Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., March 20, 2007 Nisan 1, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:32 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
No humanism in journalism
By Shiri Lev-Ari

"The Journalist Who Crossed the Line" is not a new suspense book by Ram Oren or Yair Lapid, but a new book tying together journalism and literature. The book consists of 23 stories written by journalists, which deal with their work. The book was initiated and edited by Talma Admon, who was the editor of Maariv's literature supplement for 10 years and later moved on to edit at Modan Publishing for a year. While working at the publishing house, she got the idea to turn to a group of journalists and ask them each to submit a story they had written.

In a way, the collection of stories provides a behind-the-scenes look at the Israeli press. Some of the stories take place in the halls of the editorial offices, and some occur outside of them. The book includes stories by Yaron Fried about a former columnist, a story by Einat Keidar about a letter "H" that slipped the mind of a proofreader, and other stories by Raanan Shaked, Amir Ben-David, Gideon Levy, Noa Yedlin, Uri Misgav, Shai Golden, Yigal Serena, Benny Ziffer, Miri Hanoch, Zvi Gilat, Nelli Sheffer and others. "I sat among them," says Admon, "and I got to know many journalists around me who had other kinds of texts. Many of them don't even write for a newspaper, but work as proofreaders or editors. But I was certain they were able to create something in a different way, that they have something to say about their work environment."

What emerges from the stories? "That working at a newspaper is not particularly pleasant," replies Admon. "In many cases, it even causes suffering to those who work there. Humanism is the last thing taken into consideration, both in the journalistic text as well as in the halls where it is produced.

Advertisement

"Those who work in these places suffer on a personal level as a result of what they do and because of the rules of the game which they must abide to. Each one of the writers included in the book took this fact to a different direction. Many of the stories represent 'the little man,' the average journalist. But even when the protagonists are senior editors, they suffer from their impulses, and others suffer from them, too. The press factory functions like any other factory, only that it has more ability for self-reflection and reflection on its surroundings. This is why the suffering is even greater."

The Israeli journalism world as it is portrayed in the book is characterized by cynicism, of which even the younger generation of journalists is aware. "I used to think that the young generation enjoy the profession more and feel more at home," says Admon. "But that's not true, everyone suffers from the profession.

"In the age of the Internet and Web blogs, there is a sense that print journalism may be a profession whose time has passed. There is no doubt that printed media is something archaic. Furthermore, words are not as important these days. Photos play a much more important role - in the printed press as well. Those people who express themselves well with words are not as desirable today as they were in the past."

Admon continues: "There is both a future and a present for online journalism, but it's much less controlled and demanding in terms of its messages and values. The internet is something anarchic. The journalism we used to know - something regulated and reliable, with rules and order, values and morals - has been lost. It's a long process that began 15 years ago and has accelerated during the last five years."

Admon herself has published several books: "Noa Doesn't Live Here Anymore" - a collection of essays from 1985; "A shack blows in the wind" - a children's book from 1989; "Lakes" - a collection of stories published in 2005; and "Letters to Amos," a novel released in 2006. Today she spends her time writing and translating.

In your opinion, does journalistic writing contribute to the development of literary writing, or the contrary?

"It depends on how much you commit yourself to journalistic writing. If you devote yourself to it fully, and it robs you of your time - in both the literal meaning as well as with reference to the time in your heart and mind - then you're distancing yourself from literary writing. Journalistic writing can harm literary writing, there is proof of that. So, whoever wants to write books should not devote their soul to journalistic writing. That way, maybe, they can protect themselves from it."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dosh on Display
An exhibit on the works of cartoonist Kariel Gardosh will open in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.
Follow the leader
Thousands of Israelis have taken up the Scandinavian sport of orienteering.
 Today Online
Burston: Name that war - Your chance to rewrite Israel's history
Responses: 121
Editorial: Israel can and should cooperate with new PA unity gov't
Responses: 165
Ze'ev Schiff: A cease-fire could be good for Hamas - and Israel
Responses: 43
Fania Oz-Salzberger: Germans must decry anti-Israel attacks
Responses: 116
Shlomo Ben-Ami: Back to the Bill Clinton peace proposal
Responses: 43
Norway becomes first European state to talk to new PA gov't
Responses: 314


More Headlines
00:50 Dozens of settlers take over building in Hebron, claiming they bought it
21:09 Egypt says would-be Hamas suicide bomber arrested near Israeli border
19:03 Report: Assad says expects little progress in peace talks in next two years
00:12 Hamas slams Abbas' decision to appoint Dahlan as security chief
00:14 Peres: Olmert will continue to serve as PM despite Winograd report
00:14 New Palestinian high-school textbooks reject existence of Israel, peace
23:27 Reform Judaism leaders vow to increase influence in Israel
23:03 Elbit Systems: Israeli-made drones in action in Iraq, Afghanistan
18:24 U.S. grants Ahmadinejad visa for address to UN Security Council
17:33 Committee appoints 15 new rabbinical judges, including 13 ultra-Orthodox
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved