Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., April 10, 2007 Nisan 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 21:22 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
What are we waiting for?
By Zalman Shapira

At the Madrid Conference in January, senior government officials from the Arab world got up one after the other and expressed their amazement: What has happened to Israel? For the first time in the history of the conflict, not only Egypt and Jordan but the entire Arab League is proposing peace, but Israel is turning its back.

Has something changed in the Arab world? Have the Arabs really changed? Nobody has a precise answer. In effect, we can reasonably assume that to the Arabs we are still a foreign implant in the region. It is not the Arabs who have changed, but the circumstances.

A new enemy is confronting the Arab elite, even more frightening and dangerous than Israel. Radical Islam threatens not only the public survival of the elite, but its physical survival as well. Ostensibly the military-civil establishment is still in control, with the support of the intellectual elite, but the masses are already captivated by radical Islam.

Advertisement

All the external signs warn that the Middle East is facing a tremendous geopolitical change. The seed of the disaster of radical Islam has already been planted in its womb. The fetus is gradually developing. Nobody knows the date of birth, since the laws of nature do not apply to the Middle East, but when it takes place, it will bring about a fundamental change.

Every society needs an ethos to survive properly. With the help of the ethos the elite maintains its control over society. The nationalist ethos was short-lived, almost a passing episode in the history of the Arab world, and it is gradually disappearing. The ethos of Islam is coming back into power. When the ethos changes, so do the elites. At the end of the era of Mubarak, Assad and the other secular rulers, the victory of Islam will be unavoidable, either through elections or through a popular Iran-style revolution.

That is the reason for the Arab elite's desperate cry for peace. It is also the reason for the Saudi initiative and for the willingness of the Arab League for a normalization with Israel. The Arab elite is convinced - that was my impression from discussions in Madrid - that Israel Defense Forces activities in the territories are causing unrest among the masses. Arab satellite television, which broadcasts from every corner of the territories, is bringing the victims of the intifada into every home in the Arab world. This unrest is fertile ground for the growth of radical Islam.

According to the Arab elite, Iran is exploiting this unrest to extend its influence in the region. Only an end to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict in the Middle East is likely to stop the progress of this Shi'ite country and prevent it from becoming a regional superpower.

The power of the State of Israel in the Middle East is limited. It cannot stop the domination of Islam, but it must prepare for its advent. Israel's national interest requires determining the borders of the country and getting them recognized by the Muslim world before the Islamic storm floods the region. Only legitimate borders will constitute an impenetrable obstacle to radical Islam.

To create legitimate borders Israel needs a partner. In the North the partner is Syria, and negotiations should be conducted only with that country. The obstacle on the way to negotiations with Syria is not the Bush administration, but the weak government of Olmert, which is fighting for political survival. When it comes to the Palestinians the situation is more complex. Israel's only partner, the representative of Palestinian nationalism, Fatah, is out of power. Hamas, which represents radical Islam, is not a partner for setting the final borders due to its refusal to recognize Israel.

The solution is to conduct negotiations with the Arab League, a legitimate and supra-state body. The Arab countries will help to reach diplomatic arrangements and to make peace in the Middle East because the Arab elite believes an end to the conflict will contribute to stopping radical Islam and checking Iranian influence in the region. In all Israel's 59 years there has not been such a favorable diplomatic atmosphere for ending the conflict. This is a final historic opportunity before the Islamic storm sweeps away the last vestiges of moderation in the Middle East.

The writer is a political consultant.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Urban Kibbutz
The residential sections of agricultural settlements are now considered urban land.
Dirty water
Petrol water pollution has recently become a growing environmental concern.
  1.   "the victory of Islam will be unavoidable" 10:32  |  Judith, Haifa 29/03/07
  2.   A nice try but history didn`t stop with the birth of Israel 10:40  |  Joe 29/03/07
  3.   Arabs awash with fear 10:43  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  4.   Sorry Joe, lost me on this one.... 10:52  |  Tuvia 29/03/07
  5.   "Television broadcasts from every corner of the territories." 11:14  |  Maureen Ann 29/03/07
  6.   #1, Judith 11:16  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 29/03/07
  7.   Star of David 11:20  |  Marilyn 29/03/07
  8.   if islam victory is a matter of time then don`t give up anything 11:29  |  joe 29/03/07
  9.   Sorry Marilyn 11:33  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  10.   Where is Daniel Leopold when you need him? 11:40  |  Johnboy 29/03/07
  11.   5#maureen anne 11:50  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  12.   9#Marilyn is an angry,fustrated & delusional individual 12:06  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  13.   Arab peace plan is plan for Israel`s suicide 12:19  |  Yacov 29/03/07
  14.   The Arabs have not changed 12:26  |  Michael 29/03/07
  15.   stupid article 12:29  |  American 29/03/07
  16.   Cipora hi! 12:31  |  Judith 29/03/07
  17.   not that simple 12:32  |  analyst 2 29/03/07
  18.   2 joe,what you say is true 12:42  |  lakshmi 29/03/07
  19.   Hi lakshmi 12:53  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  20.   # 12 12:56  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  21.   Is Europe feeling the heat? 12:56  |  Francis 29/03/07
  22.   analyst 2 - it is that simple 13:02  |  Judith, Haifa 29/03/07
  23.   Marilyn 13:03  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  24.   lakshmi 13:09  |  pundit 29/03/07
  25.   #11 you are wrong on one thing Alon 13:11  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  26.   lakshmi you must have dengue fever 13:12  |  pundit 29/03/07
  27.   Shapira and the Arab League 13:16  |  David Teich 29/03/07
  28.   Islamic storm 13:27  |  sandra chitayat 29/03/07
  29.   the Arabs are waiting for 13:30  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  30.   24 pundit,not interference,but moral responsibility 13:33  |  lakshmi 29/03/07
  31.   10johnboy,hubris is the right word,add racism and moral turpitude 13:43  |  vijaya 29/03/07
  32.   Lakshmi you are indeed lacking 13:46  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  33.   30# 13:57  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  34.   # 5 MaureenAnn...world is not stupid,dearie 14:00  |  The Equalizer 29/03/07
  35.   I agree, the time has come... 14:01  |  whomever 29/03/07
  36.   The arab world is starting to understand... 14:03  |  Edith 29/03/07
  37.   Judith and Cipora... 14:04  |  Maimon 29/03/07
  38.   25# you will have too answer that one nerys 14:11  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  39.   The Job of the Arab League 14:14  |  yaakov sullivan 29/03/07
  40.   A great Saudi offer 14:16  |  Tosefta 29/03/07
  41.   The so-called refugee problem 14:19  |  Tosefta 29/03/07
  42.   haaretz what are these Indian Israel bashers posting here for? 14:20  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  43.   What didn`t change 14:21  |  Gee 29/03/07
  44.   lakshmi :"the pals have very little representation" 14:27  |  pundit 29/03/07
  45.   What are we waiting for? 14:29  |  Ralph 29/03/07
  46.   lakshmi the pakistanis and the pals are not dissimilar 14:31  |  pundit 29/03/07
  47.   Hello lakshmi & vijaya 14:34  |  angry sikh :( 29/03/07
  48.   Nearly all the cards have been dealt 14:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 29/03/07
  49.   lakshmi why would we hindu peoples 14:37  |  pundit 29/03/07
  50.   ali tosefta "saudi plan is an opening bid" 14:41  |  absum 29/03/07
  51.   ali tosefta "saudi plan is an opening bid" 14:41  |  absum 29/03/07
  52.   Palestine is becoming an irritation to the Arabs. 14:46  |  Akram Zekaria 29/03/07
  53.   To lakshmi 14:46  |  an indian-american 29/03/07
  54.   46#Pundit 14:46  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  55.   Waiting? 14:49  |  Mark Lincoln 29/03/07
  56.   INDIAN SECURITY FORCES TORTURE KASHMIRI REBELS!!! 14:49  |  alonitzafoni 29/03/07
  57.   20#Nerys 14:57  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  58.   39# The Irish identification with palestine 15:10  |  Alon Fisher 29/03/07
  59.   Test of true intent of Arab `peace`...... 15:11  |  Jeff 29/03/07
  60.   #39 sullivan and the FREEDOM OF THE HUMAN SPIRIT 15:16  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  61.   Killing Israel softly with Arab peace-terms 15:17  |  Alicia 29/03/07
  62.   How will borders stop radical Islam? 15:20  |  McQueen 29/03/07
  63.   Why do you hate arabs and love Germans? 15:24  |  Marilyn 29/03/07
  64.   #41 Tosefta - now the Arabs have made you their spokesman? 15:25  |  McQueen 29/03/07
  65.   Zalman Shapira, this is a very thoughtful assessment. 15:26  |  Abu Moossa 29/03/07
  66.   Do you really think your intended audience will take their greedy 15:26  |  Apartheid 29/03/07
  67.   # The article`s major error 15:29  |  Bob 29/03/07
  68.   Survival against Islamic Ego and Arab Greed 15:29  |  B 29/03/07
  69.   #45 Ralph, definitely Soldier Shalit shouldbe free... 15:31  |  Hamza 29/03/07
  70.   Arabs dont offer peace. They offer war with words instead of gun 15:31  |  David 29/03/07
  71.   Beware, we know how Israel responds to the hand of peace 15:35  |  Ibrahim 29/03/07
  72.   Dear indians.... 15:35  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  73.   Maureen Ann the White occupier/settler, still did not answer .... 15:37  |  Chanan 29/03/07
  74.   lakshmi #18, 30 have you already solved the Kashmir issue? 15:40  |  Chanan 29/03/07
  75.   Then negotiate not with "Arabs" but their changing circumstances! 15:45  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  76.   "Desperate Arab cry for peace" 15:50  |  Charlie Abzug 29/03/07
  77.   lakshmi you used to be a peaceful Hindu, why then did you convert 15:52  |  Chanan 29/03/07
  78.   War is inevitable in Gaza....do it soon. 16:00  |  The Equalizer 29/03/07
  79.   Hi, hi,We couldn`t ask for better enemies than such foolish Jews! 16:00  |  Jalal 29/03/07
  80.   Marilyn 59# 16:03  |  Nerys 29/03/07
  81.   I`m here Johnboy ready to debate mate [1] 16:08  |  Daniel Leopold 29/03/07
  82.   This article is proof that Arabs need Peace more than Israel does 16:10  |  Chanan 29/03/07
  83.   McQueen on Tosefta #60 16:10  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/03/07
  84.   Fear and submission in the Middle East 16:13  |  Pilly 29/03/07
  85.   #47 Akram Zekaria 16:18  |  Johnboy 29/03/07
  86.