Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., May 04, 2007 Iyyar 16, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:16 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
More than 100,000 people rallying in Tel Aviv's Rabin Square on Thursday to call on Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Defense Minister Amir Peretz to resign. (Nir Kafri)
Last update - 23:57 03/05/2007
Roughly 100,000 people rally in Tel Aviv to call on PM, Peretz to quit
By Barak Ravid, Roni Singer-Heruti and Nir Hasson, Haaretz Correspondents, Haaretz Service and Agencies

More than 100,000 people rallied in Tel Aviv's Rabin Square on Thursday, in the first national protest calling on Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Defense Minister Amir Peretz to resign over the damning Winograd report on the Second Lebanon War.

While police would only say the number of protestors was over 100,000, the rally's organizers said closer to 200,000 were in attendance. A banner reading "Failures, Go Home!" hung behind a podium set up at one end of the square in front of Tel Aviv city hall.

"Ehud Olmert, you said you work for us. Olmert, you are fired!" said the evening's keynote speaker, author Meir Shalev. "Amir Peretz - you said [Hezbollah leader Hassan] Nasrallah will never forget your name. Neither will we."

Advertisement

"Olmert and Peretz, we have received authorization that both of you came to power in the wrong positions," he continued. "You can't handle the position, you failed, go home."

Despite the fact that the rally organizers had made great efforts to include protestors from a wide political spectrum, Shalev overstepped the bounds of the rally's consensus, and was booed by many of the demonstrators.

"Not only do you not know how to make war, but also peace," he said. "The war you embarked on was not the first stupidity, but thanks to it, we have understood what has happened after 40 years of occupation. This is the result, go home, goodbye and good riddance."

Rally organizer Uzi Dayan, who is chairman of the Tafnit movement and a retired senior general, also addressed the crowd, saying: "Democracy has emerged victorious."

"The Winograd Committee that the prime minister established has courageously stood up to him and said clearly - Mr. Olmert, you failed," said Dayan.

"The prime minister is refusing to accept personal responsibility and resign, and is therefore undermining the foundations of democracy," Dayan continued. "Olmert, don't stall for time, don't delay the end until the summer, do the right thing and go home."

"I came to protest against the government for not doing anything," said Tal Geva, a student at Sderot's Sapir College and a resident of the borderline community of Ein Habesor. "For not implementing the Winograd conclusions, for not taking care of Sderot and other Gaza-area residents properly, for not providing us with reinforced buildings, and for sending us to reserve duty and then not taking care of us."

"We're here to tell Olmert ... to go," protestor Yigal Armoni said at the demonstration. "He's on the edge of a cliff. All he needs is a small push, but tonight we'll give him a big one."

Olmert adviser Tal Zilberstein shrugged off the rally, saying it would not prompt the prime minister to rethink his decision not to resign.

Some political demonstrations in the past have attracted hundreds of thousands of protesters, and the size of this one was seen as a critical sign of the extent of public anger.

The organizers of the mass demonstration decided Wednesday that politicians would not speak at the rally, but bereaved families, artists, and intelligentsia would speak instead.

The rally's organizers said their decision to hold the protest without politicians was made because they wanted to attract as many people as possible. However, they called on all politicians interested to come and protest, even if they do not speak.

"This is an exceptional opportunity to bring the Israeli democracy back to its natural place, and this is in the city's square," Dayan said Wednesday.

"Citizens from all over the political spectrum and the country will come to Rabin Square. This is the time when the public will sound its voice loud and clear and send the failures home."

The office of Likud Chairman Benjamin Netanyahu said Netanyahu was less likely to attend the rally now that it is clear that he will not be among the speakers at the event.

The event is hosted by Osnat Vishinsky, bereaved mother of Lior, who died in an armored vehicle explosion on the Philadelphi route in 2004.

Artists such as Aviv Gefen, Subliminal, Gilad Segev, Shay Gabso, and Nimrod Lev were expected to perform songs related to the Second Lebanon War.

Yakir Aviv, chairman of the Hebrew University Students' Union, Roni Tzigenbaum, representing the IDF reserves, and Ariela Goldman, mother of Noam Goldman who was killed in the Second Lebanon War, were all expected to speak. The writer Meir Shalev and the poet Chaim Guri will also speak at the protest.

Representatives from movements across the political spectrum attended the rally, including the representatives of both the Yesha Settlement Council and the Meretz party.

Though politicians were intentionally not invited to speak at the rally, several politicians attended the event. Labor MKs Ami Ayalon, Ophir Pines-Paz and Danny Yatom, three of the candidates for leadership of the party, were present. Also from Labor, MK Avishai Braverman attended the rally.

However, conspicuously missing from the event was former prime minister Ehud Barak, who will also vie for leadership of the Labor party during the upcoming primaries. Barak is the last remaining candidate that has not yet expressed any views regarding the Winograd report.

MKs from Likud, the National Religious Party, the National Union party and Meretz also attended the demonstration.

Tel Aviv University students also joined the crowd at the really, and several small groups marched from Haifa, Sderot and Jerusalem to participate in the rally.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Grave celebration
At Yehoshua Bin Nun's grave in the Palestinian village Kifl Harith, religious Jews rejoice.
Seeing red
Claims Israeli students only care when their pockets are hit are angering strike leaders.
  1.   No politicians - only the people...FANTASITIC! 00:02  |  bat yam 03/05/07
  2.   rally 05:38  |  colin 03/05/07
  3.   the peasents are revolting 09:04  |  SJ 03/05/07
  4.   WE ARE THE PEOPLE 10:09  |  Burkhardt 03/05/07
  5.   #3 - The peasants are revolting 10:25  |  Tamar 03/05/07
  6.   Correction to name 11:38  |  Mati Milstein 03/05/07
  7.   it is raining 13:18  |  Dror 03/05/07
  8.   I Scream For Ice Cream 14:24  |  Reuven Brauner 03/05/07
  9.   Disturbing my burger! 15:39  |  Nik Miller 03/05/07
  10.   Ehud has united the people 15:50  |  Meir 03/05/07
  11.   A breakthrough for Israeli democracy at last? 16:22  |  David Hoffman 03/05/07
  12.   Correction to #8 17:19  |  Reuven Brauner 03/05/07
  13.   Israel . a banana republic. what a joke 18:24  |  gorge bush 03/05/07
  14.   Rabin Square protest 18:48  |  ans jansen-meurs 03/05/07
  15.   Forget Being "Pure": Rally Behind the Opposition 19:04  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 03/05/07
  16.   Rediculous Narcissism Defeats Us All Again 19:16  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 03/05/07
  17.   SO WHO IS PAYING FOR THE RALLY? 19:23  |  PERITO 03/05/07
  18.   Correction to name 19:35  |  Avi Morrison 03/05/07
  19.   Only the people can 19:42  |  Oded 03/05/07
  20.   rally because you lost the war. get used to this 20:05  |  sami 03/05/07
  21.   MORE LIKE 150,000 20:19  |  Daniel 03/05/07
  22.   To the (GORGE BUSH). 13. 20:28  |  David Nigel Braham 03/05/07
  23.   Unimpressive 20:28  |  Not in my name 03/05/07
  24.   To Avi Morrison.18. 20:30  |  David Nigel Braham 03/05/07
  25.   Rally 20:34  |  Ehud Olmert 03/05/07
  26.   me too 20:52  |  amir peretz 03/05/07
  27.   Demonstration Appears To Be A Failure-Olmert Is Safe 20:57  |  Ben Israel 03/05/07
  28.   Bat Yam - Election reform 21:00  |  Omran 03/05/07
  29.   To paraphrase John Lennon: `All We Are Saying, Is ...` 21:02  |  Chick Corea 03/05/07
  30.   Sami from Yaffa 21:02  |  TamTam 03/05/07
  31.   response to 27 21:10  |  Amir 03/05/07
  32.   Olmert adviser Tal Zilberstein Is A Idiot 21:21  |  Shepherd 03/05/07
  33.   #31 I hope you are right - My feeling is #27 is correct 21:25  |  Harry 03/05/07
  34.   Rabin Sq.?! It was jerk Rabin who started the rot in Israel 21:27  |  Absolute Sweden 03/05/07
  35.   Catch 22 Situation 21:34  |  Shimon Z. Klein 03/05/07
  36.   To #31 21:40  |  Manny 03/05/07
  37.   Truly dreadful 21:41  |  Marilyn 03/05/07
  38.   meir shalev spoiled the party.... 21:48  |  gabriela 03/05/07
  39.   #30. I will take one for the team anytime. even if I die. great 21:56  |  sami 03/05/07
  40.   Time for an Israeli version of Augustus Caesar 22:02  |  Jake 03/05/07
  41.   As Patty Smith sang..... 22:02  |  Roberto Tedeschi 03/05/07
  42.   Response to 31 (Who are you kidding?) 22:03  |  Jeff 03/05/07
  43.   Omran, there is no such equivalent 22:07  |  Jake 03/05/07
  44.   #20 Sami 22:14  |  Jane 03/05/07
  45.   Mavens Anonymous:Out of 100,000 How Many Would know 22:15  |  Ronnie Wolman 03/05/07
  46.   It´s OK Ehud, thankyou, you can go now 22:21  |  juan 03/05/07
  47.   The Strength of Democracy 22:29  |  Danite 03/05/07
  48.   OLMERT AND PERETZ RESIGN NOW! 22:36  |  John 03/05/07
  49.   100,000 ? 22:42  |  MK 03/05/07
  50.   It`s the Israeli peoples fault and they blame their leaders 22:44  |  bruce 03/05/07
  51.   bad vs worse 22:44  |  Frederique 03/05/07
  52.   He`ll stand if the Lord wants him to stand. 22:46  |  period 03/05/07
  53.   What`s the alternative to Olmert? 22:48  |  Paul Henzen 03/05/07
  54.   #41 why? this is my home & ancestors home. 22:54  |  sami 03/05/07
  55.   #27 Ben Israel 22:54  |  alan 03/05/07
  56.   Giving Meir Shalev the floor was a mistake 22:55  |  eli sverdlof 03/05/07
  57.   My sympathies are with Olmert 22:59  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 03/05/07
  58.   To all of my Jewish Brethren. YOU SOUND VERY FICKLE... 23:00  |  Kath` 03/05/07
  59.   Ronnie #45 23:06  |  Danite 03/05/07
  60.   Olmert --good job ---fire everyone that demonstrated 23:10  |  Sal 03/05/07
  61.   # 54 SAMI. you heard Jane,You Get out and take Bishara with YOU.. 23:11  |  Kath` 03/05/07
  62.   sami #54 - But I`m sure you still wouldn`t live in Gaza 23:13  |  Moises 03/05/07
  63.   Poor Olmert. He does not deserve this 23:14  |  Foxbat 03/05/07
  64.   Bruce, that is only partly true 23:14  |  Jake 03/05/07
  65.   It was more like 200,000 people.....i was there 23:18  |  jay 03/05/07
  66.   #14 23:18  |  Jane 03/05/07
  67.   # 40 Jake. I could say:Etu Brute,but I will not .... 23:18  |  Kath` 03/05/07
  68.   #14 ans jansen-meurs - Apartheid is a Dutch word 23:22  |  Yonatan 03/05/07
  69.   Absolute Sweden, "let sleeping dogs lie" 23:22  |  Jake 03/05/07
  70.   #54 23:23  |  Jane 03/05/07
  71.   # 56 Please, tell me you did not catch the scent of the left 23:25  |  fresh air 03/05/07
  72.   Jeff, you are wrong 23:26  |  Jake 03/05/07
  73.   #54 sami - You are the rejects of the whole Arab World 23:27  |  Yonatan 03/05/07
  74.   Nothing will really change 23:30  |  Yonatan 03/05/07
  75.   Bruce in Wellington 23:32  |  rich 03/05/07
  76.   I wonder... if all those who once demanded the swift strike went 23:33  |  curious 03/05/07
  77.   Marilyn: the last time i checked... 23:33  |  Richard S 03/05/07
  78.   Avi from Kfar Saba King David was not better than Rabbin 23:43  |  Bolton 03/05/07
  79.   just 4% of the total population 23:43  |  Simon Mohammed 03/05/07
  80.   bruce your views of Israeli politics is slanted 23:52  |  Bolton 03/05/07
  81.   The Time is Coming 00:01  |  Josiah 04/05/07
  82.   Sami you must be below age-and Israels taxes paid for your educat 00:03  |  Shalom 04/05/07
  83.   Sami 00:08  |  TamTam 04/05/07
  84.   The PM was mainly successful 00:22  |  William Kinney 04/05/07
  85.   Marilyn uses your brain before posting 00:28  |  dean 04/05/07
  86.   Had this demonstration happened here 00:36  |  Mark Lincoln 04/05/07
  87.   William Kinney 00:37  |  Mark Lincoln 04/05/07
  88.   Olmert: I order you to stay in power for years. 00:37  |  Egyptian Pharaoh 04/05/07
  89.   Jake 00:43  |  bruce 04/05/07
  90.   Kath`, I meant Augustus Caesar, not Julius Caesar 00:48  |  Jake 04/05/07
  91.   Marilyn #37 00:51  |  Zelkha 04/05/07
  92.   Dayan is a danger to Israel! 00:58  |  Sunny Barkats 04/05/07
  93.   Danger! Netanyau is worse then Olmert! 01:02  |  Ivan 04/05/07
  94.   rich of little understanding in London 01:02  |  bruce 04/05/07
  95.   Change of Course 01:13  |  Ayman 04/05/07
  96.   # 60 Sal. Where do you think you are,to suggest such stupidity?? 01:16  |  Kath` 04/05/07
  97.   Jake #80 01:16  |  bruce 04/05/07
  98.   Rally in Tel Aviv 01:18  |  Smolich 04/05/07
  99.   Olmert is not a failure BUT Hizboulla are stronger 01:28  |  Noora 04/05/07
  100.   Yonatan - No Apartheid in Israel ! 01:37  |  Paul Henzen 04/05/07
  101.   # 86 Mark Lincoln. So pleased to read your approval... 01:41  |  Kath` 04/05/07
  102.   Danite P1 01:47  |  TonyL 04/05/07
  103.   Danite P2 01:49  |  TonyL 04/05/07
  104.   Danite P3 01:50  |  TonyL 04/05/07
  105.   # 86 - You are full of stuffin - especially in Texas!!! 02:11  |  An American 04/05/07
  106.   WHY DON`T THEY RALLY LIKE THIS AGAINST THE OCCUPATION?.... 02:45  |  Dutch 04/05/07
  107.   # 74 Yonatan.I have said this on other occasions 02:47  |  Kath` 04/05/07
  108.   "roughly 100000" - media bias!!! 02:48  |  josh 04/05/07
  109.   #86 TO MARK LINCOLN 03:27  |  Oetis 04/05/07
  110.   Effect of rally 03:30  |  hannah 04/05/07
  111.   Effect of rally 03:30  |  hannah 04/05/07
  112.   How long until Bibi is PM? 03:47  |  Josh 04/05/07
  113.   where was this protest in June? 03:59  |  Pssd Off American 04/05/07
  114.   THEY SAY GEORGE BUSH`S POPULARITY RATING IS BAD 04:31  |  DAVE 04/05/07
  115.   How significant is 100 - 200 thousand ? 05:12  |  Fortuna Benmayor 04/05/07
  116.   Olmert and Peretz 05:33  |  Naim S. Mahlab 04/05/07
  117.   Vice Premier Shimon Peres must be fired 05:55  |  Joseph E . 04/05/07
  118.   Bruce, sorry, you understand nothing about Israeli society 06:03  |  Jake 04/05/07
  119.   Why did you wait 6 months to oust Olmhert?? 06:32  |  DEB 04/05/07
  120.   Richard S is disgusting 07:00  |  Marilyn 04/05/07
  121.   The will of the people is meaningless 07:11  |  The Cid 04/05/07
  122.   Rich #75 09:34  |  bruce 04/05/07
  123.   Jake #91 09:48  |  bruce 04/05/07
  124.   Bolton #80 10:09  |  bruce 04/05/07
  125.   The only way to get Olmert out 10:34  |  Zev 04/05/07
  126.   Emotionalism 12:13  |  Jim 04/05/07
 Today Online
U.S. presents Israel, PA with detailed demands
Responses: 209
Sources: Evidence on Bishara sufficient for indictment
Responses: 33
Avi Issacharoff: The world has forgotten about Gaza
Responses: 51
Editorial: Peres must assume temporary leadership of country
Responses: 25
Mairovich: Israel will again correct failures by going to war
Responses: 28
Rosner's Domain
* Bush, Rice, Olmert, Livni: the State of affairs
* What Americans can learn from the Winogard report
* Poll: What should be done now politically?
* Iraq and Lebanon: What happens when you don't win


More Headlines
15:20 PMO: Israel can't commit to some of U.S. demands
14:12 Olmert vows to stay on despite mass rally calling on him to quit
16:32 PA officials deny reports Abbas may resign over int'l sanctions
16:12 Junior academic staff slams university heads' ultimatum to students
16:09 Police Chief Cohen appoints new officers to top positions
16:19 Sources: Evidence on Bishara case sufficient for indictment
17:19 Jewish monument in Germany vandalized a second time in days
14:03 Indictment filed against alleged organized crime boss Asi Abutbul
02:20 Kadima, PM fear Winograd backlash will push Labor to quit government
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved