Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., May 07, 2007 Iyyar 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 19:18 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
George Tenet: We didn't believe Jonathan Pollard was a Wye accord deal-breaker. (AP)
Last update - 22:25 02/05/2007
Ex-CIA director: I prevented move to release spy for Israel
By Shmuel Rosner, Haaretz Correspondent

Former CIA chief George Tenet claims that he is responsible for scuppering a deal to free Jonathan Pollard, the former U.S. Navy analyst who received a life sentence for spying for Israel.

In his memoirs, Tenet says he told former U.S. president Bill Clinton during the 1998 Israel-Palestinian summit at the Wye Plantation that he would resign if Pollard were freed.

In his account of a meeting between himself and Clinton, he says that he remained "very calm and matter of fact," even though he had issued an ultimatum to the president.

Advertisement

"It's just the wrong thing to do," Tenet says he told the president. If you do this, he said, "I won't be your CIA director in the morning."

The demand to free Pollard came from then-prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, as a condition for Israel's acceptance of the agreement on the table at the time.

Tenet says that he was told by then-U.S. secretary of state Madeleine Albright that, "If you're going to say anything to the president about Pollard, now is the time to say it."

According to Tenet, he and U.S. Mideast envoy Dennis Ross did not believe that Netanyahu would give up the Wye accord because of Pollard.

He writes that Ross told Clinton that if he had promised Netanyahu he would free the convicted spy, then he had to stand by his word. But, Ross reportedly said, "This agreement is too good for Bibi [Netanyahu] to give up. Hang tough and we will get a deal [without Pollard]."

In the book, Tenet says that former U.S. ambassador Martin Indyk described a meeting in which Clinton told Netanyahu that he could not release Pollard because the CIA director would resign.

Netanyahu reportedly told Clinton that if that was the case, then the deal was off.

"This was a game of chicken," Tenet concludes. As he and Ross had foreseen, Netanyahu went on to sign the agreement anyway.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Why he must go
Israel's culture of governance can change only after Olmert and his ilk are gone.
The cello was proud
Breaking the Muses' silence during the thunderous days of Winograd is truly naive.
  1.   Tenet 22:35  |  Brod 02/05/07
  2.   9/11 might have been prevented if he had quitted 22:39  |  Absolute Sweden 02/05/07
  3.   Bibi the Chicken - Pluck yourself 22:54  |  Henri 02/05/07
  4.   George Tenet should occupy Pollard`s cell 22:56  |  Michelle 02/05/07
  5.   trade pollard 23:33  |  steve 02/05/07
  6.   Tenet---The fish rots from the head on down 23:35  |  Phil 02/05/07
  7.   #4 is right, Tenet did far more damage to US than Pollard 23:43  |  Dr. L. Brnd 02/05/07
  8.   Tenet 23:49  |  rich 02/05/07
  9.   Michelle 23:54  |  RFE 02/05/07
  10.   Tenet threatens 00:00  |  Miransky 03/05/07
  11.   Dennis Ross-another despicable Jew 00:01  |  PJ 03/05/07
  12.   Tenet a real loser 00:06  |  G 03/05/07
  13.   Re: all the unethical things Tenet did 00:11  |  Daniel 03/05/07
  14.   Tenet - a zero 00:13  |  Lev Strauss 03/05/07
  15.   Pollard`s life sentence. 00:15  |  Harry Greenblatt 03/05/07
  16.   #2 Right 00:21  |  Sidney 03/05/07
  17.   Pollard is a lying trader....a judas to his country 00:22  |  Sam 03/05/07
  18.   Tenet has no credibility and is an anti-Semite 00:25  |  BradL 03/05/07
  19.   No. 11--PJ 00:35  |  steve 03/05/07
  20.   #9Michelle 00:38  |  Fussion 03/05/07
  21.   Ex-CIA director: I prevented move to release spy for Israel 01:01  |  Mythbuster 03/05/07
  22.   Broken man 01:05  |  Joseph 03/05/07
  23.   Let the weasel rot in jail!! 01:16  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  24.   no. 13--Harry 01:20  |  steve 03/05/07
  25.   Harry Greenblatt 01:33  |  Man 03/05/07
  26.   Pollard The Traitor Should Rot In Jail For Life 01:37  |  chet 03/05/07
  27.   POLLARD COULD BE OUT NOW 01:46  |  Chana 03/05/07
  28.   PJ - ROSS THE GOOD JEW 01:49  |  StephenConnor 03/05/07
  29.   He deserved what he got!!! 01:49  |  Zev 03/05/07
  30.   Time to get back to the Clinton`s..... 01:50  |  Stright 2 the point 03/05/07
  31.   ISREA! NEVER RE`ELECT THE 100% LIAR BIB! 01:51  |  SABRA... 03/05/07
  32.   #13 02:06  |  bob 03/05/07
  33.   Not treason Harry 02:24  |  Kaiser Willy 03/05/07
  34.   Brod...Pollard 02:34  |  John 03/05/07
  35.   My Adventures On Corfu 02:56  |  Yosemite 03/05/07
  36.   Tenet- A Failed Bureaucrat 03:08  |  Nate 03/05/07
  37.   Jews Don`t Spy 03:54  |  dan 03/05/07
  38.   Re `#11 Dennis Ross -- another dispicable Jew.` 04:09  |  Colin Wright 03/05/07
  39.   Protecting Israel is not in the US constitution 04:11  |  Nick W 03/05/07
  40.   Hypocrits.... 04:34  |  Cherice 03/05/07
  41.   #39 Nick...get your facts stright.... 04:34  |  Stright 2 the point 03/05/07
  42.   Steve (#19 & #28)- Dennis Ross is a BAD Jew! 04:50  |  E 03/05/07
  43.   #39Protecting Israel is not in the US constitution 04:54  |  Joseph 03/05/07
  44.   pollard 05:11  |  tom 03/05/07
  45.   poor pollard 05:23  |  natan 03/05/07
  46.   Justice for America! 06:08  |  Erik 03/05/07
  47.   Re: Jews Don`t Spy 07:44  |  Cherice 03/05/07
  48.   Re: poot pollard 07:48  |  Cherice 03/05/07
  49.   Re: #39 Nick...get your facts stright.... 07:57  |  Cherice 03/05/07
  50.   So To Make A Long Story Short... 08:10  |  Yosemite 03/05/07
  51.   to nR 40 - HYPOCRITS 11:35  |  ari 03/05/07
  52.   Pollard - item 51 cont. 12:22  |  ari 03/05/07
  53.   no shame, no ethics here, only arrogant Jews 12:31  |  Mark B. 03/05/07
  54.   ballistic, and Bashara 12:45  |  Jane 2 03/05/07
  55.   4: A Convicted Spy vs Presidential Medal of Freedom 13:03  |  Tupac 03/05/07
  56.   tenet was afraid he would be ruined in cia, so what does that say 13:10  |  Pavel 03/05/07
  57.   37: Jews don`t Spy, NOTaccording to the jury tht found him guilty 13:10  |  Tupac 03/05/07
  58.   a spy is a spy is a spy....... 13:16  |  rose 03/05/07
  59.   #9rfe - Tenet`s worse than Bishara & Bishara`s worse than Pollard 13:30  |  Michelle 03/05/07
  60.   American first and Jewish never interferes 13:34  |  Albert Amato 03/05/07
  61.   Albert Amato - The Big Question 13:56  |  Stephen Connor 03/05/07
  62.   Kaiser Willy - "SPYING FOR A FRIEND"?? 14:02  |  Stephen Connor 03/05/07
  63.   Stright 2 the point(less). "...get a hat and cover it up." 14:08  |  Stephen Connor 03/05/07
  64.   SO HE WAS STRONGER THAN CLINTON TO SAY NO TO BIBI 14:15  |  Marco 03/05/07
  65.   Stephen`s answer is YES 14:16  |  Albert Amato 03/05/07
  66.   #1 Yep, Clinton was the most corrupt and .. 14:35  |  John Allen 03/05/07
  67.   #15 Thank you for the factual def. of spying. 14:48  |  John Allen 03/05/07
  68.   #29 Thank you for explaining..... 14:57  |  John Allen 03/05/07
  69.   JOhn Allen, I guess you don`t read the news anymore 15:02  |  bbl 03/05/07
  70.   Pollard. 15:07  |  David NIgel Braham 03/05/07
  71.   The outlandish Netanyahu 15:13  |  Tosefta 03/05/07
  72.   Pollard and US Jews 15:24  |  Tosefta 03/05/07
  73.   John #34 15:32  |  Brod 03/05/07
  74.   Releasing - more harm than good 15:34  |  Sam 03/05/07
  75.   Very Difficult to Release Pollard 15:45  |  Ronnie Wolman 03/05/07
  76.   Dont like the humour????? 16:07  |  Ronnie Wolman 03/05/07
  77.   Pollard not an exeption to the rule 16:12  |  K 03/05/07
  78.   cherice #48 16:26  |  natan 03/05/07
  79.   make Pollard US president 16:31  |  mehmet 03/05/07
  80.   tupac 16:31  |  natan 03/05/07
  81.   Pollard 16:38  |  Jason Grelli 03/05/07
  82.   stephen connor 16:38  |  natan 03/05/07
  83.   Bibi 16:39  |  Av10.3830 03/05/07
  84.   POLLARD was a traitor.Was he worse than other US traitors? 16:41  |  PETER SM 03/05/07
  85.   Judiciary 101 for Tupac 16:44  |  Jacob Blues 03/05/07
  86.   So long as pollard is alive it`s never too late to help him. 16:57  |  Seth Halpern 03/05/07
  87.   ROSS rightly showed his first loyalty was to the USA 16:59  |  PETER SM 03/05/07
  88.   To Mark B. re 53 17:03  |  Lee 03/05/07
  89.   Stephen Connor nAnd Cherice... I said facts.....you have none!!! 17:03  |  Stright 2 the point 03/05/07
  90.   38 Colin Wright 17:05  |  American Jew 03/05/07
  91.   #33 - Pollard no friend - rot in prison 17:06  |  Rick 03/05/07
  92.   To Steven Connor re 61 17:08  |  Lee 03/05/07
  93.   Presidential pardons 17:12  |  Avrum 03/05/07
  94.   To Stephen Connor 17:13  |  Lee 03/05/07
  95.   American Jew 17:33  |  me 03/05/07
  96.   Stright 2 the point on the top of your head 17:37  |  StephenConnor 03/05/07
  97.   Raise your right hand... 17:39  |  natan 03/05/07
  98.   Exchange Vanunu for Pollard... 17:56  |  Rufus 03/05/07
  99.   American Jew - You are the exception 18:19  |  me 03/05/07
  100.   #54 Jane 2; what`s your point? 18:22  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  101.   #53 Well, Mark; it appears you have hit the nail 18:24  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  102.   #84 Hey Peter SM; get your facts straight! 18:29  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  103.   QUESTION 18:35  |  Mark of Lewiston 03/05/07
  104.   American Jew 18:42  |  StephenConnor 03/05/07
  105.   #102 KNICKER Elastic NAME THEM ALL AND THE TIME SERVED 18:49  |  paul harris 03/05/07
  106.   Seems to me Pollard case failed to deter other Jewish traitors 19:02  |  Joe 03/05/07
  107.   #17 19:14  |  Jane 03/05/07
  108.   Why didn`t Clinton pardon Pollard along with other criminals? 19:14  |  Toronto`s Finest 03/05/07
  109.   #23 19:15  |  Jane 03/05/07
  110.   Trade Pollard for 10,000+ Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails? 19:42  |  Mimi 03/05/07
  111.   Bush`s Biggest Mistake 19:42  |  Chick Corea 03/05/07
  112.   Jane, are you sure? 19:49  |  Ibrahim 03/05/07
  113.   #96 Stephen Conner, Sorry about my spelling, sorry 2 offend u.. 19:56  |  Stright 2 the point 03/05/07
  114.   #63 One more thing. Stephen, Why the Rusian shot down KAl? 20:00  |  Stright 2 the point 03/05/07
  115.   The right thing 20:16  |  W 03/05/07
  116.   # 111 Chick.US should tell Israel what to do.They give $billions! 20:16  |  Toronto`s Finest 03/05/07
