Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., March 18, 2007 Adar 28, 5767 | | Israel Time: 05:31 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Shin Bet chief Yuval Diskin. (Kobi Gideon / BauBau)
Last update - 07:15 17/03/2007
PMO to Balad: We will thwart anti-Israel activity even if legal
By Yoav Stern, Haaretz Correspondent

The Prime Minister's Office has sent a letter to the editor of the publication of the predominantly Arab party Balad saying it would combat the activity of any group or individual seeking to harm Israel's "Jewish or democratic character," even if that activity was carried out through legal means.

"The Shin Bet security service will thwart the activity of any group or individual seeking to harm the Jewish and democratic character of the State of Israel, even if such activity is sanctioned by the law," read the letter, sent by the Prime Minister's Office on behalf of the Shin Bet to editor Ala Hlehel.

The letter, published Friday, also said that the Shin Bet would fulfill this task with the "force of the principle of a democracy that defends itself."

Advertisement

Hlehel petitioned the PMO last week following media released information of a closed-door meeting between Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and head of the Shin Bet, Yuval Diskin, in which the latter reportedly described Israel's Arab population as a "strategic threat" to the prime minister.

The two reportedly discussed four documents drafted by groups representing Israel's Arab population which call for a change in Israel's character: "The Future Vision of the Palestinian Arabs in Israel" by the Higher Arab Monitoring Committee, the Musawa oganization's "Ten Point Document," the "Democratic Constitution," by the Adala Center and the yet unpublised "Haifa Treaty."

When Hlehel accused the Prime Minister's Office of "attempting to shut mouths," the Shin Bet responded by saying that there was nothing wrong with the formulation of the documents "unless they reflect or encourage subversive activity," and that the Shin Bet's activity includes foiling such activity on the part of various groups "even if their activity utilizes democratic tools."

Hlehel told Haaretz on Friday that the Shin Bet's response violates the law that regulates its activity, constitutes a blatant breach of its authority, and proves that the "era of military rule imposed upon Arab citizens never ended."

"The Shin Bet is supposed to defend the security of the country, not prevent democratic discussions over the nature of the state... this is very grave and affects all citizens of the state, not just the Arabs," he added.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Family Affair
Yariv Bron and his daughter Mikey live in Kiryat Ono with their dog Ketem.
Salvager of a culture
Ahad Ha'am had a vision that foresaw many of the Jewish state's most pressing problems.
  1.   Patriotism trumps all in the ( New Middle East ) 16:00  |  Najdt 16/03/07
  2.   If true this is very dangerous news.... 16:31  |  B`Galil 16/03/07
  3.   We will thwart anti-Israel activity even if legal 16:33  |  Bubba 16/03/07
  4.   Harming Israel`s "Jewish or democratic character"? 16:48  |  Ronen 16/03/07
  5.   Najdt 16:50  |  Polybios 16/03/07
  6.   yes there are limits. democracy should contain within its own des 16:50  |  ralph 16/03/07
  7.   We will thwart anti-Israel activity even if legal 16:58  |  etnav 16/03/07
  8.   Ronen 17:18  |  rich 16/03/07
  9.   Anti Israel Activity 17:27  |  Edifice 16/03/07
  10.   Apartheid! 17:39  |  Jews for peace 16/03/07
  11.   Jewish democracy 17:43  |  Mandela 16/03/07
  12.   Heavyhanded 18:06  |  Regev 16/03/07
  13.   Long Live Democracy and freedom of speech 18:08  |  Yellowbirdwoman 16/03/07
  14.   It`s official 18:35  |  Colin Wright 16/03/07
  15.   Shin Bet article 18:37  |  Louis 16/03/07
  16.   What`s anti Israel activity? 18:52  |  Andreas 16/03/07
  17.   #3 Bubba. Got carried away equating `Israel` with `democracy`? 18:59  |  zmogus 16/03/07
  18.   Wrong direction 19:11  |  Alex 16/03/07
  19.   re #7 `Anti-Israel Activity.` 19:14  |  Colin Wright 16/03/07
  20.   jewish character of israel 19:18  |  freeda 16/03/07
  21.   I thought Israel was supposed to be a democracy? 19:19  |  peacelover 16/03/07
  22.   Well, at least real signs of Israel integrating in the ME!!!! 19:20  |  zmogus 16/03/07
  23.   Olmert talking Tough again 19:44  |  Johnny 16/03/07
  24.   Just pass a law to make their activity illegal 19:44  |  Gili 16/03/07
  25.   It would be interesting... 19:50  |  Nik Miller 16/03/07
  26.   A contradiction in terms. 20:00  |  Richie 16/03/07
  27.   When legality is criminalized and illegality is favorized 20:02  |  Danna 16/03/07
  28.   #24, Gili: Already got enough apartheid laws 20:10  |  Bar 16/03/07
  29.   Big Talk but facts say quite the opposite 20:24  |  Chick Corea 16/03/07
  30.   Olmert desperate for more popularity points 20:28  |  Galit 16/03/07
  31.   Gili # 24 -What you advocate makes you different 20:29  |  Najdt 16/03/07
  32.   We will defend free speech to the death... 20:31  |  Navy Vet 16/03/07
  33.   We will defend free speech to the death... 20:33  |  Navy Vet 16/03/07
  34.   "Even if Legal?" 20:36  |  Mark Lincoln 16/03/07
  35.   simple question 20:39  |  rose 16/03/07
  36.   KAFKAESQUE: arbitrary justice 20:40  |  aristocrat 16/03/07
  37.   Diskin, ruah shaked 21:16  |  R 16/03/07
  38.   Pardon me, Ronen? 21:30  |  Jake 16/03/07
  39.   What do the documents say? 21:33  |  MissyWoo 16/03/07
  40.   The Jewish Character of Israel 21:40  |  Maki 16/03/07
  41.   TO JEWS FOR PEACE 21:41  |  ADAM 16/03/07
  42.   mark Lincoln #33 21:42  |  Danite 16/03/07
  43.   34 21:50  |  bo 16/03/07
  44.   ANother Israeli hypocrisy 21:51  |  Gaza Mo 16/03/07
  45.   #27 Danna. If FENCE IS DESTROYED as you want and suicide 22:17  |  Vittorio 16/03/07
  46.   #33 SIMPLE ADVICE FROM A SIMPLETON 22:18  |  paul harris 16/03/07
  47.   mark Lincoln every country has the right to protect 22:23  |  Jew 16/03/07
  48.   zmogus #17 22:26  |  KT 16/03/07
  49.   What is treason? 22:38  |  tim 16/03/07
  50.   Yes, Nik #25, it would be interesting 22:46  |  KT 16/03/07
  51.   The Jewish Character of Israel 22:49  |  Maki 16/03/07
  52.   Tik Tik Tik Tik.... 22:49  |  Roni Feingold 16/03/07
  53.   Legality and Morality ..... What`s that 22:57  |  mgb 16/03/07
  54.   Giant Step Backwards 23:00  |  Double Click 16/03/07
  55.   Democracy is the means only... 23:15  |  a 16/03/07
  56.   Laws Can Be Changed 23:18  |  Efox 16/03/07
  57.   re: Jews for peace on 50 years back 23:24  |  Efox 16/03/07
  58.   Mr Feingold wins a free ticket to hell 23:25  |  bo 16/03/07
  59.   when is a democracy not a democracy? 00:10  |  Josh Goldman 17/03/07
  60.   PM is an idiot 00:45  |  Nathaniel 17/03/07
  61.   Roni Feingold and Josh Goldman 00:59  |  Jake 17/03/07
  62.   Foolish Remark 01:14  |  Bill 17/03/07
  63.   Israeli/Arab Relations 01:42  |  Duryeh Getas 17/03/07
  64.   Shin Bet is of harm for democratic character 01:47  |  Intelligent Agent 17/03/07
  65.   "Brain Fart" 01:50  |  Double Click 17/03/07
  66.   #59, Josh: when is a democracy not a democracy? 02:07  |  Yariv 17/03/07
  67.   What exactly is the Jewish Charater of the state? 02:58  |  Hagi 17/03/07
  68.   Needs to resign 05:15  |  Regev 17/03/07
  69.   Christain Character of USA 05:22  |  JC 17/03/07
  70.   THE CHARACTER OF THE UNITED STATES 06:32  |  US Citizen 17/03/07
  71.   Democracy is ok for nations at peace 07:12  |  David 17/03/07
  72.   democracy 07:38  |  alex 17/03/07
  73.   one more shared value between america & israel. 08:20  |  arab 17/03/07
  74.   # 70 to us citizen from us citizen 08:25  |  eric 17/03/07
  75.   #70 09:15  |  bill 17/03/07
  76.   re #71 `Democracy is okay for nations at peace` 13:28  |  Colin Wright 17/03/07
  77.   re `one more shared value between America and Israel.` 13:37  |  Colin Wright 17/03/07
  78.   If activities are legal they must be allowed - 14:49  |  Fairplay 17/03/07
  79.   #78 FAIRPLAY VISITS DISNEY LAND FOR LEGAL OPINION 18:14  |  paul harris 17/03/07
  80.   #76 MR WRIGHT GETS IT WRONG AS USUAL 18:18  |  paul harris 17/03/07
  81.   Jewish State - No Arabs need to apply! 18:23  |  Abe 17/03/07
  82.   Its Not Just The Arabs 18:51  |  David 17/03/07
  83.   Israel is rooted in democratic traditions 19:04  |  Peter 17/03/07
  84.   # 3 Bubba. No dissent accepted here. 19:14  |  Nick Ferriman 17/03/07
  85.   # 59. Well said Josh. 19:16  |  Nick Ferriman 17/03/07
  86.