Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., April 11, 2007 Nisan 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:57 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
 Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 10:20 09/04/2007
PA: Talks over Shalit swap have taken 'big step' forward
By Amos Harel, Amiram Barkat and Jack Khoury and Haaretz Service

Palestinian Authority cabinet spokesman Ghazi Hamad said that talks toward a prisoner exchange to free captive Israel Defense Forces soldier Gilad Shalit had taken a "big step" forward in recent days, and that the sides had reached an understanding over the numbers and the types of Palestinian prisoners to be released by Israel.

Palestinians involved in the negotiations have said that Israel has agreed to release prisoners "with blood on their hands," as well as veteran prisoners whose sentences began before 1993 signing of the Oslo peace accords, and political leaders such as Marwan Barghouti.

"There is perhaps a decision in principle between the Palestinian side, or between the Egyptian side, and the Israeli side, on the numbers and on the types of prisoners" to be released, Hamed told Army Radio.

Advertisement

Cairo has acted as a mediator in the prolonged negotiations for the release of Shalit, held since last June, when a joint force of Hamas and other armed groups attacked Shalit's base on Israeli soil just outside the Gaza Strip.

"I think that the big fight is over names," Hamad said. In a separate interview, he told Israel Radio that Israeli officials had been given a list of names of prisoners the Palestinians want to see released. Asked how long the negotiations could last, Hamad said, "It depends on the Israeli side. If they say that they accept the Palestinian list, we could reach an agreement within a week."

Israeli officials have confirmed that progress has been reached in negotiations to bring about Shalit's release, but cautioned that the path to resolving the negotiations was still long.

Israeli media reports have said that Hamas has demanded that the deal include Fatah leader Barghouti, sentenced to five life sentences for involvement in terror attacks against Israelis, and Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine leader Ahmed Saadat, who ordered the 2001 assassination of Israeli cabinet minister Rehavam Ze'evi.

Palestinian sources said the deal would proceed in three steps:

  • Transfer of Shalit to Egyptian authorities, in exchange for freeing an initial group of minor and ailing prisoners.

  • Transfer of Shalit to Israel and the release of a further group of Palestinian prisoners.

  • After a few months - an additional prisoner release, including leading Palestinian political figures. According to the sources, "There will be no deal without Marwan Barghouti."

    Security sources Saturday night had confirmed that "certain progress" was made in the efforts to free Shalit. The same sources noted that there were many complex obstacles in the way to completing the deal with Shalit's kidnappers and warned that the process may take time.

    "Indeed, a certain progress has been made, but there is still a long way [to Shalit's release]," sources in Jerusalem said.

    The sources also warned reporters that "you should not rely on reports originating among Palestinians because they may create unrealistic expectations."

    An Israeli source involved with the negotiations on Saturday confirmed that a list with the names of prisoners Hamas wishes to see released has reached Israel. Hamas presented the list in recent days, but the problem is that Israel finds some of the names on the list unacceptable.

    Israel will agree to the release of some prisoners "with bloodied hands" (those who have participated in attacks in which Israelis were killed), but not necessarily to the senior figures Hamas is demanding.

    A likely problem that could have a negative effect on the negotiations revolves around the friction between Hamas' political and military wings in the Gaza Strip.

    The head of the military wing in the northern Gaza Strip, Ahmed Ja'abari, is responsible for a number of attacks and attempts along the border fence in recent weeks. In practice the meaning of these attacks is that the military wing of Hamas has ceased to abide by the cease-fire, and this may result in a further escalation with Israel in the near future.

    It has also emerged in recent days that Fatah-affiliated security organizations have learned where the abducted BBC correspondent, Alan Johnson, is being held, but have avoided rescuing him out of fear that the operation will result in heavy casualties. His captors, according to the same sources, are members of the Darmush clan.

    Meanwhile, an Israeli Arab, Jihad Ziara, was abducted on Friday in the Gaza Strip. Ziara, originally from the Gaza Strip, was visiting his first wife when gunmen kidnapped him.

    • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Health benefits
    After years of negotiations, victims of the 1950s polio epidemic will get compensation.
    Mammary woes
    No one can identify the gel Russian doctors used in breast implants in the 1990s.
      1.   Terrorists with Jewish blood on their hands 03:13  |  Connie 08/04/07
      2.   A NO BRAINER 03:27  |  Brant 08/04/07
      3.   What with the IDF soldiers with palestinian children blood? 03:43  |  Ivan 08/04/07
      4.   This swap goes against what Shalit was fighting for! 04:25  |  Jared (Yered Shmuel) 08/04/07
      5.   The Truth 04:29  |  josh 08/04/07
      6.   Ivan 04:40  |  Connie 08/04/07
      7.   #3 Ivan 05:09  |  * BEN JABO 08/04/07
      8.   Trade Noam, Olmert, livni, peretz and all the lefties for Shalit 06:20  |  Shiloh 08/04/07
      9.   To #3 06:29  |  Shmuelshachor 08/04/07
      10.   Terrorists with Palestinian blood on their hands 06:37  |  Palestinian 08/04/07
      11.   #7 BEN 06:38  |  jake 08/04/07
      12.   Jewish terrorists 06:38  |  Israeli 08/04/07
      13.   connie the settler: they are not soldiers, they are 06:41  |  Honest human being 08/04/07
      14.   #6 Connie 06:42  |  tad 08/04/07
      15.   to #12 07:51  |  vik 08/04/07
      16.   Honest Human Being 08:04  |  Connie 08/04/07
      17.   Tad 08:14  |  Connie 08/04/07
      18.   connie, the fanatical settler 08:42  |  Honest human being 08/04/07
      19.   Death penalty? 08:44  |  Nechama 08/04/07
      20.   Both Israel and US are terrorist 08:46  |  Israeli 08/04/07
      21.   # 1/ # 3 / # 7 / # 9 Stop fighting, both sides have.... 09:04  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/04/07
      22.   Connie, I need your help 09:11  |  Isdodi 08/04/07
      23.   #17 Connie 09:12  |  Moury 08/04/07
      24.   Jewish Terror and Scare Tactics must End 09:27  |  Khalil 08/04/07
      25.   Isodi 09:43  |  Connie 08/04/07
      26.   Moury 09:55  |  Connie 08/04/07
      27.   Human being,maybe 10:01  |  Connie 08/04/07
      28.   Fatah Leader(Sic) Bargouti 10:07  |  Nora 08/04/07
      29.   Another Olmert/Livni SURRENDER 10:08  |  Dr. Dave 08/04/07
      30.   PA hints sides agree on numbers in Shalit swap 10:08  |  Phil Goldstein 08/04/07
      31.   Palestinian 10:10  |  Medo 08/04/07
      32.   #22 Your mom lied to you 10:17  |  Yosef 08/04/07
      33.   GPS tracking 10:34  |  yoni 08/04/07
      34.   #22 Isdodi, I don`t think so 10:46  |  Jonathan 08/04/07
      35.   Free discussion 11:00  |  Berg 08/04/07
      36.   We are better off trying to rescue Gilad 11:18  |  Gili 08/04/07
      37.   Way to go Ehud & the Kadimas 11:31  |  Michael 08/04/07
      38.   Israel did wrong.. 11:37  |  Onur from Turkey 08/04/07
      39.   What a shameful act on the part of the PA!!! At first they 11:48  |  Petra 08/04/07
      40.   Hurry release-Pals need their top terros for the coming war 11:52  |  Alan Sa 08/04/07
      41.   A lot can change in 6 months. 12:14  |  Paulo 08/04/07
      42.   Marwan Barghouti`s release 13:01  |  Josh 08/04/07
      43.   get rid of mass murderers, not let them kill us 13:05  |  sam 08/04/07
      44.   Paulo - Why do you care about Olmert if you don`t 13:41  |  Beyamin 08/04/07
      45.   Is Shallit a BOW or civilian taken hostage? 14:46  |  John 08/04/07
      46.   Ismail not Ivan 15:12  |  Nerys 08/04/07
      47.   These Trades Are Insane 15:13  |  Dyinglikeflies 08/04/07
      48.   who cares for what u think, murderer 16:05  |  arab 08/04/07
      49.   who cares for what u think, murderer 16:06  |  arab 08/04/07
      50.   PA`s BIG STEPS 16:09  |  Mary 08/04/07
      51.   they cannot even prove he is alive or deliver. 1 for 1and if dead 16:23  |  ralph 08/04/07
      52.   Prisoners deal and good PR 16:51  |  Twogunz 08/04/07
      53.   Jake # 11 16:54  |  Twogunz 08/04/07
      54.   Isdodi 22` 17:00  |  Twogunz 08/04/07
      55.   Palestinian Prisoners 17:01  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 08/04/07
      56.   Accurate Chronology 17:03  |  Double Click 08/04/07
      57.   Kahlil # 24 17:04  |  Twogunz 08/04/07
      58.   "ISRAELI"why not give the other aliases you use here 17:16  |  PETERSM 08/04/07
      59.   # 21 Swiss Dino 17:17  |  Jim 08/04/07
      60.   This is ONE MAN SHOW ! 17:19  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 08/04/07
      61.   # 31 17:26  |  Jim 08/04/07
      62.   Jews problem is HAUGHTINESS (arrogance) 17:32  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 08/04/07
      63.   A lot can change, writes Paulo, who wishes that 17:32  |  Beyamin 08/04/07
      64.   Jews work great but lose as stupid 17:37  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 08/04/07
      65.   #53 Twogunz 17:41  |  jake 08/04/07
      66.   # 22 17:44  |  Jim 08/04/07
      67.   # 56 only one thing wrong (everything) 17:48  |  ChanahS 08/04/07
      68.   #11 jake - you`ve missed the point. 17:52  |  * BEN JABO 08/04/07
      69.   If Jews lose with Israel 17:53  |  Atilla Karagozoglu 08/04/07
      70.   #13 Honest Human Being - not really-read on: 18:00  |  * BEN JABO 08/04/07
      71.   Connie Knows the gig is up but 18:03  |  Labhras 08/04/07
      72.   #45 John UK 18:05  |  * BEN JABO 08/04/07
      73.   EVERY BODY HAS BLOOD ON THEIR HANDS!!! 18:09  |  ABU ALI 08/04/07
      74.   # 59 Jim 18:28  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/04/07
      75.   # 65 Chanah S 18:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/04/07
      76.   WORLD PROBLEMS OVER? Time for Israel to go for ever. 18:58  |  Proud Canadian 08/04/07
      77.   Atilla is cool 19:12  |  Dyinglikeflies 08/04/07
      78.   Proud Canadian, Land Thief 19:44  |  Dyinglikeflies 08/04/07
      79.   Proud Arab posing as a Canadian 19:55  |  Larry 08/04/07
      80.   tad #14 19:57  |  GABE1 08/04/07
      81.   55 AtiLLa 20:03  |  Nerys 08/04/07
      82.   If you don`t like what I say... 20:15  |  Reader 08/04/07
      83.   Proud Canadian 20:28  |  rich 08/04/07
      84.   Shalit kidnapped for Israeli breach of the cease fire 20:31  |  Tosefta 08/04/07
      85.   To Number 71 20:34  |  Simon 08/04/07
      86.   Larry`s tirade 20:48  |  Reader 08/04/07
      87.   an idea for exchange of prisoners 20:54  |  mike 08/04/07
      88.   Heck No!!! 20:57  |  David 08/04/07
      89.   The big stp ended to soon 21:08  |  Dr David I Gross 08/04/07
      90.   being an iriah priest is the best job in the world 21:21  |  dodgypriest 08/04/07
      91.   when the eu stop the largesse to ireland 21:22  |  dodgypriest 08/04/07
      92.   to #13,"The honest human being"?????????? 21:23  |  Shmuelshachor 08/04/07
      93.   did ye hear anything like it in ireland 21:26  |  dodgypriest 08/04/07
      94.   To Connie on #6 21:30  |  Shmuelshachor 08/04/07
      95.   Tosefta #84 21:31  |  Danite 08/04/07
      96.   #84, Tosefta 21:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/04/07
      97.   Gabe1--you should be the last person 21:49  |  tad 08/04/07
      98.   82 Connie --Scary Haaretz???!! 21:53  |  tad 08/04/07
      99.   #67 Chanah, really? Who was pray tell? 21:55  |  tad 08/04/07
      100.   Swap-Politicians` Chess Game? 22:35  |  warmapril 08/04/07
      101.   Bird from Outerspace #96 22:37  |  Tosefta 08/04/07
      102.   Connie, i like your posts; please continue. 23:02  |  vladimir 08/04/07
      103.   #101, Tosefta 23:20  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 08/04/07
      104.   Free Barghouti; we have a good excuse 23:25  |  Tosefta 08/04/07
      105.   #75 Swiss 00:06  |  ChanahS 09/04/07
      106.   Who the boy is 00:16  |  From the Moon 09/04/07
      107.   PA pattern 00:16  |  Anita 09/04/07
      108.   The big lies 00:30  |  Rami 09/04/07
      109.   Israels fighting spirit is dead surrender is the prefered choice 00:50  |  zionist forever 09/04/07
      110.   Rlease of any prisoners means terrorists have won 01:08  |  bernard ross 09/04/07
      111.   All of you are pathetic 01:26  |  Whatever 09/04/07
      112.   Tosefta the freak 01:33  |  Danite 09/04/07
      113.   UGY the she-camel`s owner 01:36  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      114.   BBC and Shalit 01:41  |  fred 09/04/07
      115.   #84 Tosefta - Then why do they kidnap press people 02:10  |  * BEN JABO 09/04/07
      116.   #104 Tosefta - Barghouti? 02:13  |  * BEN JABO 09/04/07
      117.   Blood for Connie 02:13  |  Reader 09/04/07
      118.   Will this satisfy you? 02:18  |  Reader 09/04/07
      119.   tad #97 02:20  |  schafe82 09/04/07
      120.   For Vic in New York 02:28  |  Reader 09/04/07
      121.   Danite, Cipora, and Tosefta 02:45  |  Smadar 09/04/07
      122.   to ivan # 3,what about the palestinians with palestinian children 02:51  |  terrornator 09/04/07
      123.   #104, "such people are not simple murderers" 03:10  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      124.   to honest human being # 18 after reading your post,i see your 03:11  |  terrornator 09/04/07
      125.   Labhras concerning David 03:32  |  Connie 09/04/07
      126.   Shmuelshachor 03:35  |  Connie 09/04/07
      127.   Talk to a Bird from Outerspace #103 - 2nd try 03:37  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      128.   Does Bernard Ross wish to be a Terrorist? 03:38  |  Reader 09/04/07
      129.   #121, Smadar 03:39  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      130.   Kidnapping (Ben Jabo #115,6) 03:44  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      131.   Smadar #121 03:54  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      132.   #68 BEN 04:05  |  jake 09/04/07
      133.   #130, Tosefta 04:07  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      134.   #68 BEN 04:17  |  jake 09/04/07
      135.   Proud Canadian 04:20  |  Connie 09/04/07
      136.   # 21 Swiss 04:54  |  Lynn 09/04/07
      137.   #131, Tosefta 05:41  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      138.   International law (Bird from Outerspace #133) 05:50  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      139.   #134-2 Jake - Here`s how Pali`s sacrafice their own 05:56  |  * BEN JABO 09/04/07
      140.   #138, Tosefta 06:18  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      141.   That`s one big step for the PA...no steps for Shalit 06:37  |  Jacob Blues 09/04/07
      142.   # 136 Lynn 09:25  |  Swiss (Dino) 09/04/07
      143.   #104 Tosefta: Free Barghouti may be a good idea 11:32  |  Tzfonit 09/04/07
      144.   Negotiationsmyarss 13:26  |  Terrorist Demands!!! 09/04/07
      145.   prisoner swap 15:17  |  cowboy joe 09/04/07
      146.   This promise, too, slips into the back pages 15:27  |  Paul Freedman 09/04/07
      147.   tzfonit #143 15:45  |  BRACHA Kahba 09/04/07
      148.   EthnoCentric Headline 15:51  |  Double Click 09/04/07
      149.   Free the all terrorists the Palestinians want 16:30  |  Jason Steinberg 09/04/07
      150.   #148 2MILLION IN USA JAILS MAJORITY BLACK !! 16:42  |  paul harris 09/04/07
      151.   #140 Cipora 17:25  |  Smadar 09/04/07
      152.   Only Solution is Peaceful Reversal of Zionist and... 17:40  |  Hani 09/04/07
      153.   Atilla Karagozoglu 17:53  |  David Israel 09/04/07
      154.   Sorry John, but POW`s, have rights 17:58  |  Jacob Blues 09/04/07
      155.   Connie--you take a lot for granted ole girl! 18:33  |  tad 09/04/07
      156.   Jacob Blues #141 18:40  |  GABE1 09/04/07
      157.   Best way to deal with extortion - institute death penalty 18:46  |  BG 09/04/07
      158.   Cipora - don`t mind Hamas cheerleader Tosefta 18:56  |  Jewboy 09/04/07
      159.   Beyamin 19:10  |  Ernie 09/04/07
      160.   Yet again 19:12  |  Greg 09/04/07
      161.   #149 majority in Zionist jails are Palestinians, why? 19:22  |  tad 09/04/07
      162.   ChanahS 19:24  |  Ernie 09/04/07
      163.   #151--the Palestinians helped Hitler, period 19:59  |  Paul Freedman 09/04/07
      164.   # 134 jake 20:06  |  Lynn 09/04/07
      165.   It may sound cruel but..... 20:32  |  paul 09/04/07
      166.   To 151, "role reversal" 20:54  |  Dyinglikeflies 09/04/07
      167.   #150, Smadar 20:55  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 09/04/07
      168.   All is but a big scam. Stop the game, get Haniye & do a 1 for 1. 21:40  |  Rami 09/04/07
      169.   # 151 Not all Pals 21:44  |  Lynn 09/04/07
      170.   Sorry Hani, but it`s a noun, not an adjective 22:24  |  Jacob Blues 09/04/07
      171.   44# the question should be 22:58  |  Alon Fisher 09/04/07
      172.   Hold It!!! 23:15  |  Wisdom of Solomon 09/04/07
      173.   Bird from Outerspace #140 23:27  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      174.   #150 Smadar (re Cipora) 23:39  |  Tosefta 09/04/07
      175.   MADNESS 00:06  |  paul 10/04/07
      176.   Big Mistake 00:12  |  Salty 10/04/07
      177.   #162, Tosefta 00:44  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/04/07
      178.   Tosefta aka Dana(currently) vs Cipora 01:18  |  GABE1 10/04/07
      179.   NO WAY 01:54  |  manny 10/04/07
      180.   #165, Gabe1 02:34  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/04/07
      181.   Dense Bird from Outerspace #164 02:53  |  Tosefta 10/04/07
      182.   Cipora #166 PART ONE 03:38  |  GABE 1 10/04/07
      183.   Cipora #166 PART TWO 03:49  |  Gabe1 10/04/07
      184.   Deal of the WEAK 03:53  |  paul 10/04/07
      185.   Tosefta 03:59  |  paul 10/04/07
      186.   Cipora Julianna Kohn #169 04:14  |  CHGODMK 10/04/07
      187.   Cipora re: Hamas Cheerleader T. 04:36  |  Steve 10/04/07
      188.   #182, Steve 05:25  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 10/04/07
      189.   So Tosefta is currently Dana ??? 06:23  |  Smadar 10/04/07
      190.   Cipora and CHGODMK 06:28  |  Danite 10/04/07
      191.   Smadar did you hear that?? 06:32  |  Danite 10/04/07
      192.   Danite: An Alternative 07:01  |  CHGODMK 10/04/07
      193.   Who`s Coaching WHOM 07:21  |  CHGODMK 10/04/07
      194.   ChGODMK 07:26  |  Danite 10/04/07
      195.   Smadar 07:27  |  Danite 10/04/07
      196.   Danite: The Hunt 07:45  |  CHGODMK 10/04/07
      197.   Danite 08:28  |  Smadar 10/04/07
      198.   shalit is one person 12:11  |  mehmet 10/04/07
      199.   BIG STEP FORWARD - 3 STEPS BACKWARDS 00:58  |  * BEN JABO 12/04/07
     Today Online
    Hamas: Israel's terms for prisoner deal make it 'doomed to fail'
    Responses: 228
    AG: Settlers at Hebron house can petition against eviction
    Responses: 156
    Lawyers for Hezbollah detainees say they deserve POW status
    Responses: 64
    Amira Hass: Not all Palestinian prisoners are criminals
    Responses: 153
    Report: Hezbollah says prepared for summer war
    Responses: 121
    Rosner's Domain
    * Senator Fulbright, 1967: The trouble is that Jews think they control the Senate
    * Rosner's Guest: American life has annihilated Jewish Peoplehood
    * Blog and Poll: The Middle East is Pelosi's playground
    * The Jewish Factor: Democrats better on Darfur, Church-State


    More Headlines
    02:55 U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates to visit Israel
    02:44 Negotiator: Damascus genuinely willing to initiate peace talks
    02:56 AG: Settlers can petition court against Hebron house eviction
    00:10 Balad: Return of MK Bishara's wife proves he hasn't fled Israel
    01:42 Body of Israeli found in China identified as Ada Gershkowitz
    19:25 Hamas: Prisoner deal 'doomed to fail' according to Israeli terms
    20:05 BBC chief to head to Middle East to appeal for missing reporter
    23:57 Closed 1967 Senate protocols reveal bids to pressure Israel
    01:30 Rights group: Prisons Service blocking inmate's kidney transplant
    21:34 Migrant workers group: Judiciary treats human traffickers lightly
    Previous Editions
    Special Offers
    Advertisement
    Skin Care Products
    Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
    JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
    The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
    A Different Israel Experience
    Unique programs for adults of all ages
    Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
    Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
    Junkyard
    Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
    CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
    Israel's international summer camps!
    Learn Hebrew Online
    Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
    Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
    © Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved