Israel rejects 'baseless' Egyptian claims of nuclear espionage - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Sat., September 08, 2007 Elul 25, 5767

Israel Time: 15:37 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel



		A photograph issued by the Egyptian authorities showing nuclear engineer Mohammed Sayed Saber Ali, arrested on suspicion of spying for Israel. (AP)

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 21:37 17/04/2007

Israel rejects 'baseless' Egyptian claims of nuclear espionage

By Barak Ravid, Haaretz Correspondent, Haaretz Service and Agencies

Israel on Tuesday rejected as baseless claims by Egypt that it had recruited a nuclear engineer at the Egyptian Atomic Energy Agency to spy on the country's atomic program.

The engineer has been charged with spying for Israel, Egyptian officials said, adding that he had received software to hack into the Agency's computers.

The Foreign Ministry in Jerusalem dismissed the accusations, saying that this was not the first time that Egypt had made such claims.

	Advertisement

"To Israel's sorrow, we hear from time to time stories like this from Cairo, and it ultimately becomes clear that they are preposterous and baseless," Army Radio quoted the Foreign Ministry as saying.

"It is a shame that such reports appear with such frequency in Egypt," the ministry said in a statement later Tuesday.

The suspect was named as 35-year-old Mohammed Sayed Saber Ali, who works at the Inshas reactor. Egyptian state security prosecutor Hisham Badawi said that two foreigners, one Japanese and one Irish, were also wanted in connection with the case but remained at large.

Badawi said Ali stole important documents from the Atomic Energy Agency and passed them on to agents of Israel's Mossad intelligence service in return for $17,000. Ali first met the two foreigners in Hong Kong between 2004 and 2006, Badawi said.

A statement by the Egyptian government named the Irishman as Brian Peter and the Japanese man as Shiro Izo. They told Ali at one meeting in Hong Kong that they wanted him to work for their company from inside the Atomic Energy Agency, it said.

"The first accused [Ali] said that he understood from the course of this meeting that the company referred to was no more than a front for the activity of Israeli intelligence," it said.

At a later meeting in Hong Kong in December 2006, Ali gave Peter documents containing secret information about the Atomic Energy Agency and the nuclear reactor at Inshas, it said.

During his final trip to Hong Kong, in February 2007, Israeli intelligence gave Ali lie detector tests for two days as a condition for him receiving computer software for hacking into the Atomic Energy Agency's computer systems, it added.

Ali's family denied the accusations Tuesday, saying he was the one to report to authorities that the people he worked with in Hong Kong were suspicious. The family did not know more specific details.

"We leave it to God to take revenge on his behalf. Is this what he gets for informing about them and trying to defend the security of his country? He did nothing wrong," Ali's wife said from her home in Giza, Cairo's twin city. She declined to give her name because of the sensitivity of the issue.

Ali graduated from Alexandria University in 1994 with a bachelor's degree in nuclear engineering and obtained a diploma in nuclear reactor physics from Cairo University in 1999, Badawi told the news conference.

He got a job at the Atomic Energy Agency in 1997 and went to the Israeli embassy in Cairo in May 1999 to ask for a grant to study nuclear engineering at Tel Aviv University.

The visit aroused the suspicions of Egyptian authorities, who told Ali not to go to the embassy without informing his superiors at work, the statement said.

The statement said Ali's contacts were interested in information about the capability of the Inshas reactor, how many hours it operated, the type of experiments conducted with it, any technical problems with the reactor and reasons for them.

They also wanted to know how frequently the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspects the reactor, it said.

Egypt has a small research atomic reactor. It has recently announced plans to develop a nuclear energy program more than 20 years after it abandoned the idea of building a reactor in the aftermath of the 1986 Chernobyl disaster.

Egyptian Minister of Electricity and Energy Hassan Yunis said this year that his country could have an operational nuclear power plant within 10 years. The plan is to build a 1,000-megawatt nuclear power plant at Al-Dabaa on the Mediterranean coast.

This is the second spy scandal that has been exposed in the past two years. Previously, Mohammed el-Attar, 30, a former student at the Islamic Al-Azhar university in Cairo, was arrested on January 1, 2007 as he returned from abroad to visit his family in Egypt.

According to prosecutors, el-Attar confessed to spying for Israel and gave a detailed account of his role in collecting information about Egyptians and Arabs living in Turkey and Canada in return for money.

He also received instructions from the three Israelis, said to be intelligence officers, to recruit Christian Egyptian immigrants in Canada using money and sex.

The alleged confession claimed el-Attar fled Egypt in 2001 and sought asylum with the UN refugee agency offices in Turkey after he was sentenced to three years in prison for bank fraud.

The confession also alleged that el-Attar converted to Christianity in Istanbul and was allegedly sent to Canada, where he delivered more reports about Christian Egyptians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Yes. I don't want to
	Saying 'Insh'Allah' to Jewish bosses was the politest way of telling them 'I don't want to.'


	What comes naturally
	Jaffa-born photographer Amos Nachoum specializes in close-ups of large mammals.




1.	Probably EGYPT thinks that EGYPTIANS have an ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY	16:40	\|	Vittorio	17/04/07

2.	As usual	17:55	\|	MS	17/04/07

3.	#2 MS	18:38	\|	* BEN JABO	17/04/07

4.	THEY WILL ADMIT TO NOTHING.	19:04	\|	Cool B.	17/04/07

5.	Israel`s nature, and #3	19:43	\|	Genesis	17/04/07

6.	No, of course, Israel NEVER spies!	20:27	\|	Moshe Merkel	17/04/07

7.	Cool B., you have got to be kidding	20:58	\|	Jake	17/04/07

8.	Ha ha Egypt is Pretending to have caught a Spy	21:15	\|	Efox	17/04/07

9.	Israel telling the truth? Give us all a break	21:41	\|	Tim	17/04/07

10.	#7 Jake..sure..and cat`s can fly	21:43	\|	Tim	17/04/07

11.	"preposterous and baseless"	21:49	\|	Joe	17/04/07

12.	As Usual?	22:02	\|	B	17/04/07

13.	Mossad Recruiting Arabs For Another 9/11 Style False Flag?	22:32	\|	Mr. Knowitall	17/04/07

14.	Spies and....spies	00:01	\|	From the Moon	18/04/07

15.	Israeli Spies.	00:35	\|	Maureen Ann	18/04/07

16.	#11 Joe - Ramallah	00:41	\|	* BEN JABO	18/04/07

17.	You said it yourself, Tim, HISTORY	00:47	\|	Jake	18/04/07

18.	Joe, you wouldn`t mind seeing an innocent Arab hanged	00:56	\|	Jake	18/04/07

19.	"confession also alleged that el-Attar converted to Christianity"	01:20	\|	Jake	18/04/07

20.	Israel`s nature	01:35	\|	Michael	18/04/07

21.	Mossadrecruiting	01:49	\|	Michel	18/04/07

22.	I have my doubts that he confessed	02:06	\|	* BEN JABO	18/04/07

23.	why the whining?	02:29	\|	Lynn	18/04/07

24.	Christian Egyptians spying for Israel?	05:51	\|	Honi	18/04/07

25.	#24 Honi - just where do you think	01:17	\|	* BEN JABO	19/04/07

26.	#13 Cold in Minn.	01:21	\|	* BEN JABO	19/04/07

27.	#15 Maureen Ann	18:31	\|	* BEN JABO	19/04/07

28.	Spying, denial, peace, and whatnot.	10:40	\|	Blacklander	22/04/07

Today Online


	Bradley Burston: The Special Place in Hell awards, 5768
	Responses: 224


	Arab League: IAF incident discredits Israel peace bid
	Responses: 199


	Editorial: Britain should support Israel with a royal visit
	Responses: 162


	Gideon Biger: Viable peace deal will involve population transfers
	Responses: 162


	Rosner: Study finds young U.S. Jews alienated from Israel
	Responses: 81


	Ex-Yad Vashem head may face probe into role in WWII murders
	Responses: 109

Rosner's Domain

* Too many Jews here at the Nuremberg trials

* Rosner's Guest: Author of Sex, God, Christmas & Jews

* New Poll: Will the next year be better for Israel?

* Why you should never trust my predictions ever again (if you ever did)

More Headlines
14:40 Fayad: Mideast peace conference must lead to deal on statehood


15:17 PA official: IDF kills Palestinian teen near Gaza-Israel border


13:30 Arab League: IAF incident casts doubt on Israel's intentions on Mideast peace


12:05 U.S. Senate okays bill including first cluster bomb restrictions


14:14 Israel to go up against England in Euro 2008 qualifier match


09:45 Bin Laden: The U.S. is vulnerable despite its military, economic strength


11:16 20 wounded as Hamas forces beat Fatah men praying in Gaza


20:51 Egypt's Bedouin protest government mistreatment in Sinai


18:49 U.S. judge fines Iran for killing Marines in 1983 Beirut bombing