Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., May 05, 2007 Iyyar 17, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:32 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
A boycott by any other name ...
By James Bowen

In the late 19th century, changes in Ottoman law created a new class of large landholders, including the Sursuq family from Beirut, which acquired large tracts in northern Palestine. A similar situation had long existed in Ireland, where most land was controlled by absentee landlords, many of whom lived in Britain.

The 1880s, however, initiated dynamics that led the two lands in different directions. In 1882, the first Zionist immigrants arrived in Palestine, starting a process that subsequently led to the eviction of indigenous tenant farmers, when magnates like the Sursuqs pulled the land from under their feet, selling it to the Jewish National Fund.

In contrast, in 1880, Irish tenant farmers started a process that turned them into owner-occupiers. A former British army officer played a role in this drama, which introduced his name as a new word into many languages.

Advertisement

Western Ireland was again suffering near-famine conditions. The potato crop had failed for the third successive year. Captain Charles Cunningham Boycott, agent for Lord Erne, the absentee landlord of an estate in County Mayo, refused the request of tenants for a rent reduction and, instead, in September 1880, obtained eviction notices against 11 of them for failure to pay their rent.

Thirty years earlier, evictions had expelled huge numbers of Irish to North America. But times were changing: A nationwide tenants' rights movement, the Land League, had recently been formed, under the leadership of Charles Stewart Parnell, a scion of the landlord class, whose pro-tenant sympathies were inherited from his American mother, a woman whose grandfather had been one of George Washington's bodyguards. Speaking on September 19, 1880, Parnell outlined the strategy of the league:

"When a man takes a farm from which another has been evicted, you must shun him on the roadside when you meet him, you must shun him in the streets of the town, you must shun him at the shop-counter, you must shun him at the fair and at the market-place and even in the house of worship, by leaving him severely alone, by putting him into a sort of moral Coventry, by isolating him from the rest of his kind, as if he were a leper of old, you must show him your detestation."

Three days later, court officials attempted to serve Boycott's eviction notices on the tenants, and the Land League policy went into effect. Within two months, Boycott's name had become a synonym for ostracism, he had left the estate, and both landlords and government had discovered the power of ordinary people. Within a year, legislation at Westminster provided government finance for tenants wishing to purchase their farms.

For too long, Israel has been taking land from which Palestinians have been evicted, and detestation is spreading around the world. In Ireland, photos of Israeli bulldozers are placed beside those of landlords' battering rams. Even a former U.S. president has recognized hafrada ("separation" in Hebrew) as apartheid. Disgust has reached such a level that even highly conservative institutions that normally try to avoid politics are driven to express concern.

One such body is Aosdana, the Irish state-sponsored academy of artists. Its annual general assembly on March 28 passed a resolution whose full text is: "Mindful of the August 4, 2006 call from Palestinian filmmakers, artists and cultural workers to end all cooperation with state-sponsored Israeli cultural events and institutions, Aosdana wishes to encourage Irish artists and cultural institutions to reflect deeply before engaging in any such cooperation, always bearing in mind the undeniable courage of those Israeli artists, writers and intellectuals who oppose their own government's illegal policies towards the Palestinians."

Although on the surface, this is a mild resolution, it is a boycott call in all but name. Its significance was not lost on Dr. Zion Evrony, the Israeli ambassador in Dublin. The very same day, he issued a press release that was replete with cliches that might have worked several decades ago, when Irish people were still unaware of the horrors that Israel has inflicted on the Palestinians.

Possibly, the alacrity of Dr. Evrony's response was due to the fact that the strength of feeling among Irish artists had been rehearsed in the Irish press. Indeed, the proposer of the motion, playwright Margaretta D'Arcy, who is Jewish, had written in The Irish Times on February 16 that, "I was reluctant to advocate a cultural boycott of Israel until I visited the country for the first time last November ... I became convinced that a cultural boycott was necessary, if only as an act of solidarity with those in Israel who seek to remove the inequality, discrimination and segregation of their society."

Continuing, she quoted from "Land Grab," by Yehezkel Lein, published by B'Tselem - the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories: "The settlement enterprise in the occupied territories has created a system of legally sanctioned separation based on discrimination that has, perhaps, no parallel anywhere in the world since the apartheid regime in South Africa."

Ms. D'arcy finished by saying: "My uncle went to live in the Holy Land in the 1920s to help set up the utopian dream of peace, justice and equality between Jew and Arab. It was only when I arrived there that I realized how mistaken he was. He would have done better to have stayed in the East End of London to struggle for peace, justice and equality in England."

Parnell finished his call to action by saying that "there will be no man so full of avarice, so lost to shame, as to dare the public opinion of all right-thinking men."

They were both right.

Prof. James Bowen is the national chairperson of the Ireland-Palestine Solidarity Campaign.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Singing their song
Many of the up-and- coming songwriters in the local music market are artists themselves.
A receding world
Existence and the non-existence do not balance out; they amplify the longing.
  1.   boycott 23:23  |  Naim S. Mahlab 14/04/07
  2.   We Answered This Baseless Lie THOUSANDS Of Years Ago Too 23:23  |  Yishai Kohen 14/04/07
  3.   Jeremy Bowen who`s lost an arab boy-friend in Lebanon takes 23:25  |  Absolute Sweden 14/04/07
  4.   St Bernard of Clayvau, and St. Malachi 23:35  |  Benlolo 14/04/07
  5.   Whose bread you eat, his song you sing 23:42  |  afraid to reveal 14/04/07
  6.   Disgusted 23:43  |  Michal 14/04/07
  7.   bowen`s hatred to remembered for yom ha shoah 23:50  |  Tzvi 14/04/07
  8.   The Irish.............. 23:50  |  Bill Pearlman 14/04/07
  9.   A boycott by any other name ... 00:00  |  Mark Jeffery Koch 15/04/07
  10.   Ireland can certainly teach the world a lesson... 00:13  |  David 15/04/07
  11.   Mea culpa :Jeremy isn`t James but Paddies are the same 00:18  |  Absolute Sweden 15/04/07
  12.   # 1 00:29  |  christa 15/04/07
  13.   Racist Irish 00:40  |  Serge 15/04/07
  14.   Irish tokenism 00:44  |  Serge 15/04/07
  15.   Biblical Israel is 3300 yrs old before word of Palestine. 00:49  |  sam 15/04/07
  16.   Israel Makes It Hard 01:01  |  Will 15/04/07
  17.   No Jews Allowed 01:03  |  Alex Bruner 15/04/07
  18.   Boycott 01:09  |  victor whitman 15/04/07
  19.   boycott=solidarity with Israelis?! 01:25  |  McQueen 15/04/07
  20.   for years deluded leftists, self-haters, know-no-history jews dis 01:30  |  ralph 15/04/07
  21.   Will has it exactly backwards 01:55  |  Serge 15/04/07
  22.   Is Israel occupying Arab land or Arabs occupying Israeli land? 01:59  |  Vel 15/04/07
  23.   Boycotting the Boycotters. 02:17  |  Shalom_M 15/04/07
  24.   I reall don`t understand 02:54  |  Steve 15/04/07
  25.   Let The Irish Aosdana Adopt The Loveable Pals 03:11  |  Not Jewish 15/04/07
  26.   boycott 03:20  |  Naim S. Mahlab 15/04/07
  27.   Exterimists needs 03:30  |  Micheal 15/04/07
  28.   Lost our way 04:06  |  Will 15/04/07
  29.   Propaganda - pure and simple. 04:48  |  sg 15/04/07
  30.   #28 "at the expense of others" !??? 04:54  |  SM 15/04/07
  31.   #23 - Boycotting the Boycotters 04:59  |  Ralph 15/04/07
  32.   Propoganda Rag 05:02  |  Tom 15/04/07
  33.   Palestine Free Press 05:58  |  Avram 15/04/07
  34.   Israel is the target of a genocidal assault by the Arabs... 06:11  |  MG 15/04/07
  35.   Non Article 06:43  |  Bill 15/04/07
  36.   Serge #12 06:58  |  Bill 15/04/07
  37.   False Comparison 07:33  |  David 15/04/07
  38.   The incoherent Prof 07:42  |  Jameson whiskey 15/04/07
  39.   Haaretz 08:53  |  Vilgot T 15/04/07
  40.   Boycott 09:09  |  Steve 15/04/07
  41.   Propaganda - or the truth? No. 29 09:23  |  Palestinian Brit 15/04/07
  42.   Dear MG 09:37  |  Standish 15/04/07
  43.   Wolf Wolf ! 09:38  |  Cynic #2 15/04/07
  44.   solidarity 09:56  |  jethro 15/04/07
  45.   Please be accurate in your terminology 10:13  |  AA 15/04/07
  46.   whos land is it 10:37  |  victor 15/04/07
  47.   Boycott Israel 18:06  |  Annchen Doherty 15/04/07
  48.   ...South African? 20:12  |  Vilgot T 15/04/07
  49.   jethro I`m with you 21:49  |  deborah 15/04/07
  50.   Boycott Israel 01:12  |  Lewis Beyman 16/04/07
  51.   good for Bowen 19:14  |  deborah 05/05/07
 Today Online
Hamas, PRC: We'll thwart U.S. benchmark proposal
Responses: 518
Avi Issacharoff: The world has forgotten about Gaza
Responses: 119
Editorial: Peres must assume temporary leadership of country
Responses: 72
Mairovich: Israel will again correct failures by going to war
Responses: 137


More Headlines
20:29 Hezbollah: We had no contact with Azmi Bishara
16:23 Hamas, PRC say will act to torpedo new U.S. benchmarks for Israel, PA
18:31 Egypt: Israeli political crisis delaying moves on Arab peace plan
20:01 200 protested demolition orders in Wadi Ara unrecognized village
19:12 Report: Jordan says it has uranium for nuclear program
19:07 Qassam rocket hits Sderot house, causing damage but no injuries
18:18 German FM meets with Fayyad in first talks with PA unity government
14:28 Peres: Hamas is continuing its involvement in firing Qassam rockets
08:22 Rescuers recover body of two-year-old girl missing in Upper Galilee
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved