Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 10, 2007 Nisan 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:42 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The IDF's lost honor
By Uzi Benziman

On the eve of Pesach, MK Effi Eitam told the nation that he now sleeps a lot better. This occured after he heard Chief of Staff Gabi Ashkenazi tell the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee about how he will make sure that at the end of the next war there will be no doubt over who won. Until then Eitam was worried about the spirit pervading the IDF command, but the briefing by the new chief of staff filled him with optimism: Ashkenazi's language was lucid, he posed clear objectives and he gave his listeners a sense of confidence that he knows what he's doing.

Fighting moods are a bad thing when they come from the chief of staff. During the 1950s, chief of staff Moshe Dayan told prime minister David Ben-Gurion that he preferred commanders who were noble stallions, ones that needed to be restrained when they exhibited excessive enthusiasm to encounter the enemy. Battalion, brigade and division commanders and their subordinates are indeed expected to be soaked in fighting spirit and ready to carry out the missions assigned to them. The members of the general staff, on the other hand, must be much more level-headed in the way they approach the political-security situation.

The Second Lebanon War has left the IDF damaged. The army feels it failed to meet expectations and has since been obsessed with a wish to make amends. A short while after the cease-fire, circles in the IDF began airing assessments that by the following summer (which is closing in) there will be a second round of fighting. The general staff concluded in a series of meetings last November that it was necessary to prepare for an offensive by Syria and Hezbollah in the summer of 2007.

Advertisement

In December 2006, a dispute emerged between the Mossad and military intelligence over Syria's intentions. In February, Brigadier General Yossi Beiditch, head of research at military intelligence, told the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee that the Syrian leader is indeed serious about peace with Israel, on his terms, but is preparing for a confrontation because he does not want to be surprised. Last week, the chief of military intelligence, Major General Amos Yadlin, told the cabinet that Syria, Iran and Hezbollah are preparing for an American assault against Iran in the summer, and that Syria is taking into account that Israel is actively involved, and so Damascus is preparing for all eventualities.

All this talk is dangerous. Israel emerged from the Second Lebanon War bruised, and with an eroded deterrent. It recognizes this and its enemies believe it. The mere image of a country whose wings have been clipped entices Syria, Hezbollah and the Palestinians to challenge it. At the same time, the feeling of stained honor has aroused in the IDF a desire to once more raise the flag of victory and teach the hostile neighbors a lesson they will remember for a long time. There is also a feeling of plain vengeance, and a basic desire to restore to Israel its deterrent. This constellation of considerations and motives feeds a dialogue inside the general staff, which echoes beyond the conference rooms and gives Israel's enemies the impression that it is preparing for war in the coming months - whether this takes place in the Gaza Strip or at the northern border. This situation is sufficient to escalate the tension and begin the motion toward a boiling point.

The politicians were burned in the July-August 2006 conflagration, and it is safe to assume that there will be no rush to go to war, as suggested by the prime minister's statement last week that sought to calm Syrian fears of an Israeli offensive. Nonetheless, the fighting spirit now forming in the IDF - whether against Hamas or Hezbollah - has a great force that can affect the views of the prime minister and his cabinet. The chief of staff will make a serious mistake if he looks at the northern and southern fronts solely through the perspective of weapons. It would not be superfluous to remind him that his real test will be more in preventing war by restoring the deterrent capacity of the IDF, instead of ordering the army's divisions once more into battle.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Urban Kibbutz
The residential sections of agricultural settlements are now considered urban land.
Dirty water
Petrol water pollution has recently become a growing environmental concern.
  1.   HEZB should disappear.- Ir is the condition to prevent a war. 12:12  |  Vittorio 08/04/07
  2.   give the Hezbalah an ultimatem 13:27  |  Eli 08/04/07
  3.   ISRAEL`S DETERRENCE 13:37  |  A.J. MYERS 08/04/07
  4.   To #3 AJ Myers, HaaretzOSLO paper should be last in giving advice 15:02  |  amir 08/04/07
  5.   Benziman, Did You Say Anything About Reservist Training ? 18:25  |  Tod Zuckerman 08/04/07
  6.   IDF not interested in peace 18:52  |  cristina 08/04/07
  7.   Hezbollah needs a Palestinian enemy 19:20  |  Future1 08/04/07
  8.   Ask the US about winning 20:13  |  Marilyn 08/04/07
  9.   lost honor or lost power? 22:54  |  newageblues 08/04/07
  10.   The outcome of Lebanon 2 was adequate 23:44  |  Hal 08/04/07
  11.   To Marilyn 00:30  |  Major R 09/04/07
  12.   Who Would Win? 01:50  |  mike 09/04/07
  13.   Finish`em 04:11  |  Kavkazy 09/04/07
  14.   To all the fools and Haartz writer... 04:20  |  Stright 2 the point 09/04/07
  15.   to #12 mike 05:05  |  Boaz 09/04/07
  16.   Totally sober Major R 06:03  |  Marilyn 09/04/07
  17.   to newage blues 06:50  |  Paul 09/04/07
  18.   To Sober Marilyn 07:06  |  JEH 09/04/07
  19.   IDF LOST HONOR 07:41  |  HENRYK 09/04/07
  20.   IDF lost but not honor 07:43  |  Margarita 09/04/07
  21.   To JEH and Major R 08:21  |  Ivar 09/04/07
  22.   Lost honor 08:26  |  Zach 09/04/07
  23.   LOST HONOR 10:49  |  john 09/04/07
  24.   Stealing land. a lesson for Marilyn 11:15  |  Fairplay 09/04/07
  25.   #18 Canadian Squatter talks 12:07  |  Labhras 09/04/07
  26.   Deterrence 16:00  |  Paul 09/04/07
  27.   IDF WON ! 19:12  |  Hansje 09/04/07
  28.   #25 21:13  |  JEH 09/04/07
  29.   Lost Honor? 21:27  |  P. J. Casey 09/04/07
  30.   War 22:20  |  Ronnie Bell 09/04/07
  31.   Questions for Marilyn & #25 22:48  |  JEH 09/04/07
  32.   to hard headed marilyn 01:28  |  even 10/04/07
  33.   To anyone who responds to Marilyn 02:10  |  Albert Namatjira 10/04/07
  34.   Dera Marilyn 04:45  |  Kapule David Mabuta 10/04/07
  35.   Marilyn :These stupids are warmongers 06:36  |  observe 10/04/07
  36.   Excellent Post #34 07:41  |  JEH 10/04/07
  37.   Marilyn 07:51  |  Steve 10/04/07
  38.   Living on Aborigine land 11:38  |  Albert Namatjira 10/04/07
 Today Online
Shin Bet: Hamas planned massive T.A. Passover bombing
Responses: 89
Suicide bombing masterminds on Hamas list for swap
Responses: 83
Arens: Teddy Kollek sold out the Irgun. And he wasn't alone
Responses: 8
U.S. Conservative rabbis more open to ordination of gays than in Israel
Responses: 2


More Headlines
07:49 Shin Bet: Hamas planned T.A. Passover bombing
10:02 Hamas said demanding bombing masterminds be freed in swap
11:25 Labor MK Pines-Paz presses to have party quit government
05:31 University students launch open-ended strike over tuition
11:33 Study: Conservative rabbis split over ordination of homosexuals
10:28 Bomber blows himself up in Morocco, police kill second suspect
10:32 Secondary school teachers to go on strike beginning Wednesday
08:06 UN genocide exhibit on Rwanda delayed after Turkey objects
02:42 Israelis flood Northern tourist sites, hotels for first time since war
05:36 Schneider doctors sign petition to replace hospital's CEO
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code HAARETZ for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved