Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., April 30, 2007 Iyyar 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 08:29 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Rabbi Lau is unworthy
By Haaretz Editorial

There are no special skills required for the position of president of the state, but it is appropriate for the head of state to express in his character and his record the values to which the state aspires and not those according to which it is being run in this insane time. One might have thought it sufficient for two presidents - Ezer Weizman and Moshe Katsav - to have ended their tenures in shame to convince Rabbi Israel Meir Lau to avoid proposing himself as a candidate for the position. But last week Maariv reported that Rabbi Lau has decided to run despite the fact that he, like the Knesset that will elect the president, is aware of the complaints of sexual harassment and the allegations of misconduct that have accompanied his public career for years.

Rabbi Lau is a charismatic personality who charms some and is repellent to others, and he is connected to Israel's social elite, in part by officiating at their weddings. For years Rabbi Lau illegally received payments for performing marriages while he was on the public payroll, both as chief rabbi and as rabbinical courts president. Despite having declared his renunciation of this practice a decade ago, he has continued this unacceptable behavior even in his present position as chief rabbi of Tel Aviv.

Rabbi Lau's corrupt behavior in financial matters has never undermined the respect he enjoys among many, which is the basis for his presidential bid. The fact that three women have testified that he harassed them sexually did not prevent his appointment as chief rabbi of Israel. If the Knesset ignores these facts this time as well, it will signal that the cynicism of its members is unlimited and irredeemable.

Advertisement

Another question relevant to Lau's candidacy is whether it is appropriate to choose an Orthodox rabbi as president of a secular state. Rabbi Lau is not merely a religious man who lives by his faith; rather, he is part of the rabbinical establishment, with all its flaws. Several months ago Haaretz Magazine reported that Rabbi Lau strongly opposes genetic testing during pregnancy since he believes a pregnancy should not be ended because of a genetic abnormality in the fetus. This outlook contradicts medical progress and is particularly troubling when it is advocated by the president of the state. A president could have a negative influence on the decisions of pregnant women, and could have a similar impact on organ donations and on autopsies.

If it was difficult to accept the alienation of Moshe Katsav from Reform rabbis, it would be even more difficult to accept the fact that Rabbi Lau would not agree to shake the hands of women, including heads of state, in a position that is purely ceremonial.

The president will be elected by secret ballot in a few weeks, but the secrecy should not facilitate the selection of an unworthy candidate. If the country's MKs once again choose a president whose shortcomings are known to them, it could spell the end of the institution of the presidency. Rabbi Lau should refrain from presenting himself as a candidate, in order to avoid the ignominy. Each of the other candidates is better and more worthy than he.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
The street's call
Not the politicians, not even the media will decide the Prime Minister's fate.
Miracle wants Koufax
71-year-old Hall of Famer hasn't started a game in over 41 years.
  1.   David Landau is not worthy 10:26  |  Moshe 29/04/07
  2.   David Landau should go 11:00  |  Tal Greenstein 29/04/07
  3.   Moshe, the checklist is longer than that 11:14  |  Pericles 29/04/07
  4.   No Rabbis for office! 11:24  |  Isabella 29/04/07
  5.   Special skills for special duties 12:02  |  sh 29/04/07
  6.   perverted democracy 12:04  |  D Hirod 29/04/07
  7.   Rabbi Lau 12:45  |  Daniel 29/04/07
  8.   Rabbi for President 12:51  |  Daniel 29/04/07
  9.   Daniel #7 and Daniel #8 12:58  |  Daniel #8 29/04/07
  10.   Only he knows for sure 13:06  |  Meir 29/04/07
  11.   #1 and #2 13:15  |  Fussion 29/04/07
  12.   Rabbi Lau is Jewish Osama bin Laden 13:29  |  Moshe 29/04/07
  13.   And therefore what of Peres or Avital 13:50  |  Ilan 29/04/07
  14.   Lau & Law 14:02  |  Even Aharon 29/04/07
  15.   Rabbi for President 14:04  |  Naim S. Mahlab 29/04/07
  16.   Daniel, Lau doesn`t believe in democracy, won`t 14:07  |  Secular settler 29/04/07
  17.   what a horrible attack 14:21  |  Dan Kern 29/04/07
  18.   Rabbi Lau 14:40  |  yuval 29/04/07
  19.   The proud professions of the "secular" in God`s land... 15:21  |  curious 29/04/07
  20.   Rabbi Lau is an appropriate successor 15:45  |  Keith 29/04/07
  21.   Appoint a non Israeli as President 15:46  |  peter 29/04/07
  22.   lau 16:09  |  yigal d. 29/04/07
  23.   Someone who refuses to shake hands... 16:32  |  Gerrit 29/04/2007
  24.   We can not save Iran if we appoint our own Mullahs 16:36  |  PB 29/04/07
  25.   army service 17:00  |  Dan 29/04/07
  26.   If the presidency must be preserved 17:34  |  Joseph E . 29/04/07
  27.   Did Lau explain why he wants to be president? 17:50  |  krystal 29/04/07
  28.   No Thanks 17:54  |  Danite 29/04/07
  29.   What a religious guy! 18:19  |  Chaval 29/04/07
  30.   will Rabbi Lau shake the Chief Rabbi`s hand? 19:03  |  Eli 29/04/07
  31.   Absolutely Scandalous 19:44  |  Ben 29/04/07
  32.   Surprise, surprise 20:01  |  Axel 29/04/07
  33.   Is Shimon Peres Qualified To Be President? 20:44  |  Ben Israel 29/04/07
  34.   RabbiLau 21:56  |  ROXY 29/04/07
  35.   Rabbi Lau - Osama? 22:00  |  Daber 29/04/07
  36.   Charedi parties take note 22:01  |  Ilan 29/04/07
  37.   Different view in the UK 22:14  |  Ben Azai 29/04/07
  38.   Another bigoted disgusting anti-Zionist Haaretz gem 23:05  |  Maya 29/04/07
  39.   Lau 23:58  |  Lee R 29/04/07
  40.   Please don`t nominate Lau 08:22  |  Fortuna Benmayor 30/04/07
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: Learning nothing from the Second Lebanon War
Responses: 93
Aide: Peretz did not fail as defense minister during war
Responses: 65
Pre-elections, France refrains from calling incident anti-Semitic
Responses: 264
Report: Anti-Zionist Israeli to direct film for Israel's 60th birthday
Responses: 151
Poll: 75% of Israeli Arabs support a Jewish constitution
Responses: 84


More Headlines
07:28 Kadima source: Party could oust PM by summer
06:53 ANALYSIS: No mutiny against Olmert in coalition - for now
08:25 Two killed as household gas tank explodes in Jerusalem
07:37 Poll: Rocket strike on reservists was war's breaking point
07:39 War probe will pave way for new round of IDF appointments
05:30 Olmert's aides work to deflect blame as release of report nears
02:22 2 leading Haredi rabbis tour France, Britain to promote Torah learning
03:30 Darfur refugees in kibbutz can't work without health insurance
01:40 Sesame Street returns to Israel, PA, after more than decade off the air
02:26 Defense Ministry security chief Yehiel Horev set to retire this summer
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved