Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., April 07, 2007 Nisan 19, 5767 | | Israel Time: 06:50 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
The Palestinian refugees from Iraq
By Danny Rubinstein

Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's call for a regional peace conference with the participation of Israel and the Arab states, made on the eve of the Passover holiday, received a flood of Arab responses. Spokesmen from Saudi Arabia, Egypt and the Palestinian Authority as well as journalists and analysts in the media responded, as could be expected, with suspicion and doubt.

"Olmert is trying to run away from the subject. First and foremost, he must announce that he is accepting the Arab initiative" (a Saudi diplomat); "Olmert is being deceptive and evasive" (Nimmer Hamad, an adviser to the Palestinian chairman); "Olmert is confusing; he is trying to replace full peace with steps toward normalization with the Arab states" (Mustafa Barghouti, Palestinian information minister); "Olmert is trying to digress from the subject" (editorial in Al-Kuds).

"The empty words of a politician in trouble," senior Palestinian officials said. One of them, Jamal Zakut from Gaza, speaking at a conference in Italy, headed by Dr. Janiki Cingoli of Milan, raised the idea of actions on Israel's part. Not in the familiar vein of requests for leniency at the road blocks, freeing prisoners or dismantling outposts, but in a more dramatic and important direction: assistance to the Palestinian refugees in Iraq.

Advertisement

This is a prolonged and complicated case of suffering that reveals the ugly aspects of the Arab regimes. On the eve of the fall of Saddam Hussein, there were some 30,000 Palestinians in Iraq, almost all of them descendants of refugee families who had arrived there in 1948 from Arab villages on the slopes of the Carmel range: Ajazim (Kerem Maharal), Jaba, Umm Zinat and Ein Hud. Officers from the Iraqi army, which held the Samaria zone, demanded at that time that the villagers be recruited. The families of those who were conscripted were allowed to go to Iraq.

The Palestinians in Iraq did not get citizenship and also did not enjoy assistance from the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, but the Iraqi regime allowed them to live in almost total equality.

They did not have the right to hold a passport but were granted a laissez-passer. They were considered loyal to the Baath regime and to Saddam Hussein.

When the incidents and fighting in Iraq grew worse, the refugees became victims of the new reality. They are a weak population without ethnic or tribal backing and they came under attack - particularly from the Shiites but also from others who had suffered under Hussein and wanted to take revenge on his Palestinian loyalists.

They were expelled from their homes and places of work. In the past few years, there have been reports in the Palestinian media almost every week of robberies, arrests, abductions, tortures and murders of the Palestinians in Iraq.

Thousands of them fled, hundreds reached the borders with Jordan and Syria and were put up in tent encampments: the El Hul camp in Syria and the Ruweished camp in Jordan.

Only a few of them were allowed to enter these countries and most of them remained in the camps which have in effect turned into internment camps. The camps received some help from the Red Cross but they did not have organized health or educational services.

Jordan announced that it did not have the strength to deal with the problem. Tens of thousands of Iraqis had come to Jordan in the past few years and that country, like Syria, has been suffering from economic woes and growing inflation.

The refugees appealed to the Arab countries for assistance but did not get it. Only the Palestinian Authority announced it was prepared to absorb them; but there is border control on the part of Israel, making their absorption impossible.

A short while ago, Canada agreed to accept several dozen sick and elderly people from among these refugees. There are at least several hundred people in the camps and according to Zakut's proposal, Israel could allow them to enter the West Bank and be reunited with their families in Samaria.

This step does not have demographic implications since more than 50,000 Palestinians have left the areas in the West Bank under discussion since the outbreak of the intifada.

This is also not a step toward implementation of the right of return; there is not even a hint of this. This is merely a humanitarian step of political importance.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Forgotten exodus
From 1948 to 1956, nearly 80,000 Jews left Egypt, half of them going to Israel.
Theater of the absurd
New York's only Jewish theather is run by quite a provocateur.
  1.   Return Palestine, 10:14  |  JW 05/04/07
  2.   Extend a helping hand. 10:21  |  sg 05/04/07
  3.   Is anyone paying attention? 10:46  |  Yonatan 05/04/07
  4.   To No.1 11:11  |  Hastaroth 05/04/07
  5.   Returning home. 11:13  |  M. Franks-Lhermann 05/04/07
  6.   #2 Good idea but how to hel them? 11:13  |  Hastaroth 05/04/07
  7.   Israel wouldn`t allow Palestinians with American citizenships 11:52  |  Joe 05/04/07
  8.   7# Joe stop talking rubbish 12:25  |  Alon Fisher 05/04/07
  9.   A NEW OLD STORY 12:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 05/04/07
  10.   I just love the blatant hypocrisy here 12:32  |  Marilyn 05/04/07
  11.   Palestinians 12:32  |  Baruch 05/04/07
  12.   Sadly same happened in Kuwait, Liban 12:42  |  Jean Khalil Estephan 05/04/07
  13.   Apartheid prison walls, blah blah blah 12:51  |  PK 05/04/07
  14.   Jean Khalil, Palestinain must stay in Iraq, Lebanon, Kurd forever 13:18  |  Tamir Gaza 05/04/07
  15.   # 7 Joe stop lying 13:20  |  Lynn 05/04/07
  16.   # 12 Americans opening their doors 13:30  |  Lynn 05/04/07
  17.   Jea Khalil, your Leb and Iraqi citizenship is too low class 13:36  |  Tamir Gaza 05/04/07
  18.   Right of return for Jews but not Arabs - discrimination or what? 13:58  |  Hoxa 05/04/07
  19.   #10 I just love Marilyn`s imaginary history 14:09  |  Yonatan 05/04/07
  20.   To Cipora Julianna Kohn 14:21  |  Paleisraeli 05/04/07
  21.   #10 Marilyn. No-one knows n-o-t-h-i-n-g! 14:29  |  Maureen Ann 05/04/07
  22.   #13 PK 14:29  |  Itsik 05/04/07
  23.   She`s right you know. 14:50  |  Zero 05/04/07
  24.   Hypocrisy Nr. 10 14:50  |  Polish DOg 05/04/07
  25.   All Palestinians suffer from THEIR leadership 15:06  |  The Equalizer 05/04/07
  26.   This is WHY a Palestinian state must be formed 15:08  |  Fed Up 05/04/07
  27.   #7 Joe re lynn #15. 15:14  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  28.   #8 Alon Fisher 15:19  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  29.   And #21 Moron-Ann who knows N-O-T-H-I-N-G 15:21  |  Ari ben Yisrael 05/04/07
  30.   All Pal-Arabs should be moved to Iraq 15:26  |  MG 05/04/07
  31.   Only if 15:59  |  Mary 05/04/07
  32.   MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD 16:02  |  B 05/04/07
  33.   Iraqi evil 16:07  |  Sherlock Holmes 05/04/07
  34.   #23 Zero 16:12  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  35.   WB pals don`t want them and their stooge Rubinstein knows it 16:16  |  Absolute Sweden 05/04/07
  36.   Arab countries perpetuate refugees 16:28  |  The Barber 05/04/07
  37.   Yes, we need more Saddam supporters in West Bank 16:44  |  McQueen 05/04/07
  38.   They are now Iraqis, occupying stolen Jewish property 16:46  |  Jake 05/04/07
  39.   #23 zero. Yup, it is obvious why you like the 16:46  |  John Allen 05/04/07
  40.   #25-- Cudos, well said and thanks 16:48  |  John Allen 05/04/07
  41.   Joe Ramallah, `Palestinian refugees` OCCUPY Jewish property 16:52  |  Jake 05/04/07
  42.   Misleading article in respect to their former status in Iraq 16:52  |  Chick Corea 05/04/07
  43.   to Mauree Ann 16:52  |  david 05/04/07
  44.   24#MARILYN BLAMES ISRAEL FOR HER BLOCKED NOSE 16:57  |  alonitzafoni 05/04/07
  45.   #16 Lynn,s small burb. 16:59  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  46.   #20 Hey, Paleisraeli, some corrections! 17:04  |  ballistic 05/04/07
  47.   TO ALL AUSSIE ISRAEL BASHERS 17:05  |  alonitzafoni 05/04/07
  48.   #21 Maureen Ann 17:09  |  Marilyn 05/04/07
  49.   If you helped a snake... 17:12  |  Walter 05/04/07
  50.   18 institutionalised discrimination against Bedioun and Palestin 17:26  |  17 05/04/07
  51.   Palestinian refugees from Iraq should be absorbed by Israel 17:36  |  deborah 05/04/07
  52.   Similarities between history of jews & Palestinains. 17:46  |  Rami 05/04/07
  53.   #20Paleisraeli 17:53  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  54.   to Maureen Ann#21 18:02  |  Ilya 05/04/07
  55.   What other Arabs did to the Pal`s in `48 continues 18:03  |  Jason 05/04/07
  56.   give the Palestinians their land back 18:16  |  margaret 05/04/07
  57.   26#MAUREEN & MARILYN FIGHTING OVER MUSLIM BOYFRIENDS 18:16  |  alonitzafoni 05/04/07
  58.   Palestine? 18:21  |  Akiva 05/04/07
  59.   Gee you guys are touchy 18:23  |  Marilyn 05/04/07
  60.   # 10 18:27  |  Akiva 05/04/07
  61.   #33 FAKE Ballistic fails acting test again 18:35  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  62.   #26, various corrections to the corrector 18:36  |  newageblues 05/04/07
  63.   Bad Guys in Charge 18:38  |  DIP 05/04/07
  64.   #40 These refugees are Iraq`s responsibility 18:48  |  Bob 05/04/07
  65.   to marilyn 18:48  |  david 05/04/07
  66.   ARABS ABUSE PAL REFUGEES 18:54  |  alonitzafoni 05/04/07
  67.   To Zero 18:56  |  david 05/04/07
  68.   Palestinians refugees 19:00  |  Gerard 05/04/07
  69.   to labhras 19:11  |  David 05/04/07
  70.   to #41 and 43 19:11  |  Ilya 05/04/07
  71.   Great idea, should be expanded 19:12  |  Tosefta 05/04/07
  72.   # 54, Marilyn`s hypocracy 19:14  |  Bob 05/04/07
  73.   to newageblues 19:17  |  david 05/04/07
  74.   60 newageblues rewrites history 19:22  |  Bob 05/04/07
  75.   to Gerard from Francanistan 19:22  |  david 05/04/07
  76.   67 Gerards logical fallacy 19:26  |  Bob 05/04/07
  77.   #34 John Allen re #23 Zero 19:26  |  Labhras 05/04/07
  78.   to all Australians settlers 19:30  |  david 05/04/07
  79.   Massada2000 19:35  |  DIP 05/04/07
  80.   #20 FALSE BALLISTIC 19:35  |  ballistic 05/04/07
  81.   #61 Hey Labhras; re fake ballistic 19:39  |  ballistic 05/04/07
  82.   alonitzafoni@47 - calm down please 19:57  |  Aliza 05/04/07
  83.   #62 newageblues - You have a lot of reading to do 19:59  |  Chick Corea 05/04/07
  84.   to ballisitc 20:01  |  daivd 05/04/07
  85.   Olmert stands out - about 2 cm high 20:07  |  Mark Lincoln 05/04/07
  86.   Tosefta # 71 I Don`t Think That Expansion Is Practical 20:12  |