Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., May 16, 2007 Iyyar 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:01 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
It smells like discrimination
By Muhammad Amara

The widening gap between Israel's Jewish majority and the Arab minority is worrying and poses many questions as to the country's Arab-Jewish coexistence. Nearly every day statements are heard from senior figures concerning the legitimacy of Arab citizens, and unbridled attacks have become routine: MK Israel Hasson of Yisrael Beiteinu is talking about a second War of Independence against the Arab citizens in Israel, MK Otniel Schneller of Kadima is talking about establishing task forces to examine the possibility of population exchanges and the head of the Shin Bet security service is talking about the Arabs as a strategic threat.

Public opinion polls show that more than half of the Jewish respondents support government encouragement of Arab emigration, and a high percentage of those surveyed think Arab citizens do not deserve full equality. To put it simply, a significant segment of the Jews does not believe in real partnership with the country's Arab citizens.

The "lynch" atmosphere of recent weeks and the unprecedented verbal attacks on the Arab leadership in particular and the Arab public in general is intolerable. Many Arabs see the investigation of former Balad MK Azmi Bishara as political persecution whose aim is to deal with Arabs who constitute a strategic threat - as defined by the head of the Shin Bet. The latter has declared that the Shin Bet "will take care of" any attempt to change the Jewish nature of the state, even if this is done by Arabs using democratic means.

Advertisement

During this fragile period, it appears that more and more Arabs are doubting the partnership in national politics and their ability to influence their situation by parliamentary means. They wonder how they have benefited from the political game thus far, which has not significantly improved their situation (the proportion of Arabs who voted in the last elections was 53 percent, as compared to more than 90 percent in the 1950s).

Arabs across the political spectrum are declaring that they are not enemies of the state, while the opposite picture is being painted among the Jewish public. It should be remembered that Moshe Dayan once called the Arabs "the quietest minority in the world." The Arabs are struggling for a comprehensive change in the game in democratic ways and not through violence. They want equal and meaningful citizenship, and they also want the state to serve them and to belong to them as well as to the Jews.

The relations between the state and the Arabs do not revolve only around ideology and symbols. The discrimination against Arabs cries out to the heavens in every area. Half of the Arab population is under the poverty line, and the government's policy toward them has made a significant contribution to worsening their depressed state. For 60 years, there has been talk of equality but, in fact, all the talk has been just empty slogans. The preferential treatment of Jews over Arabs can be seen and smelled everywhere.

This harsh reality necessitates a long-term vision and government policy to allow Arabs to get closer to the establishment and to government power in order to build true relations between the sides. To my regret, this has not happened, and the Arabs remain in the status of present absentees. They are edged out of consciousness and of active participation in the public domain, and they have hardly any influence on what happens in the country, both in the political and socioeconomic realms.

As a member of the team that participated in the writing of "The Future Vision," and like most of the Arab population, I say: We recognize a state that recognizes its Arab citizens, we want real partnership with the Jews in the country, fundamental equality and true citizenship; we wish for an honorable life, and we want relations based on solid values, and not on the kindness of anyone's heart.

It is the obligation of intellectuals, academics and politicians, from both sides, to start a real and painful and continuing dialogue. To this day there has never been such a dialogue. At most there have been diktats from the majority side. To put it simply, the Arabs have been told that if they don't like it here, they have 21 countries. And recently the Arabs are being told that they have a Palestine that has not yet arisen and that may well never arise.

The author is a lecturer at Bar-Ilan University and Beit Berl College.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Searching for a cause
A police program fails to reach clear conclusions on what causes accidents.
We need a Blair
Israel can only wish to have a charismatic and inspiring leader like Tony Blair.
  1.   Bishara and the Arabs 09:43  |  Niall 10/05/07
  2.   It smeels like descrimination 10:21  |  Jennifer Byk 10/05/07
  3.   impossible 10:49  |  Khalid 10/05/07
  4.   Re: Niall 10:57  |  Sami 10/05/07
  5.   Israel apartheid in action! 11:05  |  maria 10/05/07
  6.   Israel apartheid in action! 11:05  |  maria 10/05/07
  7.   Israel apartheid in action! 11:05  |  maria 10/05/07
  8.   How come no Israeli Arabs condemned Bishara`s actions? 11:28  |  Sherman 10/05/07
  9.   UNDER STAR OF DAVID 11:39  |  indrajaya 10/05/07
  10.   BOYCOTT DIVESTMENT SANCTIONS 11:40  |  Sami 10/05/07
  11.   cause and effect 11:41  |  joe jew 10/05/07
  12.   To Sherman@8 12:42  |  IsraeliArab 10/05/07
  13.   indrajaya 12:44  |  JN 10/05/07
  14.   Have at least the honor and integrity to admit Amara is correct 13:10  |  lennybruce 10/05/07
  15.   No two ways with Bishara 13:27  |  Ilan 10/05/07
  16.   To lennybruce, No 14 13:38  |  Palestinian 10/05/07
  17.   How could it be an "apartheid State" when the "Haaretz" censor is 13:44  |  Absolute Sweden 10/05/07
  18.   no use... 14:06  |  zoozee 10/05/07
  19.   Khalid 3 POSSIBLE 14:42  |  The Equalizer 10/05/07
  20.   Smells more like an attempt to destroy Israel 15:43  |  McQueen 10/05/07
  21.   "Partners" who want the profits but make no investment 15:44  |  McQueen 10/05/07
  22.   Coexistence Is Not Possible. 15:49  |  Terry 10/05/07
  23.   smells like discrimination 15:55  |  peter 10/05/07
  24.   #16 my Palestinian friend 16:03  |  lennybruce 10/05/07
  25.   To Khalid 16:06  |  Yaron 10/05/07
  26.   To Niall: the problem 16:16  |  Yaron 10/05/07
  27.   Question to Israeli Arab 16:23  |  Yaron 10/05/07
  28.   To Israeli Arab # 8 16:29  |  Sherman 10/05/07
  29.   Partnership between Jews and Arabs 17:30  |  Briton 10/05/07
  30.   Smells Like Toal BS 17:33  |  Tod Zuckerman 10/05/07
  31.   Yaron, you have no right to expect us 17:39  |  Khalid 10/05/07
  32.   Nakbar Day v Independence Day 17:41  |  Chick Corea 10/05/07
  33.   Don`t bring Christians in here 17:42  |  Khalid 10/05/07
  34.   The best solution is Exchange of Territory 17:58  |  Tosufi 10/05/07
  35.   To Khalid 18:17  |  Yaron 10/05/07
  36.   Khalid - who`s the racist? 18:21  |  Tuemi 10/05/07
  37.   democracy v. Zionism 18:33  |  bobby 10/05/07
  38.   It is very simple 19:11  |  Dr.Ari Nir 10/05/07
  39.   A Jewish State, not bad. Why can`t it be fine?? 19:55  |  dana 10/05/07
  40.   bobby 20:57  |  inigo montoya 10/05/07
  41.   To Sherman in New York: there is nothing to condemn 21:02  |  John 10/05/07
  42.   Balfour - All Israelis - Arabs and Jews and Druze and Bedouins 21:15  |  PB 10/05/07
  43.   inigo 21:23  |  bobby 10/05/07
  44.   #10 Sami 22:00  |  Boycott 10/05/07
  45.   Ha`aretz Publishes Satire ! 22:19  |  Yoram 10/05/07
  46.   To John # 41 23:15  |  Sherman 10/05/07
  47.   Arabs should have rights as individuals 00:14  |  Avi Yerushalmi 11/05/07
  48.   DEAD OR ALIVE ? 00:25  |  sal 11/05/07
  49.   #10 Stop Financial Aid to Palestinians 00:55  |  semsem 11/05/07
  50.   WHAT DOES G-D`S WORD COMMAND ISRAELI ARABS ?? 01:20  |  Bill. 11/05/07
  51.   Ah Khalid, must be writing for that mickey mouse knockoff 01:38  |  Jacob Blues 11/05/07
  52.   #3 Khalid - oh the hypocracy 02:01  |  Adrian de Klerk 11/05/07
  53.   No Amara, Israeli Arabs want to take over Israel 03:21  |  Chaim 11/05/07
  54.   #5 Maria - easy questions 03:35  |  * BEN JABO 11/05/07
  55.   #14 lennybruce - I hope you`re not like your namesake 03:40  |  * BEN JABO 11/05/07
  56.   arabs are not loyal citizens of the jewish state 04:19  |  uzi 11/05/07
  57.   this is for palestinian supporters as well israel... 05:32  |  maria 11/05/07
  58.   Why not exchange some of those Israelis ? 07:48  |  Dutch 11/05/07
  59.   The discrimination of Amara 10:43  |  Hastaroth 11/05/07
  60.   to indrajaya 10:59  |  daughter of the One 11/05/07
  61.   Arabs in Israel 11:27  |  US CITIZEN 11/05/07
  62.   #55 Ben Jabo - thanks for half the story 11:33  |  lennybruce 11/05/07
  63.   #62 Lennybruce 17:36  |  * BEN JABO 11/05/07
  64.   #58 Daffy Dutch 17:38  |  * BEN JABO 11/05/07
  65.   A tip to Khalid 10:33  |  Stan 12/05/07
  66.   All citizens must be treated with equality 03:03  |  Ben Azai 13/05/07
  67.   Haven`t we got enough enemies? 03:05  |  Sherlock Holmes 13/05/07
  68.   #66 Ben Azai 18:40  |  * BEN JABO 13/05/07
  69.   #57 Maria - stop asking questions, start answering 02:55  |  * BEN JABO 14/05/07
  70.   #57 Maria 02:58  |  * BEN JABO 14/05/07
  71.   #62-2 Lenny Bruce - News Flash for YOU 03:00  |  * BEN JABO 14/05/07
  72.   #57 Who really owns the land of Israel? 06:38  |  Ralph 16/05/07
 Today Online
Goel Pinto: Forgive us our anti-Muslim racism
Send response
Editorial: PM should forge policy for division of Jerusalem
Responses: 3
Palestinian militants resume Qassam fire on Negev
Responses: 44
Aid to PA nearly tripled in 2006 despite international boycott
Responses: 13
French Jews fear revenge over murder of Arab taxi driver
Responses: 11


More Headlines
10:13 Five die as gunmen storm home of Gaza Fatah chief
10:26 Qassam rocket strikes house next to Peretz's home in Sderot
06:22 Aid to PA nearly tripled in '06, despite international boycott
06:08 Experts: IAEA chief exaggerated Iranian nuclear progress
08:20 French Jews fear revenge over murder of Arab taxi driver
04:46 T.A. Mayor Huldai urges Rabbi Lau not to run for presidency
10:49 Copies of Nazi archive to be released to Holocaust institutions
06:41 Friedmann proposes search committee for court presidents
02:03 Knesset passes law easing path for courts to pull indictment
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM