Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., May 19, 2007 Sivan 2, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:46 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:29 23/04/2007
Israel - Love it or leave it
By Bradley Burston

I am one of the lucky ones. I live here.

Every day, I receive a letter from someone telling me to leave the country. Day in and day out, someone takes the trouble to tell me that I don't belong here. Once a day, someone from Texas, or Ramallah, from a settlement in Samaria or from Boro Park in Brooklyn, finds the energy and the need to let me know that I have no business being here.

But this is my home. This is where I belong.

There are those - knowing themselves to be more Jewish than I will ever be, more genuinely, wholeheartedly Zionist than I could ever aspire to becoming, more anti-compromise, anti-surrender, pro-settlement, pro-Total War On The Palestinians than I am likely to one day turn - who tell me that, for the sake of the future of the Jewish state, I should move immediately to the Arab nation of my choice.

Many of these people live half a world away.

There are those - knowing themselves to be more pro-Palestinian than I will ever be, more sagely critical of Israeli policy than I could hope to be, more permanently, effortlessly, irreproachably right-on than I have ever in my life been, who will tell me that I should give it up and let it go, that it's only a matter of time before the land I stole reverts to its rightful owner.

These letters, as well, come from exotic foreign lands, places like New Zealand, New Delhi, New Mexico.

The people who care enough to tell me to clear out, have a special bond with this place, this Holy Land, this incubator and nursing home for grand dreams. Each of them has a grand dream for this place, Greater Israel, Greater Palestine, one nation, under God, from sea to shining stream.

I am one of the lucky ones. My dreams are no longer grand. I live here. And that is more than enough.

I have seen the nobility in the small gesture of true humanity. I have seen the miracle of the Arab who sees the Jew as a fellow human being, and the Jew who sees the Arab the same way.

The ultrazionists who worship at the altar of Greater Israel are convinced that I don't belong here, that I defile this place with my doubts, my defeatism, my lack of commitment to the Cause, which is to say, my belief in moderation.

The Lawrence of Arabia types who worship at the altar of Israel-hate are no less convinced that I have no business being here, that I'm a foreign presence, a living, breathing expression of obsolete colonialism, an exponent of an occupation they equate with history's foremost campaigns of genocide.

I'm one of the lucky ones. I'm convinced they're wrong.

Look at this face, the unruly features, the hood on the eyes, the incurable tangles in my hair, the long knot of a nose. Palestinian Gazans I have known are unanimous in agreement: It is the face of an Arab. Perhaps an Iraqi. Moroccan Israelis I have known are every bit as certain: It is the face of a Mizrachi, a Jew from the East. Perhaps an Iraqi.

This is my home. When it is daytime here, it is the middle of the night in the place I was born.

I grew up in California, an anomaly among the fair of straight locks and the ocean blue of eye. These bones of mine were not from the Pacific rim. These gangly hands, this, in Hollywood terms, misshapen face, belonged to another place. Long ago, so long ago that no one could trace it, these bones were dragged from the Holy Land, perhaps first to Rome, later probably to Spain, then to White Russia, and finally to Ventura Boulevard and Laurel Canyon.

I was one of the lucky ones.

My father got out of his home town in what is now Belarus. A few years later, the Nazis came and killed all the remaining Jews before they could be sent to a concentration camp.

I was one of the lucky ones. My in-laws survived Auschwitz, came here and survived the 1948 war, so that their daughter could become my family and I hers.

I was one of the lucky ones. Had my birthday been April 24, I would have had to go to Vietnam, for two years. As it happened, my birthday was the next day. According to the rules of the surreal lottery in place at the time, I was exempt from service.

I was a kid there when Vietnam began. I used to collect bumper stickers, one of which read "America - Love It or Leave It."

I still have it. I loved America with all my heart, but I took the sticker with me when I left.

I learned a lot when I came to Israel. I learned to envy extremists. I learned that they were pleased no matter what calamities befell the rest of us, that whatever happened shored up their belief in the infallibility of their belief systems, that whatever happened only deepened their remarkable love of themselves.

After a few years, I found myself in uniform. I was one of the lucky ones. I served with commanders who risked their lives and used every ounce of their creativity to prevent injury to civilians, and who saw to it that all of those under their command treated Palestinians and Lebanese with humanity.