  117.   #11 PJ 20:42  |  Boycott 03/05/07
  118.   PutThis Matter To Rest and Just Execute Pollard 20:49  |  Mr. Knowitall 03/05/07
  119.   #116 Toronto`s Worst 20:57  |  Chick Corea 03/05/07
  120.   CIA and Pollard 21:17  |  P. J. Casey 03/05/07
  121.   about allegiances 21:31  |  American Jew 03/05/07
  122.   What is Israel whinging about now 21:38  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/05/07
  123.   #!05 Hey Paul; what has that got to do with the price 21:42  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  124.   is not that telling?? 21:43  |  arab 03/05/07
  125.   #106 Hey Joe; read your right minded post! 21:45  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  126.   my heart is changing towards Tenet. 21:45  |  arab 03/05/07
  127.   You can`s be American, if you want J Pollard Free! 22:05  |  omolll 03/05/07
  128.   Stright 2 the point 22:08  |  American in NY 03/05/07
  129.   #111 Hey Chick; and exactly what does your expose 22:09  |  ballistic 03/05/07
  130.   I tell you what 22:14  |  Chris Linthwaite 03/05/07
  131.   ballistic 23:08  |  reasonable 03/05/07
  132.   ALL worse traitors than pollard were set free, why is he not??? 23:08  |  SHIMON 03/05/07
  133.   a spy is a spy 23:10  |  Jason 03/05/07
  134.   ballistic 23:11  |  danite 03/05/07
  135.   # 127 Omolll."My country! Love it or leave it." How quaint! 23:17  |  Toronto`s Finest 03/05/07
  136.   amen brother! 23:22  |  David 03/05/07
  137.   Now tenetes an anti semite? 23:30  |  Bill Jack 03/05/07
  138.   Mr. Knowitall, you mean like the Rosenbergs, Saco and Vanzetti? 23:38  |  Jake 03/05/07
  139.   Linthwaite, Vanunu is on parole 23:40  |  Jake 03/05/07
  140.   arab, #126, Tenet also blamed Arafat for failure of peace process 23:42  |  Jake 03/05/07
  141.   misplaced sympathy for Pollard 23:43  |  ipse dixit 03/05/07
  142.   joe...and other misinformation 23:46  |  inigo montoya 03/05/07
  143.   Linthwaite`s underhanded insinuations, #130 23:47  |  Jake 03/05/07
  144.   Pollard Was Never Found Guilty 00:05  |  Efox 04/05/07
  145.   At least Tenet admitted the truth about Yasser Arafat 00:06  |  Jake 04/05/07
  146.   #129 ballistic - You show your bias and ignorance. 00:10  |  ChickCorea 04/05/07
  147.   Other Spies Who Stole More Are Free 00:10  |  Efox 04/05/07
  148.   omolll - No in the old days he`d be free 00:11  |  Dr David I. Gross 04/05/07
  149.   re: arab 00:11  |  Efox 04/05/07
  150.   Pollard Part II - Compare with other spies 00:17  |  Chick Corea 04/05/07
  151.   Pollard Part III - Compare to other spies 00:19  |  Chick Corea 04/05/07
  152.   #15 Harry Greenblatt. "Israel was not and is not an enemy of USA" 00:23  |  Maureen Ann 04/05/07
  153.   Another interesting thought about Pollard case 00:36  |  Chick Corea 04/05/07
  154.   #138 inigo montoya and his talking points 00:47  |  Joe 04/05/07
  155.   Chick Corea: Interesting comparisions 00:49  |  Ronnie Wolman 04/05/07
  156.   TENET--AMERICAN LOW LIFE 01:02  |  OBSERVER 04/05/07
  157.   # 145 Jake 01:13  |  Swiss (Dino) 04/05/07
  158.   #146 Hey Chick; oh well, all you lay out 01:35  |  ballistic 04/05/07
  159.   #131 Hey Reasonable; golly day, your post 01:39  |  ballistic 04/05/07
  160.   #138 inigo montoya and his talking points 01:39  |  Joe 04/05/07
  161.   #125 ballistic 01:40  |  Joe 04/05/07
  162.   Say Danite; is it crazy day where you are??? 01:43  |  ballistic 04/05/07
  163.   All claiming to know why he is in prison are liars 01:49  |  David 04/05/07
  164.   #134 Ah ha!! Danite 01:50  |  ballistic 04/05/07
  165.   Pollard is bad for Israel 02:31  |  Colin Wright 04/05/07
  166.   Hey Paul 02:45  |  Stephen Connor 04/05/07
  167.   Brod 02:52  |  John 04/05/07
  168.   #39 straight to the point....AIPAC is under FBI inv 03:23  |  Nick W 04/05/07
  169.   #43 Joseph. You mean all the terrorism we have b/c of 03:34  |  Nick W 04/05/07
  170.   PETER SM 03:36  |  FLOWER 04/05/07
  171.   re: ipse dixit 03:42  |  Efox 04/05/07
  172.   HEY Ballistic neither of us know exactly what he did.Thats the 03:46  |  PETER. S.M 04/05/07
