Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., April 12, 2007 Nisan 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:45 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Hezbollah detainees attending their initial hearing in September. (Ancho Gosh / Jini)
Last update - 08:23 11/04/2007
Lawyers for Hezbollah detainees say they deserve POW status
By Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondent

The attorneys for three Hezbollah militants taken prisoner by Israel Defense Forces troops in the Second Lebanon War say Tuesday that the prisoners should be recognized as prisoners of war.

An inquiry began Tuesday at Nazareth District Court into the preliminary testimony of the militants.

Lawyers for the prisoners said at the hearing that Hezbollah operated under the authority of Lebanese military forces.

Advertisement

Attorney Smadar Ben-Natan said, "Israel placed the responsibility for Hezbollah operations with the Lebanese government, and Olmert even said this."

Also speaking at the hearing was defense attorney Reuven Paz, formerly a department head at the Shin Bet security service.

The trial of the prisoners began seven months ago, and is being conducted according to standard procedures for criminal trials.

The prisoners - Hussein Suleiman of Beirut, Maher Kourani of Yaatar and Mohammed Sarour of Ita a-Shaab - are charged with, among other things, with belonging to a terror organization and for attempted murder and kidnapping.

Suleiman is charged with murder and kidnapping for his involvement with the July 12 cross-border attack at Moshav Zarit, where eight IDF soldiers were killed and two kidnapped. That attack led to the outbreak of war.

All three prisoners were members of Hezbollah, were active as militants in the organization, and even participated in military training in Iran.

Suleiman and Kourani joined the group in 1998 and Sarour in 2004.

Their attorneys, Ben-Natan and Itai Hermlin, say the accused are not bound by the laws of the state, and are entitled to the status of prisoners of war.

The Northern District State Prosecutor's Office said Tuesday in the indictment order that the defendants are not prisoners of war by its legal definition, but "illegal combatants," as they do not follow the rules and practices of war.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Health benefits
After years of negotiations, victims of the 1950s polio epidemic will get compensation.
Mammary woes
No one can identify the gel Russian doctors used in breast implants in the 1990s.
  1.   good for you 03:57  |  Gus 11/04/07
  2.   NO justice for Arab in Israel 04:01  |  gus 11/04/07
  3.   A nation has one army not two or three 04:19  |  Chick Corea 11/04/07
  4.   I thought Hezbollah terrorists were so tough 04:37  |  Sherman 11/04/07
  5.   Screw That 04:45  |  J K 11/04/07
  6.   until our soldiers are accounted for and alive these guys should 05:02  |  ralph 11/04/07
  7.   lemons for their lawyers and a cell with no key until we see our 05:03  |  ralph 11/04/07
  8.   Hezbollah howlers and hooters 05:05  |  Star of David 11/04/07
  9.   Even if they were soldiers 05:24  |  Ilan 11/04/07
  10.   What Chutzpah 05:26  |  * BEN JABO 11/04/07
  11.   What are Hezbollah Lawyers complaining about 05:49  |  * BEN JABO 11/04/07
  12.   No justice? 06:04  |  Lynn 11/04/07
  13.   POWs my ass 06:05  |  Lynn 11/04/07
  14.   TO GUS #1 and 2 06:17  |  even 11/04/07
  15.   Jewish lawyers for hizballah 06:22  |  Jason 11/04/07
  16.   Did these soldiers notice Hezbollah could care less about them 06:52  |  Shepherd 11/04/07
  17.   Lawyers for the Israeli hostages say they deserve POW status 07:40  |  Dan 11/04/07
  18.   Another question 07:51  |  Real Swiss 11/04/07
  19.   lawyers 08:47  |  jaime eiswn 11/04/07
  20.   Lawyers for Hezbollah detainees 08:58  |  Ros 11/04/07
  21.   Geneva Convention. 08:58  |  Adel 11/04/07
  22.   WHAT DO YOU CALL THEM? 08:59  |  indrajaya 11/04/07
  23.   equal treatment 09:10  |  fadi 11/04/07
  24.   Indrajya seething 09:11  |  SLAVO 11/04/07
  25.   Hezbollah is not an official Lebanese agency. No POW status 09:30  |  Marwan مروان خوري 11/04/07
  26.   Adel #21 09:46  |  Sarah 11/04/07
  27.   comparable status 09:57  |  Joseph 11/04/07
  28.   Conditions for POW Status 10:12  |  Steve 11/04/07
  29.   LET THEM GET A PART OF 70 VIRGINS PROMISED 10:14  |  NAD 11/04/07
  30.   who cares? 10:23  |  flashman 11/04/07
  31.   I CALL THEM 10:25  |  Nerys 11/04/07
  32.   Gus in israel we dotn have the Death penalty 10:31  |  Alon Fisher 11/04/07
  33.   FYI 10:39  |  Nerys 11/04/07
  34.   RETURN GOLDWASSER, REGEV AND ARAD!!! 10:51  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 11/04/07
  35.   Gilad and the rest 10:52  |  Nerys 11/04/07
  36.   Amazing.... 11:34  |  Cherice 11/04/07
  37.   israel`s biggest political enemy in the uk 11:41  |  dodgypriest 11/04/07
  38.   Hizbollah prisoners - hide them 11:59  |  Mike 11/04/07
  39.   combatant vs POW 12:08  |  SJ 11/04/07
  40.   #2 Gus No Justice 12:35  |  * BEN JABO 11/04/07
  41.   Release these innocent men! 12:45  |  Jared (Yered Shmuel) 11/04/07
  42.   Indrajaya 13:18  |  Nerys 11/04/07
  43.   wadha 15:51  |  convert 11/04/07
  44.   My apoologies for all Israeli and Lest Timor citizens 15:57  |  Indrajaya 11/04/07
  45.   Convert 16:04  |  Nerys 11/04/07
  46.   TO BE A POW YOU HAVE TO BE PART OF A NATIONAL ARMY 16:07  |  paul harris 11/04/07
  47.   The Hezbollah army? 16:17  |  S 11/04/07
  48.   POW = Life Sentence 16:46  |  Simple Tom 11/04/07
  49.   yeah, I`m sure!??! 16:57  |  Dave 11/04/07
  50.   Hezbollah prisoners. 16:59  |  David Nigel Braham 11/04/07
  51.   wadha - convert 16:59  |  Christian 11/04/07
  52.   I Dont Think So 17:02  |  Elisabeth 11/04/07
  53.   to Fake Indrajaya #44 18:01  |  Gus 11/04/07
  54.   to Fake Indrajaya #44 18:01  |  Gus 11/04/07
  55.   indrajaya - tell me something 18:06  |  natan 11/04/07
  56.   # 37 Gallaway is another 18:08  |  Lynn 11/04/07
  57.   gus 18:27  |  Lynn 11/04/07
  58.   Amin Gmael warned of dividing Lebanon into 2 states 19:18  |  Tamir Gaza 11/04/07
  59.   57 Lynn, lets hope Lebanon will get divided as Amin Gemael said 19:26  |  Tamir Gaza 11/04/07
  60.   It Doesn`t Make Any Difference 20:37  |  Jeff Northridge 11/04/07
  61.   It doesn`t pay for Israel to subvert international standards 20:51  |  Tosefta 11/04/07
  62.   Indra and friends 21:50  |  Truly yours 11/04/07
  63.   Gus 21:56  |  Truly yours 11/04/07
  64.   Where are all the posts? 22:21  |  Eli Ashkenazi 11/04/07
  65.   It doesn`t pay for Israel to subvert international standards 22:41  |  Tosefta 11/04/07
  66.   From now on 23:13  |  Danite 11/04/07
  67.   #62 Tosefta 00:44  |  * BEN JABO 12/04/07
  68.   Keep them under lock & key 02:50  |  * BEN JABO 12/04/07
  69.   Hezbollah Militia Members Are Not Terrorists 03:06  |  Mr. Knowitall 12/04/07
  70.   to indy # 22 "what do you call them",,,,terrorist MF`s 03:28  |  terrornator 12/04/07
  71.   #69 Mr. KnowNothing 04:53  |  * BEN JABO 12/04/07
  72.   Ben Jabo #67 04:56  |  Tosefta 12/04/07
  73.   #69 Knowitall from Frostbite Falls 05:15  |  Star of David 12/04/07
  74.   obviously too many lawyers with nothing to do! need real work 06:18  |  ralph 12/04/07
  75.   Tosefta: Toseft or Siftach???? 07:20  |  Star of David 12/04/07
  76.   # 65, TOSEFTA 08:10  |  indrajaya 12/04/07
  77.   Lawyers and snakeoil 08:23  |  Connie 12/04/07
  78.   POW Status?? 09:23  |  Zev 12/04/07
  79.   Very funny indeed 09:42  |  Margie in Tel Aviv 12/04/07
  80.   Margie: it is funny 10:49  |  Star of David 12/04/07
  81.   #72 Tosefta - Where is Ron Arad? 17:40  |  * BEN JABO 12/04/07
 Today Online
U.S. seeks Israeli support for arms sales to Saudis
Responses: 90
Ari Shavit: Israeli society must rally behind the IDF
Responses: 31
Suleiman: Peace accord could happen in 6 months
Responses: 84
Paying an exorbitant ransom for Shalit may bring more abductions
Responses: 25
Senator Fulbright, 1967: The trouble is that Jews think they control the Senate
Responses: 75
Rosner's Domain
* Rosner's Guest: American life has annihilated Jewish Peoplehood
* Senator Fulbright, 1967: The trouble is that Jews think they control the Senate