Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., April 16, 2007 Nisan 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 18:58 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 14:07 05/04/2007
Report: Israeli objections delaying U.S. arms sale to Arab countries
By Haaretz Service

Israeli objections are delaying a major arms-sale package that the Bush administration is planning to offer Saudi Arabia and other Persian Gulf allies to deter Iran, the New York Times reported on Thursday.

Israeli government officials confirmed the report, saying that Israel has pressed the United States not to offer a major weapons deal to its Gulf Arab allies for fear it would damage Israel's military deterrent in the Middle East.

Israeli Defense Minister Amir Peretz raised the matter during a March 11 meeting with U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates, the officials said on condition of anonymity since they were not authorized to discuss the sensitive subject with the press.

Advertisement

While there is no official dollar figure provided for the planned sales, an American defense industry executive said that if the transaction would be performed as planned - including tanks, warships and advanced air defense systems - the deal could run from $5 billion to $10 billion.

According to the report, a series of Israeli officials, including former defense minister Shaul Mofaz, have come to Washington in recent months to argue against parts of the planned sales.

Israel's main concerns lie with the possible handover of precision-guided weapons that would significantly enhance Saudi warplanes' ability to accurately strike targets, officials told the NY Times.

There is less Israeli opposition, however, to possible sales to Gulf countries of several advanced weapons systems that are seen as more defensive in nature. These include advanced Patriot anti-missile batteries as well as new missile-armed coastal warships and a version of the sophisticated Aegis radar system, officials and defense industry executives told the NY Times. One defense industry official said Saudi Arabia was considering buying as many as a dozen of the new ships.

The United States has made few, if any, sales of satellite-guided ordnance to gulf countries, several officials said. Israel has been supplied with such weapons since the 1990s and used them extensively against Hezbollah in the Second Lebanon War.

Several officials in the State Department and the Pentagon told the paper that plans to formally notify Congress about the potential weapons sales had been delayed at least until later this month. After notification, Congress has 30 days to decide whether to block the sales.

Support for maintaining Israel's military superiority remains strong on Capitol Hill, and administration officials are discussing how to allay the concerns, including the possibility of a separate arms package for Israel, the NY Times said.

David Siegel, a spokesman for the Israeli Embassy in Washington, declined to comment "due to sensitivities of issues such as this," he said.

Administration officials told the paper that Israel did not seem intent on using its political clout in Congress to kill the entire planned sale.

"It's not like the Israelis are going to end up with nothing," said a senior administration official, adding "the Israelis understand that it's in our interest and their interest" that the United States try to shore up military systems for Sunni Arab allies. But Israel is also concerned that the Bush administration's ambitions for an American-Israeli-Sunni coalition allied against Iran may never materialize, or that there could be a revolution in Saudi Arabia that would leave the mostly American-made Saudi arsenal in the hands of militant Islamists, the paper said.

"The Israelis believe the government of Saudi Arabia is under a great deal of pressure," said David Schenker, a former Pentagon official who is now a senior fellow on Arab politics at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.

"Osama bin Laden would like to change the Saudi government to what he considers a real Islamist government. So Israel doesn't want them to have this heightened military capability," he told the paper.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Modern-day lepers
The state must turn peoples' fear of the mentally ill into true empathy and a desire to give.
The shekel mountain
Financial stability, high foreign investment, and low inflation have made the shekel soar.
  1.   once more "Is-it-real" meddles in U.S. foreign policy 09:29  |  samos 05/04/07
  2.   When things become more equal...... 10:26  |  Deborah 05/04/07
  3.   The boycott on Iran... 10:36  |  Maureen Ann 05/04/07
  4.   Corrupt Arab Governments 10:38  |  Political 05/04/07
  5.   America cannot continue to pay hard earned cash to the Arabs 10:44  |  Adel 05/04/07
  6.   Iran--Shia is a real threat to Saudies. Israel needs secutity. 10:48  |  Vittorio 05/04/07
  7.   Deaf Ears 10:49  |  wally 05/04/07
  8.   to #1...yes samos...it is real..and has been for 60 years 11:05  |  SLAVO 05/04/07
  9.   To Deborah #2 11:08  |  Stayin Alive 05/04/07
  10.   1: samos, there`s antsemitism because of hate filled 11:34  |  David Teich 05/04/07
  11.   #1 samoosa Yep ISRAEL IS REAL us JEWS too 12:00  |  Ari ben Yisrael 05/04/07
  12.   Saudi statements show GPS bombs are to target Israel, not Iran 12:22  |  Dr. L. Brnd 05/04/07
  13.   NO to arms to the dark forces 12:43  |  Brod 05/04/07
  14.   logical decision and wont cause damage to US economy or jobs 12:56  |  zionist forever 05/04/07
  15.   Keep Those Arabs Barefoot And In The Kitchen 13:23  |  Jimmie Cotter 05/04/07
  16.   IS THIS TODAYS JOKE ?? HOW MANY TRILLIONS HAVE THE ARABS 13:49  |  paul harris 05/04/07
  17.   Well if the US won`t sell them 14:20  |  Chris Linthwaite 05/04/07
  18.   is there anything the israel lobby will not stick her nose in ?? 14:29  |  eugen stummel 05/04/07
  19.   The neocons opened up a can of worms 15:01  |  Oscar Resife 05/04/07
  20.   # 18 Stummel 15:11  |  ChanahS 05/04/07
  21.   look at what happen in iran 15:16  |  paulo2005 05/04/07
  22.   to 2 15:32  |  paulo2005 05/04/07
  23.   Stop being so self-centred. 15:35  |  Zero 05/04/07
  24.   #18 Nope, not when it comes to Israel`s security 15:41  |  * BEN JABO 05/04/07
  25.   maintaining superiority 15:42  |  Jan Elshout 05/04/07
  26.   Chris Lint twat 15:57  |  Sar of David 05/04/07
  27.   12 - Dr.L. Brnd 16:03  |  zionist forever 05/04/07
  28.   Here`s the solution 16:05  |  Travis 05/04/07
  29.   To jews from EU 16:07  |  Christian from EU 05/04/07
  30.   Saudi Arabia @ Israel 16:09  |  Johnf 05/04/07
  31.   Give them money 16:17  |  Mike 05/04/07
  32.   US-MADE satellite-guided ordnance killed UN OBSERVERS in KHIAM 16:18  |  PEACE THE SOLLUTION 05/04/07
  33.   No more weapons to the arab countries 16:21  |  The Barber 05/04/07
  34.   THE U.S. MUST STOP THE ARMS RACE & HELP MAKE PEACE 16:23  |  END CHENEY/BUSH RULE 05/04/07
  35.   #1 Samos 16:25  |  Itsik from Middx 05/04/07
  36.   to #10 David Teich 16:35  |  Jim Botha 05/04/07
  37.   Israeli objection to "Love thy war G`D" 16:41  |  Joseph E . 05/04/07
  38.   Sale to Saudi`s is what`s really Immoral 16:57  |  Mikhail 05/04/07
  39.   Israel`s military deterrent : Get Real Israel!! 17:00  |  Tupac 05/04/07
  40.   Military Edge Must Remain 17:08  |  TMH 05/04/07
  41.   What is here the real game, politics or trade? 17:09  |  H.H.M 05/04/07
  42.   arms to Saudis and allies 17:11  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  43.   AIPAC 17:14  |  W 05/04/07
  44.   The Arab Gov`ts themselves... 17:25  |  Walter 05/04/07
  45.   palestine will be liberated before USA 17:49  |  arab 05/04/07
  46.   Correction....David Teich 17:54  |  Gaza Mo 05/04/07
  47.   US arms sales to Arab countries. 18:04  |  David Nigel Braham 05/04/07
  48.   so long, Israel 18:10  |  margaret 05/04/07
  49.   Arabs Are On Iran`s Side 18:13  |  Yosemite 05/04/07
  50.   answer to number1 18:16  |  a Jew 05/04/07
  51.   Israel, the Jews, and the growing problem in America 18:21  |  American 05/04/07
  52.   Maureen Ann 3 18:22  |  a Jew 05/04/07
  53.   This is not Israel`s business 18:24  |  Irish Sensation 05/04/07
  54.   WHAT`S THE CONCERN IF YOU`RE BAD? 18:24  |  Cool B 05/04/07
  55.   22 Labhras 18:28  |  a Jew 05/04/07
  56.   Stupid Israel strikes again 18:30  |  Marilyn 05/04/07
  57.   who run america ? 18:33  |  mehmet 05/04/07
  58.   THE U.S. MUST STOP THE ARMS RACE & HELP MAKE PEACE 18:47  |  END CHENEY/BUSH RULE 05/04/07
  59.   THE U.S. MUST STOP THE ARMS RACE & HELP MAKE PEACE 2/2 18:47  |  END CHENEY/BUSH RULE 05/04/07
  60.   #47 Irish Sensation 19:01  |  * BEN JABO 05/04/07
  61.   Force will be and stays the Israeli problem 19:14  |  Sharif Hafez 05/04/07
  62.   #34 Jim Botha When did you get USA Citizenship 19:19  |  Joe Moer 05/04/07
  63.   #46 Not EVEN in your wildest WET dream doll! 19:24  |  Ari ben Yisrael 05/04/07
  64.   if israel is sovereign country why listen to america ? 19:28  |  mehmet 05/04/07
  65.   #26 Sar of David 19:35  |  Chris Linthwaite 05/04/07
  66.   #60 Ben Jabo 19:40  |  Chris Linthwaite 05/04/07
  67.   Reasonable request by Israel 19:43  |  Tosefta 05/04/07
  68.   Margaret #48. A Bit of Hypocrisy. 19:50  |  Ambrose 05/04/07
  69.   *Take* weapons from non-peaceful Arabs, do not sell. 20:01  |  Solon 05/04/07
  70.   a Jew - OH Jew! Go Get your pound of flesh 20:04  |  Me 05/04/07
  71.   #55 AJew 20:07  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  72.   tosefta #67 20:09  |  jimmie cotter 05/04/07
  73.   Good deal 20:10  |  tadchase 05/04/07
  74.   Back then in 1989, .... 20:14  |  Sharif Hafez 05/04/07
  75.   # 57 Mehmet 20:26  |  tadchase 05/04/07
  76.   #18 Hey Eugen----"NOPE"!!!! 20:26  |  ballistic 05/04/07
  77.   Saudi Arabia is NOT a US ally 20:38  |  Briton 05/04/07
  78.   #48 dream on maggie 20:45  |  vildechaye 05/04/07
  79.   The Spread of Wahabism 20:58  |  Bruriah Sarah 05/04/07
  80.   U. S. Arms Sales 21:13  |  P. J. Casey 05/04/07
  81.   BULLISTIC 21:14  |  Stash 05/04/07
  82.   #79 Bruhriah Sarah version viii 21:16  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  83.   #77 Briton suggest you cc the bushes 21:26  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  84.   Labhras 21:27  |  a Jew 05/04/07
  85.