Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., March 20, 2007 Nisan 1, 5767 | | Israel Time: 13:23 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
MK Ahmed Tibi (Archives)
Last update - 23:21 18/03/2007
Poll: Over 25% of Israeli Arabs say Holocaust never happened
By Fadi Eyadat, Haaretz Correspondent and The Associated Press

More than a quarter of Israel's Arab citizens believe the Holocaust never happened, and nearly two thirds of Israeli Jews avoid entering Arab towns, a poll by a University of Haifa sociologist showed Sunday.

The poll, conducted by Sami Smoocha, a prominent sociologist at the University of Haifa, showed a wide gap of mistrust, anger and fear between Israel's majority Jews and its Arab citizens, who make up a fifth of Israel's citizens.

In its most dramatic finding, the poll showed that 28 percent of Israeli Arabs did not believe the Holocaust happened, and that among high school and college graduates the figure was even higher - 33 percent.

Advertisement

According to Smoocha's analysis, radicals in the Arab world believe the Holocaust to be a political event, and many feel that by denying it they are expressing opposition to Israel.

Among Israeli Jews, 63 percent said they avoid entering Arab towns and cities, and 68 percent fear the possibility of civil unrest among Israeli Arabs.

Pollsters interviewed 721 Arabs and 702 Jews. The margin of error was 3.7 percentage points. Asked about Israel's war with Hezbollah guerrillas in Lebanon last summer, nearly half of the Israeli Arabs polled - 48 percent - said they believe that Hezbollah's rocket attacks on towns in northern Israel during that war were justified, even though numerous Arabs were killed and wounded in those attacks.

While 89 percent said they view Israel's bombing of Lebanon as a war crime, only 44 percent said they see Hezbollah's attacks on Israel as such. Hezbollah pelted northern Israel with nearly 4,000 rockets.

Half of Israeli Arab respondents said Hezbollah's capture of Israel Defense Forces reserves soldiers Ehud Goldwasser and Eldad Regev in a cross-border raid was justified. That incident sparked the 34-day conflict.

In a press release accompanying the poll's publication, Smoocha expressed surprise at the results.

"One would have expected more pro-Israeli results among Israeli Arabs due to the uniqueness of the most recent war: a war with no involvement of the Palestinians, a war in which the lives and belongings of Israelis were endangered, a war against an Islamic fundamentalist group that most of them don't support," Smoocha said.

MK Ahmed Tibi (United Arab List-Ta'al) said he doubted some of the findings. Tibi said he could not explain the numbers indicating support for Hezbollah, but noted that usually there is no empathy for the aggressor, which Tibi said was Israel.

Tibi also said he doubted that the statistics on Holocaust denial reflect the situation in the Arab elite. Tibi called the Holocaust the worst crime ever against humanity and said Holocaust denial is immoral.

But some of the sentiments, he said, "might stem from reservations about the way the Holocaust is used as a political tool by Israel."

The poll also found that Israeli Arabs have fears about their future in Israel: 62 percent worry that Israel could transfer their communities to the jurisdiction of a future Palestinian state, an idea supported by one of the parties in Israel's current governing coalition. Sixty percent said they are concerned about a possible mass expulsion.

Among the Arab respondents, 76 percent described Zionism as racist.

But more than two thirds said they would be content to live in Israel as a Jewish state, if it existed alongside a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dosh on Display
An exhibit on the works of cartoonist Kariel Gardosh will open in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.
Follow the leader
Thousands of Israelis have taken up the Scandinavian sport of orienteering.
  1.   So, close to 100% Jews don`t believe in the Nakba 18:33  |  Marilyn 18/03/07
  2.   I`m beginning to believe that a nakba will happen to these people 18:52  |  Aaron 18/03/07
  3.   Over 25% of the Arabs should loose all State benefits 19:00  |  Steven 18/03/07
  4.   re #1 `Jews don`t believe in the Nakba` 19:00  |  Colin Wright 18/03/07
  5.   Marilyn and her usual lies 19:03  |  Steven 18/03/07
  6.   Marlyn I`m sure your family has a picture of Hitler at home... 19:03  |  Tom 18/03/07
  7.   25% 19:03  |  wh 18/03/07
  8.   #1 | @M.: How many Jews got thrown out of several arab countries? 19:07  |  Spoon 18/03/07
  9.   Well, How can be sure that it happened? 19:09  |  Palestinian 18/03/07
  10.   nothing we didn`t know already 19:11  |  garrick 18/03/07
  11.   Colin Wright is WRONG as usual 19:17  |  GZLives 18/03/07
  12.   #9 19:17  |  Spoon 18/03/07
  13.   How many jews believe that Holocaust happened? 19:20  |  Marcel 18/03/07
  14.   SHAME ON YOU MARILYN 19:24  |  Nephtaly 18/03/07
  15.   Arabs don`t mind being murdered by other Arabs 19:24  |  Allon 18/03/07
  16.   Why Palis SHOULD pay for the Holocaust 19:25  |  GZLives 18/03/07
  17.   re # 1 your hate worst than your ignorance !!! 19:26  |  Alberto Cohen 18/03/07
  18.   also it did happen 19:26  |  Mary 18/03/07
  19.   Marilyn 19:26  |  Allon 18/03/07
  20.   100% Jews deny Deir Yassin happened 19:29  |  Joe 18/03/07
  21.   Response to `Palestinian`, holocaust denier 19:34  |  Shai 18/03/07
  22.   SPoon: Arab Jews were asked and terrorized to leave 19:35  |  KA 18/03/07
  23.   Hopeless #9 19:38  |  Oddvark 18/03/07
  24.   re #9 `Well, How can be sure that it happened?` 19:41  |  Colin Wright 18/03/07
  25.   please Marilyn 19:50  |  AK 18/03/07
  26.   El Nakba and Holocaust 19:54  |  From the Moon 18/03/07
  27.   how are these things even related 19:56  |  ola 18/03/07
  28.   So What? 19:58  |  Dovy 18/03/07
  29.   Historical perspectives and self interest 19:59  |  Joseph 18/03/07
  30.   but you trust the french.... 19:59  |  ola 18/03/07
  31.   Oriental Jews - Holocaust Denial 20:05  |  Klaus Bloemker 18/03/07
  32.   reply to # 9 Why should we believe... 20:05  |  Ben Azai 18/03/07
  33.   Joe, which Jews apart from those in your head did you poll? 20:10  |  Allon 18/03/07
  34.   To Palestinian. 20:13  |  Neutered Observer 18/03/07
  35.   Expel the dark forces 20:14  |  Brod 18/03/07
  36.   Arabs and the Holocaust 20:18  |  Sherlock Holmes 18/03/07
  37.   Dovy not Jewish 20:18  |  Allon 18/03/07
  38.   Sure we believe in the Nakba: Yom Haatzmaut 20:27  |  Ilan 18/03/07
  39.   Israeli Arabs 20:36  |  R 18/03/07
  40.   Palestinians 20:38  |  Mohammed 18/03/07
  41.   #31 - Klaus Bloemker - You quote an Israel-hater 20:38  |  dromit 18/03/07
  42.   Nephtaly, Marilyn is telling the truth 20:40  |  Palestinian 18/03/07
  43.   Ok, Do Jews respect other people`s lives? 20:41  |  American living here 18/03/07
  44.   Alberto Cohen`s stupid soundbites 20:43  |  KA 18/03/07
  45.   don`t push holocaust on arabs face 20:43  |  GIRISH 18/03/07
  46.   Next time make sure all Hezb rockets land in Arab towns 20:43  |  McQueen 18/03/07
  47.   why should it matter? 20:45  |  bernie 18/03/07
  48.   Associated Press BIAS 20:46  |  Double Click 18/03/07
  49.   Marilyn: I am an Israeli Arab and am proud of you 20:51  |  Ahmed 18/03/07
  50.   UN Res. 194 Implies Nakba 20:57  |  Bryan 18/03/07
  51.   Unsettling results- especially about Lebanon and Hezbollah 21:07  |  Chick Corea 18/03/07
  52.   Joe Ramallah ... 21:08  |  GZLives 18/03/07
  53.   WHY SHOULD THEY TOE ZIONIST LINE OF CURRENT AND PAST HISTORY? 21:08  |  JACKAL 18/03/07
  54.   25% and Friends like to be provocative. 21:14  |  Alan-SA 18/03/07
  55.   Oriental Jews - Warschawski 21:15  |  Klaus Bloemker 18/03/07
  56.   #48 Double Click 21:17  |  Boycott 18/03/07
  57.   To Marilyn an the other Fools 21:18  |  Shalom 18/03/07
  58.   CWRIGHT.Did a Jew write "from time immemoral"?Sure? 21:30  |  PETER SM 18/03/07
  59.   KA, Palestinian - AKA Khalid Amayreh 21:31  |  Boris 18/03/07
  60.   KA, Palestinian - AKA Khalid Amayreh 21:31  |  Boris 18/03/07
  61.   Isn` t it bizarre....?? 21:33  |  Swiss (Dino) 18/03/07
  62.   Truman and America turn of the century 21:53  |  GZLives 18/03/07
  63.   To Bryan 21:57  |  Ziggy 18/03/07
  64.   THE JEWISH PEOPLE TODAY 21:57  |  Nephtaly 18/03/07
  65.   Boris..most Russian immigrants eat pork 21:57  |  Israeli 18/03/07
  66.   The only solution: Lieberman`s plan of giving up arab villages! 22:01  |  Roni 18/03/07
  67.   Palestinian, post no. 9, I will not try to convince you about the 22:04  |  Nadav 18/03/07
  68.   Where is Rami? 22:09  |  Gene 18/03/07
  69.   Swiss 22:14  |  Nephtaly 18/03/07
  70.   #20 Joe and his Blatant Lies 22:20  |  Alex 18/03/07
  71.   #26 Marilyn`s blind hatred is an embarassment to humanity 22:21  |  Alex 18/03/07
  72.   THE JEWISH PEOPLE TODAY 22:27  |  Nephtaly 18/03/07
  73.   In the end 22:35  |  David 18/03/07
  74.   #49 22:39  |  AK 18/03/07
  75.   Who`s indoctrinating them? 22:49  |  KUTW 18/03/07
  76.   AK....A LITTE NOTICE 22:55  |  Nephtaly 18/03/07
  77.   #1 - every Israeli I know agrees 700,000 arabs fled 23:04  |  redmike 18/03/07
  78.   To convince them, you need to... 23:13  |  TheBilu 18/03/07
  79.   re # 44 KA sorry!!! if we just dont`t drop dead 23:15  |  Alberto Cohen 18/03/07
  80.   Until 9/11... 23:18  |  Mrs. 18/03/07
  81.   The Question/REAL ISSUE Here Is--Is It A VALID Excuse? 23:25  |  Proud Pal Defender 18/03/07
  82.   The Paradox of Holocaust consequences 23:27  |  Mozie 18/03/07
  83.   # 1 Marilyn - real `nakba` is Arab immigration... 23:40  |  Paul Henzen 18/03/07
  84.   #20 Joe from Ramallah. Nazis and Arabs 23:46  |  Sherlock Holmes 18/03/07
  85.