Subscribe to Print Edition | Fri., March 23, 2007 Nisan 4, 5767 | | Israel Time: 11:03 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Giving up the goal
By Aluf Benn

A year after the elections, it's safe to say Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's policy has gone offtrack. The most blatant expression of this is Israel's diplomatic holding action against the Palestinian national unity government. Once again, foreign statesmen who met with senior Hamas members are being boycotted, and once again we are pulling out a magnifying glass to identify these statesmen. That is the sum total of Olmert and his government's diplomatic creativity.

Olmert complains the public is turning its back on him while he is working hard to run the country. He should be reminded that leadership is not measured by the length of one's work day, but by one's ability to indicate a direction and a path, to present goals and to fulfill them. With all due respect to his diligence and knowledge of details, an effort that lacks a goal has no value. And to borrow a soccer metaphor, the best team in the world is not worth anything if it doesn't kick toward the goal.

Olmert was elected for one purpose: to guarantee a "stable and solid" Jewish majority in the State of Israel, achieved through withdrawal from most of the West Bank. "A division of the country to guarantee a Jewish majority is the lifeline of Zionism," he declared when his government was sworn in by the Knesset. "I know how difficult it is, but with all my heart I am convinced this act is essential."

Advertisement

Now we should ask what exactly Olmert and his government have done to fulfill this goal. In what way has his policy toward the Palestinians contributed to saving Zionism from a demographic decline that will turn the Jews into a minority in their own country?

Olmert boasts of his success in recruiting an international front against Hamas. He is paying for it with useless talks with Mahmoud Abbas and rejection of proposals to invade Gaza. The government is saying "absolutely not" to negotiations for a final status agreement, and under the cover of the diplomatic smoke screen, it continues to build the separation fence and expand the settlement blocs. When we add to that the excavations at the Mugrabi Gate, the settlers' entrance into a Hebron house and the frozen outpost evacuation, the surprise increases. It is hard to translate Olmert's decisions and deeds into a clear message the public can understand and identify with. Everything looks like a collection of tactics that fail to form a strategy.

The Israeli public, which gave Olmert and his party limited credit even in the elections, sees the confusion at the top and is reacting with disapproval in the polls. Olmert is unpopular not due to poor public relations, as he claims, but due to his lack of a compass. Israelis want to understand where he is leading them, if at all. What does he want? Has he given up the division of the country in favor of a renewed partnership with the settlers? Is Israel on the way to another war in the territories? Have the demographics changed and the threat to Zionism been removed?

The prime minister's bureau now wants more credit. Let him get through Winograd and then you'll see, they say. They say Olmert genuinely wanted to promote a diplomatic move, but Abbas betrayed him and closed a deal with Hamas. They are asking for time to formulate an alternative plan. They are whispering that Olmert's cautious policy toward the Palestinians is helping consolidate an international front against Iran. They are reminding us that Ariel Sharon spent some time in office before finding a direction and a path.

Olmert's problem is that given the failure in Lebanon and the widespread scandals and corruption among the country's leadership, it is hard for him to convince anyone he still has some cards up his sleeve. His heroic battle to save his seat may be a good script for a soap opera, but it is not a national policy. The time has come for him not to give the public excuses for what was, but to say where we are going from here. How we can promote the worthy goal of saving Zionism, which he posited when he came to power. If he has given up on it, he should say so and resign.

But if the demographic danger is still threatening Israel, Olmert must show how he will stop it in the time his government has left. If he continues to hesitate, he will go down in history as a footnote who spent time on the job between a failed war and serial investigations.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Bursting with color
Gideon Oberson's new swimsuit collection is simple, comfortable and feminine.
Theatrical comfort zone
It's interesting to examine the difference between repertory theater and commercial theater.
  1.   OLMERTS PROBLEM GOES WAY BACK TO THE 10:22  |  paul harris 22/03/07
  2.   On the contrairy 10:39  |  Friend 22/03/07
  3.   Olmert as the perfect symbol for Israels "weakness" 11:08  |  Swiss (Dino) 22/03/07
  4.   Don`t like Olmert, but this article is rather pathetic! 12:20  |  Psalm 22/03/07
  5.   The Palestinians give Olmert no real option 12:59  |  Shalom Freedman 22/03/07
  6.   olmert and zionism 13:35  |  Joey 22/03/07
  7.   LEADERSHIP ROLE IS PROTECTION OF G-D`S LAND INHERITANCE FOR JEWS 13:55  |  Bill. 22/03/07
  8.   You Can`t Please Everyone , So ..... 14:59  |  Klaudia 22/03/07
  9.   No need to "save" Zionism 16:33  |  Mark Lincoln 22/03/07
  10.   Bernn - He Wants Olmert to Be Even More of a Disaster 16:37  |  Tod Zuckerman 22/03/07
  11.   Benn gets it backwards 18:26  |  Steven 22/03/07
  12.   Tired of the "patience" game 19:14  |  David Hoffman 22/03/07
  13.   Aluf Benn ,your Lefties push in favor of the Saudi Plan,flooding 10:01  |  Absolute Sweden 23/03/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: Hamas, best friend of the settlers
Responses: 2
Member of war probe: IDF deterrence eroded by years of restraint
Responses: 20
Shmuel Rosner: The attack on the 'Jewish lobby' keeps coming
Responses: 32
Sagi and Stern: Even Palestinians must recognize Israel's Jewish character
Responses: 1
Settlers facing eviction petition court for compensation
Responses: 3


More Headlines
09:13 Member of war probe: Restraint eroded IDF deterrence
08:06 W. Bank settlers facing eviction petition court for compensation
07:32 Iran sanctions resolution due for Security Council vote Saturday
09:18 Hirchson's NGO received free services from Yad Vashem
06:11 IDF officers strike plea bargain in death of elite commando
10:00 Top Hamas man charged with murder of 36 Israelis in string of attacks
01:51 Abbas says framework deal reached on freeing captured soldier Shalit
06:29 England players arrive in Israel ahead of Euro 2008 qualifier
09:05 Israeli television archive in danger of vanishing if not digitized
04:57 Treasury appoints committee to name new Israel Tax Authority head
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved