Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., March 29, 2007 Nisan 10, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:23 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Settlers scuffling with security forces at a synagogue in Homesh during the disengagement in 2005. (Archives)
Last update - 02:50 26/03/2007
IDF: Force will be used against attempts to resettle Homesh
By Nadav Shragai and Amos Harel, Haaretz Correspondents

The Israel Defense Forces and police will invest only limited effort in preventing right-wing activists from marching Monday on the ruins of the former West Bank settlement Homesh, but warned that protesters would be evacuated by force if they tried to resettle the area.

Security forces estimate that they will be outnumbered by about three times the number of protesters expected to participate in the march on the former northern West Bank settlement, which was evacuated as part of the disengagement in 2005.

The IDF believes that at least 5,000 people will participate in the march, but only 1,000 policemen and Border Policemen and 500 IDF soldiers will try to block access to the site. With this ratio, the IDF knows the chances of completely blocking all the participants from reaching Homesh are slim.

Advertisement

Senior officers in the IDF Central Command held talks throughout the day with the march's organizers, in an attempt to dissuade the participants from trying to bypass security forces by walking through Palestinian villages and thus taking an unnecessary risk.

Settlers planning to march said Sunday that they had reached a "security understanding" with officers during the meeting.

According to the organizers, the understanding with the security forces follows IDF warnings that if the roads to Homesh is blocked, the settlers would be forced to make detours through Arab villages, some of which are hostile. Fearing this scenario, said the organizers, the IDF decided to allow the protest march.

However, the IDF on Saturday warned settlers not to execute their plan, and notified them that the penalty for resettling an area evacuated in the disengagement is two years incarceration. The police also sent a warning letter to the organizers of the operation.

The IDF asked the organizers of the operation, called 'Homesh First' to promise not to stay in the former settlement permanently. Organizers have refused to make this commitment.

Military sources deny having reached an agreement with the organizers. The IDF said its primary goal is to avoid the resettlement of Homesh, and said an effort would be made to block the marchers' way before they reach the site. Nevertheless, the army is taking into account the possibility that a few activists will infiltrate the area.

The march to Homesh is being organized by a non-partisan right-wing organizations that opposed the Yesha Council policy during the disengagement. Although the council does not support the operation, the Yesha Rabbinical Committee does.

According to an operational pamphlet, participants are to reach pick-up points, from which they will be transported to the community Shavei Shomron. From there, participants plan to march to Homesh on foot. The organizers instructed the participants "to bring supplies for a 48-hour stay."

Organizers also instructed participants "not to confront the security forces that have been sent by the government, but to bypass them." However, they do add that "violent policemen are criminals and you are lawfully allowed to protect yourself against them."

It is the core group of Homesh settlers that are planning to re-establish the community. The core, which is made up of 30 families, arrived in Homesh a few years before the disengagement to bring religious reinforcement to the settlement.

In a separate announcement, the Homesh core stated that "for the last year and a half the Homesh exiles have been in caravans in Shavei Shomron, tortured by the fact that their destroyed settlement is only seven minutes away."

According to the Homesh core, "the injustice in the destruction of northern Samaria was even greater than the injustice of the destruction of the Gaza settlements. The destruction of Samaria makes no sense. It did not have a political or military purpose, and the defense minister's internal political considerations are the only reason the exiled settlers have not been allowed to return home."

Boaz Ha'etzni, one of the Homesh organizers, told Haaertz that the purpose of the operation is not merely the return to Homesh, but the revival of the struggle against the disengagement.

IDF, police say may not be able to block return to settlement
In recent days, security forces have been preparing for a predicted attempt on the part of settlers to reestablish the settlement of Homesh in the northern West Bank, which was evacuated as part of the Disengagement in August 2005.

IDF sources have stated that the army and the police will do everything possible to prevent the founding of an outpost on the ruins of Homesh, but have expressed doubt if it will possible to do so, as the ruins of Homesh are not fenced-off or closed.

The army on Saturday warned settlers intending to return to the Homesh area to abandon their plans to try to rebuild the settlement saying that the punishment under law for anyone who enters territories evacuated under the Gaza Disengagement and attempts to resettle the area is two years imprisonment.

"In view of media reports that Israeli citizens intend to enter the area of the evacuated settlement Homesh during the Passover holiday in order to reestablish the community," the warning said, "the IDF and the Israel Police wish to emphasize that the law enabling the disengagement bans Israeli citizens from entering and staying in the area without permission."

The army warned that "all means necessary to preserve law and order in the area" would be employed and that anyone violating the law is subject to consequences.

The police have also released a warning to organizers of the Homesh event saying that in addition to criminal charges, event organizers and participators could be subject to paying punitive damages to the state for costs accrued by security services as a result of the event.

Organizers of the event are hoping that thousands will participate in the campaign to reestablish Homesh, and have plastered flyers announcing the event in synagogues throughout the West Bank. The announcements detail staging areas where participants will gather and organize for the trip to Homesh, and instruct participants to bring supplies for a long stay.

"This event will require the presence of security forces who are busy implementing the lessons of the Second Lebanon War, and also places further burden on the security forces who are engaged in protecting the citizenry during the upcoming holidays," a police statement read.

In response, leaders of the Return to Homesh campaign announced they were not surprised by the threats.

"We have grown accustomed to the fact that the authorities in Israel are concerned with laws of expulsion and withdrawal. In all other matters of law there is anarchy, neglect and apathy. The big surprise today is the threat to sue us in civil court for the expenses that the state will incur for suppressing the return to Homesh," they said.

The fact that we could be made to pay security costs brings to mind a similar situation in Saddam Hussein's Iraq, where families had to pay for the ammunition used to kill their loved ones." Event leaders said they would be happy to pay the fines, as soon as all other citizens who are causing the police to spend a great deal of money, and used as examples Israel Islamic Movement head Ra'ad Salah, former justice minister Haim Ramon, President Moshe Katzav, and the Parinyan brothers.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
History in the making
Beit Lessin's 'The History Boys' reveals three insights into Israeli theater.
One of Israel's best
Clos de Gat winery is now widely recognized as one of the country's top wineries.
  1.   Jews Will Return to Homesh, Sa-Nur and Gush Katif 07:15  |  Ben Israel 25/03/07
  2.   Comment on Ben Yisrael #1 08:30  |  Esther 25/03/07
  3.   ofcourse they can be stopped 08:52  |  rose 25/03/07
  4.   Esther #2 is delusional 08:53  |  Ofer 25/03/07
  5.   Response for Ofer #4 09:39  |  Esther 25/03/07
  6.   let them 10:11  |  jake 25/03/07
  7.   The only places Jews can`t live 10:20  |  Efox 25/03/07
  8.   #4 - Ofer, it was right to get out 10:32  |  Avner 25/03/07
  9.   We WILL return to all of our land 10:32  |  Homesh 25/03/07
  10.   They don`t want to stop them 10:33  |  Eyal 25/03/07
  11.   reestablishing settlement 10:36  |  Butch 25/03/07
  12.   Police and IDF 11:16  |  Roland 25/03/07
  13.   IDF IS NOT A TERRORIST ARM OF HAMAS 11:20  |  Yacov 25/03/07
  14.   Not "unable" but "unwilling" 11:25  |  Khalid 25/03/07
  15.   Response for Efox #7 11:31  |  Esther 25/03/07
  16.   #9 - Homesh, want to make history? 11:36  |  Avner 25/03/07
  17.   police may be unable to block return to settlement 11:39  |  John Saul 25/03/07
  18.   Olmert is not a good son to Jewish mother homeland Israel 11:39  |  Joseph E . 25/03/07
  19.   To Esther #2 12:38  |  Choni Davidowitz 25/03/07
  20.   FUNNY LINES FROM PARIS SAUL WEEPS FOR LAW . 13:10  |  paul harris 25/03/07
  21.   Let the IDF stop rockets from Gaza instead 13:25  |  Steven 25/03/07
  22.   settlers 13:50  |  granny 25/03/07
  23.   Steven # 21 13:53  |  SJ 25/03/07
  24.   SJ so? 9/11 14:00  |  Steven 25/03/07
  25.   One can easily explain it in one sentence..... 14:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 25/03/07
  26.   Steven # 24 14:15  |  SJ 25/03/07
  27.   Esther #2 14:16  |  Gabe1 25/03/07
  28.   Why prevent them? 14:28  |  Yonatan 25/03/07
  29.   T Z AH L 14:35  |  chaim 25/03/07
  30.   Such Transparent Excuses 14:49  |  Ziggy 25/03/07
  31.   PAUL HARRIS 14:51  |  eva 25/03/07
  32.   WHY SHOULD IDF STOP THEM 14:53  |  B 25/03/07
  33.   Time to stop wasting money 15:05  |  Mark Lincoln 25/03/07
  34.   EXCELLENT !!! 15:09  |  Wendy 25/03/07
  35.   Can`t or won`t? 15:11  |  Sharona 25/03/07
  36.   Just pretend 15:29  |  W 25/03/07
  37.   Response for Choni #19 15:33  |  Esther 25/03/07
  38.   #27 Gabi1, Get a backbone... 15:37  |  Avner 25/03/07
  39.   SJ = Historic revisionist (24) 15:38  |  Steven 25/03/07
  40.   #33 MARK CONFUSED AS TO ABILITY AND WILL 15:38  |  paul harris 25/03/07
  41.   Esther No 2 - Some good news for you..... 15:40  |  Miriam 25/03/07
  42.   To all those that believe the land belongs to the Palestinians 15:52  |  Zev 25/03/07
  43.   not a problem 15:54  |  Space 25/03/07
  44.   Why can`t they just settle somewhere else until borders agreed? 15:57  |  Ron 25/03/07
  45.   #5Esther. YES, we would have been at Peace now 15:59  |  Arik 25/03/07
  46.   #7Efox, how on earth can you justify...... 16:08  |  Haroun Al rash 25/03/07
  47.   #9 Homesh, SORRY cannot join you in ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES, 16:15  |  Aaron 25/03/07
  48.   Is this a signal by The S F , that settlers may REOCCUPIED the se 16:23  |  Moshe 25/03/07
  49.   #13 Yacov. I D F never attacks 16:30  |  Josh 25/03/07
  50.   Aaron 47 believes in colonal rule! 16:33  |  Steven 25/03/07
  51.   poor pitiful IDF 16:41  |  margaret 25/03/07
  52.   #44 PLEASE EXPLAIN IN DETAIL; WHY RON 16:46  |  paul harris 25/03/07
  53.   #42 Zev 16:47  |  jake 25/03/07
  54.   margaret historic revisionist (51) 16:53  |  Steven 25/03/07
  55.   #18 Joseph E. The road WITHOUT PEACE 16:56  |  Ehud 25/03/07
  56.   Jake you make up international law. 16:58  |  Steven 25/03/07
  57.   # 13 Yacov of Ashkelon 17:01  |  Lynn 25/03/07
  58.   This is our land 17:01  |  e 25/03/07
  59.   # 8 Avnr, I agree with you 17:02  |  Lynn 25/03/07
  60.   Give then a RED CARD 17:06  |  Becky 25/03/07
  61.   Ron #44 17:14  |  DOV KORET 25/03/07
  62.   #50 Steven. I do believe to return back what is NOT ours. 17:17  |  Aaron 25/03/07
  63.   A few rational ways to stop the lawless settlers 17:24  |  Tosefta 25/03/07
  64.   Aaron do you have memory loss? 17:25  |  Steven 25/03/07
  65.   Aaron one more thing on the majority of Jews 17:32  |  Steven 25/03/07
  66.   Tosefta sue the IDF and the Israeli gov`t 17:34  |  Steven 25/03/07
  67.   Kudos to Esther and Avner 17:50  |  Otto Rand 25/03/07
  68.   To Efox of New Mexico 17:55  |  Otto Rand 25/03/07
  69.   #56 Steven..you make up... 18:01  |  jake 25/03/07
  70.   Even Steven #66 18:03  |  Tosefta 25/03/07
  71.   lol nice job "police" 18:10  |  Omar 25/03/07
  72.   Stealing land. I guess the UN stole the land, blame the UN (69) 18:10  |  Steven 25/03/07
  73.   Living in a Dream 18:11  |  RealityChild 25/03/07
  74.   `E` #58 18:12  |  JJ 25/03/07
  75.   The US would bomb Canada out of existance (70) 18:15  |  Steven 25/03/07
  76.   RealityChild 18:21  |  Steven 25/03/07
  77.   #64.Steven.remember Rachel Corrie, 18:31  |  Aaron 25/03/07
  78.   #65 Steven, If we cannot support the Majority.... 18:38  |  Aaron 25/03/07
  79.   To Steven#72 18:42  |  Otto Rand 25/03/07
  80.   SETTLERS: Should March All The Way Back To Europe And Russia " Go 18:45  |  Proud Canadian 25/03/07
  81.   Otto Israeli Arabs attacked Jews for genocide 18:47  |  Steven 25/03/07