Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 10, 2007 Nisan 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 22:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The forgiveness game
By Yoel Marcus

Tony Blair's warning of "further measures" if the kidnapped British seamen were not released immediately reminds me of the Jewish joke about Hershele Ostropoler, who walked into a restaurant and demanded free food. Otherwise, he threatened, he'd do what his father did. The proprietors, quaking in their boots, quickly set the food before him. After the danger passed, they asked him what his father did. Hershele's reply: He went to bed hungry.

The moral of the story is that even the biggest, strongest superpowers have no answer for the primitive form of warfare known as kidnapping that Islamic bullies have added to the menu in their fight against Western civilization. With our experience of brutal kidnappings, who knows better than we how problematic they can be, and how high a price one is forced to pay to bring hostages home, alive or in a box.

In this cruel game, they are on top. The kidnapping of Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev dragged us into a war that ruined our reputation, and we still have no idea whether they are alive and where they are. Not to mention Gilad Shalit, who has been held hostage under our noses for nine months without a letter or a single sign of life.

Advertisement

In this game of horror, the kidnappers have the upper hand, because they know that in the civilization they are out to destroy, human life is valued above all. How did Yitzhak Rabin put it when he agreed to the Jibril Rajoub prisoner exchange deal? "I couldn't take the pressure of the mothers descending on my home and office."

A country with values is at a disadvantage when it comes to kidnapping. Yes, Blair raised his voice and threatened to take firmer action if a solution wasn't found right away. So he threatened. So what? The Iranians countered that the use of force would only complicate matters.

The fact that an angry mob stormed the British Embassy in Tehran, lobbing stones and smoke bombs, hinted that using force might endanger the lives of the navy men and diplomats. Theoretically, Britain could respond in a variety of ways, but in the case of hostages held by people who will stop at nothing, employing force would have been the devil's doing for sure.

The Iranian leadership chose to adopt the stance of the British foreign minister and resolve the problem in quiet negotiations. They decided not to wrangle with Britain over such a trivial affair while embroiled in a major clash over their nuclear program.

Unlike the kidnappings carried out by Hezbollah and terror organizations in Israel, Iran has treated the British naval crew reasonably well. Fourteen days after their capture, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad announced he would release them as a "gift to Britain." By the same token, the opposite could have happened: They might have disappeared for a year or two until Iran's demands were met.

One thing is certain: Within a couple of days or weeks, we will find out the price Great Britain paid for the release of these hostages. Iranians are known for their keen business sense. There is no such thing as a free gift.

Axis-of-evil-type kidnapping is planned with steely reserve on orders from above. The targets are carefully chosen. In February 1979, shortly after Khomeini returned to Iran and the despised Shah fled, the Revolutionary Guards were ordered to take the whole U.S. Embassy hostage.

For 444 days, 52 American diplomats were imprisoned in the compound as angry crowds gathered outside every day, cursing them and hurling stones and garbage. All America watched in shock. Yellow ribbons were tied around trees as an expression of solidarity with the hostages.

President Jimmy Carter, who was hated by the Iranians because of Camp David and for giving asylum to the dying Shah, ordered a military rescue operation. The mission failed after of a slew of ridiculous blunders that called to mind the bumbling cops in the silent movies.

The Iranian hostage crisis ruined Carter's chances for reelection. The "gift" of releasing the diplomats was bestowed on President Ronald Reagan, who coined the term "evil empire," toppled the Soviet Union and became Israel's greatest friend. Since the first Lebanon war, hostage-taking has been used against us as a cruel instrument of war, torturing the families of captured soldiers and crushing the spirit of Israeli peace-seekers. Behind this violence stands Iran, which is not only threatening Israel, but also moderate Arab countries and Europe.

One can only hope that this supposedly humanitarian gesture of "forgiving" Britain will not stop Bush and Blair from persisting in their battle to keep Iran, whose declared goal is the destruction of Israel, from achieving a nuclear capability.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Urban Kibbutz
The residential sections of agricultural settlements are now considered urban land.
Dirty water
Petrol water pollution has recently become a growing environmental concern.
  1.   One advantage 09:40  |  JW 06/04/07
  2.   finally somebody with a reasonable mind... 10:03  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  3.   Reactions to kidnapping 10:14  |  Israel Israeli 06/04/07
  4.   The weapon of the weak 10:20  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/04/07
  5.   Yoel Marcus is completely wrong 10:26  |  Clickfool 06/04/07
  6.   The cost to Britain. 10:55  |  David Nigel Braham 06/04/07
  7.   #4 MORE DRIVEL WHEN JERRY IS ABSENT !! 11:08  |  paul harris 06/04/07
  8.   kidnapping. 11:10  |  mike davis 06/04/07
  9.   For JW # 1 11:10  |  Clickfool 06/04/07
  10.   #4, Dino 11:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 06/04/07
  11.   For David Nigel Braham # 6 11:31  |  Clickfool 06/04/07
  12.   The battle for the title "Mr. SPIN OF THE WORLD" 1/2 11:31  |  WorldGuardian 06/04/07
  13.   Who shall win the title "Mr. SPIN OF THE WORLD" 2/3 11:33  |  WorldGuardian 06/04/07
  14.   THIS IS ALL ABOUT SLIPSHOD AND INCOMPETENT NAVAL OFFICERS 11:41  |  paul harris 06/04/07
  15.   An Eye for an Eye 11:43  |  soldier 06/04/07
  16.   "Mr. SPIN OF THE WORLD" 3/3 - BLAIR? BUSH? OLMERT? 11:51  |  WorldGuardian 06/04/07
  17.   # 7 paul harris 11:56  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/04/07
  18.   clickfool # 9 12:06  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  19.   worldguardian # 13 12:12  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  20.   # 10 Cipora Julianna Kohn 12:17  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/04/07
  21.   #4 Swiss Dino 12:18  |  paul 06/04/07
  22.   scallywag #2 12:22  |  Yonatan 06/04/07
  23.   my, my...sounds like you are frustrated... 12:25  |  samos 06/04/07
  24.   Can somebody explain to me... 12:25  |  Somebody from Europe 06/04/07
  25.   Prisoners 12:26  |  Ralph 06/04/07
  26.   The reasons for the Easter gift 12:32  |  Jonathan S 06/04/07
  27.   #9 Clickfool 12:42  |  Yonatan 06/04/07
  28.   # 21 paul 12:47  |  Swiss (Dino) 06/04/07
  29.   To #19 scallywag 12:58  |  WorldGuardian 06/04/07
  30.   Yoel, you`re 13:09  |  Abby 06/04/07
  31.   Questions that need to be answered 13:18  |  Chris Linthwaite 06/04/07
  32.   yonatan #22 13:23  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  33.   #5 Clickfool 13:30  |  Labhras 06/04/07
  34.   #12 WorldGaurdian Blair blunders. 13:38  |  Labhras 06/04/07
  35.   worldguardian # 29 13:40  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  36.   For Yonatan # 27 13:46  |  Clickfool 06/04/07
  37.   Israel is the source of terror in the ME 14:01  |  American 06/04/07
  38.   Maliciously 14:03  |  Jan Elshout 06/04/07
  39.   Clickfool number 11. 14:52  |  david Nigel Braham 06/04/07
  40.   331 Chris linthwaite - whatever do you mean 15:15  |  carmen 06/04/07
  41.   HERSHELE AND ABU NAWAS ARE THE BEST 15:21  |  indrajaya 06/04/07
  42.   A big price will be paid by being conned by kindness 15:27  |  The Equalizer 06/04/07
  43.   CHANGED TIMES 15:32  |  Brant 06/04/07
  44.   kidnapping 15:46  |  elizabeth 06/04/07
  45.   #15. Right on 15:50  |  John Allen 06/04/07
  46.   #21 Paul 15:54  |  John Allen 06/04/07
  47.   Peace in our Time 16:00  |  Neville Chamberlain 06/04/07
  48.   This sounds like the ignorant rant of an American talk show host 16:00  |  Apartheid 06/04/07
  49.   # 21 Swiss Dino 16:00  |  paul 06/04/07
  50.   #23 samos we know that your are an 16:02  |  John Allen 06/04/07
  51.   Marcus` Guru,wretch Rabin ,soft on kidnappers 16:03  |  Absolute Sweden 06/04/07
  52.   hostage of 52 american diplomats 16:11  |  saul a. readner 06/04/07
  53.   In 1980 Carter lost his reputation in the world of Islam... 16:25  |  Somebody from Europe 06/04/07
  54.   They are not mad You are soldier 16:28  |  John 06/04/07
  55.   Machmoudi Dressed Them Up Like Easter Bunnies... 16:29  |  Yosemite 06/04/07
  56.   The price is obvious and cannot be reduced 17:00  |  Mark Lincoln 06/04/07
  57.   SAMOS 17:02  |  TOBIA 06/04/07
  58.   #36 Clickfool 17:03  |  G 06/04/07
  59.   IRAN CAN DO WHAT HE WANTED TO DO, ALMOST LIKE ISRAEL (ALMOST) 17:05  |  indrajaya 06/04/07
  60.   What many in the west forget 17:09  |  Danite 06/04/07
  61.   racist bulls*** 17:19  |  jj 06/04/07
  62.   No, Its the fear game. 17:26  |  Joel in Albany 06/04/07
  63.   Griboedov 17:29  |  david 06/04/07
  64.   If Olmert were in Blair`s place.. 17:37  |  Tosefta 06/04/07
  65.   # 4 Swiss 17:45  |  Lynn 06/04/07
  66.   Erratum 17:45  |  J 06/04/07
  67.   The American emabassy was seized by a mob reacting to the transfe 17:55  |  Apartheid 06/04/07
  68.   Bush was right all along..... 17:57  |  Carl 06/04/07
  69.   Nice gift! now lets give them one in return 18:46  |  Jason 06/04/07
  70.   Value human lif!? Yea Right! 18:46  |  Guss 06/04/07
  71.   If Olmert were in Blair`s place.. 19:05  |  Tosefta 06/04/07
  72.   Why do you refuse to post my entry? 19:09  |  nacl 06/04/07
  73.   how iran would have reacted if its US /Israeli sailors 19:09  |  sir castic 06/04/07
  74.   Israel legalised kidnapping years ago 19:27  |  Marilyn 06/04/07
  75.   It is Barbary Coast, once again 19:28  |  Benlolo 06/04/07
  76.   to worldguardian 19:34  |  scallywag 06/04/07
  77.   Keystone Cops? 19:35  |  Ben Azai 06/04/07
  78.   No Abby # 30 . You are wrong 19:47  |  Avrum 06/04/07
  79.   to scallywag 19:56  |  david 06/04/07
  80.   30 Abby,add to abu graibh,Israel`s criminality in the OT 19:59  |  sara 06/04/07
  81.   the trade was made...and a deal for silence 20:11  |  the negotiator 06/04/07
  82.   Ahmadinejad`s Easter Egg is rotten 20:12  |  Clickfool 06/04/07
  83.   Iran real Gift. 20:19  |  Akram Zekaria 06/04/07
  84.   Actually, A Surprisingly Good Column 20:21  |  Tod Zuckerman 06/04/07
  85.   # 38 carmen 20:54  |  Lynn 06/04/07
  86.   # 59 apartheid