Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., April 13, 2007 Nisan 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 03:40 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 20:41 10/04/2007
Help free them. They could've been yours.
By Bradley Burston

Option 1: Free them because they could have been yours

They could have been yours. One of them could have been your brother, your child, your friend.

It could have been anyone standing on sovereign Israeli soil at dawn on June 25, when gunmen of Hamas and two other armed groups passed under the Gaza border via a long tunnel, to attack an army post near Kibbutz Kerem Shalom, killing two soldiers.

Advertisement

It could have been anyone, but it was Gilad Shalit they took captive.

It was chance, as well, that it was Udi Goldwasser and Eldad Regev who were patrolling the border on sovereign Israeli soil, on July 12, the last day of their 28-day stretch of reserve duty. It could have been anyone in their Humvee driving from Moshav Zarit to Moshav Shetula, on the Israeli side of the border with Lebanon, when Hezbollah gunners shelled a wide area, providing covering fire for a Hezbollah force which killed three soldiers in the Israeli patrol.

It was Udi Goldwasser and Eldad Regev whom they took captive, back across the border into Lebanon.

At this point, we know nothing definitive about of the welfare or their whereabouts.

We do know this: One word from Syria or Iran, and the soldiers held in Lebanon would be sent home. One word from Hamas, and Gilad Shalit would be sent home.

Is there anything that individuals can do to help them? There is. You can sign a petition to the government of Israel and Prime Minister Olmert, asking them to do all they can to free the soldiers.

Americans can write their representative in Congress, they can contact their U.S. senator, or send a letter or e-mail to President Bush.

Britons can contact their MPs.

You can donate funds to help the effort to free the soldiers, and you can support or join a march across the length of Israel.

Option 2: Free them. Even if the price is Barghouti. Or worse.

It's time we meant what we said.

We say, time and again, that we will not abandon soldiers in the field.

We say with conviction that we will do everything in our power to win their release.

We know the price. The price is releasing people we fear and loathe.

The price will be Marwan Barghouti. The Fatah leader serving five life terms for ordering terror attacks.

The price may even be worse. Certainly for the families and loved ones of the victims of terrorism.

But we also know, from past experience, that waiting longer only does two things. It raises the price, and it increases suffering for the families and loved ones of the captives.

Option 3: Free them, even if they could have been your enemy

There will be many among our readers who believe that Hamas and Hezbollah were well within their rights in taking the soldiers captive.

They will cite the more than 9,000 Palestinians being held by Israel. They will note that Israel has held Samir Kuntar, a member of the Abu Abbas terror group, captive since he brutally killed an Israeli and his 4-year-old daughter on a Nahariya beach in 1979.

All the more reason that they should work for the release of the three servicemen.

It is through the freedom of the three that Arab prisoners held by Israel will be released.

Now is the time to help free them. Even if for the wrong reasons.

They could have been yours. Or they could have been your enemies.

Help free them. It is rare that enemies can have a common interest.

_________________


Related blogs:

Tie a blue ribbon for Gilad
Free the monster Samir Kuntar

__________________


Recent blogs:

Next year in divided Jerusalem
A place at the table
Muslim atrocities, Muslim victims, our silence
Welcome to Settler Nation. Now, obey!


_______________



The guiding principles of the talkback forum for this article will be mutual respect and openness to dialogue. Participants, even if they rule out, dismiss or oppose coexistence, must, within the confines of this forum, practice it.

Censorship will be unapologetic.

Political orientation will have absolutely no bearing on whether a comment is posted or rejected.

The following will be grounds for deletion:

1. Racist remarks, as well as slurs on the basis of religion, ethnicity and gender.
2. Use of the terms Nazi, Hitler, to describe the actions and policies of Israelis, Palestinians or other parties to the Israel-Arab conflict.
3. Disparaging remarks, personal attacks, vulgarities and profanities directed at other participants in the forum.
4. Advocacy of violence against individuals or religious, ethnic or racial groups, including statements which may be construed as urging attacks on leaders, officials, security forces or civilians.



