Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 12, 2007 Adar 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:46 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
Last update - 11:21 11/03/2007
German chief cardinal apologizes for 'Ramallah ghetto' remarks
By Eli Ashkenazi, Haaretz Correspondent

The head of the German Bishops Conference has conceded that some statements made by members on a recent visit to Israel and the West Bank were "inappropriate."

Cardinal Karl Lehmann responded a few days ago to a letter sent to him by Avner Shalev, chairman of the Yad Vashem Martyrs and Heroes Remembrance Authority, protesting a statement made a short time after the group visited Yad Vashem earlier this month, and then traveled to Ramallah.

"In the morning we saw the Warsaw Ghetto and now it's the Ramallah Ghetto," one of the bishops said.

"In light of the painful reality of the separation fence," Lehman wrote in his letter to Shalev, "some of the members of the delegation said harsh tings, some of which were not appropriate."

In his letter Lehmann reiterated the heavy responsibility the German people bear due to the Holocaust, and that even those who expressed themselves harshly recognized Israel's right to defend itself.

He said the bishop who made the statement had no intention to compare the past and the present and wrote, "It is impossible to compare current problems with the murder of the Jewish people."

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israelis pay more
Average households pay NIS 430 in annual bank fees for regular checking accounts
Changing banking rules
Israel Discount Bank is now in the hands of Matthew Bronfman and his group.
  1.   Lol 02:22  |  Colin Wright 11/03/07
  2.   Is he against the two state solution ? 02:36  |  Tom 11/03/07
  3.   The rotten fruits of Yad Vashem`s own Prof.Bauer`s Leftie politic 02:45  |  Absolute Sweden 11/03/07
  4.   Less for the love of Humanity and more for the hatred of the Jews 05:03  |  Shalom 11/03/07
  5.   To Tom #1 05:18  |  Jerry 11/03/07
  6.   re #3 "Less from the love of humanity..." 05:59  |  Colin Wright 11/03/07
  7.   Tom, this is an act of rape, not two-state solution 07:51  |  Jerry 11/03/07
  8.   Germany should apologize to the Palestinian people 07:56  |  khalid 11/03/07
  9.   Ghetos 08:02  |  Abu Amar 11/03/07
  10.   I AM SORRY 08:24  |  TOBIA 11/03/07
  11.   With this appology should come Carter`s appology and the appology 09:00  |  Nadav 11/03/07
  12.   #8 Please TELL ME 09:05  |  TOBIA 11/03/07
  13.   Lehmann`s no Jimmy Carter 09:05  |  Clickfool 11/03/07
  14.   to 1#: Remarks of the German cardinals 09:14  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  15.   # 8, Khalid 09:29  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  16.   #11 Hate of Jewish people? 09:48  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  17.   keep blackmailing the world and they will love you more. 10:03  |  Greg 11/03/07
  18.   MILLIONS of Moslems in Germany.Why not please them 10:06  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  19.   Germans know what ghettos are, after all... 10:22  |  Tom Smitsloo 11/03/07
  20.   #14 you are pulling our legs, arent you, Stefan? 10:23  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  21.   The Cardinal is being political 10:25  |  JW 11/03/07
  22.   SMITSLOO.After years of black rule.When will ALL Soweto get power 10:34  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  23.   GREG Who exactly blackmails the world with terrorists 10:40  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  24.   GREG Who exactly blackmails the world with terrorists 10:40  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  25.   absolute racism 10:45  |  arab 11/03/07
  26.   CATHOLIC APOLOGIES ARE PIE CRUST 10:46  |  paul harris 11/03/07
  27.   #17 DO YOU REALLY BEIEVE GREG THAT CATHOLICS LOVE JEWS ? 10:49  |  paul harris 11/03/07
  28.   #KHALID REWRITES HISTORY!! REMEMBER THE MUFTI OF 10:53  |  paul harris 11/03/07
  29.   Comparisons 10:54  |  LA 11/03/07
  30.   # 17, Greg 11:07  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  31.   #18, PETER SM 11:09  |  Fritz 11/03/07
  32.   Missing the point 11:10  |  Fairplay 11/03/07
  33.   the guy has no guts 11:11  |  Tara 11/03/07
  34.   #19, Tom Smitsloo 11:21  |  Fritz 11/03/07
  35.   Apologizes 11:23  |  Frank 11/03/07
  36.   #26 Never thought I would ever agree with PAUL HARRIS... 11:31  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  37.   Khalid & Co., it would be useful to remember a few matters about 11:39  |  Nadav 11/03/07
  38.   POPE BENEDICT WON`T DO THAT 11:41  |  indrajaya 11/03/07
  39.   # 20, Andreas 11:47  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  40.   German Bishop`s Educational Curriculum Sorely Lacking In ... 12:14  |  Lavi 11/03/07
  41.   Cardinal hasn`t renounced the words of Jesus 12:19  |  Yacov 11/03/07
  42.   germans are not supposed to speak the truth about israel 12:43  |  ravi 11/03/07
  43.   #41 Maybe we need to overcome all the old books, Yacov... 13:00  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  44.   Fritz."right" of any other group in Germany to preach hatred? 13:03  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  45.   #41 Andreas: "old books" of Jews don`t spew hatred towards Xians 13:10  |  Yacov 11/03/07
  46.   #41, Yacov 13:12  |  Fritz 11/03/07
  47.   Fritz, WE, sir, have not done anything that resembles YOUR deeds, 13:18  |  Nadav 11/03/07
  48.   C.WRIGHT.Any analogy will do if you ignore the acts of one side. 13:30  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  49.   @8, khalid, germany ownes pals nothing, 13:41  |  vladimir 11/03/07
  50.   we shal hang you abu amar, @9 13:42  |  vladimir 11/03/07
  51.   Stefan: rationalizing genocide 13:46  |  Khalid 11/03/07
  52.   Stefan: rationalizing genocide 13:46  |  Khalid 11/03/07
  53.   KHALID.YOU were running pogroms long before your Nazi allies 13:52  |  PETER SM 11/03/07
  54.   # 46, Fritz 13:55  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  55.   "painful" reality of separation fence ? 14:02  |  yahn goodey 11/03/07
  56.   #45 Yacov, #46 Fritz Biblical bias and cruelty 14:07  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  57.   Far worse 14:18  |  Cavler Crociatus 11/03/07
  58.   #46 Fritz: Your Xian deception- more of Jesus` words of "love" 14:23  |  Yacov 11/03/07
  59.   #51, Khalid 14:27  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  60.   # 56, Andreas 14:51  |  Stefan 11/03/07
  61.   @20, andreas, orthodox church did support 15:01  |  vladimir 11/03/07
  62.   Fritz haven`t we agreed that it is neither for 15:17  |  Petra 11/03/07
  63.   Khalid`s false information 15:20  |  Fairplay 11/03/07
  64.   #60 Stefan, You got me completely wrong.. 15:34  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  65.   Germany, a past that will not pass 15:55  |  Jonathan S 11/03/07
  66.   Palestinian ghettos-True 17:04  |  Yan 11/03/07
  67.   #9 Abu Amar - of course it`s worse than 17:23  |  * BEN JABO 11/03/07
  68.   Out of Passau – Hommage to Anne Rosmus 17:37  |  Jonathan S 11/03/07
  69.   @27,paul harris, zionism is 4300 years old and not 3000 17:39  |  vladimir 11/03/07
  70.   German Bishops blessed the Waffen SS 17:53  |  Menachem Ben Yakov 11/03/07
  71.   To Stefan - WRONG! YOU NEVER GET IT, DO YOU? 17:57  |  Greg 11/03/07
  72.   If only the Warsaw ghetto had been like Ramallah 18:06  |  Roberta Seid 11/03/07
  73.   8Khalid: Pals should apologize for their leader, The Mufti 18:29  |  Logician 11/03/07
  74.   Re: Germany should apologize to the Palestinian people 19:22  |  Olli 11/03/07
  75.   That Doesn`t Make Reality, Tara 19:41  |  Tex 11/03/07
  76.   #31,Lying Fritzi,what about Mullah Kaplan deported from Germany? 20:01  |  Absolute Sweden 11/03/07
  77.   Khalid, Dieter Wisliceny would disagree with you 20:22  |  Jake 11/03/07
  78.   YACOV, SOME CORECTION 20:29  |  Bandar Michaels 11/03/07
  79.   Its Palestinan Christians that suffer the most... 20:31  |  Andreas 11/03/07
  80.   #78 Bandar: Your Xian miscorrection, deception, propaganda 21:02  |  Yacov 11/03/07
  81.   # 65 Germany,a past will not pass 21:16  |  werner 11/03/07
  82.   Colin Wright 23:08  |  Albert Seligman 11/03/07
  83.   #79 Andreas 00:36  |  * BEN JABO 12/03/07
  84.   #1 Colin WRONG - you`re denying facts. 00:43  |  * BEN JABO 12/03/07
  85.   #79-2 Andreas - Kowtowing to Muslim`s 01:24  |  * BEN JABO 12/03/07
  86.   # 71, Grag, you don`t get it 08:04  |  Stefan 12/03/07
  87.   #62, Petra 08:17  |  Stefan 12/03/07
  88.   Inappropriate apology 10:16  |  John 12/03/07
 Today Online
Bradley Burston: The Plot - Use the UN to rid the world of Israel
Responses: 1
Akiva Eldar: What's Olmert got to lose? He should talk to Hamas
Send response
Gay activists seek to hold Pride Parade in Jerusalem in June
Responses: 26
Churchill essay partly blames Jews for anti-Semitism
Responses: 179
Islamic Movement condemns Palestinian lesbian conference
Responses: 104
Rosner's Domain
* Washington notes: AIPAC is all about sanctions
* Test your Jewishness: How hopeful are you about Iran?
* King Abdullah's not-so-courageous call for peace
* Rabbi Levi Shemtov on the state of Judaism in America


More Headlines
08:11 U.S. in talks with Saudis, Israel ahead of Arab meet
08:13 Hamas: No connection between Shalit release, formation of unity gov't
10:20 Settlers seek to rebuild evacuated W. Bank settlement
08:32 New formula could cut payments to Holocaust survivors, heirs
09:13 Envoy to El Salvador recalled, reportedly found naked, drunk
08:32 Bush urges Iran, Syria to act on vow to help end Iraq violence
08:20 Top IDF officer: PM did not order advanced preparation for war
06:26 Gov't okay Peres' economic peace corridor plan as national project
04:14 Civil Service investigating complaints against GPO head
06:03 Ethiopian seamstresses may lose work due to lack of gov't funds
Previous Editions
Special Offers
Advertisement
A Different Israel Experience
Unique programs for adults of all ages
JOIN FREE AT JDATE.COM
The most popular online Jewish dating community in the world! Explore the possibilities! Click Here!
CAMP KIMAMA ISRAEL
Israel's international summer camps!
Learn Hebrew Online
Learn Hebrew from the best teachers in Israel live over the Internet
Home| Print Edition| Diplomacy| Opinion| Arts & Leisure| Sports| Jewish World| Underground| Site rules|
© Copyright  Haaretz. All rights reserved