Subscribe to Print Edition | Sun., May 06, 2007 Iyyar 18, 5767 | | Israel Time: 20:49 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Saudi Arabia's Foreign Minister Prince Saud al-Faisal, speaking at the International Conference for Support to Lebanon in Paris on January 25. (Reuters)
Last update - 04:14 14/03/2007
Arab leaders rule out amending Saudi proposal
By News Agencies

With Israeli leaders showing renewed interest in a regional peace plan, heavyweight Arab countries said Tuesday the land-for-peace offer should not be changed during an Arab summit in Saudi Arabia later this month.

Last week, the Arab League said it would relaunch the 2002 initiative in an effort to end the decades-long conflict with Israel. But Arab leaders said the peace deal would not include changes Israel has been pushing for.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni has said that Israel would not accept the Arab peace plan as it is, but would ask that any reference be dropped on the issue of the right of the Palestinians displaced in the 1948 War of Independence to return to their homes inside Israel. On Sunday, Prime Minster Ehud Olmert told his Cabinet he was prepared to treat the Saudi proposal seriously.

Advertisement

Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Syria on Tuesday explained their reasons for turning down Israel's request to amend the proposal.

"We have the Arab peace plan and we are committed to it as a whole. Talk about amending it is baseless," Syrian Vice President Farouk al-Sharaa said Tuesday after meeting with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak. "What we want is returning all the occupied land including Jerusalem."

Mubarak's spokesman Suleiman Awwad said Egypt also rejects the Israeli demands for amending the plan.

"Israel cannot pick and choose from the initiative and then jump into establishing normal relations with Arabs," Awwad said. "The Arab plan offers full withdrawal for full peace."

"We have no desire to negotiate over this," said Saudi foreign minister, Saud Al-Faisal. "They accept the resolution and then they talk about putting preconditions that should be accepted before negotiations or discussions or even the acceptance of the proposal. This is not a good
way to do business.

The initiative is a set of principles that would offer Israel full recognition and permanent peace with the Arab states in return for Israel's withdrawal to 1967 lines, the establishment of an independent Palestine with East Jerusalem as its capital and an agreed, just solution to the issue of Palestinian refugees in accordance with UN General Assembly Resolution 194 of 1948.

"There will be no retreat, and no change to the Arab initiative, because the Palestinian people have got rights, detailed in the initiative ... such rights must be protected," Egypt's Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit said.

Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni is expected to discuss the initiative during her meeting Wednesday in Washington with Rice, who is scheduled to fly to the region next week in a fresh bid to revive efforts by the Quartet of Mideast peace negotiators - the U.S., EU, U.N. and Russia - to try to
jump-start the Palestinian-Israeli peace talks.

Aboul Gheit said that Rice will meet with foreign ministries of Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and United Arab Emirates on March 25 in Aswan, southern Egypt. He also said that she will back to the region in April.

Saudis slam Israel over peace talk preconditions
Saudi Arabia criticized Israel on Tuesday for setting preconditions to Middle East peace talks and urged it to accept the Arab initiative first and discuss details later.

"We only hear of conditions from Israel about everything, but no acceptance. You cannot have negotiations like that, you accept the proposals then you talk about this," al-Faisal said.

"This seems a ludicrous way of doing business," he said at a news conference with visiting European Union foreign policy chief Javier Solana.

A 2002 Arab League summit in Beirut adopted a Saudi initiative offering Israel normal ties with Arab countries in return for full withdrawal from land it occupied in the 1967 Middle East war.

On Sunday, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert appeared to open the door to exploring whether the Saudi plan could aid the quest for an Israeli-Palestinian settlement. The initiative, he said, "is a subject we would be willing to treat seriously."

But Israel has said it cannot accept some terms in the proposal, including the total withdrawal from territory captured in the 1967 Six Day War and the return of Palestinian refugees to Israel.

Diplomats in Riyadh, which hosted Palestinian crisis talks in the holy city of Mecca last month, speculate that Saudi Arabia wants to revive the initiative.

The Mecca meeting led to a unity government deal between Islamist group Hamas and Palestinian Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas's Fatah faction, and ended fighting between the two groups.

Prime Minister Ismail Haniyeh, who belongs to Hamas, said on Saturday he and Abbas would travel to Saudi Arabia after the government is formed for a summit to revive the plan.

Prince Saud praised the EU for welcoming the Mecca deal. "We look forward to the (EU) support ... for the Palestinian government," he said.

Solana said the EU would grant more aid to the Palestinians this year than in 2006. Israel has been withholding tax revenues the Palestinian Authority uses to pay government staff since Hamas won parliamentary elections in January 2006.

Meanwhile, a Hamas source said Tuesday that part of the $100 million in tax revenues transferred by Israel to Abbas went to pay security services, including members of a Hamas-led force.

Western powers have also frozen direct aid to the Hamas-led government.

"We will not let the Palestinian people down," Solana said.

Lebanon crisis
Prince Saud hinted little progress had been made in ending a rift between the Lebanese government and opposition parties, led by the Shi'ite Muslim Hezbollah, after a rare visit to Riyadh by Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad earlier this month.

Hezbollah is backed by Syria and Iran, while Saudi Arabia, the United States and France support the government.

"We hope that Iran, whatever influence it has over some of the factions in Lebanon, will work for normaliztion so that negotiations can be carried out between protagonists, without feeling they have a gun pointed at their heads," he said.

Solana said he would discuss with Syrian President Bashar al-Assad in Damascus on Wednesday how to improve the situation in Lebanon.

He said the next meeting of the Quartet of Middle East peace brokers - the United States, European Union, Russia and the United Nations -- would be held in the region with Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabi and the United Arab Emirates also attending.

Diplomatic sources say the meeting will be held in Egypt in the second half of April.

Related articles

  • Israel warns EU concessions on Hamas will lead to 'more terror'
  • Livni, Rice to discuss Saudi initiative in Washington meeting
  • ANALYSIS: The Saudi plan will advance the peace process

  • Bookmark to del.icio.us
    Gems from a scholar
    One of Yiddish's greatest writers tells a narrative of Russia under the czars.
    Lag Ba'Omer
    In this week's Torah portion, the great bonfires that mark this day are shrouded in mystery.
      1.   V ERY GOOD SO SAUDI RECOGNISES ISRAEL FIRST 18:32  |  paul harris 13/03/07
      2.   israeli acceptance 18:41  |  mike 13/03/07
      3.   Saudi Arabia 18:44  |  Edifice 13/03/07
      4.   Saudis need to be overthrown 18:46  |  Sa 13/03/07
      5.   Israel rejecting the road map and Saudi plan 18:46  |  ILGWU Houses 13/03/07
      6.   Saudi precondition for peace: Israel`s suicide 18:54  |  Yacov 13/03/07
      7.   Saudis blowing hot air 18:57  |  Dov 13/03/07
      8.   Always a dictatorship 18:57  |  Avi Cohen 13/03/07
      9.   Saudi peace conference 19:01  |  Sam 13/03/07
      10.   Sorry all. What I really mean is.... 19:06  |  Avi Cohen 13/03/07
      11.   NO to Saudi Crap 19:08  |  Brod 13/03/07
      12.   arab market negotiations. dealer asks 100 offer 1 then way later 19:13  |  rallph 13/03/07
      13.   let me get this straight 19:13  |  vik 13/03/07
      14.   We are both angry? 19:21  |  From the Moon 13/03/07
      15.   Saudi Arabia 19:26  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/03/07
      16.   It is only fair that the Palestinians be allowed to return 19:26  |  Ted 13/03/07
      17.   Israel Must Be Forced To Accept Peace 19:30  |  Bullwinkle J. Moose 13/03/07
      18.   # 1 this question should be for u if u have brains at all 19:36  |  arab 13/03/07
      19.   can someone on our cousins` side explain something? 19:38  |  natan 13/03/07
      20.   Call their bluff 19:44  |  robert 13/03/07
      21.   #10 Downing Street Avi? 19:49  |  natan 13/03/07
      22.   no desire for peace on israeli side 19:50  |  john 13/03/07
      23.   The Arab Way in "Business" 19:51  |  Johnny 13/03/07
      24.   Cavete 19:54  |  eh-oop 13/03/07
      25.   not a victim! 19:55  |  david 13/03/07
      26.   And I Hope He Makes That Clear To Rice 19:57  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      27.   Saudis slam Israel 19:58  |  Sharonelle 13/03/07
      28.   Negotiate Changes to Arab Initiative with Abbas 20:13  |  Mozie 13/03/07
      29.   SULLIVAN 20:14  |  Cipora Julianna Kohn 13/03/07
      30.   The Saudi Plan 20:21  |  gabriel b.-a. 13/03/07
      31.   Preconditions 20:29  |  JW 13/03/07
      32.   But you, madame, are not #29 20:36  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      33.   Not 2002!!! 20:38  |  Blogowitz 13/03/07
      34.   gabriel b-a, of course not! Address the Proposal!! #30 20:40  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      35.   Oh come on! 20:45  |  Sam 13/03/07
      36.   A translation: "First accept our conditions and only then... 20:51  |  Ephraim 13/03/07
      37.   Israel is right 20:59  |  mohammed Hussein 13/03/07
      38.   Peace + Israel = Oxymoron 21:10  |  Khalil 13/03/07
      39.   mohammad Hussein in riyad #37 21:19  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      40.   To: paul harris # 1 21:19  |  Gabi 13/03/07
      41.   Preconditions, JW, #31 21:20  |  Sharonelle 13/03/07
      42.   The job of Condaleeza Rice 21:22  |  Sam 13/03/07
      43.   FIRST the Saudis had a proposal then THEY changed it under pressu 21:23  |  PETER SM 13/03/07
      44.   Saudi/Israeli negotiations #26 21:24  |  Sharonelle 13/03/07
      45.   Israeli Stupidity Strikes Again 21:36  |  Tod Zuckerman 13/03/07
      46.   Sullivan, you`ve made your point; you hate Israel 21:40  |  McQueen 13/03/07
      47.   why is asking for terrorism to stop too much to ask for?!?!?! 21:44  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      48.   if arabs cant meet simple requests like no terrorism, why bother? 21:46  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      49.   Arabs only conditions for peace are ones they KNOW are impossible 21:47  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      50.   ARABS ALWAYS AVOIDING PEACE 21:48  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      51.   PEACE IS A TWO WAY STREET!! When do the arabs have to start????? 21:49  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      52.   NAME A SINGLE THING ARABS HAVE DONE FOR PEACE!!! 21:50  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      53.   One point in Saudi proposal unacceptable 21:50  |  Esther 13/03/07
      54.   sullivan #39...jews didnt leave...they were KICKED OUT! 21:52  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      55.   What is there to discuss? 21:53  |  Salty 13/03/07
      56.   Arabs are not remotely capable of peace 21:53  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      57.   Yaakov, how does one make peace with terrorists who dont want it? 21:56  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      58.   Not Israel`s pre conditions but Saudia`s 21:58  |  Jasmine Murphy 13/03/07
      59.   ilgwu house taken over by anti israel forces-sad 22:00  |  larry from maine 13/03/07
      60.   McQueen, get a life! #46 22:01  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      61.   ted 22:04  |  larry from maine 13/03/07
      62.   Who really wants peace? 22:04  |  U.S. 13/03/07
      63.   Esther on refugees and the Saudi proposal #53 22:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      64.   You are all missing the point 22:07  |  The Realist 13/03/07
      65.   re: Shimon #50 22:16  |  Paulo 13/03/07
      66.   And So Too is....Shimon #57 22:17  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      67.   Israeli preconditions 22:21  |  Tosefta 13/03/07
      68.   Saudi Initiative 22:22  |  Carey Jaffee 13/03/07
      69.   No Saudi pre conditions 22:23  |  Najdt 13/03/07
      70.   @8, avi cohen? you are illiterate idiot, criminals rabin 22:24  |  vladimir 13/03/07
      71.   Yaakov Sulliva would gladly walk israel into oblivion if he could 22:25  |  SHIMON 13/03/07
      72.   Saudi Plan 22:29  |  kiwgirl 13/03/07
      73.   @17, bulwincle idiot, how can you enforce 242 on israel? 22:31  |  vlad 13/03/07
      74.   @18, arab, continue and you will be in misery 22:32  |  vladimir 13/03/07
      75.   #39 Sullivan 22:33  |  Nice bloke 13/03/07
      76.   the realist on his history #61 22:35  |  Yaakov Sullivan 13/03/07
      77.   No preconditions? Accept Saudi terms 22:36  |  Paul Freedman 13/03/07
      78.   Israeli preconditions 22:39  |  Tosefta 13/03/07
      79.   #18 stupid Arab 22:43  |  Alex 13/03/07
      80.   What is Saudi Arabia anyway? 22:43  |  Sheik Wachad 13/03/07
      81.   Ted Is it fair to return to Israel 22:46  |  Aby 13/03/07