Subscribe to Print Edition | Sat., March 31, 2007 Nisan 12, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:17 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Back to the spirit of Sebastia
By Israel Harel

Thirty-three years ago on Passover eve the effort to establish a foothold in Sebastia began. The media and the government sowed fear and claimed that a putsch was afoot. A generation passed and we live in a democratic country, much more democratic than it was in 1974. If there is a threat to democracy after the moderate, responsible and dignified response of the orange camp to the unfortunate and infuriating uprooting from Gush Katif and northern Samaria - and in the long term it exists - it will not come from the settlers' camp.

Sebastia started at a time of national gloom and despair that afflicted the public after the Yom Kippur War. Even though the war ended with an unprecedented victory, there were some who felt, as many feel after the Second Lebanon War, that there is an existential threat to the state. But while most individuals and movements focused on deepening the despair, one group, Gush Emunim, stood up and declared that the war actually proved how strong the country and its people are.

This group stated that the main reasons for the despair were psychological and not essential. To cure the systems of national shell shock (which in many respects continues to this day) Gush Emunim chose an optimistic course. The only resource available to it was an enthusiastic core of people who were willing to enlist "in the aid of the people": settling in the heart of the Land of Israel. This is the means, they felt, to restore the country's confidence in the justness of its ways and in the IDF. The settlement effort, after all, had always been the jewel in the crown of Zionism.

Advertisement

However, to denigrate the process in the public's eyes, it had to be described as a revolt. The media led the assault and did not merely collaborate with the government in leading the spin. One of the main sources of the motivation, determination and adherence to the cause of the activists of those days, and of the youth of Gush Katif, Amona and Homesh today, is the anger against the unrestrained distortion of their pure intentions.

The initiators of the return to Homesh feel that a return to it will correct, if only slightly, the Zionist judgment, as well as the strategic error in uprooting settlement blocs. In their opinion, such a correction will help raise national morale which is not at a low because of the failure of the disengagement, the failure in Lebanon and the corruption in the government and police leadership.

Even if this is a naive thought, it should not be mocked. Only dreamers and the determined bring about a turning point at historic junctures. Not the cynics, not the ones who protect the citrons and raise them up, and certainly not those entering the political fray out of a lust for power or financial gain.

Will Homesh be the second Sebastia and power a significant national endeavor? It depends on the core group, its supporters (most of whom remained at home this week) and the government's actions. But more than anything else, success is dependent on public support.

In 1974, most of the public supported the Sebastia settlers, even though the media and the government described the settlers as enemies of Israel. The popular support and not the episodic reasons that opponents of the settlement enterprise still cling to prompted Yitzhak Rabin to agree, with clenched teeth, to the Kadum compromise.

It seems that today as well most of the public, even if it is not convinced that the settlement is the answer to the government's malaise and the people's weakness, is with this innocent and devoted youth. This support, which the shapers of the "right opinions" will do everything to eliminate, should be taken into account in the next attempts to gain a foothold in Homesh. It is important to note. Only after eight attempts that ended in despair and continued for an entire year did the government have to say to itself: "My children have defeated me."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Citizen K
I've thought about it and this mutation known as an Israeli Arab has to become extinct.
A day in the dunes
A full day of flowers, honey, cheese, and gorgeous lunar landscapes.
  1.   the settlers are the heros of israel 09:59  |  kiryat sefer 29/03/07
  2.   WHAT DEMOCRAZY??????????????? 10:03  |  VOICE of MOSHIACH))) 29/03/07
  3.   supposing there is peace with the arabs 10:07  |  gideonsway 29/03/07
  4.   israel lives on the coast of the levant 10:10  |  gideonsway 29/03/07
  5.   Harel, one more literary stone in collective memory monument? 10:12  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  6.   the arabs will try various tactics to make us retreat 10:16  |  gideonsway 29/03/07
  7.   THIS IS THE POWER AND STRENGTH OF ISRAEL 10:38  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  8.   #5 MOGUS AND THE ILLUSORY STATE 10:41  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  9.   #1, kiryat sefer. Good opportunity to have outsider`s look at IDF 10:55  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  10.   Arabs continue to rue lost opprotunities - belatedly as usual. 11:03  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  11.   #10 Star of David......wrong CHAVER!! 11:31  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  12.   #8, paul harris. Definitions of democracy? "waffling"?... 11:41  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  13.   #11 Ari Ibni 11:47  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  14.   is this really Harel??? 12:19  |  izzy d 29/03/07
  15.   Harel himself has a settler mentality 12:19  |  KA 29/03/07
  16.   #13 Magen (LOL)David! 12:22  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  17.   the settlers have succeeded in making Israel 12:24  |  Khalid 29/03/07
  18.   Settlers should be paid a one way ticket 12:40  |  Ariel 29/03/07
  19.   whay of our future relationship with the arab world 12:40  |  gideonsway 29/03/07
  20.   #16 Ari yedidi 12:40  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  21.   #17 DREAM ON Khalid 12:43  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  22.   we in israel want a jewish state 13:02  |  gideonsway 29/03/07
  23.   israel should try and double the size of the big settlements 13:04  |  kiryat sefer 29/03/07
  24.   the arab world have tried everything to dislodge us 13:23  |  kiryat sefer 29/03/07
  25.   # 22 On the Jewish State 13:42  |  Lynn 29/03/07
  26.   Settlers and Palestinians want one-state solution 13:57  |  Rocky 29/03/07
  27.   #11 ARI BEN ISRAEL, yes my we are not greedy 14:09  |  Solomon 29/03/07
  28.   Pattern: NAtional disasters followed by messianisn , then bust 14:10  |  Tosefta 29/03/07
  29.   #9 zmorgus. How right you are 14:18  |  Arik 29/03/07
  30.   #24, kiryat sefer. It`s simpler than Gordian knot 14:20  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  31.   ali tosefta no messianism here 14:21  |  absum 29/03/07
  32.   "Jewel in the Crown" Indeed! 14:26  |  Yaakov Sullivan 29/03/07
  33.   #28 Tosefta way too cute 14:31  |  Star of David 29/03/07
  34.   Meitave, we can wait 14:32  |  Khalid 29/03/07
  35.   Olmert and democraty 14:36  |  Ralph 29/03/07
  36.   What he (Y A) always wanted will happen, thanks to thee 14:36  |  Abu the Filistine 29/03/07
  37.   #26 you`re right, it will be one state eventually 14:42  |  Oliver 29/03/07
  38.   zmogus schoolboy word games are for schoolboys 14:45  |  kiryat sefer 29/03/07
  39.   SETTLERS THREAT TO JIHAD AND BASELESS HATRED 15:06  |  B 29/03/07
  40.   re #1 Most motivated? or......... 15:09  |  T A Sheppard 29/03/07
  41.   Arab Apartheid is threat to democracy 15:12  |  Yacov 29/03/07
  42.   Religion vs. reality (Star of David #33) 15:13  |  Tosefta 29/03/07
  43.   Israel Harel , Try facing reality 15:40  |  Dutch 29/03/07
  44.   Pre-Inquisition dreams - Post-Enlightenment Realism 15:44  |  DIP 29/03/07
  45.   Heroism defeats terrorism 15:47  |  Anonymous 29/03/07
  46.   #37. I`m Just like you TA Sheppard.... 16:04  |  Jose 29/03/07
  47.   Tosefta 16:29  |  ODP 29/03/07
  48.   #35, kiryat sefer. Even a schoolboy would have understood it 16:33  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  49.   #18 ARIEL NEEDS TO DEFINE CRIMINAL ACTS 16:59  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  50.   #41 DORIS IUS BORING US TO DEATH WITH HER FALSE MANTRAS. 17:01  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  51.   Israel Harel, Their futures lie down the road 17:02  |  Dutch 29/03/07
  52.   WHERE`S CLICKY!!! 17:06  |  io 29/03/07
  53.   WHERE`S CLICKY!!! 17:06  |  io 29/03/07
  54.   #45. Zmogus Seems to me that ecah time .... 17:08  |  Arik 29/03/07
  55.   Ari Ben Yisrael 17:17  |  Choni Davidowitz 29/03/07
  56.   Do the kids say that? (ODP #45) 17:23  |  Tosefta 29/03/07
  57.   zmogus the point is this 17:26  |  kiryat sefer 29/03/07
  58.   #47 kriminal acts 17:37  |  ariel 29/03/07
  59.   #48 open your eyes 17:45  |  Ralph is back 29/03/07
  60.   the fight for israel`s existence 17:59  |  michael 29/03/07
  61.   The new Jews 18:19  |  christoph 29/03/07
  62.   #52/3 io...............WHO CARES!! 18:42  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  63.   #55 Choni, yes you do that. Pass on that message 18:47  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  64.   #57, kiryat sefer 19:07  |  zmogus 29/03/07
  65.   #Christoph, "the Weapons" 19:44  |  Hamza 29/03/07
  66.   #41 ALL apartheid is a threat! 19:48  |  T A Sheppard 29/03/07
  67.   Corruption of the youth 19:56  |  Norman Levitt 29/03/07
  68.   Ari Ben Yisrael 20:00  |  Choni Davidowitz 29/03/07
  69.   Hamza 20:33  |  christoph 29/03/07
  70.   Misled youth 21:27  |  Esther 29/03/07
  71.   Israel is settled and settlers have become dinosaurs. 21:36  |  Yossi Cronenberg 29/03/07
  72.   Israel is settled and settlers have become dinosaurs. 21:36  |  Yossi Cronenberg 29/03/07
  73.   A Schizophrenic state of existence... 22:01  |  Dutch 29/03/07
  74.   #73 DORIS IT READS JUST LIKE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE RICH AND 22:49  |  paul harris 29/03/07
  75.   Youth that saving us 22:52  |  Yehuda 29/03/07
  76.   #68 Choni have you joined the "Baiters" 23:09  |  Ari ben Yisrael 29/03/07
  77.   Yehuda, These youth will lead us to 01:12  |  Arik 30/03/07
  78.   #50Harris describes hisself 01:35  |  Labhras 30/03/07
  79.   # 10 Star of David. WHILE I MAY AGREE INFINITELY WITH YOU.... 03:59  |  Kath` 30/03/07
  80.   The settlers are the key to Israels democracy 04:00  |  Dr David I.Gross 30/03/07
  81.   Yom Kippur was an unprecedented victory - get real 05:59  |  honestywithoutmercy 30/03/07
  82.   Dutch 06:26  |  David 30/03/07
  83.   to onestywithoutmercy 06:32  |  David 30/03/07
  84.   to David 07:12  |  honestywithoutmercy 30/03/07
  85.   YOU ARE LOSING, ISRAEL 09:19  |  indrajaya 30/03/07
  86.