Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., May 04, 2007 Iyyar 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 04:20 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
To Rabin Square
By Ari Shavit

The Israeli public is the real hero of the past decade. It supported the bold peace process of 2000. It overcame the massive terrorist offensive of 2001-2004. It supported Ariel Sharon's efforts to reduce the occupation in 2005. It withstood the Katyusha attacks of Hezbollah against the North in the summer of 2006.

Over six years of difficult challenges, the Israeli public exhibited maturity and responsibility. It did not get carried away by extremism or defeatism, it did not become delusional or despondent. Lacking an inspiring leadership, it defended its home. It developed a vibrant economy under conditions of conflict, and a stable, normal day-to-day routine despite the constant threats. Even when the State of Israel failed, the Israeli public showed its mettle.

But this last year, the Israeli public failed: It did not manage to impose its views on its government. Immediately following the Second Lebanon War, the citizens of Israel understood the severity of the war and its implications. They recognized that the government failed and would be unable to lead the corrective process. They understood the national leadership is unworthy.

Advertisement

Nonetheless, for eight months the country's residents allowed their leadership to ridicule them. They did not join the reservists' protest en masse; they did not put the prime minister, whose moral authority was lost, under political siege. Except for David Grossman, all the authors kept quiet. Except for Eli Hurvitz, all the leading economic figures kept quiet. The general public complained but it did not protest. Here and there some dogs barked, but the convoy kept on moving.

The five impressive members of the Winograd Committee told the public this Monday that the convoy is heading for an abyss. The implication of their hard-hitting document is unequivocal: Israel is in the hands of failed leaders. The leadership's failure during the war was total. The prime minister is not a reasonable statesman who made an acceptable mistake, but the field marshal heading the march of folly. A march that is still not over. The march of folly that Ehud Olmert led to the last war is now making its way, under his leadership, to the next war.

But now there are no more excuses. We cannot hide behind "we are waiting for Winograd." We cannot hide behind "we are afraid of Benjamin Netanyahu." We cannot be evasive and say that Ehud Barak is also not something to write home about. Now it is clear that a man who is endangering the State of Israel is at the head of its government. And when the prime minister responds the way he did to the Winograd report, it is blatantly clear that he is irreparable.

Today is the day the Israeli public needs to correct its own error. The day in which it must have its say, do what the writers did not do, what the economic leaders did not do, what the politicians did not do. It should say: no more. Get rid of this government of folly. Put Israel on a new path.

It is not simple. It is not easy for the blue to stand with the orange. It is not easy for the secular to stand with the religious. It is not easy for those with contradictory points of view to sound a common voice. But the peace camp should know that there will not be peace unless Israel is renewed. The security camp should know that there will be no security unless Israel is renewed.

And under the leadership of a spin government, Israel will not be renewed; it will soon find itself in a real existential crisis. This evening, in Rabin Square, the Israeli public and Israeli democracy are facing their ultimate test. This time the challenge is not terror; it is not Hezbollah. This time the challenge is ensuring that the nation has a worthy government. To ensure that our best will overcome the evil. To restore Israel to itself.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Grave celebration
At Yehoshua Bin Nun's grave in the Palestinian village Kifl Harith, religious Jews rejoice.
Seeing red
Claims Israeli students only care when their pockets are hit are angering strike leaders.
  1.   LIVNI AND THAT KIND OF SPECIES 09:49  |  indrajaya 03/05/07
  2.   take it FURTHER 09:57  |  aristocrat 03/05/07
  3.   ELECTORAL DICTATORSHIPS A MENACE TO ALL DEMOCRACY 10:03  |  paul harris 03/05/07
  4.   The real hero 10:20  |  Andrew Watson 03/05/07
  5.   Power to the People 10:23  |  Burkhardt 03/05/07
  6.   It`s up to the Israeli public now. 10:24  |  Willy 03/05/07
  7.   Another government...Another DEFEAT!!! 10:54  |  Abdallah 03/05/07
  8.   # 1 Happily, Israel is not Indonesia where 11:10  |  ziggurat 03/05/07
  9.   # 8, ZIGGURAT 11:38  |  indrajaya 03/05/07
  10.   all of a sudden ... 11:58  |  christoph 03/05/07
  11.   It`s Not Just Olmert..... 12:09  |  Ben Israel 03/05/07
  12.   Arie`s Che Guevera T-shirt 12:18  |  FOX 03/05/07
  13.   to aristocrat:we r not gonna let u start another holocost, sir... 13:03  |  Pavel 03/05/07
  14.   No more excuses 13:26  |  Tzfonit 03/05/07
  15.   Stop Dreaming 13:43  |  cares 03/05/07
  16.   something wrong here. 13:48  |  cares 03/05/07
  17.   # 7 Abdallah - real men? 15:07  |  Paul Henzen 03/05/07
  18.   There is a saying... 15:08  |  Lena 03/05/07
  19.   Israeli people deserve a better government-I hope they get it 15:34  |  Briton 03/05/07
  20.   Israeli public is not seeing the forest through the trees 16:15  |  Be Still 03/05/07
  21.   TO Paul Henzen 16:34  |  Lebanese 03/05/07
  22.   Lap Dog for George Bush continues to work 16:42  |  David Hoffman 03/05/07
  23.   # 21 Lebanese 16:53  |  Paul Henzen 03/05/07
  24.   Where are the people? 17:55  |  the cohen brother 03/05/07
  25.   The IDF lost their luster YEARS ago... 17:58  |  Ibrahim 03/05/07
  26.   ##17,21 Paul Henzen and His Confusing "Framework of Orientation". 18:17  |  Arik 03/05/07
  27.   "We have seen the enemy and the enemy is us!" 18:17  |  Bingo 03/05/07
  28.   Bing, Bingo! 18:48  |  Mark Lincoln 03/05/07
  29.   PAVEL, it`s time to come out of the trench 20:14  |  aristocrat 03/05/07
  30.   # 26 Arik - Political Islam IS the problem ! 20:20  |  Paul Henzen 03/05/07
  31.   Arrogant Abdallah, don`t count on it 20:22  |  Jake 03/05/07
  32.   Excellent article, Ari Shavit. 20:35  |  Fortuna Benmayor 03/05/07
  33.   To "Lebanese", have you heard the expression `Pyrrhic victory`? 20:43  |  Jake 03/05/07
  34.   #22. David Hoffman, us? We? 20:46  |  Jake 03/05/07
  35.   Olmerts supporters 20:54  |  Jo Jo 03/05/07
  36.   Paul Henzen`s babbles.... 21:20  |  Ibrahim 03/05/07
  37.   #30 Paul Henzen 22:37  |  Arik 03/05/07
  38.   Israeli public is only "hero" to Nasarallah. Why 23:07  |  shhhh 03/05/07
  39.   # 36 Ibrahim - Islamism is the new fascism ! 00:13  |  Paul Henzen 04/05/07
  40.   To Jake #34 00:38  |  David Hoffman 04/05/07
 Today Online
Dichter urges PM to keep Livni on as he mulls reshuffle
Responses: 87
Ex-CIA director: I prevented move to free Jonathan Pollard
Responses: 153
Int'l community keeping watch on post-Winograd fallout
Responses: 61
More than 100,000 rally in T.A., call on PM, Peretz to quit
Responses: 89
U.S. court clears ex-Shin Bet chief Dichter in war crimes suit
Responses: 100


More Headlines
03:28 U.S. presents Israel, PA with detailed demands
02:20 Kadima, PM fear Winograd backlash will push Labor to quit government
03:29 Over 100,000 rally in Tel Aviv to call on PM, Peretz to resign
20:17 Netanyahu: Leadership failed in war, can't remain to fix failures
18:46 EU, Fayyad to make coordinated salary payments to PA employees
02:37 Gov't to striking students: Settlement offer will not be renegotiated
19:37 Rice meets Syrian FM in first high-level U.S.-Syria talks in two years
00:50 Forest fire destroys 100 dunam of Mount Carmel park
22:15 First pro-Hamas Palestinian newspaper launched in Gaza Strip
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved