Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., March 30, 2007 Nisan 11, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:21 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Former justice minister Haim Ramon appearing in Tel Aviv District Court for his sentencing hearing on Thursday. (Archives)
Last update - 21:31 29/03/2007
Complainant in Ramon case to donate compensation money to charity
By Nir Hasson, Haaretz Correspondent

The woman whose complaint led to the conviction of former justice minister Haim Ramon for assault said on Thursday she would donate her compensation money to a women's rights organization.

"I think the trial's message has been conveyed to women in the most effective way: It is a woman's right to be in control of her body at all times, even if [the person harassing her is] a powerful person with connections," she said.

"I've moved on in my life. I haven't dealt with the verdict at all and as far as I'm concerned that chapter in my life ended when the court ruled I was telling the truth," she added.

Advertisement

Earlier on Thursday, State Prosecution said it was considering an appeal of the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court ruling Thursday that Ramon was not guilty of moral turpitude.

The decision means Ramon can remain in the Knesset and even resume serving as a government minister.

Attorney General Menachem Mazuz will host deliberations on the issue soon.

The court upheld Ramon's indecent assault conviction Thursday morning, sentencing him to 120 hours of community service and ordered him to pay the victim NIS 15,000 in compensation.

The Kadima MK was convicted in January for kissing a female soldier against her will.

Meanwhile, Justice Minister Daniel Friedmann said Thursday that he is "pleased that Haim Ramon can resume political activity."

The prosecution had asked for a suspended jail sentence for Ramon, while the defense had asked for the court to overturn the former justice minister's conviction and sentence him to community service.

The three-judge panel of Hayota Kohan, Daniel Beeri and Daniela Sahrizali ruled that "there is no doubt that there are substantial considerations in the defendant's favor. He is a known Israeli public figure."

"For many years, he played many public roles, as a Member of Knesset and as a minister," wrote the judges. "His public service is to his credit, and was taken into consideration when we decided his fate."

"We were not blind to the distress and pain that were the defendant's fate given the loss of his public career," added the judges.

The court ruled that the incident was isolated and "does not demonstrate that we are dealing with a sex offender or someone has a pattern of criminal behavior."

"The act itself is not among the more severe forms of this crime, and it is our impression that it was an unplanned event. We are certain that [Ramon] learned his lesson, and that the defendant will be extra precautious from now on."

Judges: All the defense tactics were aimed at slander

The judges added that they were aware of the heavy price paid by Ramon following the conviction, yet they criticized his statement of regret, maintaining that it did not coincide with the way he acted during the trial. "All the defense tactics were directed against the complainant, slandering her and crushing her dignity," they said.

"And in general, bringing three false testimonies added to the fire. Up until now, we still hear echoes of the defendant shouting at the complainant- 'you're a liar.' How can that utterance hold with remorse and internalization? Nice words will not clean the act."

However, the judges ruled that it was not a crime of moral turpitude. "This isolated and unplanned act by the defendant was carried out after a conversation that was made in poor taste, in an apathetic manner. The act lasted 2-3 seconds, and stopped immediately."

"The conviction was upheld, as opposed to recommendations from the government psychological evaluations services, and the ruling that the crime was not one of moral turpitude, is the correct balance between the different interests, and provides a fitting expression of the various aspects that arose in this case," the judges wrote.

In the conclusion of the ruling, the judges wrote that Ramon's punishment is his conviction, and therefore his penalty must be minimal, so that any future harm caused will be directly proportional to the nature of the crime and its circumstances.

Prosecution, defense pleased with ruling

Following the ruling, Ramon spoke to journalists and said. "I apologize for bothering you; I'm confident we won't meet here again."

The prosecution expressed satisfaction that the conviction was upheld. Rafi Levy, a senior prosecutor in the Tel Aviv district, said "the decision to uphold the conviction sends an explicit and bold message - a woman's right over her body is certain and clear. Any act carried out by force is forbidden and requires a conviction. Even if the complainant chose to hug the defendant, it is still her right not to have her body harmed."

Ramon's attorney Dan Sheinman said the conviction will not stop Ramon's political career. "The ruling that the crime was not one of moral turpitude and the punishment of only community service, creates a situation in which there are no obstacles to [Ramon] continuing as an MK or minister."

Sheinman did not comment on whether Ramon would appeal the court's ruling.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Top tourist attraction
In 2006, Jerusalem's Biblical Zoo in was Israel's top tourist site for the second straight time.
A desk, a chair, a book
It shouldn't be complicated for the Israeli school system to teach the children to read.
  1.   Small fry compared to Katsav 06:44  |  SJ 29/03/07
  2.   Ramon 08:46  |  ronka 29/03/07
  3.   Make examples of them 08:48  |  Liat 29/03/07
  4.   Katzav and Ramon and all the rest 09:28  |  Big Al 29/03/07
  5.   Ramon 09:57  |  Esther 29/03/07
  6.   RAMON SUPPORTED SHARON`S DEPORTATION GUSH QATIF.MUST BE CONVICTED 10:01  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 29/03/07
  7.   ramon 10:25  |  joe 29/03/07
  8.   Save political person versus anti ?Bousaglio vs Bousaglio. 10:38  |  H.H.M 29/03/07
  9.   ramon`s conviction 10:43  |  xxx 29/03/07
  10.   The Kissing MK 10:45  |  US CITIZEN 29/03/07
  11.   To US CITIZEN 10:54  |  Big Al 29/03/07
  12.   Joe #7 11:02  |  S 29/03/07
  13.   felony? 11:38  |  A.M. 29/03/07
  14.   And what of DeLay? 11:39  |  Ilan 29/03/07
  15.   whats in a kiss? 12:25  |  neutral-man 29/03/07
  16.   to #10 and 11: what if it was yr wife being hit on? 12:28  |  neutral-man 29/03/07
  17.   think about morale if he gets off easy... 12:29  |  neutral-man 29/03/07
  18.   Israel, the true banana republic 12:34  |  Scott M. 29/03/07
  19.   Why is Katsav different from Ramon? 13:17  |  Ilan 29/03/07
  20.   #18 What about Iran,Iraq,Saudi Arabia etc 13:30  |  Hastaroth 29/03/07
  21.   Ms A - run, run far away 14:00  |  Alex 29/03/07
  22.   ilan 14:07  |  A.M. 29/03/07
  23.   AM: to people who care about women.... 14:19  |  Ilan 29/03/07
  24.   moral turpitude 14:37  |  Ralph 29/03/07
  25.   #23 15:20  |  S 29/03/07
  26.   Moral Turpitude?? 15:45  |  Lila 29/03/07
  27.   too much compensation 16:42  |  john 29/03/07
  28.   #19 Ilan 17:03  |  J. B. 29/03/07
  29.   # 18 Scott M. 17:10  |  J. B. 29/03/07
  30.   Technical news 17:27  |  Citizen 29/03/07
  31.   Hounding Ramon again 19:51  |  Esther 29/03/07
  32.   NIS 15,000? 20:18  |  Chazer Zakhar 29/03/07
  33.   Ramon should Joint his corrupt Buddies in Kadima 21:14  |  Norman 29/03/07
  34.   Decorum please 22:16  |  Esther 29/03/07
  35.   DONATION 06:44  |  colin 30/03/07
  36.   RAMON`S CONVICTION 09:08  |  XXX 30/03/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Muslim atrocities and victims, our silence
Responses: 11
Israel must talk with those who do not want to annihilate it
Responses: 1
Yoel Marcus: Ehud Barak is better than Netanyahu
Responses: 1
2 Palestinians arrested for selling Hebron house to Jews
Responses: 32
U.K. gov't worried by growing anti-Semitism on campuses
Responses: 17
Olmert seeks talks with Saudis, Arab moderates
Responses: 26
Rosner's Domain
* The final four of the moderates
* The emerging inter- marriage consensus
* Will the prospective Middle East envoys please stand up?
* Poll: Was Rice's trip to the Middle East a big success?


More Headlines
09:05 Olmert seeks talks with Saudis, moderate Arab states
10:22 Mossad chief urged IDF to delay reaction after soldiers abducted
10:33 Captors reportedly step back from deal on Shalit's release
10:20 Jordan, PA arrest 2 Palestinians for selling Hebron house to Jews
10:19 IDF widows organization blacklisted minority members
05:00 U.K. gov't worried by growing anti-Semitism on campuses
08:49 Sources: Haim Ramon will return to cabinet if Olmert asks
10:42 Security guard killed in Holon supermarket robbery
06:10 IDF: Protecting Gaza envelope from Qassams will cost NIS 1b
10:33 Report: Peres calls for direct talks between Israel and Arabs
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Skin Care Products
Beauty and skin care from the Dead Sea. Coupon code ?HAARETZ? for 10% off!
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved