Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 24, 2007 Iyyar 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:11 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Balad Chairman Azmi Bishara speaking with reporters following a meeting with Arab League leaders in Cairo on Sunday. (AP)
Last update - 01:55 23/04/2007
Balad opposition delays partial lifting of Bishara case gag order
By Jack Khoury and Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondents

Police had agreed on Sunday to partially lift the gag order regarding the investigation into Balad chairman Azmi Bishara, but the court hearing on the matter was delayed until Wednesday due to the Israeli Arab party's objections.

The Justice Ministry on Sunday afternoon banned all entry to Balad's Knesset office of Balad party chairman MK Azmi Bishara, hours after he submitted his resignation from parliament at Israel's embassy in Cairo.

Balad announced Sunday it would prefer that the gag order, which prohibits publication of suspicions against Bishara or details of police investigations into the allegations, be rescinded completely.

Advertisement

Balad sources said that "a partial lifting of the gag order will allow police to present their version in a selective and distorted manner, while Balad is prevented from publishing details."

The party further called the allegations against Bishara an attempt to destroy his political career and silence the Arab MK.

Israeli Ambassador to Egypt Shalom Cohen and his deputy, who were present when Bishara submitted the letter, confirmed that he had resigned.

Bishara explained that he does not want to allow lawmakers, particularly rightists, "to hold a festival" over the issue of lifting his immunity as a member of Knesset and deposing him as a member of the parliament.

Bishara added that he did not wish to turn the matter into a campaign of incitement against him personally and against the Arab public as a whole.

In an interview with Al-Jazeera following the resignation, Bishara said he was aware that the step would end his parliamentary immunity and that his status would be that of a regular citizen, such that Israel could arrest him or demand his extradition.

He added that he has "no intention of hiding."

Bishara, who left Israel about a month ago, added that he has no intention of being far from his homeland.

"I will no doubt return, but I will choose the timing of my return by myself," he said. "This depends on many factors, including consultations with my friends in Israel and in the Arab world."

Bishara said he would not allow Israeli security officials to "decide the rules of the game for him," and that he wanted to set the rules himself.

"Now I have become an ordinary citizen," he said. "Now there are new rules for the game in which I define the limits, rules where the investigation does not touch my ideological and political position nor my social standing within the Palestinian people."

Bishara was quoted Saturday as saying in Egypt that he was considering staying abroad because he feared a long jail sentence and an end to his political career.

A fiery Arab nationalist lawmaker, Bishara told a group of Egyptian intellectuals late Saturday that he might not return to Israel, to avoid a trial.

"I will not venture going back while these threats still stand," Bishara was quoted as saying by the intellectuals meeting with him. They spoke on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue.

They also said that Bishara claimed the accusations are politically motivated and aim at ending his political activities, but had ruled out the possibility of resigning from the Knesset.

Bishara declined to talk to reporters on the record because no official charges have been raised yet.

In his letter of resignation, addressed to Knesset Speaker Dalia Itzik, Bishara wrote: "During my work in the Knesset I did my best to represent the universal values in which I believe, such as equality and democracy, human rights and just peace between the peoples."

"I also acted to loyally represent all citizens, in particular the Arab citizens," he said.

"I can look back and say with satisfaction that I contributed to the development of a new parliamentary discussion regarding the Arab population as a collective nation and the concept of citizenship," he continued. "Since the last elections, I arrived at a decision to resign and make time for public activism, as well as contemplative and literary writing."

Bishara met Saturday morning in Cairo with Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit, according to a report featured Saturday on an Arabic-language Web site considered to be affiliated with the party.

According to the report, Balad MK Wasil Taha was also present at the meeting.

The Web site indicated that the two lawmakers arrived in Egypt on Thursday for a meeting with Egyptian officials and with "thinkers and cultural figures."

The meeting reportedly lasted one hour, and dealt with political issues such as Egyptian diplomatic efforts and the Arab peace initiative.

Bishara has in the past angered many in Israel by openly identifying with Syria and with Lebanon's Hezbollah militants. Critics charge he has encouraged violent attacks against Israel, which Bishara denies.

Israeli police have confirmed that they were investigating Bishara's case.

Police spokesman Micky Rosenfeld has said there was an inquiry against Bishara by the Israeli police international crime and investigations unit. He said the court forbade disclosing any other details, including what charges Bishara might face, until the gag order expires on April 23.

Last week, Bishara confirmed his intention to resign from the Knesset on Thursday, telling the Nazareth-based newspaper Hadith A-Nas that he is being persecuted.

Several days, later, he told Al-Jazeera in a televised interview Sunday that an ongoing criminal investigation against him has left him with three options - martyrdom, exile, or prison.

In Israel, his party issued a statement denouncing what it called a witch hunt and calling on authorities to lift the gag order and allow Bishara to clear his name. It said it was considering petitioning Israel's Supreme Court on Bishara's behalf.

The Petah Tikva Magistrate's Court ruled on Sunday that the press could discuss the existence of the probe into Bishara's activities, but not its substance, lifting a rare court order which had forbidden even the publication of the existence of a gag order.

Next week, the Knesset House Committee is expected to discuss revoking some of the benefits Bishara receives as a Knesset member. The benefits that may be revoked include free newspapers and funds given to stay in contact with the public, but not his monthly salary.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
In praise of smoking
The quick, simple way to smoke meat or fish for immediate consumption.
Concrete Eden
After we've paved paradise, what we are left with is our constructed landscape.
  1.   As an Israeli Arab, I am so glad Bishara finally 13:54  |  Haled al-Qudsi 22/04/07
  2.   Bishara bundled out for good 14:24  |  Star of David 22/04/07
  3.   Witch-Hunt Zionist Style 14:30  |  Clickfool 22/04/07
  4.   Fair well, Mr. Bishara. Stay where you are and don`t come 14:54  |  Nabil S 22/04/07
  5.   to clickfool 14:58  |  saul a. readner 22/04/07
  6.   ## Clickfool: a hypocritical pom. Again 15:08  |  Star of David 22/04/07
  7.   UK Witch-Hunt: English style 15:11  |  Star of David 22/04/07
  8.   To Haled al-Qudsi 15:12  |  Hershel 22/04/07
  9.   #1 - thank you - I hope that we can live together peacefully ! 15:24  |  redmike 22/04/07
  10.   GOODBYE TO BAD RUBBISH 15:34  |  Ian 22/04/07
  11.   Bishara is a traitor 15:38  |  Clickfool 22/04/07
  12.   Bye, bye! 15:40  |  Tulip 22/04/07
  13.   As an Israeli Arab... Farewell... 16:00  |  mike Higgins 22/04/07
  14.   #13 mike higgins 16:29  |  Yonatan 22/04/07
  15.   #1 Halid we salute you !!!! 16:31  |  dezon 22/04/07
  16.   Israeli Arabs couldn`t stand him 16:31  |  Yonatan 22/04/07
  17.   You, Higgins, tell me who I am and how I should 16:34  |  Haled al-Qudsi 22/04/07
  18.   #1#2#3#4#5#6#7#8#9#10 16:37  |  Mark 22/04/07
  19.   Arabs are a welcome minority in Israel 16:38  |  Daniel 22/04/07
  20.   Mike Higgins from London... 16:40  |  Ehud 22/04/07
  21.   MK BISHARA - enemy of integration & peaceful co-existence .. 16:52  |  DAVID KOHEN 22/04/07
  22.   We don`t need you back bishara 16:56  |  Rami 22/04/07
  23.   People like Haled al-Qudsi .. 16:56  |  DABID KOHEN 22/04/07
  24.   #16 is absolutly right.. 16:58  |  Rami 22/04/07
  25.   #1 Haled al-Qudsi 17:04  |  Clickfool 22/04/07
  26.   to mark 17:22  |  saul a. readner 22/04/07
  27.   to clickfool, no. 25 17:24  |  saul a. readner 22/04/07
  28.   gag order expires tomorrow 17:27  |  Potash Katiftof 22/04/07
  29.   That`s one down..still afew more to go! 17:31  |  Nemesis 22/04/07
  30.   # 25 Clickfool - You may wonder as muc as 17:35  |  Haled al-Qudsi 22/04/07
  31.   to 25 - israel is not egypt,syria,saudi arabia,iran,,,,, 17:41  |  ron arad 22/04/07
  32.   # 13 First and foremost....... 17:41  |  Lynn 22/04/07
  33.   Pace Bishara, Jews and Arabs can live together peacefully in Zion 18:11  |  AA 22/04/07
  34.   Arab integration into Israeli society. 18:24  |  sandra chitayat 22/04/07
  35.   #25 18:53  |  clickfool 22/04/07
  36.   I fear, Mr. Al-Qudsi, most Israeli Arabs aren`t like you 18:56  |  Daniel 22/04/07
  37.   Daniel # 36 - You ae right to a very large extent, I am sorry to 19:06  |  Haled al-Qudsi 22/04/07
  38.   ARABS FOR BASHARA SHOULD LEAVE AND ARABS FOR INTERGRATION STAY 19:09  |  Meir Weinstein 22/04/07
  39.   Mike Higgins 19:12  |  rich 22/04/07
  40.   #1 I salute you Sir! 19:14  |  British Leftie 22/04/07
  41.   Brit Leftie 19:23  |  GZLives 22/04/07
  42.   to Daniel 20:06  |  not important 22/04/07
  43.   Has he got a well paying job line up, bashing Israel? 20:23  |  PETER SM 22/04/07
  44.   #41 Gaza 20:27  |  British Leftie 22/04/07
  45.   (way off the-) Mark, #18 21:16  |  akiva P 22/04/07
  46.   Congratulation it is good news, He is a new terrorist leader 21:42  |  e.m 22/04/07
  47.   Only see yourselves 21:42  |  Mike 22/04/07
  48.   Bishara 21:42  |  yuval 22/04/07
  49.   Reply To "Not-Important" from Al-Kuds (#42) 21:55  |  Important 22/04/07
  50.   HEY MARILYN ,MAUREEN ANNE,INDRAJAYA 22:12  |  alonitzafoni 22/04/07
  51.   The people who voted for him feel that he has deserted them 22:30  |  Omar 22/04/07
  52.   TO # 38 ALL p`arabs SHUD GO & HERE`S WHY : 22:50  |  MOSHE 22/04/07
  53.   to Haled al-Qudsi 23:22  |  CRAZY HORSE 22/04/07
  54.   #1 Haled al Qudsi 23:31  |  Labhras 22/04/07
  55.   #49 Important 23:43  |  Labhras 22/04/07
  56.   THe Israeli Hardliners are alienating the world. 01:02  |  Dutch 23/04/07
  57.   # 1 # 4 Haled and Nabil 01:24  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  58.   # 13 Mike Higgins 01:26  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  59.   Mark # 18 01:29  |  ChanahS 23/04/07
  60.   Mike Higgins, the old imperialism is alive and well, I see 02:36  |  Jake 23/04/07
  61.   Yuval the Exile#48 03:04  |  Fairman 23/04/07
  62.   A day will come when the Shin Bet will regret this 03:11  |  Richard Silverstein 23/04/07
  63.   Bishara deserved what he got 03:35  |  Clickfool 23/04/07
  64.   Bishara 05:08  |  Gadban 23/04/07
  65.   Honest Support to the Isreli Arab Citizens 05:11  |  PB 23/04/07
  66.   HE WILL MAKE MORE PROBLEMS 06:51  |  TOBIA 23/04/07
  67.   To British lefty #44 You need to research a lot more. 08:51  |  Dana 23/04/07
  68.   #44 brit leftie on the beeb 10:00  |  Ari ben Yisrael 23/04/07
  69.   #25 clickFOOL 10:06  |  Ari ben Yisrael 23/04/07
  70.   #67 Dana 11:03  |  British Leftie 23/04/07
  71.   The real story 14:47  |  FOX 23/04/07
  72.   Balad, from Arab eyes 15:43  |  FOX 23/04/07
  73.   To Omar #51 21:12  |  Slibovitz 23/04/07
  74.   whats wrong with israel being a real democracy? 22:57  |  cristina 23/04/07
  75.   is # 1 an arab uncle tom? 23:07  |  cristina 23/04/07
  76.   Cristina, Israel is the state of the Jewish People 19:49  |  Jake 24/04/07
  77.   Cristina, not discrimating against Israeli Arabs 19:50  |  Jake 24/04/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Israel - Love It or Leave It
Responses: 260
Israel to mark Independence Day with 7,150,000 citizens
Responses: 328
Sarid: PA must curb its terrorists like Ben-Gurion curbed Etzel
Responses: 265
Orit Shohat: Is Olmert really trying to prevent the next war?
Responses: 96
U.S. had emergency plan for attacking Israel in 1967
Responses: 289
Rosner's Domain
*John Edwards learns that Israel will not do the trick
<
* What do Israelis think about America's role in the world?