Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., June 23, 2007 Tamuz 7, 5767 | | Israel Time: 17:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 07:50 14/04/2007
We like our Arabs to be traitors
By Bradley Burston

If Azmi Bishara had never existed, the right would have had to invent him.

There is the irresistible juxtaposition of the good suits and the revolutionary rhetoric, the erudite professor of philosophy seated alongside Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah at a memorial in Syria for Hafez Assad, the Christian from Nazareth praising Hezbollah as a heroic example of Islamic resistance which has "lifted the spirit of the Arab people."

The right can't afford to lose Bishara. He is subversive beyond its wildest dreams. As the first Arab to run for prime minister of the Jewish state, his brilliance, his flamboyance, his refusal to compromise, have allowed the right to milk the word treason for all its worth.

Bishara always made too good a target. For people like Avigdor Lieberman, Bishara is an electoral secret weapon, fuel for the fire of any campaign that trades on fear of Arabs, hatred of Arabs, suspicion of Arabs, revulsion at the fact that they live here among us, well over than a million of them. One of them for every four of us.

Bishara, however, is not our real problem. We are our problem.

There is something deep down in many of us, which causes us to takes a quiet satisfaction in the notion that if push came to shove, the Arab citizens of Israel would prove themselves disloyal.

Too many of us want our Arabs to be traitors. Too many of us see Israeli Arabs, as a group, as hypocrites, parasites, their dual-loyalty a thin disguise for support of terror in the service of Palestine.

There is a quiet sense among many of us, that Israeli Arabs are fleecing the state, even as they grouse about inequality and nurse plans to de-Judaize the national home of the Jewish People.

It is, in many ways, a form of classical anti-Semitism in which the Semites in question happen to be Israeli Arabs.

We complain that they live off the rest of us, that they flaunt our zoning laws and evade the taxes we pay, that they are happy to take our welfare while spurning the notion of defending the country.

It makes us feel somehow more secure in our own identity as Jews in a Jewish state. It makes our dislike of them, our educational, economic, and social discrimination against them, seem more of a reasoned response than what it actually is, which is institutional racism.

Consider an article currently making its viral rounds on the e-mail circuit among Israeli Jews.

"They're so 'downtrodden' that tax collection in the Arab sector is a joke, and statistics on this are known to all those who care to know them," the article states. "Not only national levies like income and value-added taxes, but they can't really be bothered to pay their own municipal taxes, all the while expecting the government to cover the deficits they themselves created."

A fascinating condemnation, proving, perhaps more than anything, that Israeli Arabs have learned remarkably well to become as Israeli as the next guy.

The article goes on to paint a picture of the Israeli Arab as posing as a victim of crushing racism and poverty while actually living a life of luxury far beyond the means of the average Israeli Jew.

"They're so 'discriminated against,' that this entire [Arab] sector lives in single-family houses, that is to say, villas, which are, in fact, huge castles."

According to the anonymous author, "Every one of them lives on a jabel [hillock] of his own, as though land were an unlimited resource in this land.

"Residents of [the Israeli Arab village of] Sakhnin complain of 'confiscation of lands.' But they forget that in Sakhnin, 20,000 residents live on 8,000 dunams, while in Ramat Gan, for example, upwards of 150,000 people live on a total area of 12,000 dunams, a quarter of which is taken up by parks."

The real relish, however, is reserved for the blend of treachery and hypocrisy which the author finds endemic among Israeli Arabs.

"They're so 'oppressed,' that that they can openly identify with the worst of our enemies, Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas, Syria, the Islamic Jihad and they rest of the scum, and no one even seriously considers demanding the least loyalty to their own state."

At the same time, the author notes, Israeli Arabs have no interest in moving to a future Palestinian state. In a reference to a Lieberman proposal, he concludes, "They're not even prepared to remain in place and have the border fence be moved - leaving them in 'Palestine' without their having to leave their homes."

Finally, we can all begin to sleep well at night, knowing that we can make our Arabs fit any misconceptions we choose. We can convince ourselves, in the space of an inbox, that Israeli Arabs enjoy unparalleled freedoms and prosperity. We can even accuse them of treason and, at the same time, console ourselves with their lack of true political conviction.

They live here among us. We can look right at them, and not see them at all.


__________________


Recent blogs:

Help free them. They could've been yours.Next year in divided Jerusalem
A place at the table
Muslim atrocities, Muslim victims, our silence



_______________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Second to the saints
Neusner believes he's best suited to represent Judaism in its disputes with Christianity.
Spirit of the times
Author Yehudit Hendel merits a central place in the '1948 Generation' pantheon.
  1.   RACIST STATE OF ISRAEL 10:49  |  indrajaya 13/04/07
  2.   Burston bombs out 10:54  |  Star of David 13/04/07
  3.   It`s painful to acknowledge 11:15  |  sad puppy 13/04/07
  4.   You also like to call your Jews with a heart and a brain 11:23  |  John 13/04/07
  5.   Taking that hard look at one self 11:30  |  Gregory Sender 13/04/07
  6.   Arab stupidity = Smiling Israeli right-wingers 11:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/04/07
  7.   We would like the Arabs to be a responsible loyal minority 11:48  |  Shalom Freedman 13/04/07
  8.   Blame the victim - How typical of the left 11:53  |  Zev 13/04/07
  9.   COUNT YOUR CHOICES 11:57  |  ravi 13/04/07
  10.   to gregory sender 12:05  |  alef 13/04/07
  11.   To Shalom Freedman 12:09  |  IsraeliArab 13/04/07
  12.   stop profiling others! 12:18  |  liz 13/04/07
  13.   Bradley projecting again 12:22  |  FOX 13/04/07
  14.   The title of this article is "sensational" 12:42  |  S 13/04/07
  15.   Request to Ari 12:51  |  Choni Davidowitz 13/04/07
  16.   Another self hating jew 13:10  |  david 13/04/07
  17.   The Others (The Arabs) 13:10  |  Atilla Karagözoğlu 13/04/07
  18.   Zoning Laws? Is This Racial Segregation? 13:12  |  Texas Ranger 13/04/07
  19.   Swiss #6 13:21  |  Lynn 13/04/07
  20.   Arabs are necessary for Israel security 13:24  |  Angel of wind 13/04/07
  21.   Yes Dino #6 ! 13:50  |  S 13/04/07
  22.   And (many) Arabs like tjeir Jews to be dead 14:01  |  Hastaroth 13/04/07
  23.   Traitors 14:04  |  Yosef Ben Tzion 13/04/07
  24.   # 19 Lynn 14:14  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/04/07
  25.   #7 Shalom Freedman 14:23  |  American in NY 13/04/07
  26.   #6 DINO AT LAST LISTENS TO JERRY!! 14:50  |  paul harris 13/04/07
  27.   Burston, the 19thcentury European 14:51  |  Benlolo 13/04/07
  28.   Many of us want our Arabs to be LOYAL Israelis! 14:57  |  Alicia 13/04/07
  29.   #7 Shalom Freedman - discriminated minority vs fifth column 15:02  |  dana 13/04/07
  30.   This great experiment of Israel is possibly going to end. 15:17  |  The Equalizer 13/04/07
  31.   #15 What has this posting to do with the TOPIC 15:24  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/04/07
  32.   Keep on fooling yourselves 15:31  |  Nasser Abdu 13/04/07
  33.   # 21 S 15:33  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/04/07
  34.   No. 27 15:34  |  Mitch Cohen 13/04/07
  35.   # 25 paul harris 15:35  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/04/07
  36.   Bradley Burston You overstep the mark today 15:40  |  Ari ben Yisrael 13/04/07
  37.   They do it because Israelis like it?Not because of pan Arabism 15:43  |  PETERSM 13/04/07
  38.   My suggestion to Bradley 15:46  |  JW 13/04/07
  39.   The Right would have had to invent Bishara ? 15:50  |  Wendy 13/04/07
  40.   How could they have loyalty 15:58  |  American Conservativ 13/04/07
  41.   dana, I expect better 16:03  |  FOX 13/04/07
  42.   To Indrajaya re 1 16:09  |  Lee 13/04/07
  43.   #29 Dana, how shallow can you get? 16:18  |  FOX 13/04/07
  44.   Its a shame Burston cant see the truth 16:25  |  Sam 13/04/07
  45.   A Really Dumb Column - Par for the Course 16:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 13/04/07
  46.   Nasser Abdu #32 Why Lie? 16:35  |  FOX 13/04/07
  47.   Wendy #39 On Invention 16:40  |  FOX 13/04/07
  48.   The Equalizer #30, Thanks but no thanks 16:47  |  FOX 13/04/07
  49.   i didn`t know... 16:48  |  Igor D. 13/04/07
  50.   Swiss # 24 16:51  |  Lynn 13/04/07
  51.   # 39 on Bishara 16:56  |  Lynn 13/04/07
  52.   # 28 Many of them are loyal 16:58  |  Lynn 13/04/07
  53.   Dino #33 16:59  |  S 13/04/07
  54.   In other words, Bishara worked to destroy Israel 17:20  |  AV 13/04/07
  55.   Bradley comes from a good place. Wish the Arabs felt the same 17:25  |  Jason 13/04/07
  56.   Alicia : "OUR" Arabs??? 17:31  |  Chaval 13/04/07
  57.   Bradley,What are you talking about???? 17:37  |  TOMY 13/04/07
  58.   IMUS or Alicia in the Morning? 17:38  |  EC 13/04/07
  59.   rotting from within 17:53  |  Amin Nusseibeh 13/04/07
  60.   rotting from within 17:53  |  Amin Nusseibeh 13/04/07
  61.   Bshara 18:47  |  george dickens 13/04/07
  62.   To Alicia 19:03  |  John 13/04/07
  63.   Goerge Dickens #61 thanks but 19:03  |  FOX 13/04/07
  64.   Few Israeli Arabs are loyal, whether we like it or not 19:05  |  Chaim 13/04/07
  65.   Israeli Arabs 19:12  |  izwick 13/04/07
  66.   To Amin Nusseibeh 19:17  |  Lee 13/04/07
  67.   To FOX 19:23  |  Lee 13/04/07
  68.   Amin is the only honest poster 19:25  |  Melvin Schnell 13/04/07
  69.   Vision of a Jewish and Democratic state 19:28  |  Tosefta 13/04/07
  70.   FOX - best analogy in the US are the Mexicans 19:40  |  dana 13/04/07
  71.   TRAITORS, TREACHERY, TYRANNY AND TERRORISM 19:43  |  B 13/04/07
  72.   NOTE: The headline refers to IL-Arabs as "our"! 19:43  |  Alicia 13/04/07
  73.   To Nasser Addu 19:44  |  Lee 13/04/07
  74.   To EC re 58 19:50  |  Lee 13/04/07
  75.   FOX #41 Cont`d analogies US-Israel 19:51  |  dana 13/04/07
  76.   FOX - addendum and neocons 19:58  |  dana 13/04/07
  77.   discrimination of Arabs 20:10  |  Sari 13/04/07
  78.   Chaim #64 20:15  |  American in NY 13/04/07
  79.   Tosefta 20:18  |  ODP 13/04/07
  80.   To Tosefta re 69 20:20  |  Lee 13/04/07
  81.   JOHN 20:21  |  Alicia 13/04/07
  82.   # 50 Lynn 20:21  |  Swiss (Dino) 13/04/07
  83.   Tosefta 20:28  |  S