Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., May 05, 2007 Iyyar 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Azmi Bishara in Cairo last month. (Reuters)
Last update - 21:12 02/05/2007
Ex-MK Bishara suspected of treason, passing data to Hezbollah
By Jonathan Lis and Shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondents, and News Agencies

Police on Wednesday ended the final layer of secrecy surrounding the investigation into former MK Azmi Bishara, saying that he is suspected of treason and espionage, for allegedly having aided Hezbollah during the Second Lebanon War in July and August 2006.

Bishara, the chairman of the Balad party, is suspected of having been in contact with Hezbollah intelligence agents during the 34-day conflict.

In an interview from Amman, Jordan, Bishara said Wednesday that he was a victim of political persecution.

Advertisement

"It is very clear they have a plot, he said. It's a classic manifestation of how the security establishment works in Israel when they target someone for political reasons."

A senior Shin Bet official told reporters earlier in the day that Bishara had had prolonged contact with Hezbollah members who were involved in gathering information on Israel.

Bishara allegedly provided "information, suggestions and recommendations," including censored material, to his contacts in Lebanon during the war.

The Shin Bet official said that Bishara was fully aware of the sensitivity of the information. According to the Shin Bet, he was given "missions" from Hezbollah, which he then carried out.

Bishara allegedly advised Hezbollah on the ramifications of firing missiles further south than Haifa. At the time, Hezbollah was debating whether to strike at targets deeper inside Israel. A few days later, missiles struck south of Haifa for the first time.

The former lawmaker is also suspected of helping Hezbollah with assessments regarding a possible Israeli assassination attempt on Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah, as well as offering advice on waging psychological warfare against the Israelis.

Investigators in charge of the case said they had difficulty assessing the extent of the damage caused by Bishara's alleged actions.

Bishara had not been privy to classified material, and from the press briefing, it seemed that the information he passed to Hezbollah could have been obtained from open media sources in Israel. The Shin Bet rejects this assumption, however, claiming that Hezbollah saw a "strategic value" in Bishara's reports.

"Any intelligence body would be happy to receive intelligence from a lawmaker of an enemy state, especially during war," officials said.

Further suspicions

Bishara is also suspected of contact with foreign intelligence agents. Investigators refuse to say which country these agents were from, but that Bishara received large sums of money indirectly from them.

The sums, estimated at hundreds of thousands of dollars, were transferred to Bishara via Jordan and from there to a Palestinian woman in East Jerusalem.

Police claim that Bishara did not declare these funds or explain from where they originated. It is unclear whether these funds were intended for Bishara or if he acted just as a courier.

The Shin Bet clarified that there are further serious suspicions against Bishara, which have yet to be made public as his departure from the country delayed the investigation. While the Shin Bet would prefer that Bishara return, they are of the opinion that he will not do so in the near future.

Reports of the investigation, whose details were initially under a strict court-imposed gag order, first emerged about a month ago. Bishara, who left Israel before the reports broke, has avoided returning, saying he fears he will not receive a fair trial.

He has been traveling in the Arab world, and resigned from the Knesset at the Israeli embassy in Cairo last month. He has denied all the allegations and accused police of conducting a witch hunt. He has vowed to return to Israel, but not said when he will do so.

Police, providing the first concrete details in the case after the lengthy gag order, said Bishara will be arrested immediately if he returns to Israel, and could face the death penalty if convicted.

According to the police and the Shin Bet security service, Bishara is accused of grave crimes against national security, and of aiding the enemy in wartime. He is believed to have secretly received hundreds of thousands of dollars via Jordan, without declaring the source of the money.

Partial details of the affair were released Wednesday afternoon, after the High Court lifted the gag order on the investigation.

Bishara was investigated twice by police on March 22 and 23, after which he went overseas. He told officers that he would return to Israel within days. His immunity as a then member of parliament made it impossible to stop him from leaving the country.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz ordered Bishara to return to Israel and face the investigation by April 22. Bishara ignored the order, and on April 26 submitted his resignation via the Israeli embassy in Cairo. He is currently classified as 'pending investigation' by the police.

Office searched
Bishara's deputy, MK Jamal Zahalka, said that he had been summoned to the Knesset on Monday because police wanted him to be present while they searched the former Balad MK's office.

Balad criticized the search, as did the Hadash faction.

MK Dov Khenin (Hadash) said, "I am very disturbed by the erosion of Knesset immunity and the immunity of its members."

Zahalka called the search "a provocation," and that sealing Bishara's office was illegal, as it had been done while Bishara was still a member of the Knesset.

Following Bishara's resignation, the Justice Ministry asked Knesset Speaker Dalia Itzik to seal the office so it could be searched, and materials were confiscated.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Gems from a scholar
Lamed Shapiro, one of Yiddish's greatest writers, tells a narrative of Russia under the czars.
Lag Ba'Omer
In this week's Torah portion, the great bonfires that mark this day are shrouded in mystery.
  1.   Olmert regime let him go to Egypt 14:58  |  Jason 02/05/07
  2.   Clamping down on the Chritian Israelis 15:07  |  Lars Hansen 02/05/07
  3.   Death penalty for espionage? 15:11  |  SLAVO 02/05/07
  4.   Will Israel send their assassination teams after him? 15:14  |  Benny Weiss 02/05/07
  5.   Interesting that in the Hebrew site there are more details 15:21  |  Judith, Haifa 02/05/07
  6.   Absolute bollocks 15:21  |  Clickfool 02/05/07
  7.   Persecution 15:23  |  Sami 02/05/07
  8.   PM and DM also aided Hizbullah. 15:49  |  Inyaki 02/05/07
  9.   re#4 To "Benny":No, they ll ask the Syrians !! 15:50  |  Alberto Cohen 02/05/07
  10.   Christians in Israel 15:52  |  Peter 02/05/07
  11.   re#4 o "Benny":No, They will issue a FATWA !! 15:59  |  Alberto Cohen 02/05/07
  12.   re#4:To "Benny":No, they will start putting on fire.. 16:01  |  Alberto Cohen 02/05/07
  13.   Bishara capital suspicion needs complete public information. 16:18  |  H.H.M 02/05/07
  14.   Hizbollah is not our enemy 16:23  |  Palestinian Arab 02/05/07
  15.   any "Israel is anti-Christian" post is absurd. 16:27  |  Richard S 02/05/07
  16.   What about Bishara`s colleagues and supporters? 16:38  |  Briton 02/05/07
  17.   treason? 16:46  |  yuval 02/05/07
  18.   Of Shadows and Terrorists 17:04  |  Pilly 02/05/07
  19.   #2 Lars Hansen 17:10  |  * BEN JABO 02/05/07
  20.   Charged with treason for discussing public information? 17:21  |  George W 02/05/07
  21.   Clamping down on Christians? - #2 17:21  |  Gil J. Yashar 02/05/07
  22.   Interesting 17:34  |  Wissam 02/05/07
  23.   #2-2 Lars Hansen 17:36  |  * BEN JABO 02/05/07
  24.   Olmert & Peretz aided the enemy and 17:38  |  Avi 02/05/07
  25.   Jonathon Pollard redux 17:39  |  W 02/05/07
  26.   #20 Geroge W (dubya?) 17:41  |  * BEN JABO 02/05/07
  27.   #2 Lars Hansen - Status of Christians 17:44  |  * BEN JABO 02/05/07
  28.   Israel anti-Christian? Who built the Nazareth Basilica? 17:49  |  Jake 02/05/07
  29.   Bishara can hardly be called a Christian Israeli 17:59  |  Jake 02/05/07
  30.   To #20 - George W. 18:21  |  Michael 02/05/07
  31.   Hey "W", was a Pollard a senator or Presidential candidate? 18:32  |  Jake 02/05/07
  32.   Bishara`s treason 19:22  |  puzzled 02/05/07
  33.   He should stand trial 19:29  |  Rami 02/05/07
  34.   balls 19:32  |  KoolG 02/05/07
  35.   Echoes Of The Case Against Barghouti? 19:33  |  chet 02/05/07
  36.   #28, Jake. You`re not serious, are you 19:33  |  zmogus 02/05/07
  37.   respond to 22 19:34  |  jamal 02/05/07
  38.   to # 2 and # 10: both are WRONG 19:37  |  Rami 02/05/07
  39.   An Arab aiding Terrorists? 19:42  |  SystemF 02/05/07
  40.   Ben Jabo 19:45  |  I understand 02/05/07
  41.   To Jake # 28 19:51  |  Rami 02/05/07
  42.   Rami / relatives abroad 19:55  |  Moshe 02/05/07
  43.   zmogus, living in a dream world 20:18  |  Jake 02/05/07
  44.   I hope Mossad brings him back for trial 20:30  |  RA 02/05/07
  45.   I am more concerned about the "Arab" minister Ghaleb Majadle... 20:35  |  bat yam 02/05/07
  46.   Israel Blackmailing its non-Jewish representative. 20:38  |  Bandar Michaels 02/05/07
  47.   Just two words to say re: Bishara....... 20:40  |  Sherman 02/05/07
  48.   Rami, #41 20:44  |  Jake 02/05/07
  49.   Ex-MK Bishara suspected of treason, passing data to Hezbollah 20:51  |  Just passing 02/05/07
  50.   Israel Needs to Give Up Territories for Peace 20:53  |  natan 02/05/07
  51.   Rami (continued) 21:10  |  Jake 02/05/07
  52.   Bishara`s Treason 21:11  |  David Cohen 02/05/07
  53.   Natan you are right 21:21  |  Bandar Michaels 02/05/07
  54.   Why the gag order?? 21:23  |  Joyce 02/05/07
  55.   Natan: Bishara lives in Jewish Nazareth Ilit, not the Meshulash 21:30  |  Jake 02/05/07
  56.   Christians are a minority that neither Jews or Moslems understand 21:38  |  Bandar Michaels 02/05/07
  57.   golani 21:38  |  idf 02/05/07
  58.   to Zmogus#36 21:42  |  Ilya 02/05/07
  59.   Is Bishara the "Dreyfus" version of the Arab Israelis? 21:46  |  JustMe 02/05/07
  60.   to number 45 22:15  |  Rami 02/05/07
  61.   To replies 54 and 56 22:22  |  natan 02/05/07
  62.   #25 Very ignorant 22:39  |  Gili 02/05/07
  63.   diversion? 22:55  |  H 02/05/07
  64.   Israel should send their terrorist death squads 23:02  |  Mike 02/05/07
  65.   JustMe and Dreyfus #60 23:05  |  Elihu 02/05/07
  66.   #65 Mike, you`re one to talk! 23:39  |  Jake 02/05/07
  67.   The Evidence is Not Flimsy 23:56  |  Eli 02/05/07
  68.   Christians in Israel 00:10  |  Robert 03/05/07
  69.   61Rami... 00:13  |  bat yam 03/05/07
  70.   Rami - Sharon`s Nazareth mosque 00:38  |  Reymond 03/05/07
  71.   To Eli 00:43  |  Richard 03/05/07
  72.   #50 Natan 01:07  |  * BEN JABO 03/05/07
  73.   Bishara and Treason 01:21  |  Larry 03/05/07
  74.   For Shame Haaretz - Journalistic Laziness 01:28  |  chet 03/05/07
  75.   to #14,Transfer is becoming more appealing 01:35  |  Take a hint 03/05/07
  76.   suspected 01:54  |  Shmuelshachor 03/05/07
  77.   #14 Palestinian Arab 02:01  |  sel 03/05/07
  78.   Bishara doesn`t have the guts to come back to Israel 02:49  |  Alberto Cohen 03/05/07
  79.   Silly Rabbit 03:51  |  Trix are for Kids 03/05/07
  80.   ARAB MK 04:02  |  Commonsense 03/05/07
  81.   Jake and Rami 04:12  |  Gina 03/05/07
  82.   I agree with #74 04:34  |  Etan 03/05/07
  83.   Bandar Michaels? #56 04:56