Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 01, 2007 Iyyar 13, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:27 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Campaign posters for Socialist party candidate for the French presidency Segolene Royal and French UMP Party candidate Nicolas Sarkozy placed in front of the Rouen city hall last week. (Reuters)
Last update - 06:12 29/04/2007
Ahead of elections, France refrains from calling incident anti-Semitic
By Yair Ettinger, Haaretz Correspondent

MARSEILLES -Days before the presidential elections in France, authorities are reluctant to label as anti-Semitic an incident in which 22-year-old Audrey Brachelle was brutally attacked last Thursday in Marseilles.

Brachelle claims her Arab assailants stripped her and drew swastikas on her body.

Brachelle, an accountant at a textile factory, told Haaretz she was followed by two Middle-Eastern looking assailants on her way to the metro station in La Rose, a Marseilles neighborhood home to many Arab immigrants as well as Jews. According to her account of the incident, they snatched her cellular phone.

Advertisement

While she was resisting the robbery, they noticed she was wearing a golden locket bearing a Hebrew "Chai." That's when the robbery turned into an anti-Semitic attack. According to Brachelle, her attackers began striking her in the head. Then, one of them pulled a knife, cut a tuft of her hair and slashed her shirt. The two men then drew a swastika on her bare chest and fled the scene.

The police do not have any evidence refuting Brachelle's story, nor have they indicated they have any reason to doubt her account. She even helped reenact the incident at the scene. Tzvi Amar, president of the Marseilles Jewish community, told Haaretz that the attorney general's office informed him that he had concluded the attack was indeed anti-Semitic. Yet the police spokesman would only say the case "required further investigation."

This may be because calling the incident an anti-Semitic attack could have far-reaching political ramifications for the final round in the presidential elections, scheduled for May 6.

Anti-Semitism and violent behavior by Arab immigrants are hot topics that right-wing candidate Nicolas Sarkozy often alludes to. He has warned voters that his left-wing rival, Segolene Royal, might endanger French society by being overly lenient in such cases.

"I don't know what really happened, but it smells fishy," Farid Tayer, who runs a vegetable stand less than 100 meters from the scene of the attack, says. "It strikes me as a provocation connected to the elections. I think someone is hoping to filch a couple of votes off of this affair. Jews and Arabs have lived peacefully for a long time. The real violence here is on the part of Sarkozy, who's threatening to use force against us immigrants."

Tzvi Amar believes the opposite. He thinks Brachelle was indeed attacked because she was Jewish, and that authorities are stifling such claims because of their electoral volatility. The local Jewish community as a whole, however, is adopting a very ginger approach to the entire affair. They have been bitten once, and now they are twice shy.

In 2004, a French woman claimed six North African immigrants attacked her and her baby in a train near Paris. She said they beat her and her son, and scrawled a swastika on her body. Political mayhem ensued, until it was revealed that the alleged victim was not actually Jewish, and that she had invented the entire story.

The Jewish community is determined not to see the incident reoccur, and is keeping a low profile on the incident.

