Subscribe to Print Edition | Wed., March 14, 2007 Adar 24, 5767 | | Israel Time: 15:42 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
On the road from Mecca to Riyadh
By Akiva Eldar

The news that Ehud Olmert expects Mahmoud Abbas not to include his "associates" in the new government suggests that the prime minister recognizes that the Palestinian unity government is a done deal. He has apparently read the intelligence assessments, according to which the concessions Hamas was driven to make in Mecca have led Arab states to recognize it as a legitimate ruling authority and thus undermined the stance of the Quartet.

Nonetheless, even though the Quartet itself announced over the weekend that it was sufficient for the new Palestinian government to "reflect" (instead of "adopt") the three preconditions for lifting the boycott, Israel insists on fighting a battle that has already been decided by the Mecca agreement. Even though the caravan has passed , the government continues to lay mines along the road the Palestinians are taking toward a unity government.

More than 13 years after the signing of the Oslo accords, which aimed to divide the country anew, the bypass method continues to contribute to deadly accidents. Yitzhak Rabin paved bypass roads the length and breadth of the occupied territories, in order to keep all the settlements in place "until a final settlement." The result: The settlers took advantage of the generosity of successive governments in order to expand their boundaries.

Advertisement

Ariel Sharon forced the Palestinians to bypass an "irrelevant" chairman Yasser Arafat by way of selecting an "irrelevant" prime minister and having to contend with a unilateral disengagement. The result: the Palestinians realized that the only thing the camp of pragmatists, led by Abbas, can be counted on to provide are the benefits of a government to its associates. The Hamas victory was just a matter of time.

Now it's Olmert's turn to pave a Hamas-bypass route. In order to get rid of Hamas, the prime minister is even willing to bypass Mecca and go straight to the upcoming summit in Riyadh. It has been five years since the Arab League first offered Israel normal relations with all its members in exchange for Israel's withdrawal from all the occupied territories, and suddenly Olmert has discovered that the proposal "has positive elements." He is even hopeful that the day will come when we will also be able to talk with the Palestinian Authority. That will be possible, of course, only after Hamas surrenders unconditionally to Israel's demands, or the Palestinians change their government. Whichever comes first.

More than a year after it entrenched its position as a popular grassroots movement, Hamas will not voluntarily disappear from the scene. After the entire Arab League gave its backing to the unity government agreement, without Hamas having had to specifically recognize Israel, no boycott can force Khaled Meshal to utter the magic words, which he considers sacrilege. Now, even his greatest enemies in Fatah cannot blame Meshal of blocking the way to diplomatic negotiations with Israel.

In the absence of a diplomatic solution, we should not expect calm. The territories will burn, the Qassam rockets will fly, and the IDF will return to the Gaza Strip. After Hamas' signing of the Mecca agreement, Egypt and Jordan will find it difficult to carry on with their peace-as-usual, and Israel's fragile relations with them will be in danger of collapse. Referring to these types of options, General David Petraeus, the commander of U.S. forces in Iraq, said last week that the army cannot provide a solution to an insurgency of the kind taking place in Iraq, and that while military operations were essential to improving security, they are not enough, and must be augmented by a political dimension.

In theory, Olmert's offer to hold "regional negotiations" with the Arab League on the basis of the Saudi initiative provides that "political dimension" big-time. But if Israel can have talks with the Arab League, why not hold talks with the Palestinian government, which is a legitimate member of that organization? Could it be that Olmert expects the league's secretary, Amr Moussa, to bypass the Palestinian government and conduct, in its place, negotiations with Israel on the exchange of territory and arrangements in Jerusalem?

What does a man with two percent public support have to lose? If Hamas agrees to discuss a final settlement with us, who will stop him? If he avoids doing so - the entire Arab League will stand against him.

Instead of making the same mistake with bypass roads leading into an abyss, why not take the high road for a change, the road that Saudi Arabia's King Abdullah has paved from Mecca to Riyadh?

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Flower power
Environmentalists are putting on display the wild orchids of Hanita Forest.
Strike season
Brought about by the gov't's weakness, Israel is about to experience a wave of strikes.
  1.   Akiva Eldar: "Just talk to Hamas". Would you, 10:38  |  Leah Yavin 12/03/07
  2.   Olmert may have nothing to lose but Israel 10:40  |  Yacov 12/03/07
  3.   Akiva Eldar is a spam-bot 10:55  |  Xaxam 12/03/07
  4.   ISRAEL MUST TALK TO HAMAS 11:17  |  indrajaya 12/03/07
  5.   Olmert Talking to hamas 11:19  |  Jaffa 12/03/07
  6.   Leah Yavin 11:20  |  A.M. 12/03/07
  7.   Eldar repeats the same mistake ad nauseum 11:40  |  Shalom Freedman 12/03/07
  8.   A.M. and Hamas recognition 11:49  |  Leah Yavin 12/03/07
  9.   You answer Akiva 11:51  |  Steven 12/03/07
  10.   Like talking to the Nazis. 12:08  |  Yacov 12/03/07
  11.   Talking to Hamas 12:15  |  Michael 12/03/07
  12.   NO NO NO NO NO 12:15  |  Nicole 12/03/07
  13.   Eldar needs a clue and a brain!!!!! 12:35  |  Chema 12/03/07
  14.   "Do you recognize Israel`s right to exist" asked a few minutes 12:41  |  Nirah 12/03/07
  15.   Great proposition! 13:20  |  Leon Rosgarten 12/03/07
  16.   Israel`s request for a right to exist is too much to ask for? 13:25  |  Daniel Mendelsohn 12/03/07
  17.   you are so wrong it is laughable except that this situation is re 13:33  |  ralph 12/03/07
  18.   On the road of destruction 13:44  |  Jonathan S 12/03/07
  19.   Olmert is just slow 14:35  |  Tosefta 12/03/07
  20.   Why? 14:41  |  FOX 12/03/07
  21.   Leon, I missed you 14:51  |  FOX 12/03/07
  22.   Does Hamas want to Speak to Israel????? 15:20  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/03/07
  23.   Of course Arab League didn`t demand Hamas recognize Israel 16:06  |  McQueen 12/03/07
  24.   Why talk to a govt. that doesn`t abide by agreements? 16:08  |  McQueen 12/03/07
  25.   What Israel would lose by talking to hamas 16:31  |  KUTW 12/03/07
  26.   Correction to Eldar: No talking with Hamas 16:43  |  Tosefta 12/03/07
  27.   CONFUSING MOBOCRACY WITH DEMOCRACY 16:44  |  B 12/03/07
  28.   Tosefta: Karl Marx and the means of production 17:29  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/03/07
  29.   mines along the road 17:34  |  KUTW 12/03/07
  30.   The Arab League plan vs UN resolutions 17:38  |  KUTW 12/03/07
  31.   The Arab League and Israel?s recognition 17:41  |  KUTW 12/03/07
  32.   Not a matter of Hamas appetite (Ronnie Wolman #28) 17:46  |  Tosefta 12/03/07
  33.   Ridiculous statement 17:51  |  Liz Biggin 12/03/07
  34.   Olmert has already caved 17:55  |  Twogunz 12/03/07
  35.   Tosefta: Managing the Fundamentals 18:32  |  Ronnie Wolman 12/03/07
  36.   Abbas the weak (Ronnie Wolman #35) 18:55  |  Tosefta 12/03/07
  37.   Moderation of Hamas; past, present, and future 18:58  |  Tosefta 12/03/07
  38.   From Mecca to Riyadh 18:58  |  P. J. Casey 12/03/07
  39.   MR Akiva Eldar is definitely right. 18:58  |  Fairman 12/03/07
  40.   4 - Hamas wants to destroy Israel and does not recognize Israel 19:22  |  Bruriah Sarah 12/03/07
  41.   16 - Israel has the superior Claim 19:25  |  Bruriah Sarah 12/03/07
  42.   31 - Mecca Plan does not recognize Israel`s right to exist 19:30  |  Bruriah Sarah 12/03/07
  43.   31 - Mecca Plan does not recognize Israel`s right to exist 19:31  |  Bruriah Sarah 12/03/07
  44.   Akiva Eldar is right - talk to Moderates 20:13  |  Smadar 12/03/07
  45.   #31 KUTW 20:15  |  Boycott 12/03/07
  46.   Tosefta or Golem in Lala land #37 20:19  |  FOX 12/03/07
  47.   #33 Liz Biggin 20:22  |  Boycott 12/03/07
  48.   #41 Bruriah Sarah 20:25  |  Boycott 12/03/07
  49.   Leave Akiva in peace! He is pregnant! 21:36  |  Absolute Sweden 12/03/07
  50.   to FOX #21 21:47  |  Leon Rosgarten 12/03/07
  51.   45. Boycott 22:56  |  KUTW 12/03/07
  52.   tosefta and "pavlovian reaction" 23:01  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  53.   tosefta and "pavlovian reaction" 23:01  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  54.   downers in tveira 23:05  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  55.   tosefta "hamas does NOT WANT to talk to israel" 23:10  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  56.   tosefta "as the polls show the pals want peace" 23:13  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  57.   pollster in tveira 23:16  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  58.   tosefta loves repeating the "geneva agreements" 23:21  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  59.   tosefta "with peace conditions there will be 23:24  |  gadalyah 12/03/07
  60.   #32 Tosefta, very good suggestion about the clause 23:32  |  Smadar 12/03/07
  61.   This cynical article 00:02  |  Dr.Ari Nir 13/03/07
  62.   #46 Rabid Fox on the loose 00:08  |  Tosefta 13/03/07
  63.   to FOX #21 00:27  |  Leon Rosgarten 13/03/07
  64.   Adults talk, children sulk. 01:07  |  Deborah 13/03/07
  65.   of course we should talk to hamas 01:33  |  dr eric 13/03/07
  66.   Coined in 1964 01:52  |  Scharker Yid 13/03/07
  67.   Reply to No 10 01:54  |  Abe 13/03/07
  68.   Right wing fear mongers 02:18  |  Mitch Cohen 13/03/07
  69.   Right wing fear mongers 02:22  |  Mitch Cohen 13/03/07
  70.   #47 Boycott 02:41  |  Liz Biggin 13/03/07
  71.   Thanks Smadar #53 02:52  |  Tosefta 13/03/07
  72.   are you nuts? 03:21  |  Daniel 13/03/07
  73.   Eldar - Either a Male Amira Haas or a Moron 03:29  |  Tod Zuckerman 13/03/07
  74.   gadalyah #50 -57 (gadalyah/flashman???) no respite for Tosefta 04:16  |  Smadar 13/03/07
  75.   Are you kidding me? 04:29  |  Soon Aliyah 13/03/07
  76.   gadalyah (oops, jumped to post #58 - very funny) 04:47  |  Smadar 13/03/07
  77.   Bad mistake (Smadar #76 re Flushman/Gadalyah) 06:32  |  Tosefta 13/03/07
  78.   #24 mcqueen 06:35  |  Racon-tour 13/03/07
  79.   what is wrong with these lefties? 07:31  |  Dr Eric 13/03/07
  80.   Leon Rosengarten, comrade #63 08:13  |  FOX 13/03/07
  81.   Toosi-Fetta 9pm LA time 08:23  |  FOX 13/03/07
  82.   An intelligent analysis at last, but... 10:46  |  Wolfram 13/03/07
  83.   Israel must talk to Hamas? 12:37  |  Michael 13/03/07
  84.   Road 2 peace is in the Bible,not in Mecca 16:36  |  sam 13/03/07
  85.   Nicole #12 19:19  |  Chicago Arab 13/03/07