all.
Far from immaterial
Comme il faut embarks on a new approach to fashion this summer, gimmicks intact.
  1.   THIS IS THE FIRST MECH`DAL SINCE `67 12:14  |  indrajaya 15/05/07
  2.   NONSENSE.The Arabs never made any mistakes.Self delusion means 12:15  |  PETER SM 15/05/07
  3.   Oslo 1993 Bringing terrorist Army into Israel 12:19  |  Shalom Freedman 15/05/07
  4.   2008: Israelis are voting Netanyahu into office 12:31  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/05/07
  5.   Oslo clearly the biggest blunder!!!! 12:46  |  Dr Alon 15/05/07
  6.   very well said, mr burston 12:50  |  eric 15/05/07
  7.   the biggest catastrophe of them all ;this colomn!!! 13:03  |  r 15/05/07
  8.   doctor alon 13:20  |  A.M. 15/05/07
  9.   To Swiss (Dino) 13:28  |  dr Alon 15/05/07
  10.   Lots of Self Guilt, Avoids The Point 13:40  |  Dyinglikeflies 15/05/07
  11.   Blunder: Failing to legislate a constitution 13:56  |  Joe Sittizen 15/05/07
  12.   To AM/swiss Dino - Oslo accords 13:58  |  Dr Alon 15/05/07
  13.   # 9 Dr Alon (1) 14:01  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/05/07
  14.   Better to be silent , than to prove foolery 14:03  |  dov epstein 15/05/07
  15.   Better to be silent , than to prove foolery 14:04  |  dov epstein 15/05/07
  16.   # 9 Dr Alon (2) 14:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/05/07
  17.   dyinglike flies, don`t be so cranky 14:14  |  newageblues 15/05/07
  18.   Sharon or Marwan Barghouti? 14:23  |  Barry 15/05/07
  19.   What would Israel´s Motivation be, Dino? 14:27  |  Garfunkel 15/05/07
  20.   The original sin 14:27  |  Marilyn 15/05/07
  21.   # 15, DINO 14:38  |  indrajaya 15/05/07
  22.   To Dino (Swiss) 14:39  |  Bandar Michaels 15/05/07
  23.   # 19 Garfunkel 14:44  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/05/07
  24.   Major blunders missing 14:49  |  Jan Elshout 15/05/07
  25.   The Biggest Blunder of the Palestinians 15:09  |  Ronnie Wolman 15/05/07
  26.   to #24 15:34  |  Realist Don 15/05/07
  27.   bunglers 15:51  |  habakook 15/05/07
  28.   Bander Michaels 15:58  |  Jeremy Woolf 15/05/07
  29.   Main blunders 16:15  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 15/05/07
  30.   Blunder of Wolman # 25 16:24  |  Jan Elshout 15/05/07
  31.   Israel`s Blunders 17:02  |  Yosemite 15/05/07
  32.   # 10 Dyinglikeflies - The odd thing is, the disagreements come 17:52  |  Virginia 15/05/07
  33.   The biggest blunder was Iraq 19:03  |  Libnanee 15/05/07
  34.   Mechdal 2008 20:31  |  Tom S 15/05/07
  35.   Always with the guilt 20:38  |  tadchase 15/05/07
  36.   # 21/22 indrajaya / Bandar Michaels 20:52  |  Swiss (Dino) 15/05/07
  37.   There is an English equivalent to mikhdal 21:01  |  Michael N 15/05/07
  38.   Israel`s BEST moves since 1967? and the Arabs? 21:33  |  S 15/05/07
  39.   The biggest blunder was the establishment of The State of Israel! 21:36  |  Toronto`s Finest 15/05/07
  40.   Pretty good list 21:48  |  Robert Farrell 15/05/07
  41.   Bradley missed the worst blunder 22:03  |  Phil B 15/05/07
  42.   Torontos finest#39 22:28  |  Danite 15/05/07
  43.   THE worst blunder.... 22:33  |  Ah 15/05/07
  44.   Mr. BB: apportioning blame 22:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 15/05/07
  45.   Blunders 23:20  |  P. J. Casey 15/05/07
  46.   You Forgot The Father Of All The Mistakes on The Arab Side 23:40  |  Tim R 15/05/07
  47.   Jan`s simplistic mind @#30 23:43  |  whomever 15/05/07
  48.   #46, Tim R 23:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 15/05/07
  49.   WRONG FROM DAY ONE 00:06  |  Dr. David I. Gross 16/05/07
  50.   Terrible column, Bradley; the REAL worst blunders ... 00:09  |  sk 16/05/07
  51.   Snafu has not been a common word since the 40`s 00:17  |  What? 16/05/07
  52.   So much effort to criticize Jews 00:53  |  Efox 16/05/07
  53.   What Burston is really trying to do 00:59  |  Chick Corea 16/05/07
  54.   I think your talkback is broken on "To Fly or Not To Fly Flags" 01:29  |  Virginia 16/05/07
  55.   Major War Crimes 01:51  |  Friendof Palestine 16/05/07
  56.   Another Blunder: Believing Ha`aretz articles? 02:45  |  Yoram 16/05/07
  57.   Israel`s Worst Blunders 03:12  |  William Crane 16/05/07
  58.   Blunders 03:13  |  GABE! 16/05/07
  59.   You Make It Sound So Simple 04:03  |  Tony Anthony 16/05/07
  60.   the Settlements/Occupation 04:35  |  Steve 16/05/07
  61.   God Bless Jerry Fallwell 05:00  |  Yosemite 16/05/07
  62.   To Dr. Alon: Oslo 05:29  |  Otto Rand 16/05/07
  63.   To Mr. Crane from Virginia 05:57  |  Otto Rand 16/05/07
  64.   The short of it you are a blander Bradley ! 07:10  |  Akram Zekaria 16/05/07
  65.   # 61, YOSEMITE 08:05  |  indrajaya 16/05/07
  66.   Irrational! 08:33  |  An Arab Neighbor 16/05/07
  67.   We Expect Better 09:16  |  ERSB 16/05/07
  68.   # 52 hey efox; the answer is simple 09:44  |  eric 16/05/07
  69.   Indrajaya You`re A Smart Guy But... 2nd Try! 10:02  |  Yosemite 16/05/07
  70.   Israel`s fundamental mistake 11:18  |  Andrew Watson 16/05/07
  71.   Bradley goes round in circles 13:04  |  Michel 16/05/07
  72.   # 69, YOSEMITE 13:51  |  indrajaya 16/05/07
  73.   Sharon`s Start of the 2nd Intafada 17:58  |  Daniel 16/05/07
  74.   New law to require referendum before future Israeli withdrawals 20:06  |  Boycott 16/05/07
  75.   Tim R #46 20:24  |  S 16/05/07
  76.   We are a nation of one chance. 21:51  |  Akram Zekaria 16/05/07
  77.   First Mech`dal is lack of global Israeli Satellite TV 22:22  |  Roberto Feldmann 16/05/07
  78.   Indrajaya You Are Right! 22:32  |  Yosemite 16/05/07
  79.   Israel`s worst blunder- electing a Kadima led govt. 23:42  |  common sense 16/05/07
  80.   Indrajaya You`re Making My Life Miserable 00:06  |  Yosemite 17/05/07
  81.   gross simplicity 00:28  |  jake 17/05/07
  82.   Hodge podge of thoughts.. 00:57  |  Ruben Misrahi 17/05/07
  83.   Biggest Blunder of the Arabs 08:03  |  Margie in Tel Aviv