Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., April 25, 2007 Iyyar 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:51 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A war in the summer?
By Orit Shohat

The talk about a sizable war this summer already started in the midst of the war last summer (there were those who called it a promo and thanked Hezbollah for having revealed its weaknesses in ample time). A "sizable war" is a code name for a war that includes Syria. The outgoing chief of staff estimated in November that there would be a war with Syria this summer, and in a series of general-staff discussions he held, there was talk of "a working assessment" that dictated exercises in anticipation of a war this summer.

Now the summer is almost upon us. Was this an assessment or a self-fulfilling prophecy? When the Syrian president says that if there is no peace there will be a war, he is responding to incessant mumbling from our side. This is where the dynamics of another war start. In a situation as explosive as that in the Middle East, the sparks can be ignited even when no one really wants that to happen.

Too many people sit in too many rooms with war maps rather than maps with peace arrangements. There are new plans with new code names. There are colorful computer presentations, and in place of every division commander who has lost face, there is another glowing radiantly for the moment with an updated military doctrine that will provide "the answer," as they say in the army, to problems revealed in the previous war. Instead of a chief of staff who relies only on the air force, we now have a chief of staff from the Golani Brigade. It can be assumed that he is fervently training regular and reserve forces for the next round after reading all the debriefings and learning the necessary lessons.

Advertisement

But the main lesson, after all, has yet to be learned. To this day, the decision makers believe that last summer's war was inevitable and was merely conducted without talent. Just a few corrections, and we can go on our way again. That is why, when the prime minister asks the new chief of staff if the Israel Defense Forces can beat the Syrians, he will apparently respond in the affirmative. A chief of staff is a chief of staff, after all. But at a meeting of military-academy graduates held last week, Major General (res.) Uri Saguy said that this result is dubious. There will no longer be a classic defeat. Israel's security concept, which is based mostly on deterrence, warning and defeat, is no longer relevant. After a war with Syria, this summer or another, the strategic reality will not change; therefore, it is possible to skip the war and move straight on to the agreements.

One can assume that in the next war, the IDF will already know how to capture Hezbollah's "nature reserves" and find those responsible for firing the Katyushas. But in the next war, we will face a mass of rockets and long-range missiles, some of which, perhaps, with chemical warheads that the Syrians will fire, not necessarily from Bint Jbeil. The home front will remain the same home front. Perhaps it will be weaker, because the civilians have also learned their lessons and know the only thing the state has to offer is firemen with hoses. Perhaps this time they will provide protection for Safed's hospital. But that belongs to the last war. Now the hospitals in Tel Aviv are on the front line.

Whoever speaks about the necessity of preparing the home front for the next war is planting false hopes. It is impossible to protect the home front, not in half a year and perhaps not at all. The only really effective protection for the home front is a political arrangement. When Ehud Olmert goes to bed at night, does he think about how to prevent the next war or how to rehabilitate his lost pride ("the deterrence") and that of the IDF? If he is afraid of being remembered as the one responsible for a defective war, perhaps he indeed is planning the "campaign for bringing back pride." But if he internalized something else last summer, for example, how a modern war looks when the home front is exposed, perhaps he will think twice before agreeing to bomb an air field of a neighboring country. Perhaps he has understood that modern war equipment does not put the home front at a greater distance, and that America's strength also stems from the fact that its home front is very far from any front.

Something very, very strange has been happening since last summer. Several months have elapsed since the last war, and it appears that it did not end, but rather just stopped for a minute. We will merely read the Winograd Committee's report and then continue. Meanwhile, rumblings are being heard, from Pakistan to Syria and Saudi Arabia, about the possibility of political arrangements. But we are still talking about Gal Hirsch and Udi Adam, and about who is more guilty for not implementing the ground forces invasion plan.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
A dirty holiday
Thousands who celebrated Independence Day left behind 800,000 tons of garbage.
Sderot's flexible laws
People in Sderot have a choice- to obey the law, or protect theirs homes from Qassams.
  1.   HOWLONG IS IT GONNA LAST??? 10:02  |  alonitzafoni 23/04/07
  2.   war in summer 10:21  |  sam 23/04/07
  3.   war should always be the very last resort 10:48  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 23/04/07
  4.   "No more war, no more bloodshed" - M. Begin 10:59  |  Barry 23/04/07
  5.   Olmert is a lame and dangerous duck 11:14  |  Khalid 23/04/07
  6.   #1, alonitzafoni, take off your rosy glasses 11:37  |  VIPER 23/04/07
  7.   We are prepared...ARE YOU!!!! 12:24  |  Khalid 23/04/07
  8.   #6 Australian "viper" 12:44  |  D 23/04/07
  9.   Yes, he is... 13:03  |  Edith 23/04/07
  10.   6# VIPERS ROSY GLASSES 13:17  |  alonitzafoni 23/04/07
  11.   KHALID LAST YEAR WAS CHILDS PLAY 13:20  |  alonitzafoni 23/04/07
  12.   The war psychlogy 13:22  |  S 23/04/07
  13.   #2 Except, Sam, you live in a fantasy land 13:29  |  Johnboy 23/04/07
  14.   stil he has the courage?? 13:34  |  Ali 23/04/07
  15.   #1 Alon, #6 Viper, #9 Edith 13:34  |  D 23/04/07
  16.   to#7...to Khalid..... 13:40  |  tiara 23/04/07
  17.   ali in beirut 14:27  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  18.   Houdini and the art of war 14:41  |  the third man 23/04/07
  19.   to ALON 14:53  |  Ali 23/04/07
  20.   war this summer... probably not 15:17  |  Joe 23/04/07
  21.   #19 Ali 15:38  |  D 23/04/07
  22.   Khalid, i complement on your readiness 15:51  |  the pope 23/04/07
  23.   19# Ali Soldiers Did not run 15:59  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  24.   to Alon....and to Ali 16:10  |  tiara 23/04/07
  25.   to Alon....& Ali 16:16  |  tiara 23/04/07
  26.   to Alon....& Ali 16:18  |  tiara 23/04/07
  27.   to Alon....& Ali 16:18  |  tiara 23/04/07
  28.   to Alon....& Ali 16:19  |  tiara 23/04/07
  29.   to the pope # 21 16:29  |  Ali 23/04/07
  30.   WE CAN AVERT THE WAR WITH REPENTANCE 16:31  |  YEHOSHUA 23/04/07
  31.   to TIARA 16:39  |  Ali 23/04/07
  32.   The Wald report 17:14  |  Michael N 23/04/07
  33.   time to rearm 17:21  |  pragmatist 23/04/07
  34.   The Wald report #2 17:32  |  Michael N 23/04/07
  35.   to ...Ali 18:09  |  tiara 23/04/07
  36.   A war 18:09  |  Baruch 23/04/07
  37.   A war 18:09  |  Baruch 23/04/07
  38.   The avoidable war with Syria and/or Lebanon 18:34  |  Tosefta 23/04/07
  39.   to no. 5 18:37  |  sonny 23/04/07
  40.   What would it be good for? 19:24  |  Fritz 23/04/07
  41.   The US home front and 9/11 19:31  |  Fritz 23/04/07
  42.   Shohat is right and very wrong 19:32  |  Chick Corea 23/04/07
  43.   #18 the third man 19:36  |  Labhras 23/04/07
  44.   Mr ORIT SHOHAT is right There is No need forWARS 19:39  |  23/04/07
  45.   #29 Ali 19:39  |  Labhras 23/04/07
  46.   Remember... 19:44  |  Khan 23/04/07
  47.   31#Tiara this man(Ali) has one course of action 19:48  |  Alon Fisher 23/04/07
  48.   Ayn B`rera? or Yesh? 20:38  |  Wade 23/04/07
  49.   It`s not Israel`s choice to go to war.... 20:40  |  David 23/04/07
  50.   LOVE AND HUMAN SOLIDARITY, NOT WAR 20:47  |  Mohamed MALLECK 23/04/07
  51.   Ali 20:52  |  marco 23/04/07
  52.   The avoidable war with Syria and/or Lebanon 21:11  |  Tosefta 23/04/07
  53.   you are so out of it. we lost cz we were not prepared nor think 21:16  |  ralph 23/04/07
  54.   HI ORIT, HOW YOU FEELING TODAY? 21:36  |  Bongo 23/04/07
  55.   #36 mohammed malleck: Speeches Do Not Stop Fascists 21:50  |  Chick Corea 23/04/07
  56.   # 38 Marco 22:05  |  Mohamed MALLECK 23/04/07
  57.   Wade #37 22:26  |  Michael N 23/04/07
  58.   Summer War? 22:33  |  P. J. Casey 23/04/07
  59.   to 12, yes Olmert MUST go ; welcome LIVNI ! 22:58  |  Nicolas from Paris 23/04/07
  60.   Ali, I would not waiste one Jewish soul on you 23:05  |  Jewboy 23/04/07
  61.   sam, who is counting Hizbullah fighters? 23:19  |  Jake 23/04/07
  62.   Khalid, I already have cousins 23:21  |  Jake 23/04/07
  63.   to 31 - open your eyes Ali 23:21  |  Nicolas 23/04/07
  64.   to 45 - Tosefta 23:47  |  Nicolas from Paris 23/04/07
  65.   to all of u 00:22  |  ahmad 24/04/07
  66.   Send Orit to the Front 00:34  |  dave 24/04/07
  67.   Democracy in the Middle East is relative (Nicholas #50) 01:05  |  Tosefta 24/04/07
  68.   Olmert only has one condition 01:19  |  Michel Norman 24/04/07
  69.   Where is the outrage? 01:38  |  Dutch Dirk 24/04/07
  70.   Israel will destroy itself 01:52  |  Zeje 24/04/07
  71.   Orit. come to Mogadishu. We Jihadists need you. 02:05  |  alioman 24/04/07
  72.   It is very, very clear 02:24  |  Mark Lincoln 24/04/07
  73.   Speeches Do Not Stop Fascists - Chick Corea 02:25  |  Mark Lincoln 24/04/07
  74.   #36 Chick Corea piles supposition upon assumption 03:22  |  Johnboy 24/04/07
  75.   Democracy in the Middle East is relative (Nicholas #50) 04:13  |  Tosefta 24/04/07
  76.   Democracy in the Middle East 06:10  |  Mark Lincoln 24/04/07
  77.   Tosefta - dealing with reality 06:16  |  Mark Lincoln 24/04/07
  78.   SYRIAN GENERALS IN IRAN 06:25  |  Tbart 24/04/07
  79.   Please please not another war 06:31  |  Maggie 24/04/07
  80.   Very Sad War 06:43  |  Tbart 24/04/07
  81.   #58 DUTCH DUD 06:54  |  Tbart 24/04/07
  82.   #69 Tbart on who would start this war 09:26  |  Johnboy 24/04/07
  83.   to Nicolas # 56 11:03  |  Ali 24/04/07
  84.   disinformation of johnboy 11:23  |  Daniele 24/04/07
  85.   #10, alon fisher, wrong again 11:44  |  VIPER 24/04/07
  86.   #71, TBART, well informed 11:49  |