Meanwhile, Brachelle does not want to leave her home. Her concerned family members told Haaretz that she has been frightened, confused and suffering from acute headaches since the incident. "We can't even go near her, she just screams at us to leave her alone," they say.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
One in every backyard
New building technologies make private pools affordable even to non-millionaires.
Party on the news
Culture-coverage on TV ranges from the jocular Haim Etgar to the veteran Sari Raz.
  1.   .... 06:37  |  Colin Wright 29/04/07
  2.   Marseille 07:45  |  jean 29/04/07
  3.   in truth it is an antisemetic country why i buycot all french pro 07:46  |  ralph 29/04/07
  4.   here`s an experiment that I encourage French Muslims to try 07:55  |  Abir 29/04/07
  5.   I can`t believe the woman` story..Jews in France 08:37  |  French 29/04/07
  6.   muslim lies 08:56  |  Watcher 29/04/07
  7.   To no.5 08:58  |  Steve Holden 29/04/07
  8.   re: Ralph #5 09:11  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  9.   answer to anti-Semitic attacks in France 09:14  |  mike levine 29/04/07
  10.   how to stop anti-Semitic attacks 09:17  |  mike levine 29/04/07
  11.   re: Abir #4 09:27  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  12.   French Citizen 09:46  |  Connie 29/04/07
  13.   Paulo, 10:18  |  Realistic 29/04/07
  14.   #8 10:18  |  james 29/04/07
  15.   Re: Paulo #8 10:30  |  Shlomo 29/04/07
  16.   Tell us Paulo 10:46  |  Michael 29/04/07
  17.   Didn`t we read about "anti-semitic" attacks exposed as hoax 10:51  |  Joe 29/04/07
  18.   A small picture of what happens in the world 11:02  |  ScotGuy 29/04/07
  19.   This is yet another 11:14  |  Nerys 29/04/07
  20.   ronnie wolman and wolfowitz 11:14  |  harvey morris 29/04/07
  21.   Portuguese joke - Paulo 11:14  |  ScotGuy 29/04/07
  22.   Portuguese antisemitism and Paulo 11:45  |  Francis 29/04/07
  23.   19#Nerys 11:47  |  Alon Fisher 29/04/07
  24.   Connie..I don`t give a damn about you and your shitty 11:50  |  French citiznen 29/04/07
  25.   jew hating in fashion in france!!! 11:59  |  Ben Uziel 29/04/07
  26.   Perhaps, just perhaps... 11:59  |  Michel 29/04/07
  27.   free the women of Islam 12:02  |  Feminist 29/04/07
  28.   Connie - Was it the French who were voted most hated 12:05  |  waiting for justice 29/04/07
  29.   French-Israeli friendship 12:13  |  Shlomo from Tel-Aviv 29/04/07
  30.   re: Realistic #13 12:16  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  31.   The Victim, Herself, Says It Wasn`t An Anti-Semitic Crime. 12:19  |  Passing Observer 29/04/07
  32.   re french citizen why should we reply him? 12:19  |  tricoteur 29/04/07
  33.   re: Shlomo #15 12:20  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  34.   re: Michael #16 12:24  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  35.   Harvey Morris: Wolfowitz and Anti Semitism 12:27  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/04/07
  36.   re: Scotguy #21 12:36  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  37.   anti-semitic or not, at least it was an agression against a woman 12:36  |  christoph 29/04/07
  38.   31#SHORT SIGHTED OBSERVER 12:39  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  39.   re: Francis #22 12:47  |  Paulo 29/04/07
  40.   We Have to Understand the Trend 12:53  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/04/07
  41.   Passing Observer 12:53  |  christoph 29/04/07
  42.   Paulo - Portuguese Joke 2. 13:01  |  ScotGuy 29/04/07
  43.   39# PAULO IS NOT CATHOLIC??? 13:20  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  44.   vichy words 13:20  |  jean marie 29/04/07
  45.   Portugal on focus 13:25  |  A Brazilian 29/04/07
  46.   Vichy indeed 13:29  |  A Brazilian 29/04/07
  47.   FROGS WOULD RATHER BE CALIPHATED 13:29  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  48.   Portugal on focus II 13:36  |  A Brazilian 29/04/07
  49.   Antisemitic 13:42  |  Ralph 29/04/07
  50.   26#WHAT DID THAT WOMAN 13:43  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  51.   IF SLUGOLENE WANTS TO WIN THE ELECTION 13:51  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  52.   paulo why you afucket up the Angola??? 13:54  |  Angolan 29/04/07
  53.   FRENCH CITIZEN THINKS HE IS LIBERAL AND HUMANE 13:57  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  54.   Shlomo 14:00  |  Alon Fisher 29/04/07
  55.   ronnie wolman i take your point 14:02  |  harvey morris 29/04/07
  56.   , Paulo 14:04  |  Realistic 29/04/07
  57.   alonitzafoni (#47) 14:05  |  european slimebag 29/04/07
  58.   "French Citizen"You are a joke under yet another alias 14:05  |  PETER SM 29/04/07
  59.   Focus in Portugal III 14:08  |  A Brazilian 29/04/07
  60.   antisemitism in france is from the immigrants 14:08  |  parismatch 29/04/07
  61.   Paulo - #33 14:08  |  Shlomo 29/04/07
  62.   Harbey I think you`ve made it now and Im sure... 14:09  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/04/07
  63.   Anti Israel and Anti Semitism and the Immigrants 14:19  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/04/07
  64.   You Zionist fanatics are ignoring reality 14:22  |  French 29/04/07
  65.   Arabs and Jews do NOT live in peace in Europe 14:26  |  Paul Henzen 29/04/07
  66.   Paulo: Israel does much better than Portugal according to the U.N 14:27  |  Francis 29/04/07
  67.   54# Nice try Alonitzafoni 14:33  |  Alon Fisher 29/04/07
  68.   Alon Fisher! 14:33  |  Nerys 29/04/07
  69.   Alonitzafoni 14:36  |  Alon Fisher 29/04/07
  70.   paulo 14:38  |  Nerys 29/04/07
  71.   # 45 a Brazilian - Racism in Portugal and Brazil 14:38  |  Paul Henzen 29/04/07
  72.   Bloody cowards 14:44  |  krystal 29/04/07
  73.   You have no case to rest 14:59  |  A Brazilian 29/04/07
  74.   SORRY NOT FOR CONNIE BUT FOR FRENCH CITIZEN! 15:01  |  Alan 29/04/07
  75.   French focus on the subject 15:08  |  Alon Fisher 29/04/07
  76.   IF JEWS DID IT TO A MUSLIM WOMEN IN FRANCE 15:09  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  77.   A THIEF TURNED INTO A POLITICIAN 15:10  |  indrajaya 29/04/07
  78.   HAARETZ I DID NOT IMPERSONATE ALON FISHER 15:16  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  79.   HAARETZ YOU DONT HAVE THE GUTS 15:18  |  alonitzafoni 29/04/07
  80.   # 72 A Brazilian - Racism isn`t a European invention 15:24  |  Paul Henzen 29/04/07
  81.   Antisemitism in Europe 15:24  |  Laurent Szyster 29/04/07
  82.   Ramallah Joe-Read the story 15:29  |  Avrum 29/04/07
  83.   To # 14 15:30  |  christa 29/04/07
  84.   Paul Henzen You`re absolutely right 15:30  |  krystal 29/04/07
  85.