Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 15, 2007 Iyyar 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:10 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 09:30 14/05/2007
Extend the truce to the West Bank
By Danny Rubinstein

It is doubtful that there are any reasonable military means for stopping the firing of Qassam missiles at Israel. However, it is perfectly clear to all Palestinian spokesmen, as well as to a good many Israelis, that there is only one diplomatic way to stop the Qassam attacks, and that is to extend the fragile truce in Gaza to the West Bank as well. To put this more clearly: It is necessary to stop preventive actions taken by the Israel Defense Forces in Judea and Samaria. This assessment is based on recent political developments in the Palestinian camp.

The Palestinians are anxiously awaiting progress concerning the Arab peace initiative. King Abdullah of Jordan's visit to Ramallah - which did not go ahead as planned yesterday - and expected visits by the foreign ministers of Egypt and Jordan to Israel, have raised hopes. All of this, however, cannot solve the problem of the security chaos that prevails in the territories, or dispel the fears of an imminent Israel attack. This is the reason that Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas (Abu Mazen) spent time in Gaza last week: It was an attempt to establish or to renew the truce with Israel.

In this context a meeting was held of representatives of the large organizations - Hamas, Fatah, Islamic Jihad, the Popular Front and the Democratic Front - chaired by Palestinian Member of Parliament Ibrahim Abu Naja. They made a decision that calls for observing the cease-fire under three conditions: The first is that it apply everywhere - that is, also in the West Bank. The second is that it be reciprocal: Israel will refrain from any military activity in the territories. The third: that the cease-fire will take effect simultaneously, on the Palestinian side as well as Israel's.

Advertisement

The innovation in this decision is a certain change in the position of the Fatah movement Abu Mazen heads, and whose stance is approaching the positions of the other organizations. In the past, after the Israeli withdrawal from the Gaza Strip, Fatah activists were saying it was necessary to maintain quiet in the liberated area, and to invest efforts in development and the welfare of the inhabitants. This position was congruent with the Israeli view, which sought to create a differentiation between the West Bank and Gaza. That is, the IDF would stop acting inside the Gaza Strip, but would continue its routine military activity in the West Bank.

Indeed, during the entire period that has elapsed since the disengagement from Gaza, on every morning news broadcast there are reports of incursions, arrests, exchanges of fire and even targeted assassinations the IDF is carrying out in the various parts of the West Bank. The first to start reacting in Gaza to attacks on their people in the West Bank have been activists of Islamic Jihad. In recent days Hamas militants have followed in their footsteps, and now it appears that Fatah is also moving in the same direction. In other words, all the Palestinian organizations are now rejecting the Israeli attempt to separate the West Bank from Gaza, and are also promising that for every Israeli action in the West Bank, they will retaliate in the Strip. This is the context of the increased firing of Qassams in recent weeks.

The prevailing Israeli argument has been that the IDF has to act in the West Bank because that is where the terror cells that prepare suicide attacks are organized. It is difficult to accept this argument because preparation for such attacks inside Israel is going full steam ahead not only in the West Bank, but also in the Gaza Strip and southern Lebanon and undoubtedly also in Syria.

There is a series of reasons, diplomatic and other, that the government of Israel is not sending the IDF to act against everyone who is organizing to harm us, and it is definitely possible to use these reasons to explain what goes on in Jenin, Nablus and Tul Karm as well. In other words, the government of Israel can and should try the diplomatic way to stop the firing of the Qassams - by agreeing to expand the truce to the West Bank as well.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Musical machine gun
Jazz musician Peter Brotzmann says music can change a person's way of thinking.
Change the ethos
Instead of amending the anthem, more money should be invested in orchestras.
  1.   Experience:Concessions don`t help. Advice of Rubinstein: 09:58  |  Vittorio 14/05/07
  2.   The ONLY Thing That Brings Peace Is Military Force 10:31  |  Yishai Kohen 14/05/07
  3.   Peekaboo! 10:41  |  The Eyes 14/05/07
  4.   A masterly statement of the obvious 10:54  |  Johnboy 14/05/07
  5.   Israel is too arrogant and too megalomaniac to accept parity with 11:19  |  Suzan 14/05/07
  6.   #4 Nice sentiments Johnboy but 11:19  |  Adrian de Klerk 14/05/07
  7.   Gawd, Dont` Israeli`s get tired of the IDF 11:24  |  Marilyn 14/05/07
  8.   what truce in Gaza?? What extention?? to Qassams from tulkarem? 11:29  |  Nathan 14/05/07
  9.   6: Wow, Suzan joins JB in stupidity and hate. Welcome! 11:37  |  David Teich 14/05/07
  10.   One must be a fool to believe that a truce will stop the Qassams 11:42  |  David G 14/05/07
  11.   Like "truces" that stopped rockets from Lebanon & Gaza? 11:50  |  Michigan 14/05/07
  12.   Feiglin will stop the Kassams in 3 days bycutting off Aza` water 12:44  |  No Water = No Enemy 14/05/07
  13.   Another Nail 12:49  |  Coffin 14/05/07
  14.   doubletalk 13:12  |  tom 14/05/07
  15.   A MONDAY MORNING COMEDY FROM HAARETZ 13:27  |  paul harris 14/05/07
  16.   So each cracker ends up 13:37  |  Marilyn 14/05/07
  17.   To all those who claim diplomacy won`t work 13:40  |  Tzfonit 14/05/07
  18.   Truce with whom? 15:08  |  Daniel 14/05/07
  19.   JOHNBOY: Just cause the Palestinians see... 15:27  |  Brant 14/05/07
  20.   Three cheers for the chamalogim 15:31  |  Meir 14/05/07
  21.   #17 GASP GASP THEY KILL EACH OTHER 15:34  |  paul harris 14/05/07
  22.   To stop kassams from Gaza 15:40  |  martyrmaker 14/05/07
  23.   Take back the lands we never should have abandoned. 16:06  |  Chaim 14/05/07
  24.   #5 Suzan`s fantasy world 16:37  |  Polybios 14/05/07
  25.   Rubinstein`s illogical self-contradictions 16:59  |  Polybios 14/05/07
  26.   Rubinstein`s delusion (#2) 17:33  |  Polybios 14/05/07
  27.   Leaving WBank before civilization hits the Palis is suicide 17:38  |  The Equalizer 14/05/07
  28.   Little wizdom, truce & peace are two way streets 17:42  |  Abu Samra 14/05/07
  29.   Fallacious argument 17:52  |  Brod 14/05/07
  30.   67 Borders - SWEET Dreams 18:22  |  Dr Alon 14/05/07
  31.   Peace in our times, again 20:15  |  Jack 14/05/07
  32.   Israel has never stopped its incursions & assassinations 21:01  |  Abe Hayeem 14/05/07
  33.   Danny Rubinstein and others have suggested cease-fire 21:15  |  Smadar 14/05/07
  34.   More Lefty appeasement Nonsense 22:23  |  Tod Zuckerman 14/05/07
  35.   Marilyn 23:20  |  Connie 14/05/07
  36.   Hog wash 2 all truces by terrorists 23:25  |  sam 14/05/07
  37.   Hey Abe #32 23:29  |  Gimmick 14/05/07
  38.   Connie you are wrong and immature. 23:39  |  Ibrahim 14/05/07
  39.   Gimmick #36, where have you been? 23:42  |  Ibrahim 14/05/07
  40.   your are crazy, what world do you live on? what are you smoking 00:33  |  ralph 15/05/07
  41.   First let them observe the truce before considering extending it 00:35  |  Briton 15/05/07
  42.   Palestinian Logic 00:40  |  Daniel 15/05/07
  43.   WHAT TRUCE 01:06  |  TOBIA 15/05/07
  44.   ABE YOU ARE SO SMART #32 01:17  |  Tobia 15/05/07
  45.   #19 Brandt thinks the Pals never give an inch 01:36  |  Johnboy 15/05/07
  46.   this writer is nuts 01:51  |  Roo 15/05/07
  47.   #39 Ibrahim 01:53  |  Gimmick 15/05/07
  48.   Only A Significant Military Strike will Halt Qassams 02:10  |  J 15/05/07
  49.   Mr. Rubenstein`s reality problem 02:39  |  Mark Lincoln 15/05/07
  50.   Marylin."crakers" are deadly explosives fired at Israeli towns 03:49  |  PETER SM 15/05/07
  51.   Mark Lincoln doesn`t want peace 04:44  |  JC 15/05/07
  52.   JOHNBOY: My Reply 05:48  |  Brant 15/05/07
  53.   #51 Brant makes a non-reply 06:35  |  Johnboy 15/05/07
  54.   GET RID OF OLMERT & LIVNI THEN THE QASSAMS WILL STOP 06:43  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 15/05/07
  55.   logic is for the weak 07:05  |  arab 15/05/07
  56.   Meir ...u got it 07:09  |  arab 15/05/07
  57.   to 42 u prove greatness of Mexico. supper 07:12  |  arab 15/05/07
  58.   52 so johnboy what do u suggest? 07:18  |  arab 15/05/07
  59.   #58 No, arab, you are quite wrong 08:52  |  Johnboy 15/05/07
  60.   #49 MARK DISCOVERS DEPRAVITY EVERYWHERE 08:54  |  paul harris 15/05/07
  61.   45: JB`s still inventing 09:09  |  David Teich 15/05/07
  62.   #61 David Teich makes his same non-points 10:44  |  Johnboy 15/05/07
 Today Online
Burston: Israel's worst blunders since '67 - and the Arabs'
Responses: 33
J'lem mayor seeks terror victim status for murdered Arab
Responses: 106
Israeli Arabs: Israel must own up to Nakba
Responses: 62
Editorial: Ban radical rabbis from visiting Temple Mount
Responses: 48
Yossi Melman: We need an Israeli Tony Blair, or two
Responses: 13
Rosner's Domain
* Thompson scores a 6 in his first Israel Factor survey
* Domain's Guest: The way to alienate younger American Jews
* Poll: The chaos in Gaza proves...
* Judge: A pressure on AIPAC was wrong


More Headlines
19:09 Two wounded by Qassam rockets in Sderot; Hamas claims responsibility
17:27 Hamas kills eight in attack on Fatah jeep near Gaza's Karni crossing
14:42 Jerusalem mayor seeks terror victim status for murdered Arab
17:46 PM: I'm ready to negotiate Saudi peace plan with Arab leaders
18:52 Egyptian charged with nuclear espionage praises Israel at trial
15:28 Red Cross document: Israel is violating int'l law in E. Jerusalem
15:33 Secret IDF anthrax experiment participants develop illnesses
18:26 Mekorot limits water supply to Arara due to local council's unpaid debt
10:39 Report: IAEA says Iran making progress on nuclear program
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy|