Subscribe to Print Edition | Tue., March 20, 2007 Nisan 1, 5767 | | Israel Time: 07:04 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul-Gheit (AP)
Last update - 00:16 15/03/2007
Egyptian FM demands Israel probe alleged 1967 POW killings
By The Associated Press

Egypt's foreign minister said on Tuesday he has demanded Israel investigate the alleged killings of Egyptian prisoners of war during the 1967 Six Day War, in comments that appeared to be an attempt to diffuse a public uproar over his earlier remarks which were decried here as too lenient toward Israel.

Ahmed Aboul-Gheit told reporters that he sent a harsh rhetoric letter to his Israeli counterpart Tzipi Livni after himself watching the Israeli-made documentary "The Spirit of Shaked" which Egyptian press claimed was evidence that an elite Israel Defense Forces unit executed 250 Egyptian POWs in the Sinai Peninsula - rather than transfer them to prison camps.

Aboul-Gheit said that, "the film raises question marks ... there was no reason for the excessive use of force by the [Israeli] military unit against the special Egyptian forces."

Advertisement

The foreign minister's comments appeared to be a veiled apology to the Egyptian public, infuriated after he earlier in the week said Cairo has no intention of cutting ties with Israel just because of a film.

The flare-up over the documentary, broadcast in Egypt in early March, led Infrastructure Minister Binyamin Ben-Eliezer - who is also a former commander of the Shaked unit depicted in the film - to postpone a planned visit to Cairo. Many Egyptian lawmakers called on the government to suspend the peace agreement with Israel, recall its ambassador from Tel Aviv and file war crimes charges against Israel.

Aboul Gheit on Tuesday did not directly accuse the IDF unit of killing Egyptian POWs but said Israel must conduct an immediate investigation and take all measures necessary to try the suspects over violations of international law.

The film's Israeli producer, Ran Ederlist, has said that Egyptian press reports badly distorted his documentary. He said the incident did not involve unarmed Egyptian POWs but Palestinian fighters killed in battle.

Egypt has already probed Israel about the incident. In 1995, Vice Premier Shimon Peres assigned a reserve Israeli army major to investigate it, but the investigation yielded no results.

Peace between Egypt and Israel came in 1978, ending a state of war that had lasted three decades and included four major conflicts. Today the two maintain high-level security ties, and Egypt plays an important mediating role between Israel and the Palestinians. But the peace agreement remains highly unpopular with many Egyptians.

Egyptian newspapers this month published several interviews with members of the Egyptian army in 1967 who talked about the killing of the POWs. The privately owned el-Masri el-Youm daily on Tuesday cited a former army officer in the 1967 war, identified as Osama el-Sadek, who recounted a scene after June 6, when orders were given to withdraw troops.

"We found some 40 [Egyptian] soldiers, shot in the head, and we saw prints of tanks that had passed over their bodies. It was a horrible scene," el-Sadek was quoted as saying.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Dosh on Display
An exhibit on the works of cartoonist Kariel Gardosh will open in Tel Aviv on Tuesday.
Follow the leader
Thousands of Israelis have taken up the Scandinavian sport of orienteering.
  1.   Demand? Or what? Have a hissy fit? 23:47  |  DS 13/03/07
  2.   the last time this story was printed rabin 00:15  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  3.   Yeah about the same time Arabs give a full account for Ron Arad 00:23  |  Kipperraes 14/03/07
  4.   #1 -cold hearted and typical 00:51  |  matthew 14/03/07
  5.   Probe? 01:26  |  GZLives 14/03/07
  6.   Probe something relevant like your a** 01:28  |  GZLives 14/03/07
  7.   The |Fog of War 01:42  |  Sam barsam 14/03/07
  8.   Isn`t it time for articles on Egyptian treatment of Israeli POWs? 01:44  |  Rememberin` `73 14/03/07
  9.   never mind 01:48  |  KT 14/03/07
  10.   Killings 01:59  |  Bill 14/03/07
  11.   demand probe of israeli pilots killed as shown on egyptian tv. 02:50  |  ralph 14/03/07
  12.   Liberal Jews causing problems again 04:26  |  Bill 14/03/07
  13.   Extend enquiry to dead Israeli POW`s found with their testcles in 05:22  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  14.   Ralph.The pilots were lynched.!Beaten to death by Arab mobs 05:28  |  PETER. S.M 14/03/07
  15.   Who started this war?!? 06:34  |  Kenneth 14/03/07
  16.   Egyptian crimes 08:13  |  Johann 14/03/07
  17.   Egyptian war crimes 08:22  |  Michel Norman 14/03/07
  18.   film? 08:33  |  michel 14/03/07
  19.   The Egyptians looking for excuse, I never trust that peace 08:44  |  e.m 14/03/07
  20.   Are they suicidal? 10:10  |  Ben Azai 14/03/07
  21.   Toaff syndrome 10:15  |  Ben Azai 14/03/07
  22.   Why opening old wounds....?? 11:06  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  23.   if selfish journalists insist on printing this story 11:08  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  24.   ben azai an excellent name 11:11  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  25.   "how could isrtael tv air such a programme" 11:16  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  26.   Egypt Should Break Relations With Britain And Italy 11:29  |  Ben Israel 14/03/07
  27.   1948.Jordanian army had no prisoner orders.Surrendred Gush Etzion 11:49  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  28.   ben israel your comments are too light hearted 11:54  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  29.   e.m you are wrong we must not defend such actions 11:55  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  30.   peter sm 11:58  |  gadalyah 14/03/07
  31.   to Kipperaes, ron arad 12:00  |  mehmet 14/03/07
  32.   Uri Milstein on the subject 12:02  |  Ilan 14/03/07
  33.   This Augurs Well For Saudi "Peace Plan" 12:04  |  Yonatan Netser 14/03/07
  34.   OPEN UP THE WHOLE SUBJECT ABOUT ARABS AND POWS 12:06  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  35.   DINO.Why? Obviously not an Egyptian peace move.Why indeed 12:06  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  36.   gadalyah we know what they are,they and their apologists paint a 12:50  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  37.   Let me teach you Dino #22 about Jews... 13:34  |  S 14/03/07
  38.   Israel is a real democracy 13:54  |  Jonathan S 14/03/07
  39.   All zio apollos trying to quash the 14:01  |  pro truth 14/03/07
  40.   # 35 PETER SM 14:18  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  41.   JUST BETWEEN CRIMINALS 14:20  |  indrajaya 14/03/07
  42.   # 37 S 14:26  |  Swiss (Dino) 14/03/07
  43.   Surprised? 14:30  |  Ahmose The Egyptian 14/03/07
  44.   I demand names of Egyptian Overseer`s 15:05  |  Ibn Musa 14/03/07
  45.   FREEDOM entails RESPONSIBILITY! 15:20  |  Alicia 14/03/07
  46.   "In 1995, VP Peres assigned a reserve major to investigate... 15:30  |  Yaakov Sullivan 14/03/07
  47.   We had seen one lying Idiot Toaff. Is R.Ederlist another one? 15:51  |  Vittorio 14/03/07
  48.   War Crimes? 15:51  |  Bill 14/03/07
  49.   #46 yaakov looks back 46 years and FINDS ISRAEL GUILTY 16:04  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  50.   the Hands of Equivelance 16:11  |  Ronnie Wolman 14/03/07
  51.   In Israel-think kindergarten excuses are always in fashion 16:13  |  Apartheid 14/03/07
  52.   In Israel think, when evidence of murdered enemy prisoners is 16:16  |  Apartheid 14/03/07
  53.   #52 AND OF COURSE ITS JUST ASTORY 16:23  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  54.   HISTORY HAS BEEN SURPRESSED 16:27  |  Cust Curious 14/03/07
  55.   In Apartheid-Think #51, 52 16:32  |  Clickfool 14/03/07
  56.   No way 16:32  |  W 14/03/07
  57.   TO # 46 YAACOV SULLIVAN 16:35  |  Just Curious 14/03/07
  58.   #54 AND WE WILL NEVER KNOW THE TRUTH 16:53  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  59.   Evidence for killing of prisoners from CNN, Time etc can be found 16:59  |  Apartheid 14/03/07
  60.   Pro Patria Egypt 17:02  |  Sharif Hafez 14/03/07
  61.   To#43- Not Surprised 17:06  |  Yonatan Netser 14/03/07
  62.   #55 Clicky 17:07  |  Itsik 14/03/07
  63.   TO CLICKFOOL #55 17:10  |  Just Curious 14/03/07
  64.   TO #58 PAUL HARRIS 17:33  |  Just Curious 14/03/07
  65.   THIS STORY PROVES ONE THING 17:39  |  Muhammud al-Swain 14/03/07
  66.   wow harris 17:49  |  wh 14/03/07
  67.   REMEMBERING U.S.S. LIBERTY 18:04  |  Muhammud al-Swain 14/03/07
  68.   #64 THEINCIDENT HAPPENED JUST LIKE THE US BOMBING OF CASSINO 18:28  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  69.   Egypt must investigate the 100 Sudanese refugees they murdered 18:32  |  Ken Jurist 14/03/07
  70.   #67 SWAINE " IT WAS OUR BELIEF THAT ..." 18:34  |  paul harris 14/03/07
  71.   TO #65 MUHAMMUD 18:41  |  Just Curious 14/03/07
  72.   Muhammud al-Swain, Forcefully converted from Coptic or pure Arab. 18:51  |  Chanan 14/03/07
  73.   Bad diction 18:58  |  Colin Wright 14/03/07
  74.   re `Liberal Jews causing problems again` 18:59  |  Colin Wright 14/03/07
  75.   re # 46 Mr. Sulivan Untruthful statement P2 20:40  |  Alberto Cohen 14/03/07
  76.   re # 46 Mr. Sulivan Untruthful statement P1 21:06  |  Alberto Cohen 14/03/07
  77.   Swiss #22 - This is the purpose 21:12  |  Moises 14/03/07
  78.   APARTHEID.In your think Arabs do no wrong.Thats apartheid 21:13  |  PETERSM 14/03/07
  79.   APARTEID.Nasty things happen in war tell the Arabs. 21:21  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  80.   PRO Patria Egypt.Can we expect the same probe from Egypt 21:24  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  81.   Bill # 12 who probably is out a job by a Hymie 21:30  |  The Equalizer 14/03/07
  82.   APARTHEID.Since when do you speak for what Israelis think? 21:33  |  PETER SM 14/03/07
  83.   Main terrorist behind 9/11 was Egyptian Mohammad Atta 21:37  |  Ken Jurist 14/03/07
  84.   An Interesting Admission by Egypt- 2nd Attempt 22:03  |  Chick Corea 14/03/07
  85.