It doesn't depend on Winograd - Haaretz

Subscribe to Print Edition

Fri., October 19, 2007 ,

Israel Time: 00:44 (EST+7)

web haaretz.com

Back to Homepage

Print Edition

Diplomacy

Defense

Arts & Leisure

Real Estate

Jewish World

National

Advertising

Magazine

Week's End

Business

Opinion

Rosner's Domain

Anglo File

Books

Travel

del.icio.us

Digg It! new

Last update - 23:25 15/03/2007

It doesn't depend on Winograd

By Haaretz Editorial

To replace a government, an opposition must coalesce and enough Knesset members must want elections. Meanwhile, no one is proposing a new agenda, and everyone seems to be comfortable in their padded chairs, with the wait for the committee's recommendations just an excuse to do nothing.

This reveals a certain amount of political infantility. The committee's investigation of the truth and summary of lessons is indeed important, but the public already knows enough to draw conclusions about the individuals involved. Prime Minister Ehud Olmert's part in the operational decision-making is not important, nor is whether responsibility falls on him and the chief of staff equally. Nor is it important whether Olmert planned the war months ahead, or initiated it on the spur of the moment. It is hard to find a single citizen today who would want Olmert and Defense Minister Amir Peretz in charge of the next potential war - that is the main thing. Does the Winograd Committee have to recommend to the heads of state that they give up their offices, or is a general lack of faith - in terms of security, at least - enough to bring together an opposition to change the government?

The bitter disappointment caused by the second Lebanon war should have shaken our very foundations, but the storm died down the moment the Winograd Committee was established, as if the country had time to waste while the committee debated the lack of talented leaders. If not for public pressure, even Dan Halutz would not have gone home. Now, similar pressure should be created to replace the leadership. It is impossible to discuss the Iranian threat seriously while placing it in the hands of Amir Peretz and Avigdor Lieberman.

	Advertisement

At the end of May, the Labor Party will hold elections for its candidate for prime minister. But if these elections continue in the quiet vein that has typified them so far, if Ehud Barak sees himself only as a candidate to replace Olmert's defense minister, the country will continue to be bogged down by trivial matters. Politically speaking, Labor's election day is more important than the Winograd report release date. Peretz disappointed his voters not only because he chose the defense portfolio and found himself in a war he most likely did not expect, but also because his contribution to government policy before and after the war was not felt, and because he agreed to take on Lieberman as a partner. Now is the time to see whether Labor knows how to draw conclusions.

The Winograd Committee's speed is dictated by the large amount of material to be studied, but the committee is not supposed to be pulling the political and public chestnuts out of the fire. If the committee decides not to make recommendations regarding individuals, but rather only to draw conclusions, as has been intimated, the public will have to do its part.

The war in Lebanon was a failure. The prisoners are still captive. The home front took 200 rockets a day. Will that same government now lead the country into a major military operation in Gaza, and continue its diplomatic passivity and ignorance of the Saudi initiative, the Syrian initiative and changes in the Palestinian government?

Bookmark to del.icio.us


	Hip Hop Rabbi
	Marc Schneier is on a mission to improve Jewish-Muslim relations.


	Man in a trap
	Olmert has a mandate from his people, but it will not help him in light of his moral weakness




1.	what legal means does the public have	01:35	\|	yahn goodey	16/03/07

2.	Public Pressure	06:09	\|	Daniel Hershtal	16/03/07

3.	New elections	11:44	\|	Zev	16/03/07

4.	just an excuse to do nothing	23:42	\|	GPWS.1	19/10/07

Today Online


	Israel rejects UN envoy's bid to open talks on Shaba Farms
	Responses: 257


	Aluf Benn: Iran nuclear threat seems far more frightening from Israel
	Responses: 118


	President Peres calls for more inclusive definition of Judaism
	Responses: 73


	FM Livni condemns Belarusian President for anti-Semitic jibe
	Responses: 86


	Firillas: On Armenia, what can Turkey learn from German reaction to Holocaust
	Responses: 37


	Bar'el: Some Israeli captives are more equal than others
	Responses: 13

More Headlines
20:11 Report: Syria dismantling facility targeted by IAF


20:12 Hezbollah slams U.S. call for 'partnership' with Lebanon army


18:49 UN chief: Peace conference decisions must get UN okay


22:27 Court orders Winograd Cmte. to reply to petition within 10 days


21:51 MKs threaten to topple Chief Rabbinate kashrut monopoly


21:31 Eight-time world surfing champion in Israel to promote peace


23:04 Egypt arrests 18 Eritreans planning to sneak into Israel


18:56 Musharraf calls strike on Bhutto convoy 'plot against democracy'


18:13 Iran says ready to help nations develop nuclear programs


19:14 Blair gets early backing in race to be EU's first president