Bookmark to del.icio.us
The dollar dive
Israel is in a panic over the declining dollar, which is approaching the NIS 4 mark.
Operation Salamander
Hundreds of salamanders in the upper Galilee owe their lives to a pair of scientists.
  1.   I`ll select my own option #3 10:57  |  S 08/04/07
  2.   Help free them through prisoner exchange 11:03  |  troy 08/04/07
  3.   They`re not my sons 11:17  |  M. Franks-Lhermann 08/04/07
  4.   Bring them home honorably 11:33  |  Joe 08/04/07
  5.   No more army but a war panel instead? 12:09  |  Kym 08/04/07
  6.   NO ONE EVER LEARNS YOU DO NOT DEAL WITH KIDNAPPERS 12:14  |  paul harris 08/04/07
  7.   twisted reasoning 12:20  |  Khalid 08/04/07
  8.   This is for you Harris Read rules 13:44  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  9.   #8 LAB - ARSE BELIEVES IN RULES BUT FAILS TO OBSERVE THEM 14:26  |  paul harris 08/04/07
  10.   Why Did This Article Take So Long To Write? 14:27  |  Yoram 08/04/07
  11.   Thie irony is 14:35  |  Alon Fisher 08/04/07
  12.   Empower IDF to bring back home our kids 14:36  |  Joseph E . 08/04/07
  13.   6#CORRECT PAUL HARRIS 14:40  |  Alon Fisher 08/04/07
  14.   Burston is not merely wrong this time 14:52  |  Sidney 08/04/07
  15.   May I propose a simple deal? 14:54  |  Clickfool 08/04/07
  16.   #8 unwarranted 15:21  |  themasmer 08/04/07
  17.   Now the PrizeFOOL #15 makes choices for the Palestinians 15:36  |  Ari ben Yisrael 08/04/07
  18.   #15 15:38  |  J K 08/04/07
  19.   Help free them. They`ll kidnap others. 15:39  |  Jak Black 08/04/07
  20.   #15 I AGREE CLIKKY RELEASE THEM ALL IN JORDAN 15:46  |  paul harris 08/04/07
  21.   Would that you had to pay the price 15:46  |  Ilan 08/04/07
  22.   Re: #3 15:53  |  SJ 08/04/07
  23.   What other counry would consider releasing a serial killer? 15:58  |  Yacov 08/04/07
  24.   AND ALLOW THE MURDERERS TO KILL MORE INNOCENT JEWS ?? 16:12  |  Bill. 08/04/07
  25.   free them in a divided city? 16:22  |  Karateka 08/04/07
  26.   you are wrong! this is war by other means, they are barbarians 16:25  |  ralph 08/04/07
  27.   Labhras - Does Israel, in your opinion, have the 16:27  |  Avihu 08/04/07
  28.   Barghouti & Burston are dead wrong 16:35  |  Spoon 08/04/07
  29.   In agreement with Bradley Burston`s arguments 16:53  |  Smadar 08/04/07
  30.   Give the kidnappers 48 hours to return Shalit 17:15  |  Zev 08/04/07
  31.   #27 Avihu Re Labarhs 17:17  |  SG 08/04/07
  32.   The Issue Might Be Encouraging More 17:37  |  Ben 08/04/07
  33.   10,000 : 1 17:38  |  ny observer 08/04/07
  34.   BARGHOUTI IS A HAMAS 17:39  |  indrajaya 08/04/07
  35.   BURSTON`S DEFEATISM IS TYPICAL OF A SUPPORTER OF OLMERT 17:52  |  DAN ROSENTHAL 08/04/07
  36.   Clickfool 17:57  |  Tabitha Kundu 08/04/07
  37.   Samir Kuntar 18:00  |  Charles 08/04/07
  38.   Help free them, They could`ve been yours. 18:13  |  mona 08/04/07
  39.   #26 18:16  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  40.   #31 18:21  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  41.   ...to poor leftist educated at Berkeley... 18:32  |  abraham...mico 08/04/07
  42.   Yes do that...but 18:37  |  Stright 2 the point 08/04/07
  43.   Clickfool 18:38  |  Connie 08/04/07
  44.   and what about the hundreds innocent palestinians in israeli jail 18:39  |  cristina 08/04/07
  45.   Let us not forget that many Pals Prisoners....... 18:56  |  Abdur R. 08/04/07
  46.   Can We Exchange Levy and Burston For Them? 19:02  |  Yoram 08/04/07
  47.   PRISONNERS!!! 19:06  |  Becky 08/04/07
  48.   Israel owes the captives, and the one in an American prison, also 19:13  |  David Turner 08/04/07
  49.   Israel owes the captives,and the one in an American prison, also2 19:14  |  David Turner 08/04/07
  50.   Israel should liberate all Political Prisoners, Women.... 19:18  |  Hamza 08/04/07
  51.   We must save them 19:24  |  SG 08/04/07
  52.   # 38 Labrhas 19:30  |  ChanahS 08/04/07
  53.   Free Barghouti; we have a good excuse 19:32  |  Tosefta 08/04/07
  54.   #11.Alon Fisher, IF, IF , & IF...... 19:36  |  FRED 08/04/07
  55.   to intrjava 19:39  |  david 08/04/07
  56.   #33 observer 10000/1 19:46  |  Fairman 08/04/07
  57.   Regarding Barghouti - and other Palestinian prisoners as well: 19:51  |  Mimi 08/04/07
  58.   Yacov#23. R U suggesting they keep them 3 captured 19:54  |  Sol. 08/04/07
  59.   on Bradly Burston and Soros 19:57  |  david 08/04/07
  60.   IDF kidnappings 20:00  |  Omran 08/04/07
  61.   They could`ve been yours 20:06  |  Shmuelshachor 08/04/07
  62.   Turner #45 20:07  |  Rebecca 08/04/07
  63.   #18, JK. there is a simple reason for this kind of swap. 20:14  |  Fred 08/04/07
  64.   #49 20:22  |  David 08/04/07
  65.   THIS IS REALLY SIMPLE! 20:23  |  John 08/04/07
  66.   #50 Chanas H 20:27  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  67.   #47 american risioner 20:51  |  Dewey 08/04/07
  68.   #62 (Part I) 21:09  |  J K 08/04/07
  69.   Labhras - Avihu did not ask you about Israel`s borders. He 21:12  |  Avi 08/04/07
  70.   #62 (Part II) 21:14  |  J K 08/04/07
  71.   # 62 (Part III) 21:18  |  J K 08/04/07
  72.   to Dewey about Polard 21:53  |  david 08/04/07
  73.   Mr Bradley Burston : Help free them 22:07  |  Daniella 08/04/07
  74.   #15, Clickfool 22:13  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/04/07
  75.   For Cipora # 74 22:32  |  Clickfool 08/04/07
  76.   Release the Palestinians 22:33  |  David 08/04/07
  77.   Avi Labhras`s answer? 22:35  |  Aby 08/04/07
  78.   To David about Pollard 22:37  |  Dewey 08/04/07
  79.   Shalit kidnapped for Israeli breach of the cease fire 22:39  |  Tosefta 08/04/07
  80.   ...to Yoram#46...good idea, they are better as enemies... 23:04  |  abraham...mico 08/04/07
  81.   #75, clickfool 23:08  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/04/07
  82.   ...to Tosefta...Dumbite is more clever than you... 23:21  |  reader 08/04/07
  83.   #69 Avi 23:37  |  Labhras