Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., September 05, 2009 Elul 16, 5769 | | Israel Time: 18:32 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
Haaretz Toolbar
Diplomacy
Defense Jewish World Opinion National
Print Edition
Car Rental
Books Haaretz Magazine Business Real Estate Focus U.S.A. Travel Week's End Anglo File
Share |
Last update - 00:00 05/02/2007
Immediate resignation
By Haaretz Editorial

The Winograd Report contains not even one lenient word to which the prime minister could cling in order to extend his term.

The members of the committee he appointed closed all the cracks and left no escape from responsibility - if not now, then in two months, when the final report is written. The hint was almost explicit: If the report's principal subjects do not take personal responsibility, the committee will make clear recommendations in July. If the prime minister does not quit, he will be thrown out in a month or two. All this is virtually self-evident from the severity of the findings. If a war broke out tomorrow morning, the present leadership would not have a mandate to lead it.

If the prime and defense ministers do not resign following the Winograd findings, their imperviousness will be additional proof that they were not worthy of their posts from the outset. Any attempt to share the failure with previous prime ministers will not succeed.
Advertisement
Personal responsibility for failure - which, as the report states, was evident in every aspect of their duties, including planning, assessment, implementation, lack of forethought, responding rashly, setting unrealistic goals and not adopting actions to reality - has never been assigned by any other committee. Nothing the prime minister should have done before he went to war was done. The colossal failure that has already been identified in their functioning, even before the entire war has been analyzed, does not permit Ehud Olmert and Amir Peretz to remain in their posts for even one more day.

The Winograd Committee stated that the very act of going to war was irresponsible, because it was not based on a detailed plan, because the Lebanese arena was not studied, because it was never possible to attain the goals set, because the massive rain of rockets on the home front was not taken into consideration, because the cabinet went into battle without an exit plan, and because the ministers who voted for this move did not know or understand its significance and where it would lead.

Even after it became clear that the army had no solution to the attacks on the home front, the necessary adjustments - for example, drafting the reserves and training them for an extensive ground operation - were not made, and the government and the army did not coordinate military moves with the situation on the ground. The war was a case of shooting from the hip: a spectacle of rashness, imprudence and lack of planning, with no objectives, no attainable goals, no knowledge of the Israel Defense Forces' military capabilities and no one taking responsibility.

No harsher report than that of the Winograd Committee on the Second Lebanon War could have been written, even if a state commission of inquiry had been established. The statements made yesterday, in precise and unequivocal language, are painful testimony to the culture of charlatanic, belligerent and irresponsible government, whose existence the public has sensed for a long time. If this government does not step down now, disgust and despair will mount. The responses of the government's public relations experts and spokespeople, prepared in reaction to a watered-down version of the report that was leaked at the end of last week, now sound hollow and divorced from reality in light of the Winograd Committee's unambiguous formulations.
PROMOTION: Mamilla Hotel
Bookmark to del.icio.us  
 
Chavez blasts Israel
Venezuela president, in Syria, slams Israel for mistreating Palestinians, being agent of U.S. imperialism.
Kindertransport revisited
Holocaust survivors re-create three-day journey that saved children in WWII.
  1.   Israel 11:40  |  Naim S. Mahlab 01/05/07
  2.   IS IT REAL THAT OLMERT`S POPULARITY IS 2 % 12:18  |  LEBANESE 01/05/07
  3.   And what about Olmert Sharon knee-jerk cheerleader Haaretz? 12:26  |  Nili 01/05/07
  4.   Change is already happening 14:02  |  steve 01/05/07
  5.   # 2 14:07  |  israeli 01/05/07
  6.   Partner for Peace? 14:36  |  Arnie 01/05/07
  7.   The writing on EVERY wall 17:16  |  Emanuel 01/05/07
  8.   Olmert andPeretz, should they resign? 17:29  |  Isaac A Olayinka 01/05/07
  9.   To Lebanese 17:49  |  Lee 01/05/07
  10.   A Silly Committe for a Silly public of a Silly country 18:13  |  Jebei 01/05/07
  11.   The UN should take over. 19:10  |  Abe 01/05/07
  12.   Abe,the UN should send troops to England to preventt you&Co 19:46  |  Absolute Sweden 01/05/07
  13.   Lebanese #2 - Hizbollah will tell you a selective truth 21:36  |  PB 01/05/07
  14.   Overanalyzed - What a Waste! 21:43  |  PB 01/05/07
  15.   must olmert resign 23:26  |  ahmed abd dullah 01/05/07
  16.   Lebanese: can`t be 2% 23:50  |  Paul Freedman 01/05/07
  17.   encouraging news 00:38  |  syvanen 02/05/07
  18.   To all UK hypocrits 05:10  |  Isac 02/05/07
  19.   Olmert and Bush 07:31  |  Wolfram 02/05/07
  20.   # 2, LEBANESE 08:36  |  indrajaya 02/05/07
  21.   Self Destructive Propoganda 05:01  |  MIKE 03/05/07
  22.   HINT*HINT* 05:07  |  MIKE 03/05/07
  23.   A MILLITARY LEADER IS NEEDED 05:12  |  MIKE 03/05/07
  24.   # 3 tsk tsk, nili 09:36  |  eric 03/05/07
  25.   To # 19 12:11  |  mohamed 03/05/07
  26.   to MIKE #21-22 12:30  |  mohamed 03/05/07
  27.   need financial aid 10:26  |  meir mahlab 08/11/08
Special Offers
Advertisement
Date Local Jewish Singles
Ready to meet your match? Join Jdate today!
Holidays are here
Minerals Aromatics Body Lotion for free! Click here.
Eldan Rent a Car
Israel's leading car rental company offers you a 20% discount on online reservations
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt
Marina Royale
Your Luxurious Suite While staying in Israel
Table to Table
Help to Israel food bank
4XP
Trading Platform Online Currency Trading
More Headlines
15:19 Hamas chief arrives in Cairo to discuss Shalit deal
15:37 'Iran prepared for Western pressure over nuclear program'
15:34 Chavez: Iran won't end quest for peaceful nuclear energy
18:21 Doctor: 90% of war casualties at Gaza hospital were civilians
18:02 Palestinians: Gaza teen dies after being shot by IDF near Israel border
17:23 Sa'ar makes fresh defense of Netanyahu against rightist, PA critics
15:03 Report: Jane Fonda joins boycott of Toronto film festival over homage to Israel
22:27 TV ROUND-UP: Hamas may finalize Shalit swap, Madonna meets Netanyahu
01:09 U.S. 'regrets' Netanyahu plan to approve new West Bank homes
17:24 Mousavi calls for renewed protests over disputed Iran election
14:20 Elderly Jews re-create kindertransport trip
12:38 Ex-Israeli judge requests parole during Peru extradition proceedings
16:18 U.S. Congressmen to EU: Condemn IDF organ harvesting article
Home | TV | Print Edition | Diplomacy | Opinion | Arts & Leisure | Sports | Jewish World | Site rules |
| Israel 2009 election results | Makom: Engaging on Israel
| Search engine marketing
Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, offers real-time breaking news, opinions and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora.
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved