Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., April 29, 2007 Iyyar 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 12:18 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Just an optical illusion
By Nehemia Shtrasler, Haaretz Correspondent

Although there are no official statistics, more Israelis apparently waved their national flag this past Independence Day. Perhaps this was out of a longing for a more innocent period, when the corrupt at least felt ashamed of their deeds, or perhaps the reason was that Bank Hapoalim distributed free flags. However, there was another phenomenon, unparalleled in any other nation: The Stars and Stripes were flown alongside the national flag. This is essentially a declaration that Israelis cannot celebrate their own independence day without remembering that their country's existence is wholly dependent on American backing.

This backing has several aspects. One of them is the military and economic aid that Israel receives annually from Uncle Sam. In this regard, there will soon be a change, in five months' time. October 1 will mark the last time Israel will receive economic aid (totaling $120 million) from the United States. This will be the closing chord of the economic aid Israel has received since the mid-1980s. After October 1, Israel will receive military aid only: $2.4 billion yearly.

The process of gradually reducing the economic assistance began in 1996, with a festive speech by then prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu to both houses of the U.S. Congress. In that address, he passionately declared that Israel had emerged from its childhood and was now mature enough to stand on its own two feet and achieve economic independence. Thus, he announced, Israel was waiving the economic aid that it had received until then from America. Members of Congress, who were moved by this gesture, gave Netanyahu a standing ovation, out of respect for someone willing to give up several hundred million dollars a year.

Advertisement

However, the truth is that this was not a freely given concession; it was a response to American pressure.

Today, 11 years after that festive "concession speech" and after Israel's celebration of its 59th year of independence, has Israel achieved the economic independence that Netanyahu promised? And is it politically independent?

There are those who argue that Israel has already achieved economic independence: For the first time in Israeli history, there was a respectable surplus in our balance of payments, with exports exceeding imports by $0.9 billion and with a large surplus ($6.8 billion) in the current account. If we also factor in a rapid growth rate of five percent for the fourth consecutive year, a negligible inflation rate, the strengthening of the shekel vis-a-vis the dollar, a lower interest rate than in the U.S., and a decrease in unemployment, it is clear why many people believe that Israel has achieved economic independence.

However, this is just an optical illusion. It is a sort of mirage, mere virtual reality - nothing more.

If any American president were to give a small cough and say, in a half-whisper, "hmm, I am considering my steps concerning Israel," our country's excellent economic situation would immediately turn topsy-turvy. Israel's international credit line would instantly freeze, the dollar would soar, and so would our inflation rate. Our balance of payments surplus would become a deficit and foreign investment would flee Israel many times faster than it came. After all, the world knows that without American backing, tiny Israel would quickly revert to its natural proportions.

Therefore, it really does not matter whether or not the economic aid ends in October. What is important is that Israel continue to enjoy the political support of the most powerful nation on earth. After all, were it not for America's veto in the United Nations Security Council, economic sanctions, a la South Africa during its apartheid regime, would have been imposed on Israel long ago. Without that veto, Israel would never have been able to continue fighting the Second Lebanon War when every other country in the world wanted it stopped as soon as it began.

Anyone who needs further evidence of the sad fact that Israel is very far from independence - either economic or political - should know that Israel recently submitted another request for an increase in American military aid. Israel is now asking for a $50 million annual increment in the military grant, so that, in another 10 years' time, it would amount to $2.9 billion.

In the current tense relationship between a Republican administration and a Democratic Congress, where there are sharp disagreements about every conceivable topic, there is only one subject on which President George Bush and Congress see eye-to-eye: unqualified support for Israel. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that Israel will soon receive that additional $50 million annually.

And when the money arrives, Israelis will have yet another reason to lift the American flag high next Independence Day. On Israeli Independence Day, that is.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
My investment advice
How can a writer live in Jerusalem, a city that doesn't even have a tavern?
The shul at IKEA
This weekend, the writer had the joy of meeting the chief rabbi of the Ikea in Netanya.
  1.   US aid to Israel 09:49  |  prairdog 27/04/07
  2.   Israel needs to learn a hard lesson 09:52  |  Dror 27/04/07
  3.   WAVE BOTH FLAGS 10:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/04/07
  4.   Not T, I don`t agreeoo Far 11:00  |  Mary 27/04/07
  5.   US rules , Israel is the 52st State 11:01  |  an American citizen 27/04/07
  6.   We control America and the stupid Americans know it 11:13  |  Californian 27/04/07
  7.   Redemption 11:18  |  Sherlock Holmes 27/04/07
  8.   Israel enjoys the support of America 11:22  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/04/07
  9.   Two reasons to end aid 11:38  |  Ilan 27/04/07
  10.   So what happens when the US walks away? 12:02  |  spyguy 27/04/07
  11.   Support 12:05  |  Sam 27/04/07
  12.   open your eyes, they will soon abandon us 12:07  |  marianitele 27/04/07
  13.   all israelis whould thank the american taxpayers 12:19  |  VIPER 27/04/07
  14.   independance? 12:26  |  ravi 27/04/07
  15.   Really American Citizen #4 ? 12:52  |  S 27/04/07
  16.   The Jews trump card in the mid-east 12:57  |  Dror 27/04/07
  17.   Kohn #7 - Don`t count on the US much longer 13:32  |  spyguy 27/04/07
  18.   Why downplay Israel`s considerable accomplishments? 13:39  |  Shalom Freedman 27/04/07
  19.   perhaps 13:49  |  canadian observer 27/04/07
  20.   interdependence 14:06  |  osvaldo 27/04/07
  21.   And the odd thing is...More and more Americans, Jews and non-Jews 14:38  |  Virginia 27/04/07
  22.   # 5 You are delusional my friend. The desire to "control" anyone 14:56  |  Virginia 27/04/07
  23.   This article is one sided 15:00  |  Andrew 27/04/07
  24.   Strassler misses the point 15:13  |  David Hoffman 27/04/07
  25.   # 14 Spyguy...US aids Egypt almost as much 15:14  |  The Equalizer 27/04/07
  26.   Israel is economically and technological impressive 15:27  |  Mark B. 27/04/07
  27.   # 15, the very fact that the world is dependent upon Arab oil 15:28  |  Virginia 27/04/07
  28.   # 4, God rules!!! And Americans know it. 15:31  |  Virginia 27/04/07
  29.   Dror #13 15:33  |  what a pity 27/04/07
  30.   Very Good point 15:36  |  Danite 27/04/07
  31.   Good point #2 15:39  |  Danite 27/04/07
  32.   It`s bullshit propaganda! 15:46  |  Uzi 27/04/07
  33.   Interdependence is Truth, Wisdom and the way things were intended 16:03  |  Virginia 27/04/07
  34.   Southern and Eastern Europe dependent, too ! 16:11  |  Paul Henzen 27/04/07
  35.   spyguy # 9 & 14 Don`t Hold Your Breath 16:53  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  36.   Californian? yeah right 17:01  |  GZLives 27/04/07
  37.   VIPER regarding what we get in return 17:07  |  GZLives 27/04/07
  38.   dror 17:10  |  jew like you 27/04/07
  39.   ISRAEL WILL SURVIVE 17:15  |  GZLives 27/04/07
  40.   "Californian" The Great Israeli Patriot 17:23  |  Danny Friedman 27/04/07
  41.   Let me correct you: Israel will survive and thrive! 17:40  |  Uzi 27/04/07
  42.   to jew like you 18:02  |  Dror 27/04/07
  43.   Jeff Northridge, finally someone who is honest 18:12  |  Dror 27/04/07
  44.   response to #4 "What is Israel without US aid 18:21  |  Labhras 27/04/07
  45.   Once again Jeff 18:38  |  Danite 27/04/07
  46.   #14, spyguy, now I am really scared 18:38  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/04/07
  47.   The Great American Ripoff 18:54  |  Tosefta 27/04/07
  48.   Labhras 19:05  |  Danite 27/04/07
  49.   Excellent article 19:06  |  Abu Firas Al Qudsi 27/04/07
  50.   spy guy one question 19:29  |  Danite 27/04/07
  51.   A poor analysis 19:35  |  John Proudot 27/04/07
  52.   Dror # 39 So Let`s Go Smart (part 1) 19:36  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  53.   Never Take Such Support for Granted 19:40  |  Tod Zuckerman 27/04/07
  54.   Dior # 39 Speak for yourself, otherwise you sound possessed. 19:41  |  Who is the "we" 27/04/07
  55.   #33 Jeff Northridge 20:06  |  Labhras 27/04/07
  56.   Is Israel Independent 20:18  |  Labhras 27/04/07
  57.   Dror # 39 So Let`s Go Smart (part 2) 20:20  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  58.   to n1 20:30  |  another US citizen 27/04/07
  59.   Dror # 39 So Let`s Go Smart (part 3) 20:52  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  60.   Labhras and his big mouth 20:53  |  Danite 27/04/07
  61.   Dror # 39 So Let`s Go Smart (part 4) 21:16  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  62.   Labhras - Israel/Ireland 21:53  |  Tuemi 27/04/07
  63.   Labhras # 55 Things Change 21:55  |  Jeff Northridge 27/04/07
  64.   Israeli independence 21:57  |  Jonathan 27/04/07
  65.   #47,Tosefta: "Israel...has few enemies..." 21:59  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 27/04/07
  66.   increase in US millitary aid =more damage to economy 22:28  |  zionist forever 27/04/07
  67.   Very true 22:33  |  Chris Linthwaite 27/04/07
  68.   will Egypt and Jordan continue with economic aid 22:42  |  zionist forever 27/04/07
  69.   ENEMIE OF MY ENEMIE IS MY FRIEND!!!! 22:59  |  dzone 27/04/07
  70.   The Merits of Holding One`s Breath 00:12  |  Tom 28/04/07
  71.   dror 00:30  |  jew like you 28/04/07
  72.   Independence? 00:39  |  P. J. Casey 28/04/07
  73.   Israel needs to independent 00:43  |  Shmuel 28/04/07
  74.   Two nations founded on idealism 01:09  |  Gary Ogletree 28/04/07
  75.   To S # 15 01:57  |  christa 28/04/07
  76.   dzone # 69 India 03:38  |  Jeff Northridge 28/04/07
  77.   #60 Danite 03:42  |  Labhras 28/04/07
  78.   #63 Jeff Northridge 03:44  |  Labhras 28/04/07
  79.   #62 Tuemi 03:49  |  Labhras 28/04/07
  80.   to dror 04:10  |  chonny 28/04/07
  81.   Cipora 04:47  |  Lynn 28/04/07
  82.   A call for total independence 04:54  |  Sam 28/04/07
  83.   # 17 spyguy 04:55  |  Lynn 28/04/07
  84.   s #15 the 51st state 05:20  |  51st state 28/04/07
  85.   Labhras # 78 So Did I 05:35  |  Jeff Northridge 28/04/07
  86.   Israel is lucky that palestinians are so stupidly anti-american 05:44  |  Voice of Reason 28/04/07
  87.   Sam # 82 The Relationship Is Mutually Beneficial 06:37  |  Jeff Northridge 28/04/07
  88.   an american citizen....israel can survive... 06:45  |  maria 28/04/07
  89.   Voice of Reason 06:56  |  Gina 28/04/07
  90.   spyguy 06:59  |  Gina 28/04/07
  91.   #5 american citizen ...God has blessed America.. 07:02  |  maria 28/04/07
  92.   Labhras runs away 07:04  |  Danite 28/04/07
  93.   Sitting bull and zionism. 08:10  |  Billy Jack 28/04/07
  94.   #86, VOR, Palestinians are split, like Americans and Israelis 08:22  |  newageblues 28/04/07
  95.   to jew like you 09:40  |  Dror 28/04/07
  96.   zionist forever 09:44  |  Dror 28/04/07
  97.   #84 51st State 11:14  |  S 28/04/07
  98.   #75,Christa 11:17  |  S 28/04/07
  99.   Arab disgust with Jews 11:47  |  Jeff 28/04/07
  100.   to an American citizen 12:54  |  the pope 28/04/07
  101.   RE: 51st state 12:57  |  will turner 28/04/07
  102.   Arab disgust for Jews #2 13:44  |  Jeff 28/04/07
  103.   # 5 - American citizen - Israel is everything ! 14:09  |  Paul Henzen 28/04/07
  104.   76..india battles terror differently 15:14  |  ravi 28/04/07
  105.   Gina #90 - Americans are self centered 15:22  |  spyguy 28/04/07
  106.   Israel is there because of Belfore`s promise and not... 15:51  |  An orthodox Jew 28/04/07
  107.   Israel`s true source of prosperity 16:03  |  JJ 28/04/07
  108.   Ravi #100 16:03  |  CHGODMK 28/04/07
  109.   To Gina # 89 16:58  |  christa 28/04/07
  110.   To # 90 Gina 17:01  |  christa 28/04/07
  111.   Very far from economic or political independence 17:04  |  christa 28/04/07
  112.   To # 74 Gary 17:10  |  christa 28/04/07
  113.   # 86 Voice of Reason 17:15  |  christa 28/04/07
  114.   CHGODMK #107 17:18  |  Danite 28/04/07
  115.   Help the US 17:22  |  christa 28/04/07
  116.   An orthodox Jew # 105 Then Pray 18:11  |  Jeff Northridge 28/04/07
  117.   To 105 - Orthodox Jew 18:14  |  Go Rimbaud 28/04/07
  118.   Sorry, Shtrasler, it is sureal Topsy-Turvy Article 19:54  |  Benlolo 28/04/07
  119.   Bravo! 22:39  |  Michael H. 28/04/07
  120.   US Israel Relationship 22:44  |  1Eagle7 28/04/07
  121.   Danite #114 22:52  |  CHGODMK 28/04/07
  122.   India battles the same cancer 23:19  |  Chetan 28/04/07
  123.   #116 Lord Balfour`s declaration ? 03:05  |  Syed Iraq 29/04/07
  124.   #115 Christa 03:16  |  Alex 29/04/07
  125.   #122 Chetan 03:27  |  Alex 29/04/07
  126.   No. 10 03:46  |  W 29/04/07
  127.   What if we sold Windows to China instead? 04:56  |  Efox 29/04/07
  128.   US support of Israel 05:21  |  D.R. Zukerman 29/04/07
  129.   will turner #101 05:40  |  51st state 29/04/07
  130.   Two Pariahs Feeding On Each Other 05:48  |  chet 29/04/07
  131.   To Jeff #87 05:51  |  Sam 29/04/07
  132.   israeli dependence on the u.s 08:22  |  joseph 29/04/07
  133.   Ireland/Israel 12:00  |  Dan 29/04/07
  134.   Israel support for US 12:10  |  Dan 29/04/07
 Today Online
Gideon Levy: Learning nothing from the Second Lebanon War
Responses: 7
Kadima MK: Party won't ask Olmert to quit over Lebanon war
Responses: 14
Pre-elections, France refrains from calling incident anti-Semitic
Responses: 28
Report: Anti-Zionist Israeli to direct film for Israel's 60th birthday
Responses: 18
Editorial: Former chief rabbi Lau is unworthy of being president
Responses: 5


More Headlines
11:43 PM: No response to Winograd report until publication
11:24 Defense Ministry: Home front inadequately protected for war
08:45 Settlers occupying Hebron house to get eviction orders Sunday
10:44 Ex-minister Pines-Paz urges Olmert, Peretz to quit at once
11:26 Report: Anti-Zionist Israeli to direct movie for Israel's 60th birthday
11:29 Iran dismisses suggestions they partially freeze atomic work
10:41 PA union slams Palestinian plan to pay workers partial wages
06:44 Communications Min. staffers probed for graft in pirate radio scandal
07:52 Baseball icon Sandy Koufax drafted by new Modi'in team
07:21 Elementary school teachers may get 30% wage hike after negotiations
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved