Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 19, 2007 Adar 29, 5767 | | Israel Time: 01:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Norwegian Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Stoere. (AP)
Last update - 00:24 18/03/2007
U.S. 'disturbed' by 'right to resist' clause in PA unity gov't platform
By Haaretz Service and Agencies

The United States said Saturday it was disturbed by the Palestinian unity government's claim of a right to resist Israel and disappointed by Palestinian Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh's speech on Saturday expressing that right.

"The national unity government's platform reference to the right of resistance is disturbing and contradicts the Quartet principles of renunciation of violence," U.S. State Department spokeswoman Nancy Beck said.

"The prime minister's speech to the Palestinian Legislative Council was disappointing and inconsistent with the Quartet principles as well as the national unity government's adherence to the foundational principles of peace," she said.

Advertisement

Israeli officials said Saturday that Israel would not have any contact with the new government or any of its ministers, and that it expects the international community "to stand by the principles that it itself has determined."

The Foreign Ministry waged a diplomatic offensive this weekend in an effort to prevent a "collapse" in the position of the international community towards the new government.

The diplomatic efforts were centered on the policy of the European Union.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni on Friday telephoned colleagues in Britain, Russia and Germany urging them to stand by the principles demanded by the Quartet of Mideast peace negotiators.

A draft initiated by Ireland and Spain calls for normalization with the new government without preconditions.

Britain, by contrast, intends to pursue a policy of dealing with Fatah lawmakers while ignoring those affiliated with Hamas.

British officials told their Israeli counterparts Friday that the United States support this position, a claim Washington denies.

Livni told British Foreign Secretary Margaret Beckett that the new Palestinian government should be dealt with as a single organization, and that it is impossible to prevent money given to Fatah members from being transferred to Hamas.

Officials in Jerusalem said Friday that Israel was having difficulty convincing the U.S. not to deal with Fatah lawmakers in the government, particularly those who have had good relations with the U.S. and EU.


Also on Saturday, the Jordanian government wished the new Palestinian cabinet success and urged it to "shoulder its responsibilities" in such a manner that leads to the lifting of the "siege" imposed on the Palestinian people.

Earlier Saturday, Norwegian Foreign Minister Jonas Gahr Stoere said his country would re-establish political and economic relations with the new Palestinian government, and the European Union welcomed the government's formation but said a resumption of aid would depend on an assessment of the new cabinet's platform and actions.

"The Presidency of the EU welcomes the formation of a Palestinian Government of National Unity pursuant to the agreement reached in Mecca on 8 February 2007, which lays the foundation for Palestinian reconciliation," a statement issued by EU president Germany said.

"The Presidency of the EU recalls the readiness of the EU to work with and to resume its assistance to a legitimate Palestinian government adopting a platform reflecting the Quartet principles. The EU will carefully assess the platform and actions of the new government and its ministers," it said.

The Norwegian foreign minister said the Hamas-Fatah coalition was taking steps toward complying with international demands.

"Norway will thus on this basis re-establish political and economic relations with the Palestinian government," he said.

Norway is not a member of the European Union, but has been a key player in Middle East peacemaking and one of the most steadfast contributors to the Palestinian Authority.

"Norway expects the Palestinian authorities to respect basic international standards as regards compliance with previously concluded agreements, renunciation of violence and recognition of Israel's right to exist," Stoere said.

He also called on Israel to "take a constructive approach to the unity government, for example by releasing withheld Palestinian revenues from taxes and fees and by increasing the freedom of movement for the Palestinian population."

Stoere said Norway would deal with the new Palestinian government but "upholds its demands on Hamas as an organization."

"It is essential that the unity government gains control of the security situation in Gaza and the West Bank, and that the rocket attacks on Israeli areas cease," he added.

The Norwegian foreign minister said the new Palestinian government should "make an active effort" to secure the release of captured Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit.

Foreign Ministry spokesman Bjoern Jahnsen said Norway's decision means that it has lifted the restrictions on political contacts and aid it had imposed on the previous Hamas-led government.

"We've resumed normal political relations," he said.

British Foreign Minister Margaret Beckett welcomed the formation of the coalition, but said the government would be judged by its actions.

"I welcome [Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud] Abbas' continued efforts at intra-Palestinian reconciliation, which have led to agreement on the forming of a national unity government.

"We will judge the government by its platform and actions and respond accordingly. As Britain has made clear, we have always been willing to work with a government based on the Quartet principles. We will also continue supporting the Palestinian people, including through continued funding of the Temporary International Mechanism.

"I welcome the ongoing dialogue between Prime Minister Olmert and President Abbas. I hope the national unity government will support President Abbas in taking this process forward. The peace process will only move forward through constructive dialogue."

On Friday, a U.S. official said that Washington would leave the door open to unofficial contacts with Palestinian Finance Minister-designate Salam Fayyad, a political independent and Western-backed reformer.

Even before Haniyeh announced the agenda of the new Palestinian government on Saturday, Israel had already ruled out talks with the new coalition between the Islamist Hamas party and Abbas' Fatah party, which was to be sworn in on Saturday.

Israel rejected the new coalition due to Hamas' refusal to accept demands, set by the Quartet of Middle East peace mediators, that it renounce violence, recognize the Jewish state, and endorse past rapprochement efforts.

But with international impatience mounting over the diplomatic impasse and deepening Palestinian poverty and lawlessness, there have been signs of Western flexibility on talking to non-Hamas members of the new cabinet in the future.

Britain will allow contacts with Fatah members and independents in the new cabinet, including Fayyad, as well as the incoming foreign minister, Ziad Abu Amr.

France has already invited Abu Amr to visit Paris.

Also on Friday, Italy's government welcomed the formation of the new government, calling it "an important opportunity that should not be missed."

In a message to Abbas, Italian Foreign Minister and deputy Prime Minister Massimo D'Alema expressed satisfaction at the news and said Italy would work to aid the Middle East peace process.

D'Alema called on the new Palestinian executive to put an end "to all kinds of violence," including the launch of Qassam rockets and the smuggling of weapons in Gaza, and urged Hamas to release Gilad Shalit.

Among the Quartet of Middle East mediators - the U.S., European Union, United Nations and Russia - the most positive reaction to the new coalition has come from Moscow.

"It is inarguably an important event in terms of consolidation of the Palestinian ranks," Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman Mikhail Kamynin said in a statement on Friday, noting that the Palestinian power-sharing deal took into account the Quartet conditions.

The U.S. was more cool. White House spokesman Tony Snow, saying he did not want to express disappointment, indicated Thursday that there would be no change in the U.S. administration's refusal to deal with the Palestinian government unless its platform changed.

"Our position has been consistent, which is, you need a Palestinian government that is going to, in fact, abide by the Quartet conditions," Snow said.

Following statements regarding international positions on the new government, Fayyad said the new Palestinian government would not be able to function for long unless the international community lifts its aid boycott and increases assistance.

Israel has announced that it will boycott the new cabinet but its officials will continue to meet with Abbas, as it has done several times in the past year, and has urged foreign powers, including the European Union, to follow suit.


Related articles:

  • Parliament okays new Hamas-Fatah unity gov't
  • Minister Majadele: Israel must hold talks with PA unity gov't
  • New PA unity government draws mixed international reactions

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Dosh on Display
    An exhibit on the works of cartoonist Kariel Gardosh will open in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.
    Follow the leader
    Thousands of Israelis have taken up the Scandinavian sport of orienteering.
      1.   Norway does more wacked things... 18:38  |  Paul Henzen 17/03/07
      2.   Good start 18:57  |  Human Rights 17/03/07
      3.   How Do Norwegian Political Physicians Treat A Patient ... 19:04  |  Lavi 17/03/07
      4.   Expect An IDF Provocation 19:29  |  chet 17/03/07
      5.   What a JOKE 19:39  |  Dr Dave 17/03/07
      6.   Norway hunts whales 19:44  |  Omran 17/03/07
      7.   The boycott is collapsing 19:46  |  Chris Linthwaite 17/03/07
      8.   norway 19:47  |  wh 17/03/07
      9.   Well done Norway. Righting a sin. 19:47  |  Nick Ferriman 17/03/07
      10.   Good on Norway 19:48  |  Benzeen 17/03/07
      11.   Lousy Norway is only a symptom of Europe`s wish to get even at 19:49  |  Absolute Sweden 17/03/07
      12.   What happened to Norway? 19:51  |  Brod 17/03/07
      13.   Norway takes the lead 19:53  |  Moe 17/03/07
      14.   Now Oslo is OVER!! 19:59  |  Benlolo 17/03/07
      15.   # 1 Paul Henzen 19:59  |  Nick Ferriman 17/03/07
      16.   And America and Israel stand glaring on the sidelines 20:39  |  Clickfool 17/03/07
      17.   #2 Absolute Sweden 20:46  |  Luxus Leverpostei 17/03/07
      18.   Shame on Norway 20:52  |  Mladen Andrijasevic 17/03/07
      19.   How Do Norwegian Political Physicians Treat A Patient ... 20:55  |  Lavi 17/03/07
      20.   #2 - Chet and his lies 21:01  |  Maurice 17/03/07
      21.   I agree as a Norwegian. Sorry we have a stupid government! 21:05  |  Harold 17/03/07
      22.   Nick Ferriman, Norway is not an honest broker here... 21:08  |  Tom 17/03/07
      23.   Norway recognizes Palestinian government 21:10  |  Hans 17/03/07
      24.   Well done, Norway! 21:11  |  Andreas 17/03/07
      25.   to my friends in Norway 21:12  |  garrick 17/03/07
      26.   Since Norway`s gov`t has decided to aid and abet Hamas terrorism. 21:23  |  Dr. L. Brnd 17/03/07
      27.   Stand your ground Norway 21:29  |  Moe 17/03/07
      28.   Hans from Oslo 21:32  |  Lynn 17/03/07
      29.   #4 CHET 21:36  |  Moe 17/03/07
      30.   Norway did not read World Bank Report 21:40  |  US Citizen 17/03/07
      31.   # 4 chet 21:40  |  Lynn 17/03/07
      32.   # 6 Omran 21:43  |  Lynn 17/03/07
      33.   Correction for Dr L.Barnd 21:45  |  Clickfool 17/03/07
      34.   Til vores venner i Norge 21:46  |  US Citizen 17/03/07
      35.   Back from Palestine 21:48  |  Moe 17/03/07
      36.   #12 Well there Brod, I guess they 21:50  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      37.   #14 Hey Benlolo; that sure is a NEW 21:51  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      38.   #1 Paul 21:51  |  Soso 17/03/07
      39.   Resist injustice 21:52  |  Ted 17/03/07
      40.   #16 Hey Clickfool; right you are 21:53  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      41.   Well, our friend "Dr" L.Brnd just admitted 21:55  |  Andreas 17/03/07
      42.   #18 Hey Mladen; whatever are you whining 21:58  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      43.   #26 Hey Doctor; what are you a Dr. of? 22:01  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      44.   #25 Hey Garrick; they are among 22:03  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      45.   # 26 Dr L Brnd 22:07  |  Nicholas Ferriman 17/03/07
      46.   CAUTION CLICKFOOL 22:07  |  Brant 17/03/07
      47.   Luxus Leverpostei,you mix up the facts 22:13  |  Absolute Sweden 17/03/07
      48.   Haniyeh`s speech 22:18  |  From the Moon 17/03/07
      49.   # 27 Ted 22:20  |  ChanahS 17/03/07
      50.   Norway ,Chicken hawks and whales 22:28  |  Najdt 17/03/07
      51.   Palestians again show why there will never be peace 22:33  |  Kipperraes 17/03/07
      52.   Moe - No35 22:34  |  Palestinain Brit 17/03/07
      53.   Absolute Sweden again 22:51  |  Luxus Leverpostei 17/03/07
      54.   #49 ChanahS 22:55  |  Ted 17/03/07
      55.   YUK YUK HEY THERE BALLE LISTICK! 22:58  |  Brant 17/03/07
      56.   to absolute childish Swede 23:03  |  Jean-Paul DOGUET 17/03/07
      57.   #44 ballistic 23:04  |  garrick 17/03/07
      58.   Noway and Sri Lanka 23:07  |  Daniel Abrams 17/03/07
      59.   # 39 Ted of Delaware 23:12  |  Lynn 17/03/07
      60.   Hey Brant; if they can deal with the rogue 23:17  |  ballistic 17/03/07
      61.   #20 Maurice - Palestinian Provocations 23:22  |  chet 17/03/07
      62.   to ballistic and other Israel-haters 23:23  |  garrick 17/03/07
      63.   Israel and America, with so much... 23:24  |  Maureen Ann 17/03/07
      64.   #49 23:28  |  Ali 17/03/07
      65.   Norway Is Not the Problem - It is Jewish Appeasers 23:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 17/03/07
      66.   Oslo agreement never had a chance 23:35  |  Hans 17/03/07
      67.   Heave 23:35  |  Colin Wright 17/03/07
      68.   Chicken hawks on wild goose chase to save whales-second attemept 23:36  |  Najdt 17/03/07
      69.   HOW IS WISH RED INDIANS` RESISTANCE HAD SUCCEEDED 23:41  |  JACKAL 17/03/07
      70.   how hell they resist the atrocities 23:41  |  last pharaoh 17/03/07
      71.   you (Clickfool as well as the warmongers) just don`t get it 23:55  |  xyz 17/03/07
      72.   #43 WEHATEVER HEIS BALLISTIC IM SURE THAT HE IS 100 23:57  |  paul harris 17/03/07
      73.   Israeli negotiation tactics 00:01  |  Marco 18/03/07
      74.   #45 THE MAN ON THE FERRY DOESNT KNOW HIS RRRS FROM A HOLE 00:03  |  paul harris 18/03/07
      75.   The Right to Confuse People with Bullshit Speeches 00:05  |  Mozie 18/03/07
      76.   #41, #45...Norwegian acts in Gaza/WBank require Israeli agreement 00:14  |  Dr. L. Brnd 18/03/07
      77.   Ted- Killing innocent people is not injustice? 00:15  |  Mozie 18/03/07
      78.   To the Absolute Swede (2nd try) 00:16  |  Luxus Leverpostei 18/03/07
      79.   The US administration CAN go to HELL 00:27  |  Sam (UK) 18/03/07
      80.