You'll never read about them. They are true heroes.

I was one of the lucky ones. Year after year I served, and year after year I came back to my family.

That October that I moved to Israel, I left my grand dreams behind. I figured I would give it a year. At the end of that year, I decided to give it one more year. And every year, in October, I make the same decision.

Something has changed this year, though. I don't know why, but this Independence week, I don't envy the extremists anymore. The fanatics can have their dreams, as well as their eventual, inevitable disillusionment, their disappointment with their own leaders, with reality, with history, with their own once-all-consuming love of themselves.

This my home. It is a place where everything is either much better or much worse than you expect, but is never what you expect.

In 20 years, or perhaps 200, this land will be carved up between the Israelis on our side and the Palestinians on the other. The grand dreams of today's fanatics will be catalogued, archived. There will be a peace that no one loves, but that most of us can live with.

Those who cannot, who are too pure for that peace, too certain of their own private reality, will probably think about leaving.

The lucky ones among us, will live to see that peace.

Me, I've decided to give it one more year.



_______________


Recent blogs:

To Hamas, for Independence Day
Holocaust denial begins at home
We like our Arabs to be traitors
Help free them. They could've been yours.

__________________


The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Arrested development
In the traditional view, developmental disability is an unchangeable birth defect.
Famous last words
'In death's glaring light all the colors of our life fuse into a filthy hueless mess.'
  1.   A STUPID ISRAEL CAN BE MORE USEFUL 09:47  |  indrajaya 23/04/07
  2.   the view from your old home 09:48  |  Dave 23/04/07
  3.   Love it or leave it is a fascist mentality 09:51  |  Khalid 23/04/07
  4.   OK !`MCOMING HOME. 09:58  |  akiva P 23/04/07
  5.   Stay put buddy! 09:59  |  Nerys 23/04/07
  6.   Burston, and all others are free to leave NOW 10:00  |  Clickfool 23/04/07
  7.   Mr. Burston: please tell us more about those heroes 10:08  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  8.   I live here. And that is more than enough. 10:09  |  Zev 23/04/07
  9.   Bradley Burston wears crimson shoes 10:18  |  Clickfool 23/04/07
  10.   #3, Khalid: where are the Arab humanists? 10:18  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  11.   Khalid the great humanist 10:20  |  Cluck Tool 23/04/07
  12.   Between the Lines! 10:26  |  An Arab Neighbor 23/04/07
  13.   Love it and Stay 10:29  |  Eli 23/04/07
  14.   clickFOOL 10:42  |  Eli 23/04/07
  15.   Poor Cipora, the perplexed bird 10:45  |  Khalid 23/04/07
  16.   clickfool 10:47  |  A.M. 23/04/07
  17.   Love it 10:48  |  Sebastian 23/04/07
  18.   cuck too..you too are poor in spirit and brain 10:54  |  Khalid 23/04/07
  19.   #9, Arab neighbour 10:58  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  20.   #15, Khalid 11:02  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  21.   Does this mean ... 11:06  |  AnotherAmerican 23/04/07
  22.   clickfool 11:08  |  A.M. 23/04/07
  23.   Loving it and not leaving it 11:08  |  Israeli 23/04/07
  24.   KHALID.Without Arab racist compulsion to kill Jews& steal 11:13  |  PETER.SM 23/04/07
  25.   But will you let us stay in our homes too 11:28  |  Ilan 23/04/07
  26.   Thanks, Bradley 11:28  |  Helen 23/04/07
  27.   Nicely said 11:34  |  Marilyn 23/04/07
  28.   I have just arrived back home! 11:41  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  29.   KHALID.Your Islamic Republic of Palestine is waiting.Ya Jihad! 11:48  |  PETER SM 23/04/07
  30.   Jewish Chronicle 11:51  |  Ben Azai 23/04/07
  31.   For Eli in Tel Aviv # 14 11:54  |  Clickfool 23/04/07
  32.   New Yorkers 11:55  |  Joe 23/04/07
  33.   For A.M. # 22 11:57  |  Clickfool 23/04/07
  34.   Another Letter from Texas 12:01  |  Johnny Weintraub 23/04/07
  35.   A beautiful article, yasher koach. 12:03  |  Allon 23/04/07
  36.   may you give it one more year for the next 50 years! 12:10  |  Cord H. Kaldrack 23/04/07
  37.   oh, I found that Khalid`s statement #3 is one of his better ones 12:11  |  christoph 23/04/07
  38.   Khalid, oh great, wise intellectual and humanist 12:13  |  Allon 23/04/07
  39.   Palestinians cannot `return` 12:15  |  Jasmine Murphy 23/04/07
  40.   Cipora 12:16  |  S 23/04/07
  41.   Sebastian 12:17  |  Jasmine Murphy 23/04/07
  42.   #18 Khalid & gaan kak too 12:19  |  Joe Moer 23/04/07
  43.   Alon Fisher 12:20  |  Jasmine Murphy 23/04/07
  44.   Wonderful Bradley! 12:23  |  S 23/04/07
  45.   MARYLIN cannot accept Jews have rights.Cannot accept that Arabs 12:25  |  PETER.SM 23/04/07
  46.   To Alon Fisher@28 12:25  |  Indiginous 23/04/07
  47.   Bradley Thank You ;o) & Chag Atzmaut Sameach 12:28  |  Ari ben Yisrael 23/04/07
  48.   an american in tel aviv 12:35  |  chetzi 23/04/07
  49.   #40, S 12:43  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  50.   Marilyn #27 12:43  |  Tim R 23/04/07
  51.   clickFOOL 12:44  |  ELI 23/04/07
  52.   To Bradley Burston 12:45  |  TonyL 23/04/07
  53.   # 47 Ari ben Yisrael 12:54  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  54.   israeli 12:55  |  A.M. 23/04/07
  55.   Khalid is an Islamist not a humanist! 13:02  |  ??? 23/04/07
  56.   46# Indiginous 13:11  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  57.   One more year might be too much 13:24  |  Efox 23/04/07
  58.   # 12 As long as they live in Palestine......... 13:38  |  Lynn 23/04/07
  59.   Happy Indepedence Day to all Israelis.... 13:42  |  Lynn 23/04/07
  60.   Israel-Love it or leave it 14:10  |  Mitch Cohen 23/04/07
  61.   One more thing #46 Indiginous 14:13  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  62.   Jasmine Murphy 14:13  |  Sebastian 23/04/07
  63.   Fascists everywhere... 14:31  |  Fatih 23/04/07
  64.   # 42 Joe Moer - Baie Dankie 14:39  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  65.   #6 - too emotional for real Clickfool. Was that him? 14:50  |  Scientist 23/04/07
  66.   Indigenous (spelling??) # 46 14:51  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  67.   Leave it! 14:58  |  David Levy 23/04/07
  68.   Strange love of Mr. Burston 15:01  |  Scientist 23/04/07
  69.   NO NEED TO CARVE UP THE LAND 15:05  |  B 23/04/07
  70.   Living at expense of others... 15:06  |  the third man 23/04/07
  71.   Chag Sameach to you too Bradely,A day to celebrate, not to hate ! 15:13  |  Alberto Cohen 23/04/07
  72.   Rare comment 15:17  |  Choni Davidowitz 23/04/07
  73.   And stop calling it a special place in Hell-It hurts and is offen 15:19  |  Choni Davidowitz 23/04/07
  74.   #6, clickfool 15:31  |  VIPER 23/04/07
  75.   An Arab Neighbor. Pals refugee must remain in Leb / Syria forever 15:37  |  Tamir Gaza 23/04/07
  76.   Your Home, Their Home 15:39  |  The Other Alan 23/04/07
  77.   #64 ChanahS 15:41  |  Joe Moer 23/04/07
  78.   a special place 15:41  |  albert paul ortiz 23/04/07
  79.   According too so many lefties 15:43  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  80.   #66 ChanahS 15:49  |  Ari ben Yisrael 23/04/07
  81.   Khalid #3: A Question To You... 16:03  |  Tim R 23/04/07
  82.   Choni, Choni, Choni #70 16:21  |  The