Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., March 25, 2007 Nisan 6, 5767 | | Israel Time: 16:56 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
MK Ophir Pines-Paz speaking at the Knesset last month. (Kobi Gideon / BauBau)
Last update - 22:37 21/03/2007
Knesset extends law banning Israeli-Palestinian family unification
By Shahar Ilan, Haaretz Correspondent

The Knesset on Wednesday voted to extend and widen the controversial Citizenship Law, which denies family unification to Israelis and Palestinians.

The law, which was to have expired next month, will be extended to July 2008 and apply to citizens of the four "enemy states" - Syria, Lebanon, Iraq and Iran - as well as to those of the Palestinian Authority.

The law was passed in its second and third reading by a majority of 35-11. The Arab faction in Knesset requested a vote of no confidence on the matter.

Advertisement

The law provides for the establishment of a committee to consider exceptions on a humanitarian basis. However, as the Shin Bet, IDF and Population Registrar will have a majority in the committee, not many exceptions are expected to be approved.

The Citizenship Law denies family unification to Palestinian men aged 18-35 and women 18-25.

The Knesset passed an amendment to the law in December, ostensibly to modify it in keeping with the criticism expressed by the High Court of Justice. But human rights organizations said the amended law was worse yet.

The amendment wished to extend the denial of family unification, which until now applied to people who have an immediate family member suspected of involvement in hostile activity, to people whose brother-in-law or nephew are suspected of such activity.

The current temporary Citizenship Law is set to expire April 16. Interior Ministry Roni Bar-On advised the Knesset's Internal Affairs and Environment Committee chairman MK Ophir Pines-Paz that unless he passed the amended law in second and third readings by the end of the Knesset's winter session today, the cabinet would extend the existing law.

Pines-Paz hastened to debate the new proposal, intending to introduce humanitarian improvements.

The committee stipulated that the committee to discuss humanitarian exceptions would have two public representatives, canceled the clause enabling denial of family unification to people whose brother-in-law or nephew are suspected of hostile activity and restricted the law's validity to July 31, 2008 (not to the end of 2008, as planned).

Pines-Paz himself voted against the law, claiming it was discriminatory and unconstitutional.

The head of the Shin Bet's counter-terrorism division told the committee that the terror groups instruct Palestinians in the territories to apply for family unification, then recruit them.

Some 40 percent of Israeli Arabs who were involved in suicide attacks in 2006 were naturalized, he said.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Taxi driver
The appearance of a Jewish friend ruins an attempt to have a chat with an Arab driver.
The wail
The image of every Arab leader Israel tries to dwarf gradually assumes tremendous heft.
  1.   very correct. let them move to any arab country of their choice. 03:17  |  ralph 21/03/07
  2.   Why is this limited by age and 4 states? All enemy states! 03:26  |  David 21/03/07
  3.   Palestinians are too much of an enemy for marriage to Israelis 04:19  |  BeHonest 21/03/07
  4.   Only In Israel! This is a family unfriendly law. 04:27  |  Timothy 21/03/07
  5.   Apartheid law extended 04:54  |  Mandela 21/03/07
  6.   A proposed amendment 06:08  |  RAB 21/03/07
  7.   what is this nation becoming? 06:25  |  jacob 21/03/07
  8.   Hey Israel haters, 40% of naturalized Arabs were suicide bombers 06:51  |  Tom 21/03/07
  9.   Behind all this 07:03  |  Colin Wright 21/03/07
  10.   At last, a sensible decision that serves Israel`s interests! 07:11  |  Roni 21/03/07
  11.   Amazing how Israel uses the term "enemy states" 07:39  |  Marlene 21/03/07
  12.   ARCHAIC AND UNBELIEVABLE 07:42  |  Marcell 21/03/07
  13.   DAVID of Boston, you armchair diplomat 07:48  |  aristocrat 21/03/07
  14.   To Do Otherwise Would Be National Suicide 07:56  |  Tod Zuckerman 21/03/07
  15.   The right of return 08:08  |  Arafat (Abu Amr) 21/03/07
  16.   This Dar El Harb Izrail doesn`t want our Dar a-Salam invasion? 08:12  |  Jalal 21/03/07
  17.   UNREALISTIC TO THINK OF ZION OTHERWISE 08:13  |  arab 21/03/07
  18.   Nothing to do with or Racism or Apartheid just realistic. 08:15  |  dona 21/03/07
  19.   Isn`t Iraq a model democracy? 08:34  |  David Howard 21/03/07
  20.   to those who are faulting the law 08:44  |  Lex 21/03/07
  21.   #8 Tom asks how I would respond... 08:48  |  Johnboy 21/03/07
  22.   Timothy what about the USA 09:17  |  Aby 21/03/07
  23.   Palestinian officials announce evey single day that their 09:28  |  Anat 21/03/07
  24.   4: Yes, Tim, war is family unfriendly 09:40  |  David Teich 21/03/07
  25.   This says it all ... 09:44  |  Yossi 21/03/07
  26.   21: JB gets one right!!!! Mazel Tov! 09:44  |  David Teich 21/03/07
  27.   Pines-Paz discriminate constitutionally against Hativah song . 09:44  |  Joseph E . 21/03/07
  28.   Mandela 09:44  |  christa 21/03/07
  29.   Answer to number 5. 09:47  |  David NIgel Braham 21/03/07
  30.   Enemy states 09:48  |  christa 21/03/07
  31.   good decision -let`s keep our country safe! 10:00  |  don 21/03/07
  32.   johnboy "zionist nutters" 10:24  |  papalbull 21/03/07
  33.   In what other democratic country? 10:26  |  JustCurious 21/03/07
  34.   This is making me feel unhappy 10:26  |  Edith 21/03/07
  35.   nasty johnboy 10:28  |  papalbull 21/03/07
  36.   there should never have been re bloody unification 10:30  |  ephraim 21/03/07
  37.   THE PALESTINIANS HATE ISRAEL 10:34  |  EPHRAIM 21/03/07
  38.   have we forgotten the palestinians celebrating 10:35  |  ephraim 21/03/07
  39.   when the second intifada started the pals 10:37  |  ephraim 21/03/07
  40.   is israel storing up huge problems for 10:40  |  ephraim 21/03/07
  41.   arab 17 10:40  |  doesnt matter 21/03/07
  42.   The only country??? 10:45  |  Serge 21/03/07
  43.   Another wedge driven between Jews and Arabs 11:33  |  Michael 21/03/07
  44.   Taking the Easy Way Out 12:04  |  Tzfonit 21/03/07
  45.   Why do Palestinians want to move to an Apartheid state? 12:28  |  Steven 21/03/07
  46.   Maybe Israel needs more enemy state Arabs, not less. 12:34  |  Michael 21/03/07
  47.   #4 tiny minded TIM 12:35  |  Ari ben Yisrael 21/03/07
  48.   The Germans also adopted this concept of ethnic purity 12:35  |  KA 21/03/07
  49.   #14 Zuckerman; "Israelis hating Israel" 12:44  |  ballistic 21/03/07
  50.   KA you are the racist! 48 12:47  |  Steven 21/03/07
  51.   #38 Ephraim; well, gee, Ephraim 12:54  |  ballistic 21/03/07
  52.   Israels dilemma 12:54  |  Swiss (Dino) 21/03/07
  53.   #44 Tzfonit 13:05  |  Ernst 21/03/07
  54.   WHY DOES THE L-RD WAIT ??? 13:10  |  Bill. 21/03/07
  55.   Good news 13:11  |  Ken 21/03/07
  56.   #8 TOM 13:13  |  wh 21/03/07
  57.   ITS TIME FOR FAMILY REUNIONS IN JORDAN 13:20  |  paul harris 21/03/07
  58.   Ernst did you cry when the Jews were ethnically cleansed? 13:28  |  Steven 21/03/07
  59.   ballistic "give the zionist government a well deserved 13:33  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  60.   Ernst # 53 A democracy indeed 13:34  |  Tzfonit 21/03/07
  61.   ballistic when did this love affair with arab slave traders 13:38  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  62.   ballistic not all israelis are whitey 13:42  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  63.   family reunification 13:45  |  one of them 21/03/07
  64.   ballistic and the white man 13:45  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  65.   Tzfonit: The Chicken,the Egg and our Kishkas 13:48  |  Ronnie Wolman 21/03/07
  66.   ballistic there is no substance in your posts 13:49  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  67.   Go ballistic someplace else 13:53  |  for those who hate 21/03/07
  68.   Indeed a model state 13:53  |  El-Birawi 21/03/07
  69.   ballistic is a totally ignorant woman 13:54  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  70.   To join the EU this law must be stopped first 13:55  |  Tamir Gaza 21/03/07
  71.   Pathetic Colin ,Timothy&Co :Sweden does the same 14:14  |  Absolute Sweden 21/03/07
  72.   what do we learn from the black ballistic 14:17  |  barry goldwater 21/03/07
  73.   Ernest #53 14:18  |  Gabe1 21/03/07
  74.   el birawi tries some sarcasm 14:26  |  hussein 21/03/07
  75.   ISRAEL`S TRAVESTY AGAINST TORAH LAW 15:08  |  abram 21/03/07
  76.   #43 Michael 15:30  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  77.   Why insist on living in Israel if it is such a bad place? 15:40  |  Olga 21/03/07
  78.   # 22 Aby re Timothy 16:09  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  79.   #4 Timoti, All other countries do not have 16:31  |  TOMY 21/03/07
  80.   # 4 - You are right! 16:50  |  Simone 21/03/07
  81.   What About the Other Percentages in Israel? 17:09  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  82.   `..Imagine house demolitions or deportations..` 17:15  |  Rufus 21/03/07
  83.   Rufus runs the gamut #82 17:28  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  84.   Yaakov Sullivan 17:45  |  ODP 21/03/07
  85.   3. BeHonest. Settlers, Carter, etc. 17:48  |  KUTW 21/03/07
  86.   5. Mandela: What about terrorism? 17:51  |  KUTW 21/03/07
  87.   #77 Olga in latvia 17:52  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  88.   40% Re#8 17:55  |  Joe 21/03/07
  89.   Hussein/Moshe you could not give away what is not yours 17:57  |  El-Birawi 21/03/07
  90.   #82 Rufus 17:59  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  91.   Timothy #4 17:59  |  Gee 21/03/07
  92.   In Norway 8month old baby of Norwegian father & OZ Mum "illegal" 18:01  |  Absolute Sweden 21/03/07
  93.   Marriage as a way to launch terror attacks 18:02  |  Rachel 21/03/07
  94.   ODP, numbers and common sense #84 18:05  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  95.   el birawi you have not addressed my question 18:15  |  hussein 21/03/07
  96.   68. . El-Birawi: a model state 18:17  |  KUTW 21/03/07
  97.   The Bottom Line 18:35  |  Jeff Northridge 21/03/07
  98.   Ronnit Wolman #65 Responsibility 18:58  |  Tzfonit 21/03/07
  99.   Israeli Arab PM Wont sing National Anthem 19:05  |  Bruriah Sarah 21/03/07
  100.   Israeli Arab PMs meet with Syria 19:06  |  Bruriah Sarah 21/03/07
  101.   75 - Israeli Arabs thrive better in israel than in Arab countries 19:16  |  Bruriah Sarah 21/03/07
  102.   Labhras # 87 Sloppy Terminology 19:18  |  Jeff Northridge 21/03/07
  103.   89 - Where is your proof that Jews took it from the arabs? 19:19  |  Bruriah Sarah 21/03/07
  104.   #88 - Joe, your calculation is not correct 19:25  |  Ronny 21/03/07
  105.   A real gentleman. 19:31  |  Solomon 21/03/07
  106.   #4. Timothy. This is democracy 19:37  |  Fred 21/03/07
  107.   #5 V I V A Mendella 19:43  |  Van Daam 21/03/07
  108.   #7#Jacob Amen to your Post... 19:50  |  Solomon 21/03/07
  109.   #34Sensible Edith 20:14  |  Mireille 21/03/07
  110.   Closing a loop hole for sham marriages 20:15  |  Schtarker Yid 21/03/07
  111.   Tzfonit: Stuck in the Middle 20:17  |  Ronnie Wolman 21/03/07
  112.   Olga # 77. You are so right!!! Very good analysis!!! 20:29  |  Avi 21/03/07
  113.   Jeff Northridge on Palestine #102 20:33  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  114.   Yaakov Sullivan 20:52  |  ODP 21/03/07
  115.   Yaakov Sullivan #2 20:56  |  ODP 21/03/07
  116.   #102Jeff Northridge 20:56  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  117.   A useless and stupid law 21:00  |  Tosefta 21/03/07
  118.   ODP, if it is Democratic AND Jewish, yes #114 21:08  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  119.   #115 the same can surely be said of Israel 21:13  |  Yaakov Sullivan 21/03/07
  120.   #77,112: Olga and Avi, same nonsense as from KKK 21:13  |  Alex 21/03/07
  121.   Rommie Wolman: The Street and the Halls of Power 21:24  |  Tzfonit 21/03/07
  122.   Labhras # 116 The Best Partner For Peace? 22:15  |  Jeff Northridge 21/03/07
  123.   A bold proof! - Apartheid!!! 22:15  |  Jews for peace 21/03/07
  124.   Family Reunification Israeli-Palestinian 22:17  |  goldie klugman 21/03/07
  125.   #101 Bruriah Credible source= Jewishvirtuallibrary 22:27  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  126.   Tsfonit #60 22:33  |  Ernst 21/03/07
  127.   Yaakov Sullivan 22:38  |  ODP 21/03/07
  128.   Tsfonit #60 part 2 22:42  |  Ernst 21/03/07
  129.   Schtarker Yid # 110 That`s About It In a Nutshell 22:46  |  Jeff Northridge 21/03/07
  130.   104 ronny 23:05  |  wh 21/03/07
  131.   to tom #8 on strange arithmetics 23:05  |  Jean-Luc Ngarambe 21/03/07
  132.   THE KNESSET`S SHAMEFUL FAMILY VALUES 23:08  |  Dutch 21/03/07
  133.   #122 Jeff Northridge 23:14  |  Labhras 21/03/07
  134.   "Family unification" and "four enemy states." 23:14  |  Maureen Ann 21/03/07
  135.   #14, goldie: Family Reunifaction NO, Land reunification YES ?! 23:18  |  Gil 21/03/07
  136.   Controversial Law 23:23  |  Edifice 21/03/07
  137.   #8 23:24  |  AK 21/03/07
  138.   Ernst 23:33  |  Tzfonit 21/03/07
  139.   Tzfonit: as Long As You Know That 23:35  |  Ronnie Wolman 21/03/07
  140.   Stone age behavior 23:46  |  Moe 21/03/07
  141.   #117 - Tosefta, if your JPost numbers of 30 cases are right... 23:50  |  Tal 21/03/07
  142.   but we dont like you 23:55  |  abu abu 21/03/07
  143.   Sullivan playing the same old game 00:10  |  ChanahS 22/03/07
  144.   Here on the far Western fringe of Judaism 00:12  |  Schtarker Yid 22/03/07
  145.   #101 Bruhriah 00:13  |  Labhras 22/03/07
  146.   ODP # 115 00:13  |  christa 22/03/07
  147.   "National" anthem for who? (99) 00:15  |  Marlene 22/03/07
  148.   Shameful law, born in fear of loosing Jewish majority 00:16  |  Ronit 22/03/07
  149.   What an analogy to make to Ernst 133 00:34  |  Marlene 22/03/07
  150.   Arabs can have reunification only in Jordan 00:46  |  e.m 22/03/07
  151.   citizenship? 00:56  |  which is which 22/03/07
  152.   #26 Thanks for the encouraging words, David 01:26  |  Johnboy 22/03/07
  153.   racist and safe 01:55  |  joykill 22/03/07
  154.   What is this nation becoming? (7) 02:20  |  Marlene 22/03/07
  155.   GODS COUNTRY YEAH SURE!!!! 03:15  |  wally 22/03/07
  156.   #136 Tal from Tel Aviv 03:15  |  Tosefta 22/03/07
  157.   in a post 9/11 world with Jihadism upsurge 03:20  |  Joseph E . 22/03/07
  158.   Hey Barry; no discussion of any 04:20  |  ballistic 22/03/07
  159.   #117, Tosefta 04:28  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 22/03/07
  160.   #32 So, papalbull.... 04:29  |  Johnboy 22/03/07
  161.   40% of Bombers were Naturalized, Not 04:46  |  Brian 22/03/07
  162.   #104 Ronny, you are still not there yet.... 04:49  |  Johnboy 22/03/07
  163.   #102 Gee, Jeff, sloppy terminology from you too 05:15  |  Johnboy 22/03/07
  164.   #15 is Funny!!!! More humor less ranting! 05:22  |  Funny Man 22/03/07
  165.   What would you do if it was your children threatened? 06:20  |  Moises 22/03/07
  166.   Anti-Zionism is based on judging by different standards... 06:29  |  Moises 22/03/07
  167.   its their age old tactic to infiltrate other societies 08:03  |  Watcher 22/03/07
  168.   #94 If indeed,as you claim, you ever lived in ISRAEL & converted 09:09  |  Ari ben Yisrael 22/03/07
  169.   On Par with South Africa 09:12  |  Kiwi boy 22/03/07
  170.   Kiwi boy - usual idiotic comparison - I dare you to answer this! 16:58  |  Moises 22/03/07
  171.   Israel CANNOT have peace 16:59  |  T A Sheppard 22/03/07
  172.   racism pure and simple 18:04  |  Deborah 22/03/07
  173.   #172 Deborah 22:59  |  alan 22/03/07
  174.   172: Deborah, you`re not in Kansas anymore 16:52  |  David Teich 25/03/07
 Today Online
Yossi Melman: Ahmadinejad sends a signal
Responses: 125
Daniel Ben-Simon: Jews who intend to vote for Le Pen
Responses: 50
Vilan & Strum: Who's afraid of the peace process?
Responses: 65
IDF, police: We may be unable to block return to settlement
Responses: 54
'No comment' on reports of Olmert-Saudi meeting
Responses: 27
Rosner's Domain
* The attack on the 'Jewish lobby' keeps coming and coming
* Ron Robin: McCain harbors deep animosity to Israel
* Notes from Atlanta on Jewish passion
* The Iran beauty contest


More Headlines
16:07 UN chief: Time is not ripe for meetings with Hamas
16:47 Settlers: IDF agreed to let us march to former settlement
16:29 At Riyadh summit, Arab states to propose increasing aid to PA
13:05 EU seeks to revive talks with Iran as UN tightens sanctions
14:11 PM: Abbas reneged on promise to secure Shalit's release
16:50 Lebanon war probe defends decision to disclose Peres testimony
15:42 Source: Hirchson may have been framed in suspected graft
09:11 IDF, police say may not be able to block return to settlement
11:27 Sharon's Negev ranch may get tax cuts as war-zone settlement
12:43 El Al Zurich flight aborted on takeoff as smoke fills cabin
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
Junkyard
Junk a car - get free towing nationwide and a tax-deductible receipt.
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
Holiday Inn and Crown Plaza Israel
Lowest internet rate Guaranteed at ichotelsgroup.com !
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved