Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., April 11, 2007 Nisan 23, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:07 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
It's not a house, it's a settlement
By Haaretz Editorial

The new settlement in Hebron is not a house, it's an entire neighborhood. Into this enormous, 3,500-square-meter edifice purchased by the Jews of Hebron in the past few weeks for $700,000, no less than 30 families and 14 individuals - more than at any other West Bank outpost - moved in with great pomp and circumstance.

The huge building dominates the Kiryat Arba-Hebron road. Its inhabitation was a showy demonstration intended to kick off the celebration of the 40th anniversary of the city's occupation. Hebron's Jews, although numbering only a few hundred in a city of over 100,000 Palestinians, are well-practiced in setting the agenda of the occupation. It is difficult to forget that Baruch Goldstein, who killed dozens of worshipers at the Tomb of the Patriarchs, launched the wave of suicide attacks in Israel.

The minister of defense has already announced his intention to evacuate the dozens of new settlers from the structure they bought, but at this stage it is a decision with no date set for action, despite the estimate by the deputy defense minister that the building will be evacuated within two weeks. The more time elapses the more entrenched the settlers will become and the harder it will be to remove them. As Amir Peretz has not managed to convince the prime minister to support the evacuation of other outposts, it is doubtful he can do so here. No one is better at exploiting official hesitation than the settlers.

Advertisement

"This time we decided to act in a legal manner," Hebron Jewish Community spokesman Noam Arnon said, referring to the deed of sale on the house, but this settlement is illegal even if the real estate transaction was carried out properly.

Hebron is occupied Palestinian land and all Jewish settlement at any site under occupation must be approved by the Civil Administration. No such permit was issued, and happily none apparently will be issued as long as Peretz remains defense minister. Hebron is not Jaffa, as the settlers are trying to claim, because it is not part of the State of Israel. On the other hand, the Jewish settlers of Hebron are Israeli citizens and as such the police can evacuate them.

Experience has taught the settlers that Israeli cabinets have less staying power than the residents of illegal settlements. If they can only hang on to the end of Peretz's term, perhaps a defense minister who is more sympathetic to their cause will replace him, one who will sign off on the necessary permits as easily as his predecessors did and dispatch soldiers to protect the new settlement.

Nevertheless, in the summer of 2005 a large crack breached the settlers' self-confidence because of the ease with which Ariel Sharon evacuated all the settlers in Gush Katif. That lesson, which the settlers certainly took on board, should also strengthen the government's hand. Amir Peretz, who for years has advocated the evacuation of the settlements, must prove that his words and promises are still valid and take at least this small step after failing to evacuate other outposts. All the public opinion polls have shown for years that there is broad public support for reducing the settlement enterprise, which is considered the main obstacle to peace agreements. How much more so when it comes to a settlement of extremist settlers in the heart of Hebron.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Curing the hospital
Doctors at Schneider hospital are demanding the replacement of their management.
Hiding the light
Only 63% of ultra-Orthodox schools seek to expand their pupils' knowledge.
  1.   criminal intent 2 violate "Human Rts." signed by Govt. 12:52  |  sam 08/04/07
  2.   Hebron - Never normal always extreme 12:52  |  Baruch Nili 08/04/07
  3.   Jews in Hebron 12:53  |  Choni Davidowitz 08/04/07
  4.   Hevron=biblical land invaded by Palestinians 12:57  |  sal 08/04/07
  5.   Transparency Please!! Who finances Haaretz??? 13:38  |  Bongo is back 08/04/07
  6.   Jews lived in Hebron for centuries - actually for MILLENNIA 14:44  |  Hal 08/04/07
  7.   The Security Cabinet rejected Peretz for giving an illegal order 14:50  |  Hal 08/04/07
  8.   If they would allow Jews to build in Hebron they would be 100,000 14:55  |  amir 08/04/07
  9.   For Bongo is Back # 5 15:06  |  Clickfool 08/04/07
  10.   Settler-terrorists 15:16  |  Mitch Cohen 08/04/07
  11.   Divine Right Of Bigots 15:22  |  Rowan Berkeley 08/04/07
  12.   DIRTY INCITING ARTICLE 15:40  |  Vladimir 08/04/07
  13.   Israel`s war crime program 15:40  |  TimothyL 08/04/07
  14.   why is a fishmonger in charge of Jewish Security?? 15:42  |  Bongo again 08/04/07
  15.   Ha`aretz only now admits that Jews own the land? 15:52  |  Dani 08/04/07
  16.   Please explain the logic 15:53  |  Ilan 08/04/07
  17.   Baruch Nili No 2 15:54  |  Mary 08/04/07
  18.   Peretz helping Arab Muslims enforce racist apartheid against Jews 16:03  |  Yacov 08/04/07
  19.   Embrace Jews! 16:22  |  Hal 08/04/07
  20.   Israel is sovereign nation - the UN is irrelevant 16:44  |  Hal 08/04/07
  21.   If a judge always sided against Jews ... 16:50  |  Hal 08/04/07
  22.   Ultra-Leftists do evil 16:59  |  Hal 08/04/07
  23.   So it is now public knowledge that Teddy Kolek ... 17:23  |  Jay 08/04/07
  24.   Hal - a brainwashed american 17:33  |  Rowan Berkeley 08/04/07
  25.   #13 TIMONTHY L AND THE OLD OLD STORY 17:41  |  paul harris 08/04/07
  26.   Jews Have Been Living in Hevron for 4000 YEARS 17:58  |  Ben Israel 08/04/07
  27.   The funny thing is. . . 18:09  |  Barry 08/04/07
  28.   Has the world gone mad - or only Haaretz 18:13  |  Zev 08/04/07
  29.   Rowan Berkeley - enemy of human rights 18:30  |  Hal 08/04/07
  30.   Actually, Jews have been living in Hevron for over 10,000 years 18:45  |  Hal 08/04/07
  31.   legally paid for 19:01  |  flashman 08/04/07
  32.   Can Palestinians buy back their homes in Israel? 19:11  |  Palestinian Brit 08/04/07
  33.   #27 Hal the comic 19:57  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  34.   Ben Israel will you grow up tedious boy 19:58  |  Marilyn 08/04/07
  35.   If Hevron becomes Jew-free, Tel Aviv will be Arab-free. 20:00  |  AV 08/04/07
  36.   #21 Hal the comic 20:01  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  37.   Hal you are an imbecile 20:02  |  Marilyn 08/04/07
  38.   Can Muslims in Judea sell their homes to Jews? 20:02  |  Hal 08/04/07
  39.   #27 Hal 20:10  |  Boycott 08/04/07
  40.   My invitation to the State of Israel 20:26  |  Clickfool 08/04/07
  41.   The UN is a cesspool of dictatorship and corruption 20:41  |  Hal 08/04/07
  42.   Marylin is a criminal 20:43  |  Joe 08/04/07
  43.   Re-Building 20:55  |  Dr Dvid i. Gross 08/04/07
  44.   #19 Hal the comic 21:15  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  45.   In a different thread, Labhras, you refused to 21:16  |  Dan Finklstein 08/04/07
  46.   Marylin is an idiot 21:54  |  Hal 08/04/07
  47.   Jews are descendants of Canaanite people. 22:10  |  Hal 08/04/07
  48.   Jews and Arabs are not related 22:13  |  Hal 08/04/07
  49.   Jews and Arabs arent related 2 22:26  |  Hal 08/04/07
  50.   Marilyn #37 22:32  |  Angel 08/04/07
  51.   #48 Hal 22:35  |  Boycott 08/04/07
  52.   # 8 amir.TOOK NOTE.WHAT HAS HAARETZ TO DO ... 22:43  |  Kath` 08/04/07
  53.   Barry No. 27 / Your comment is sick! 22:48  |  David 08/04/07
  54.   17 22:51  |  baruch NILI 08/04/07
  55.   Choni Davidowwitz 22:55  |  FLOWER 08/04/07
  56.   Those genetic studies are obsolete 22:56  |  Hal 08/04/07
  57.   #45 finkelstein lies with ease. 23:27  |  Labhras 08/04/07
  58.   Hi-rez DNA testing only available recently, after 2000 00:05  |  Hal 09/04/07
  59.   Jews are not aborigines 00:08  |  Kiwiboy 09/04/07
  60.   to Boycott 00:17  |  David 09/04/07
  61.   Would Haaretz be happy if only Arabs could buy their paper? 00:41  |  Yacov 09/04/07
  62.   Boycott (Post No. 39) 00:45  |  Johnny Weintraub 09/04/07
  63.   The Bible says Jews are aborigines 01:09  |  Hal 09/04/07
  64.   So many advocates of permanent war here 01:12  |  newageblues 09/04/07
  65.   #63 Hal 02:25  |  Boycott 09/04/07
  66.   Who is this Haaretz Editorial? 02:57  |  Efox 09/04/07
  67.   re: Mitch Cohen 03:00  |  Efox 09/04/07
  68.   re: newageblues 03:04  |  Efox 09/04/07
  69.   re: Bongo is back 03:07  |  Efox 09/04/07
  70.   re: Boycott 03:21  |  Efox 09/04/07
  71.   #Hal 63 03:27  |  Kiwiboy 09/04/07
  72.   Israeli Aggression? 03:54  |  Mark Lincoln 09/04/07
  73.   The 21st Century Challange 04:01  |  Mark Lincoln 09/04/07
  74.   Hal #6 04:39  |  StephenConnora 09/04/07
  75.   Amir #8 04:43  |  StephenConnor 09/04/07
  76.   State of Israel - Official Policy 06:02  |  Ah 09/04/07
  77.   Its evil to expel Jewish aborigines from Jewish aboriginal land 07:11  |  Hal 09/04/07
  78.   The DNA study by Nebel et al 2000 is already obsolete 07:46  |  Hal 09/04/07
  79.   #77 Hal, the issue is not their religion 08:33  |  Johnboy 09/04/07
  80.   To #64 08:38  |  paul harris 09/04/07
  81.   Is Hal a plant from Marilyn? 09:09  |  Kiwiboy 09/04/07
  82.   # 66 hey you efox 10:01  |  eric 09/04/07
  83.   # 70 "arabs being nomadic"; do you mean the bedouin? 10:16  |  eric 09/04/07
  84.   # 78 hey there, hal 10:21  |  eric 09/04/07
  85.   Palestinian Brits 10:41  |  Willy 09/04/07
  86.   For Hal # 63 11:13  |  Clickfool 09/04/07
  87.   #79 ERIC POKES HIS HEAD FROM HIS LOG CABIN 11:41  |  paul harris 09/04/07
  88.   #79 johnboy 14:42  |  paul harris 09/04/07
  89.   #85 15:13  |  sony 09/04/07
  90.   No, Paul Harris #80, my beef is with you 15:50  |  newageblues 09/04/07
  91.   Islam followers must withdraw from Judea and Samaria 17:24  |  Joseph .E 09/04/07
  92.   Don`t You Know Altalina??? 17:41  |  Sharif Hafez 09/04/07
  93.   When editor will get some knowledge? 17:50  |  Gene 09/04/07
  94.   Johnboy #79 17:55  |  Gene 09/04/07
  95.   #90 the question is how you deal with PERMANENT STUPIDITY 18:35  |  paul harris 09/04/07
  96.   They`re not moving, #91, get it thru your thick skull 18:40  |  newageblues 09/04/07
  97.   All human beings are related 19:08  |  Marilyn 09/04/07
  98.   No Jews 19:34  |  Miransky 09/04/07
  99.   Newage--yes 19:42  |  Shmuel Ratner 09/04/07
  100.   Hebron is a JEWISH Holy City on JEWISH land 19:44  |  David 09/04/07
  101.   Haaretz Editorial ignores Palestinian Apartheid Murderers 20:24  |  Left wing guy 09/04/07
  102.   The same as Haaretz editorial is lured by the economic opportunit 21:12  |  Joseph E . 09/04/07
  103.   kiwi boy....how can jews be iraqis... 21:30  |  maria 09/04/07
  104.   mark lincoln...don`t compare true.... 21:39  |  maria 09/04/07
  105.   Re Hal 22:18  |  Colin Wright 09/04/07
  106.   #95 David 22:35  |  Miransky 09/04/07
  107.   #90/94 WE DEAL WITH EMOTION AND NOT REALITY 23:27  |  paul harris 09/04/07
  108.   #96, if things were reversed, you`d understand 23:28  |  newageblues 09/04/07
  109.   ISRAEL IS SMALLER THEN THE KRUGER NATIONAL PARK 23:38  |  Gert van staaden 09/04/07
  110.   A more defeatest and despicable editorial I have not read 00:58  |  Chick Corea 10/04/07
  111.   hebron 00:59  |  sabbatai zevi 10/04/07
  112.   #13,Timothy L, what an Educational POST 01:31  |  Hamza 10/04/07
  113.   #98, idea of compromise gets you really upset, doesn`t it? 01:42  |  newageblues 10/04/07
  114.   # 87 what`s the matter paul harris? 03:48  |  eric 10/04/07
  115.   # Maria 05:55  |  Kiwiboy 10/04/07
  116.   #107 Chick Corea thinks its all about antisemitism 06:00  |  Johnboy 10/04/07
  117.   #14 Why is a fishmonger in charge of Jewish security? 06:11  |  Johnboy 10/04/07
  118.   kiwi boy.... 07:03  |  maria 10/04/07
  119.   No Shmuel Ratner, #96, not criticizing you 07:13  |  newageblues 10/04/07
  120.   re: eric 07:19  |  Efox 10/04/07
  121.   re: eric who references by post number 07:26  |  Efox 10/04/07
  122.   It`s interesting how you use the word depraved Mark L 07:55  |  Jacob Blues 10/04/07
  123.   # 120 to the efox 08:06  |  eric 10/04/07
  124.   So sad 08:57  |  Toff 10/04/07
  125.   #114 ERIC PROVIDES WRONG ANSWERS 08:59  |  paul harris 10/04/07
  126.   # 121 oh! efox! you simply amaze me... 09:05  |  eric 10/04/07
  127.   It`s not a house, it`s a settlement 09:21  |  Cherice 10/04/07
  128.   Maria 09:25  |  Kiwiboy 10/04/07
  129.   #126 ERIC PROVES THAT CATS HAVE LONG TAILS 09:27  |  paul harris 10/04/07
  130.   # 72 Mark Lincoln, Fundamentalists 10:05  |  Dutch 10/04/07
  131.   # 125 PAUL HARRIS REWRITES HISTORY! 10:07  |  eric 10/04/07
  132.   HEBRON. THE STRONGEST OLDEST ROOTS TO JUDAISM 12:58  |  HEBRON MUST NOT FALL 11/04/07
 Today Online
Israel rejects list of prisoners Hamas wants freed for Shalit
Responses: 44
Settlers to have 30 days to leave Hebron building voluntarily
Responses: 36
Lawyers for Hezbollah detainees say they deserve POW status
Responses: 41
Amira Hass: Not all Palestinian prisoners are criminals
Responses: 25
Benziman: Bishara's case points to growing Israeli Arab mutiny
Responses: 9


More Headlines
13:01 Settlers to be given 30 days to leave disputed Hebron building voluntarily
12:03 Israel rejects Hamas list of prisoners to be exchanged for Shalit
10:39 Report: Hezbollah says rearming, prepared for summer war with Israel
11:28 Report: IAEA says Iran will take 4-6 years to make nuclear bomb
08:15 Israeli civilian moderately hurt in West Bank drive-by shooting
11:39 Secondary school teachers to continue striking on Thursday
12:52 Fire seriously damages headquarters of J'lem rabbinical courts
08:23 Lawyers for Hezbollah detainees say they deserve POW status
04:54 Poland concerned by Hirchson attendance at Holocaust march
03:24 Holocaust survivors tell Knesset they have been 'trampled' by treasury
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved