Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., May 15, 2007 Iyyar 27, 5767 | | Israel Time: 23:43 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Losing Jerusalem
By Danny Rubinstein

If we examine the headlines in the Palestinian media in recent years, there is hardly any doubt that Jerusalem is the key issue on the agenda. Sometimes there's talk of restrictions on Muslims worshiping at the Al-Aqsa Mosque; sometimes there's talk of the purchase of more Arab houses by associations of religious settlers. And at the end of last week there were more reports of Muslim protests against the work at the Mugrabi Bridge, and violent demonstrations at the Qalandiya checkpoint in northern Jerusalem as well as at the crossing point to Bethlehem in the south.

Newspaper photos showed agile young men climbing the ("racist," in the Palestinian version) separation wall and flying a Palestinian flag on it.

From the Palestinian perspective, it would appear, the main problem is not recognition of Israel, the Jewish settlements in the West Bank, the violence and the terror or even the problem of the refugees and the right of return. The problem is Jerusalem. Just as the State of Israel would not be able to exist if the right of the 1948 refugees to return were to be recognized, it can be said that a Palestinian state could not exist without East Jerusalem as its capital.

Advertisement

It is in this context that the protest to the Israeli work at the Mugrabi Gate - both by Muslims in general and the Palestinians in particular - must be viewed. It is true that this work does not involve the Al-Aqsa compound itself, that the Israeli plans do not endanger anything sacred to Islam and that these demonstrations exploit the sensitivity surrounding religious issues to launch another attack on the Israeli government. This was the case in the Western Wall tunnel affair in 1996 and when Ariel Sharon visited the Temple Mount in September 2000, and this was the case in a long series of other incidents in which Israel disrupted the status quo in Jerusalem.

Every action that Israeli spokesmen define as a measure of strengthening the Israeli hold in the capital of Israel is defined in Palestinian and Arab terms as a continuation of the efforts to Judaize Jerusalem.

The Palestinians have reason to be sensitive about Jerusalem, because they are losing it. Work toward the completion of the separation fences and the walls around East Jerusalem is nearly finished. The reason for the separation is security. And while Israel is claiming that this is not a political border, the crossing arrangements at the walls are looking more and more like border crossing points between countries. At Betunia and Qalandiya to the north, at Hizma and the Mount of Olives in the east, and at Rachel's Tomb in the south, border control installations have transformed primitive roadblocks into modern terminals.

The Palestinian protests on the Jerusalem issue have not stopped, but from Israel's perspective they have become tolerable. It is possible, with great caution, to say that there are signs of Israeli-Jordanian cooperation on Jerusalem. In the peace agreement between the two countries, Israel promised to give Jordan priority in guarding the city's Islamic holy sites, and this agreement has been kept. The governments of Israel and Jordan are careful not to give positions of power to the Palestinian Authority in the control apparatus at Al-Aqsa, and are jointly working to undermine the status of the head of the Islamic Movement in Israel, Sheikh Ra'ad Salah, who is trying to become the patron of Al-Aqsa.

Can Israel's reinforced grip on East Jerusalem advance the peace process? The answer is no. Without East Jerusalem, a Palestinian state will not arise and the waning dream of "two states for two peoples" will come to an end.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Searching for a cause
A police program fails to reach clear conclusions on what causes accidents.
We need a Blair
Israel can only wish to have a charismatic and inspiring leader like Tony Blair.
  1.   E. Jerusalem is LIBERATED capital of Israel. 10:04  |  Yacov 14/03/07
  2.   Losing more 10:06  |  Ralph 14/03/07
  3.   Why are there no foreign embassies in Jerusalem...?? 10:11  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  4.   There is no Palestine 10:34  |  Rivka 14/03/07
  5.   An assuption in this article is the necessity to establish a .... 10:39  |  Nadav 14/03/07
  6.   There wo`t be a `Palestinian` state west of the Jordan River 10:46  |  Dani 14/03/07
  7.   east jerusalem where the arabs are the majority 10:58  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  8.   danny rubinstein explains 11:04  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  9.   Capital Crimes 11:15  |  Yonatan Netser 14/03/07
  10.   Gadalyah - I agree. Any future agreement should 11:16  |  Anat 14/03/07
  11.   Why are the United Nations headquarters in New York... 11:21  |  Maureen Ann 14/03/07
  12.   its inevitable 11:54  |  ravi 14/03/07
  13.   Giving up Jerusalem 12:01  |  Avi Yerushalmi 14/03/07
  14.   HOw about just no "palestinian" state 12:03  |  SLAVO 14/03/07
  15.   "Judaize Jerusalem" ,interesting term used by "Israeli" Rubinste 12:07  |  Absolute Sweden 14/03/07
  16.   #11 BECAUSE MO THE USA IS STUPID ENOUGH TO KEEP IT GOING 12:11  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  17.   What exactly is this "tightened grip"? 12:20  |  SD 14/03/07
  18.   Swiss # 3 13:01  |  Lynn 14/03/07
  19.   Maureen Ann 13:04  |  Lynn 14/03/07
  20.   Danny Rubinstein 13:19  |  Baruch 14/03/07
  21.   NO STATE FOR PALS - the best solution: NO TERRORISM,............. 13:29  |  Vittorio 14/03/07
  22.   The West Bank and Jordan 13:30  |  Joseph 14/03/07
  23.   # 3, SWISS (DINO) 13:34  |  indrajaya 14/03/07
  24.   Violence effective way to achieve Palestinian goals !!! 13:36  |  Alberto Cohen 14/03/07
  25.   Judaizing Jerusalem 13:38  |  Joe 14/03/07
  26.   If it brings peace to the region, why not, but.. 13:38  |  Sara 14/03/07
  27.   #18 lynn... 13:40  |  sigh... 14/03/07
  28.   Temple Mount in Jordanian hands 13:41  |  Jonathan S 14/03/07
  29.   No Questions Nadav just praise for your post constantly 13:44  |  Miriam Davidowitz 14/03/07
  30.   A unique city requires a unique solution 13:44  |  Sherlock Holmes 14/03/07
  31.   Usual liberal whining 13:49  |  Gene 14/03/07
  32.   Danny Rubinstein 13:55  |  Monica L 14/03/07
  33.   Nadav #5....a brilliant idea but have any politicians 13:57  |  albert amato 14/03/07
  34.   nadav, the one you arent asking #5 13:58  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  35.   Yaacov?? Sullivan??? I do not know you 14:31  |  Miriam Davidowitz 14/03/07
  36.   Maureen Ann @ 11 14:35  |  ChanahS 14/03/07
  37.   to 23 14:35  |  Harry Potter 14/03/07
  38.   why now Danny? 14:39  |  Issy Hass 14/03/07
  39.   # 18 Lynn 14:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  40.   # 27 sigh 14:42  |  Lynn 14/03/07
  41.   Albert Amato, thank you for your kind words. I think both Egypt.. 14:42  |  Nadav 14/03/07
  42.   KEEPING JERUSALEM 14:46  |  Steven 14/03/07
  43.   Wake up! 14:46  |  Sam 14/03/07
  44.   3 ZONE JERUSALEM 14:46  |  Ian 14/03/07
  45.   # 34 Yaakov Sullivan 14:48  |  Lynn 14/03/07
  46.   # 23 indrajaya 14:48  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  47.   When you, Sullivan, begin to respect us, Jews, and recognize our 14:48  |  Nadav 14/03/07
  48.   To Yaquob Suleiman #34, et. al. 14:49  |  Clickfool 14/03/07
  49.   Israel Is Doing All It Can To See This Does Not Happen 14:49  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  50.   #34 a serious question Mr O`sullivan 15:01  |  Ari ben Yisrael 14/03/07
  51.   Losing Jerusalem 15:04  |  P. J. Casey 14/03/07
  52.   # 46, SWISS (DINO) 15:05  |  indrajaya 14/03/07
  53.   Mr.Rubinstein...... 15:07  |  Hastaroth 14/03/07
  54.   Islamic Extremism 15:08  |  Stephen Connor 14/03/07
  55.   Israel is writting the blackest lines 15:09  |  simon 14/03/07
  56.   NADAV #5 15:09  |  GABE1 14/03/07
  57.   Jerusalem and the UN 15:12  |  P. J. Casey 14/03/07
  58.   Nadav 15:14  |  Stephen Connor 14/03/07
  59.   Saliv`n - Are you out to continue spitting at us, 15:15  |  Bronya Kaplan 14/03/07
  60.   M. Davidowitz, I suggest you take your hatred..#35 15:15  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  61.   That, too Lynn, should be discussed #45 15:18  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  62.   Why the hell should Israel do this? 15:22  |  Jonathan S 14/03/07
  63.   #49 15:26  |  Paul 14/03/07
  64.   Y. Sullivan 15:27  |  Stephen Connor 14/03/07
  65.   The Problem Is East Jerusalem? Hardly! 15:28  |  CHGODMK 14/03/07
  66.   Maureen Ann: What do UN headquarters have to do with J`salem?! 15:29  |  Psalm 14/03/07
  67.   # 39 Swiss 15:31  |  Lynn 14/03/07
  68.   Hastaroth (Post No. 53) 15:34  |  Johnny Weintraub 14/03/07
  69.   Jews, Christians, and Moslems 15:38  |  Scott 14/03/07
  70.   # 52 indrajaya 15:41  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  71.   Nice try, Bronya, but the phraseology give you away #59 15:42  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  72.   Lynn 15:44  |  ODP 14/03/07
  73.   It is good that a PLO state cannot and will not exist 15:46  |  Ronny 14/03/07
  74.   # 67 Lynn 15:46  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  75.   Steven in the United Kingdom (Post 42) 15:49  |  Johnny Weintraub 14/03/07
  76.   Ari ben Yisrael 15:50  |  Miriam Davidowitz 14/03/07
  77.   #62 15:50  |  Sharonelle 14/03/07
  78.   Gabe 1, the Arabs of Eretz Israel have not failed a single ...... 15:51  |  Nadav 14/03/07
  79.   #68 That is correct,Johhny 15:51  |  Hastaroth 14/03/07
  80.   "main problem" for Palestinians is EVERY issue 15:52  |  McQueen 14/03/07
  81.   Article`s weakness is that it assumes the P people exists 15:53  |  Jo 14/03/07
  82.   Yaakov, Nadav is not the 1st person 15:53  |  Avrum 14/03/07
  83.   #60 Sullivan, again, we get it:You hate Israel 15:54  |  McQueen 14/03/07
  84.   Ari ben Israel #50 15:55  |  GABE1 14/03/07
  85.   # 53 Hastaroth 15:55  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  86.   United Nations (Post No. 11) 15:56  |  Johnny Weintraub 14/03/07