  173.   Pollard is where he belongs 04:21  |  Jes 04/05/07
  174.   Absolut Nonsense not Sweden 04:32  |  jay 04/05/07
  175.   Pollard 04:41  |  Naim S. Mahlab 04/05/07
  176.   Spy 04:55  |  Gordon 04/05/07
  177.   PJ 04:58  |  Connie 04/05/07
  178.   Pollard again 05:00  |  Naim S. Mahlab 04/05/07
  179.   Mark B. 05:05  |  Connie 04/05/07
  180.   Tenet is a greater enemy of the USA than Bin Laden 05:32  |  Joseph 04/05/07
  181.   #152 Maureen Ann 05:38  |  Gabriel 04/05/07
  182.   omolll - YOU HAVE NO IDEA WHAT AMERICA IS ABOUT 05:44  |  Dr David I. Gross 04/05/07
  183.   Pollard`s Situation 05:56  |  Ethan S. Burger 04/05/07
  184.   Omar to Brad L 05:58  |  Omar 04/05/07
  185.   POLLARD 06:12  |  mike 04/05/07
  186.   9/11 might have been prevented if he had quitted 06:23  |  Lou 04/05/07
  187.   Re: 39# Nick get your facts stright 06:24  |  Leslie Duffey 04/05/07
  188.   Pollard is a lying trader....a judas to his country 06:25  |  Mike 04/05/07
  189.   #123 knicker elastic TWANGS AND APPLIES FAIR PLAY FOR ISRAEL 06:30  |  paul harris 04/05/07
  190.   corfu and yosemite 06:41  |  hostel 04/05/07
  191.   mehmet # 79 07:09  |  Eli 04/05/07
  192.   Maureen Ann #152 07:22  |  Eli 04/05/07
  193.   "ME" D.Ross clearly demonstrated that his loyalty was to USA 07:53  |  PETER SM 04/05/07
  194.   Mike 07:56  |  Connie 04/05/07
  195.   #161 Hey Paul!!! The weasel should 08:05  |  ballistic 04/05/07
  196.   MAUREEN ANN.OCUPPATION you mean big oil and CAIR 08:15  |  PETER SM 04/05/07
  197.   IF POLLARD WAS A MUSLIM HE WOULD HAVE BEEN FREED LONG AGO 09:09  |  APEASING ARABS 04/05/07
  198.   Pollard penetrated too deeply. He knows too much to be free 09:26  |  Jason 04/05/07
  199.   Iconic flaw 09:35  |  Thenet 04/05/07
  200.   Chick Corea runs the ruler over other sentences 09:40  |  Johnboy 04/05/07
  201.   #170PeterSM, That too! 10:11  |  Maureen Ann 04/05/07
  202.   # 108 toronto`s finest 10:46  |  eric 04/05/07
  203.   # 132 i have a better question for you, shimon 10:48  |  eric 04/05/07
  204.   #84 PETER SM 14:23  |  Johnboy 04/05/07
  205.   Chick Corea, the disloyal American 15:33  |  Ibrahim 04/05/07
  206.   redflag 18:39  |  highlander 04/05/07
  207.   Tenet is of Greek Orign: No wonder 20:29  |  Semsem 04/05/07
  208.   Inigo talking point What did Pollard DO? 21:13  |  Inigo Montoya 04/05/07
  209.   Loyalty 23:09  |  Jason Grelli 04/05/07
  210.   207 - Idiotic generalization 00:37  |  OldVet 05/05/07
  211.   Pollard is a criminal 00:53  |  ze`ev 06/05/07
  212.   #181 Gabriel. Not sure how to read you Gabriel. 04:08  |  Maureen Ann 06/05/07
  213.   #192Eli "If that means siding with Israel, then so be it.` 04:30  |  Maureen Ann 06/05/07
  214.   #125ballistic. About 9/11 06:55  |  Maureen Ann 06/05/07
  215.   Amazing... 19:13  |  inigo montoya 07/05/07
 Today Online
Jewish South African minister slams critics of Hamas PM invite
Responses: 53
FM: We can't make errors of Lebanon war in Gaza
Responses: 44
Shmuel Rosner: Less American attention on Israel would be nice
Responses: 20
Foreign Ministry prepping for possibility of renewed Syria talks
Responses: 23
Rosner's Domain
* New Guest: Daniel Septimus of MyJewishLearning
* Too much Israel: Small, vulnerable and endangered
* Poll: What should Israel's Labor party do?
* Bush, Rice, Olmert, Livni: the State of affairs


More Headlines
18:32 NSC: Syrian call for dialogue with Israel is 'authentic'
18:26 Olmert: Israel to respond 'severely' to ongoing Qassam rocket fire
18:24 IAF strikes Jihad rocket-firing squad in Gaza, wounding one
15:38 Abbas praises U.S. security plan as step toward easing Palestinian suffering
17:36 Student leader: Compromise presented by PMO is humiliating
14:43 Livni to meet Jordan, Egypt FMs in Cairo to discuss Arab peace plan
15:54 Jewish S. African minister slams critics of invitation to Hamas PM
14:13 Dollar dips below NIS 4 mark for first time since March of 2000
16:28 Beilin proposes bill to overturn mandatory military service law
15:46 Court overturns conviction of man involved in attack on Arabs
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved