Subscribe to Print Edition | Mon., March 12, 2007 Adar 22, 5767 | | Israel Time: 10:55 (EST+7)
Haaretz israel news English
web haaretz.com
  Back to Homepage
Print Edition
Diplomacy
Defense Opinion National Arts & Leisure Anglo File Sports Travel  
Magazine Week's End
Q&A
Business Underground Jewish World Real Estate Advertising  
Bookmark to del.icio.us
How to shorten wars
By Yossi Sarid

Something important has happened in the United Kingdom. Prince Harry, 22, the younger son of Crown Prince Charles and the late Diana, plans to take part in the war in Iraq as a platoon commander. Britain is amazed to see the third in line to the throne risking his life on Her Majesty's service, and it happens to be of great interest to grandma. And it certainly is a great cause for concern: Life is not a film, and grandma is Elizabeth II, not Helen Mirren I.

Britain is already on its way out of the valley of the shadow of death. Last week Prime Minister Tony Blair announced that 1,600 soldiers will be leaving, using the idiotic excuse of "a stabilization of the security situation in southern Iraq" around the city of Basra. By engaging in active combat, Prince Harry is likely to cause a further acceleration of the withdrawal of the remaining 7,000 soldiers. From now on the lost war will penetrate the palace; it will also penetrate every British family anxiously keeping an eye on its prince at the front. Suddenly the war will be so close.

That is the nature of several of today's wars, that they are too far away. They seem to be taking place beyond the hills of darkness, somewhere out there, out of sight and out of mind. In 1970, 74 sons of members of the United States Congress were serving in Vietnam, whereas today only the son of Democratic Senator Jim Webb of Virginia is serving in Iraq, in the Marines. Recently, at a reception, President George W. Bush asked the senator "How's your boy?" and the senator replied coldly: "That's between me and my boy, Mr. President."

Advertisement

Bush, who has sent 150,000 soldiers to Iraq and about another 30,000 to Afghanistan, does not know a single one of them. His own family, his relatives and his acquaintances do not send candidates to the U.S. Armed Forces during its wars. Their children "kill themselves in the tents of Torah" in the most prestigious colleges. Although it is known that leaders all over the world love all the boys and girls, they love their own offspring even more, and that's natural. If they knew the names given to these children by their mothers and fathers they would be less wasteful and more thrifty in using their blood.

To date 3,180 American soldiers have been killed in Iraq, and as far as official Washington is concerned, they might as well be buried in the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. At least 23,000 soldiers have been seriously wounded, and they receive medical care in disgraceful conditions. In the White House and the Pentagon they had no idea how soldiers were being treated and rehabilitated under their noses in the highly regarded and accursed Walter Reed Hospital until The Washington Post and ABC Television told them two weeks ago, to their shame.

Here the situation is different, for the time being, and it is particularly good. In Israel quite a few sons of important people still serve in combat units. Defense Minister Amir Peretz's son, who recently enlisted in the Paratroop Regiment, is one positive example. But here, too, the ranks of the fighters who come from the well-connected percentiles are gradually thinning, and our wars are also liable to become distant from the circle of decision-makers and people of influence; they are liable to widen the gap between the glorious rhetoric about victims and the victims themselves. Noblesse oblige is the rule in England, and it should oblige all the members of the aristocracy in Israel even more.

It is therefore recommended that we keep an eye on all the local princes - the sons and grandsons of VIPs - who with various excuses evade military service altogether or risk their lives on the home front. That's all we need, to imitate the Americans, as is our wont, and the Israel Defense Forces will stop being an army of the entire nation, and the same will be true of its wars and monuments.

Beware the leaders, the great educators of the generation and the preachers who do not have a single Harry at home. And the more such Harrys, the fewer the wars, or at least the shorter.

Bookmark to del.icio.us
Israelis pay more
Average households pay NIS 430 in annual bank fees for regular checking accounts
Changing banking rules
Israel Discount Bank is now in the hands of Matthew Bronfman and his group.
  1.   Couragous Man, Indeed! 09:52  |  American 08/03/07
  2.   Rumsfeld and Autopen 10:31  |  Clickfool 08/03/07
  3.   Role of military service 10:32  |  Joe 08/03/07
  4.   Brilliant article 10:59  |  Michael 08/03/07
  5.   #2 CLIKKY AND ASTORM IN ATEACUP BUT HE RABBLE ROUSES 11:04  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  6.   Excellent article, that`s the problem with a professional army... 11:07  |  Swiss (Dino) 08/03/07
  7.   To all those who hate Israel 11:21  |  Jasmine Murphy 08/03/07
  8.   PAUL HARRIS when were you last on the front line? 11:37  |  Michael 08/03/07
  9.   Harry. 11:53  |  johnnymac 08/03/07
  10.   THIS IS WHAT I FEEL 12:13  |  indrajaya 08/03/07
  11.   Good Points About America, But the Conclusion Is Weak. 12:31  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  12.   Good Points About American, But the Conclusion Is Weak II 12:39  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  13.   #8..Paul Harris... 12:41  |  Ali 08/03/07
  14.   US Pipe Dreams and Arab Racism 12:55  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  15.   #1, american, finaly 13:07  |  VIPER 08/03/07
  16.   yossi`s wrong as usual 13:19  |  joe 08/03/07
  17.   For Paul Harris # 5 13:29  |  Clickfool 08/03/07
  18.   #8 MICHAEL ASSUMES TOO MUCH AND KNOWS NOTHING 13:43  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  19.   #11 CLIKKY YOU ARE AN IDIOT DONT EMPHASISE IT ! 13:44  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  20.   18 PAUL HARRIS Thanks for confirming I`m right. 13:59  |  Michael 08/03/07
  21.   About Time 14:04  |  Martin 08/03/07
  22.   CHGODMK (Post No. 14) 14:09  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/03/07
  23.   paul harris 14:10  |  wh 08/03/07
  24.   If Bush knew Anything... 14:18  |  SR 08/03/07
  25.   # 14, CHGODMK 14:18  |  indrajaya 08/03/07
  26.   # 14, CHGODMK 14:20  |  indrajaya 08/03/07
  27.   #20 MICHAEL CONFIRMS STUPIDITY WHEN YOU HAVE EXPERIENCE OF WAR 14:45  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  28.   For Paul Harris # 19 14:48  |  Clickfool 08/03/07
  29.   #23 READ THE ANSWER AND DONT JOIN THE THRONG 14:49  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  30.   #13 ALI THE BRAVE MAN WRITES TOUGH 14:51  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  31.   Sarid`s you lied about Egyptian prisoners being killed 14:52  |  Ken Jurist 08/03/07
  32.   #7 Hey Jasmine 14:55  |  ballistic 08/03/07
  33.   #2 Hey Paul 15:00  |  ballistic 08/03/07
  34.   For wh in ontario # 23 15:02  |  Clickfool 08/03/07
  35.   #28 CLIKKY IT IS USUALLY THE DUTY OF THE BATTALION COMMANDER TO 15:03  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  36.   indrajaya 15:04  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  37.   A Triumverate of Deceivers 15:06  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/03/07
  38.   Johnny Weintraub 15:09  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  39.   PAUL HARRIS 27 learn to be quiet when you`re wrong 15:11  |  Michael 08/03/07
  40.   paul harris 15:20  |  wh 08/03/07
  41.   14 & 25 I AGREE A 100% 15:20  |  alonitzafoni 08/03/07
  42.   #33 bsallistic comes out in the sunshine TO MAKE A STATEMENT 15:28  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  43.   Michael in UK #20 15:31  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  44.   TRY BEING COMBAT SOLDIERS!!! 15:32  |  alonitzafoni 08/03/07
  45.   BALLISTIC HIGH SCHOOL KIDS DRAFTED IN IDF ALSO HAVE LIVES 15:35  |  alonitzafoni 08/03/07
  46.   32 BULLISTIC PROVES HER ANTI-SEMITISM!!! 15:38  |  alonitzafoni 08/03/07
  47.   clickfool 15:38  |  wh 08/03/07
  48.   Iraq War Mismanaged Beyond Belief 15:45  |  Jane 08/03/07
  49.   A quote just for you Yossi 15:51  |  Miriam Davidowitz 08/03/07
  50.   CHGODMK Not sure why you think I`m unsympathetic 15:52  |  Michael 08/03/07
  51.   Yaakov Sullivan, today, under the articles of Israel Harel and .. 15:53  |  Nadav 08/03/07
  52.   Michael in UK 16:07  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  53.   to Clickfool # 2 16:14  |  Sitting Bull 08/03/07
  54.   further proof you don`t understand Bush 16:19  |  margaret 08/03/07
  55.   Sarid, you supported illegal `99 bombing of Serbia 16:33  |  Jake 08/03/07
  56.   Reply to CHGODMK (Post No. 38) 16:51  |  Johnny Weintraub 08/03/07
  57.   #44 16:55  |  johnnymac 08/03/07
  58.   #39 BUT MICHAEL YOU ARE WRONG ALL OF THE TIME !! 17:18  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  59.   BUSH,CHENEY,RUMMY,WOLFOWITZ..ETC ARE BEST FIT FOR USA 17:30  |  GIRISH 08/03/07
  60.   SUPPORTING THE TROOPS - Words from Iraq 17:31  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/03/07
  61.   #25 Indiana Jones`s brov 17:31  |  Itsik 08/03/07
  62.   SUPPORTING THE TROOPS - Words from Iraq 17:35  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/03/07
  63.   #54 not quite so! 17:37  |  Itsik 08/03/07
  64.   48 Jane - The Mismanagement Continues 17:58  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/03/07
  65.   Johnny Weintraub #55: Bush 17:59  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  66.   PAUL HARRIS 57 - I`m not wrong about you. 18:01  |  Michael 08/03/07
  67.   # 58 - GIRISH ..... I`ll Fill in the Blank ... 18:08  |  Klaudia 08/03/07
  68.   54 Margaret Bush`s Genes 18:10  |  Mark of Lewiston 08/03/07
  69.   How to Shorten Wars 18:29  |  VAS 08/03/07
  70.   #66 GUESSING AGIN MICHAEL AND WRONG WRONG WRONG WRONG 18:32  |  paul harris 08/03/07
  71.   to Johnny Weintraub/about Saddam 18:33  |  Nick 08/03/07
  72.   Yaakov Sullivan, note post # 51. I am still waiting for your .... 18:36  |  Nadav 08/03/07
  73.   #72 nadav, you are? 18:58  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/03/07
  74.   For Yaakov Sullivan and other posters, my response to Sullivan .. 19:00  |  Nadav 08/03/07
  75.   #72 nadav, Really? 19:00  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/03/07
  76.   Re: johnnymac 19:05  |  Lord Kitchener 08/03/07
  77.   Sarid - Ingrate Par Excellence 19:07  |  Tod Zuckerman 08/03/07
  78.   Sullivan vs. Nadav 19:12  |  Petra 08/03/07
  79.   My goodness nadav #74 19:16  |  Yaakov Sullivan 08/03/07
  80.   Nadav`s virtual Israel 19:16  |  abd 08/03/07
  81.   Nick in St. Paul #71 19:17  |  CHGODMK 08/03/07
  82.   US boys "kill themselves in the tents of Torah" ?! RACIST!! 19:26  |  Ovadiah ben Avraham 08/03/07
  83.   if.... 20:20  |  ravi 08/03/07
  84.   #76 20:28  |  johnnymac 08/03/07
  85.   #46 Alright Paul with the BS pushing; you made 20:33  |  ballistic 08/03/07
  86.   #68 Mark of Lewiston 20:52  |  margaret