Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 13, 2007 Iyyar 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Three comments on the situation
By Yoel Marcus

1) The Winograd Committee will take care of teaching Olmert how to run a war. But how to prevent the next one is something he'll have to learn on his own. The one escape hatch left to Olmert after his inevitable fall is to keep the next war from breaking out. As someone who supported Ariel Sharon's disengagement plan and promised to continue in his path by means of convergence (to the 1967 borders), the question is whether he is prepared to start immediate talks with the Arab countries, including Syria, on the basis of the Saudi plan.

This is the best plan the Arabs have offered us to date because all the details need mutual consent. Moderate Arab states are just as worried about confrontational Islam as we are, and Israel should take advantage of that to reach an agreement. If Olmert has the guts, let's see him do something. A leader who doesn't know how to run a war and doesn't know how to make peace should go home.

2) The Second Lebanon War exposed not only the weakness of the army, but also the weakness of our national leaders, whose job it was to guide the army in carrying out missions that were doable during the war. If there ever was a time that Israel was in dire need of new blood at the top, this is it. Enough with the political wheeling and dealing. Enough with the protests in Rabin Square. Enough with the perpetual dangling on the verge of war. A real political upheaval - that's what we need.

Advertisement

We are aching for change, but a leader carrying the banner of revolution and reform is nowhere to be found. We have politicians who play games with us and subscribe to the half-coffee/half-tea school. How can Tzipi Livni sit there telling Olmert to resign when she continues to work for him? How can Ehud Barak call on the prime minister to go home, yet have no problem with being defense minister under a boss who "needs to be replaced" but could also hold out until 2008? Most of our MKs are opposed to elections.

The fear of losing one's seat has become a supreme political value. When our political representatives say that elections could bring us someone worse than Olmert, it's a sign the system is rotten and needs an urgent overhaul. Many investigative committees have come and gone, but we need a committee-to-end-all-committees that will invent a way of getting the best people, the cream of the crop, into politics - the kind of politics that will make probes extinct.

3) This Thursday it will be 30 years since the historic upheaval at the polls that brought Likud to power. Who can forget the shiver that went down many a spine when TV broadcaster Haim Yavin uttered those words: "Ladies and gentleman, the tides have turned." After eight electoral defeats, Menachem Begin was in. Begin himself was so surprised he didn't show up at party headquarters until he was sure there was no mistake. From then until now, with a few stops along the way, Likud has set the tone - building settlements, but also dismantling them, in the wake of Israel's historic peace treaty with Egypt. But what began as an era of national pride and innocence was sullied when Begin and Yitzhak Shamir left.

Their heirs, Benjamin Netanyahu and Sharon, ushered in an era of speechifying in the public square, of unwashed masses, of wheeling and dealing that sent the country into a state of moral collapse. It's hard to forget Limor Livnat's rhetorical question at the Likud Party convention: "Were we elected to hand out jobs?" "Yes!" roared thousands in unison. The land filled with political hacks. (Remember Uzi Dayan of Ra'anana, with his slogan "Never fear, Uzi is here"?) Bibi brought in the spin doctors, the PR people, the strategic advisers, the atmosphere of hatred and incitement against political rivals, while he himself starred in the role of "I am the state."

Then came Sharon with the mike-grabbing episodes and the pomposity of David Levy, whose supporters turned over tables at a party convention. The mechanisms of government were trampled as hundreds of party members converged on the Knesset and applied "moderate physical pressure" on MKs to advance their personal causes. During the last third of the upheaval era, a web of government fraud and corruption came to light. Begin was as honest as they come, but it is no accident that his three heirs - Bibi, Sharon and Olmert, plus a few other characters such as Abraham Hirschson and President Moshe Katzav - are under police investigation. The Likud era has brought Israeli society to the brink of despair. And Yavin, who retired from Israel Television this week, won't be around much longer to announce that the tides have turned.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Cordovas
A Peruvian family living in south Tel Aviv describes the good and bad sides of life in Israel.
Fine vines
The secret of my mother-in-law's superb stuffed grape leaves begins in a vineyard.
  1.   Marcus for sale,shrinked from 5 to 3 and still delusional 00:39  |  Absolute Sweden 12/05/07
  2.   Say what I like about Olmert - I respect his resiliance 02:12  |  Hal 12/05/07
  3.   Marcus` Folly - He Endorses the Saudi "Peace" Plan 02:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 12/05/07
  4.   We Can Certainly Trust the Saudis 03:23  |  Yoram 12/05/07
  5.   Winograd, Corruption and Likudism. 03:53  |  Fortuna Benmayor 12/05/07
  6.   we`ve seen many periods of despair in the region only to 06:25  |  Smadar 12/05/07
  7.   A SHRILL Yoel Marcus displays his leftist desperation 08:32  |  Dr. Dave 12/05/07
  8.   Olmert needs to go home 08:45  |  Sherri 12/05/07
  9.   Bystanders are irrelevant 08:49  |  Sam 12/05/07
  10.   an article with good proposals - 10:29  |  saul a. readner 12/05/07
  11.   tod zuckerman, no. 3 10:35  |  saul a. readner 12/05/07
  12.   yoram, no. 4 10:42  |  saul a. readner 12/05/07
  13.   "A real political upheaval - that`s what we need." 19:24  |  Yonatan 12/05/07
  14.   Corporations are the opposite of democracy 00:35  |  Hal 13/05/07
  15.   Response to Saul Reader #11 02:38  |  Tod Zuckerman 13/05/07
  16.   tod zuckerman, no. 15 11:49  |  saul a. readner 13/05/07
 Today Online
96% of Israeli Jews won't give up Western Wall for peace
Responses: 41
EU envoys said set to skip Jerusalem Day ceremonies
Responses: 24
IDF: Aspects of U.S. benchmarks may spawn more terror
Responses: 16
Zvi Bar'el: What if we spoke to Hamas and the U.S. to Iran?
Responses: 4
Olmert grasping every chance to undermine Winograd credibility
Responses: 3


More Headlines
12:01 Security cabinet to discuss Gaza steps; Qassams hit Negev
12:02 Dozens of rabbis go up to the Temple Mount in first recent trip
08:44 IDF: Two aspects of U.S. Benchmarks Plan may spawn more terror
08:28 EU ambassadors said set to skip Jerusalem Day ceremonies
10:05 IDF trying to locate top officer who slammed Peretz in media
06:04 Aid plan for Darfur refugees to be submitted to cabinet
08:08 Poll: 96% of Israeli Jews won't give up Western Wall for peace
05:55 Campaign adviser to Peres: Pull out of race for president
02:16 Nazi archives help son find long-lost mother - who refuses to see him
06:20 IDF proposes replacement to Tal Law; PM expresses support
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved