Subscribe to Print Edition | Thu., March 15, 2007 Adar 25, 5767 | | Israel Time: 02:57 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Anyone but Bibi
By Yoel Marcus

Two events are coming up at the end of this month: One, the first anniversary of the elections that brought Ehud Olmert to power, and two, the interim findings of the Winograd Committee.

Since the military has assumed responsibility for its share in the events of this past summer, and Dan Halutz, Udi Adam and Gal Hirsch have gone home, Winograd will presumably focus on the political echelon. It is highly unlikely that the politicos will be vindicated, as they were by the Agranat Commission. A bungle by any other name is still a bungle.

Maariv's prediction that, "It's going to be an earthquake," harks back to the expression used in the days of the Yom Kippur War, as the giants of the "1948 generation" tottered on the brink of the biggest fiasco of them all.

Advertisement

In the era of giants, then-minister of education Zalman Aran swore that he would follow David Ben-Gurion with his eyes closed. "But I peek every once in a while to make sure Ben-Gurion has his eyes open," he sagely added.

In the era of giants, Menachem Begin gave up all of Sinai without hemming and hawing and recognized the legitimate rights of the Palestinians in order to make peace with Egypt.

In the era of giants, Yitzhak Rabin's hand did not tremble as he signed the Oslo accords with Yasser Arafat.

So what has gone wrong? Why the loss of faith in our leadership today? The answer is simple enough: The heirs of the giants have disappointed, over and over again. The higher the pretensions of our shining political meteors, the lower they have fallen.

Benjamin Netanyahu beat Shimon Peres, one of the last remaining 1948 giants. He promised to form a government that would strive for excellence, to appoint ministers who were experts in their field, et cetera, et cetera. But he sowed the seeds of adversity and hatred, got himself involved in a slew of scandals and was beaten by Ehud Barak three years later.

These days, when Olmert is down to a mortifying 2 percent in the surveys, it is worth remembering that Bibi, even in defeat, won 43 percent of the ballot, which is close to a million and a half votes.

Barak, the Israeli army's most decorated soldier, who plays the piano and can take watches apart and put them back together, never got close to figuring out what made the political mechanism tick. With his arrogant conduct, it was a cinch for Ariel Sharon, the last of the 1948 club, to trounce him at the polls.

As someone who had done and seen it all as a warrior and a leader, Sharon took the most important historical step since the peace agreement with Egypt. He sent the dream of a greater Israel to the deep freeze. Through the disengagement, evacuating settlements in Gaza, and by embracing the Bush vision of two states, he established a new national agenda.

Olmert's ascent to power, after Sharon lapsed into a coma, was a stroke of luck. As compensation for not being awarded the finance portfolio and getting stuck with commerce and industry, Reuven Rivlin intervened on his behalf and got Sharon to sign a paper giving him the title of acting prime minister.

Olmert is considered a savvy and seasoned political activist, but as default prime minister he has not shown he is made of the stuff of leaders. He has operated on borrowed time, as Sharon's "successor." Pledging to continue Sharon's path, he said he would go beyond disengagement, to honest-to-goodness convergence.

But the second war in Lebanon sent him tumbling to the lowest level of popularity of any Israeli prime minister yet - which proves that the people are not only disappointed, but downright angry at his performance, including his cynical appointment of Amir Peretz as defense minister.

Meanwhile, the public is living off leaks, real or phony, from the Winograd investigation. Even if the committee goes easy on the political echelon, it will not come out clean in the eyes of the public. Maybe the public will push for elections and maybe it won't, but calls for the resignation of Olmert and Peretz are a distinct possibility.

One thing you can be sure of is that Netanyahu will try to scrape up 61 votes from here, there and everywhere, in the hopes of becoming prime minister without elections. There's an old Polish proverb that fits perfectly for those in favor of a Netanyahu comeback: "In the land of the blind, even a one-eyed man is a king."

In the surveys, Netanyahu is chalking up a proportional majority. But a party with all of 12 seats is not going to establish a government that will lead us anywhere, all the more so by recycling a leader who was toppled eight years ago, on the pretext that he has changed. In what way has he changed? He's not a radical right-winger anymore? He quit smoking Cohiba cigars?

If Olmert is forced to resign, Kadima, the largest party in the Knesset, can still search for someone in its ranks to put together a government without recourse to elections. Who it is, hardly matters. Just as long as it's not Bibi.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Darfur to Yad Vashem
13 Sudanese refugees who visited Yad Vashem said it reminds them of their struggle.
Bauhaus, our house
Last week, investors paid $17.5 million for a plot on Hayarkon St. in Tel Aviv.
  1.   mr. netanyahu is not good for israel 09:40  |  saul a. readner 13/03/07
  2.   So what has gone wrong? 09:54  |  Ralph 13/03/07
  3.   anyone but marcus-he hasn`t changed 09:55  |  joe 13/03/07
  4.   Anyone Wise Enough To Be Competent Wouldn`t Run 10:13  |  Paqid Yirmeyahu 13/03/07
  5.   joe and the degrees 10:17  |  saul a. readner 13/03/07
  6.   And yet Bibi will be the nezt PM. 10:26  |  Ron 13/03/07
  7.   BIBI for PM 10:49  |  RAB 13/03/07
  8.   #7 Very Well Said 11:34  |  BiBi for PM 13/03/07
  9.   natanyahu is not the man israel needs 11:45  |  yirmiyahu 13/03/07
  10.   Olmert`s last good deed 11:49  |  Eli 13/03/07
  11.   "slew of scandals" = yellow journalism 12:07  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 13/03/07
  12.   Anybody... 12:19  |  Spoon 13/03/07
  13.   "Who it is hardly matters. Just as long as its not Bibi." 12:19  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 13/03/07
  14.   Peres was never a giant - he was and is a deluded gnome 12:26  |  Jo 13/03/07
  15.   Peres was never a giant - he was and is a deluded gnome 12:26  |  Jo 13/03/07
  16.   Marcus was pro-Itnatkut, proOslo idiot: Haaretz should fire him! 12:28  |  Ronny 13/03/07
  17.   Kadima is finished but Marcus is too stupid to realize it 12:29  |  Adrian 13/03/07
  18.   to rab (no. 7) and his compagnon at no. 8 12:29  |  saul a. readner 13/03/07
  19.   Kadima is finished but Marcus is too stupid to realize it 12:29  |  Adrian 13/03/07
  20.   Very revisionist 13:26  |  Benlolo 13/03/07
  21.   barak not barak obama 13:29  |  yirmiyahu 13/03/07
  22.   Begin & Giants 13:31  |  michael cohen 13/03/07
  23.   Just as long as it`s not Bibi. 13:32  |  Alissa 13/03/07
  24.   The Perfect Solution 13:56  |  Kate 13/03/07
  25.   MARK REGEV TO RUN 14:20  |  Nicole 13/03/07
  26.   Yoel Marcus is wrong 14:39  |  Brod 13/03/07
  27.   Bibi is a great leader in every way!! 14:41  |  dr eric 13/03/07
  28.   Despite all that`s happened, and certainly a lot 14:52  |  Smadar 13/03/07
  29.   ABA and ABB 14:52  |  Ronnie Wolman 13/03/07
  30.   Can it be DSK from France ? 15:04  |  Frederique 13/03/07
  31.   Bibi-fans 16:41  |  Somebody from Europe 13/03/07
  32.   BIBI 17:03  |  MAHIR ZARA 13/03/07
  33.   WOW!!! So much Hardwash from a journalist 17:12  |  Norman 13/03/07
  34.   Indeed, stop smoking and start thinking 17:58  |  avi 13/03/07
  35.   Netanyahu is good for Jews 18:33  |  Yakov 13/03/07
  36.   Netanyahu is good for....... NOTHING 19:34  |  Me 13/03/07
  37.   Marcus didn`t even give credit for the economic success 20:45  |  Clear as Water 13/03/07
  38.   Kate 24 I loved your post, I second that 20:54  |  Clear as Water 13/03/07
  39.   Bibi is up to no good 21:34  |  Frederique 13/03/07
  40.   Anything but Haaretz 21:50  |  Jake 13/03/07
  41.   Dwarfs in the land of giants 22:00  |  Baz Mann 13/03/07
  42.   #41 B AZ ID LOVE TO KNOW WHERE IT WILL BE 25OR 50YEARS FROM NOW 23:09  |  paul harris 13/03/07
  43.   Peres, a giant? A giant LIAR. 23:10  |  Pinchas 13/03/07
  44.   Israel running out of choices 23:40  |  Racon-tour 13/03/07
  45.   I`m for Bibi 23:51  |  rich 13/03/07
  46.   Oh dear, the same Netanyahu...... 00:11  |  Esther 14/03/07
  47.   Chas-ve-chalila Bibi..... 00:13  |  Esther 14/03/07
  48.   Bibi for PM -- or Lieberman!! 00:48  |  Steven 14/03/07
  49.   i love bibi 01:05  |  bibi 14/03/07
  50.   Marcus,go away.Everything you had praised brought disaster 01:54  |  Absolute Sweden 14/03/07
  51.   A fool`s choice.... 04:06  |  Blogowitz 14/03/07
  52.   whatever leader Israel pick .. 04:35  |  Roy Galut 14/03/07
  53.   Our Leadership 05:16  |  simon 14/03/07
  54.   So Peretz, Livni, Barak, Halutz, recycled failed leaders are OK? 05:27  |  Chanan 14/03/07
  55.   The light-.welght Yoel Marcus 05:33  |  Aba 14/03/07
  56.   Bibi would be a great choice. 06:01  |  Vittorio 14/03/07
  57.   to Frlederique Paris 09:20  |  Ralph 14/03/07
  58.   Who should replace Olmert? 10:23  |  Clickfool 14/03/07
  59.   Marcus cannot say who, but just not Bibi 01:22  |  David G 15/03/07
 Today Online
Danny Rubinstein: No Palestinian state without East J'lem
Responses: 311
Peace Now: 32% of settlement land is owned by Palestinians
Responses: 168
Egyptian FM demands Israel probe alleged 1967 POW killings
Responses: 99
Solana: EU backs Syrian aim to regain Golan Heights
Responses: 204
Controversial Israeli song allowed into Eurovision contest
Responses: 67


More Headlines
01:23 Abbas, Haniyeh finalize PA unity government deal despite fresh clashes
23:39 Peretz tells UN: Lebanon cease-fire still not fully implemented
02:38 Israel, PA, Jordan agree to build joint agroindustrial park in West Bank
20:58 Solana: EU supports Syrian initiative to regain Golan Heights
00:10 Anti-Semitic incidents down in U.S. for second straight year
21:09 Bill would allow cab drivers to remove passengers without ID
00:12 T.A. Stock Exchange to close Sunday due to Bank of Israel strike
02:14 Teachers' Union inclined to resume talks, halt strikes next week
22:38 Iraqi troops raid Palestinian compound in Baghdad, arrest 15
23:04 Beinisch warns of campaign to erode public's faith in the courts
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved